Help! Please Help Me Show My Friend That She Is Doing Wrong By Her Doberman!

You know Gel Boris has been super socialized and he still wants to be the tough guy, the only thing that has worked for me is training him to obey me, come, sit and leave it, when on walks he has to sit when we pass a dog and stay focused on me. We are at 18 months now, he does it wonderfully and never gets into altercations but if I don't give him the commands he raises his hair and bow wows, so I don't know there is an answer other than not allowing him to be the aggressor, now we have the occasional idiot that thinks their little purse dog is cute and approaches anyways and I politely tell them I will release him if they don't walk around. They always do :)

We have family and friends that have dogs and he is great with them and my grand pup Libby is his BUD! they roll and play and love when they get to visit but outside the circle we just don't do. Maybe here in Minnesota with more area that is not full of rattlers and dangerous areas maybe we will do more of the exploring off leas stuff.
So far the only things that have worked on him not being such a dominant little:censored: is a couple of bitches going super nova on him.April's bitch was the first as far as I know?He went in thinking he was Tito Ortiz,she put her canines through his ear (and took off the tip)as proof he was in fact not Tito.;)
He tested himself and Daisy here,she about took his face off.Once he's put in his place he doesn't challenge it further.However,any other dog is a new test.
I will say, thinking back he's selective about it.At the vets office a couple of dogs he was completely fine,gave a sniff their direction and that was that.Another he had the Mohawk up and growling.The other dog was just sitting there, no posture or noise from him(her?) at all.
 
So far the only things that have worked on him not being such a dominant little:censored: is a couple of bitches going super nova on him.April's bitch was the first as far as I know?He went in thinking he was Tito Ortiz,she put her canines through his ear (and took off the tip)as proof he was in fact not Tito.;)
He tested himself and Daisy here,she about took his face off.Once he's put in his place he doesn't challenge it further.However,any other dog is a new test.
I will say, thinking back he's selective about it.At the vets office a couple of dogs he was completely fine,gave a sniff their direction and that was that.Another he had the Mohawk up and growling.The other dog was just sitting there, no posture or noise from him(her?) at all.
Maybe he has had some weird bad experience along the way that somehow triggers a memory
 
Hi Gelcoater is right - I just meant she is (house) training/generally training a puppy - he is just a regular household pet NOT a competition or service dog. I'm sorry if I used the wrong language I'm a little bit unfamiliar with the terminology...
 
Just as a sidebar though - to the people who have said that socialization is not essential - does that still apply if there are no other dogs in the home? Is it ok for a dog's only contact to be with humans?

Also - how much exercise do dobermans need in terms of walking and or/ chasing a ball/play. I have heard that it is really important to get dogs and puppies tons of exercise and that people underestimate the amount of exercise time that dogs need... I know that this may be difficult to quantify but I would be curious to know what a good amount of time is on average.

In my opinion and my experience, YES, it is ok for a dog to not have other dogs to play with. That may not work for every dog in the world, or every owner, but it has worked fine for me and the dogs that I have trained and worked with in the past 12 years.

Doberman need a LOT of exercise. I walk mine 2-3 miles a day, but while they are young I would suggest splitting up the walks and not doing one huge one. Also I wouldn't suggest doing any running because it can be hard on their joints till they are at least 18 months old and their growth plates have closed. Play time is essential for building a bond and for a good reward and relax period after training. Without it all else flies out the window. I walk between 30 min to an hour (for younger dogs split up into maybe two 20-30 min walks) and ball time after every training session. I would rather not play tug with my dogs. But the all like ball. I feed in the AM and switch off 15-20 min training sessions and 15-20 min ball play sessions all throughout the day. Usually throw in a walk here or there depending on time I have, weather, and his disposition....if he is tired, i won't make him walk. I should do more walks in the AM but I just never get around to it....and this week it is raining a lot :(

I hope that information helps.
 
Thanks for your detailed response, I certainly appreciate the input. I would like to clarify a few things about the circumstances to see if this makes a different. The pennies in a can is being used to scare the dog - but he is scared because she has taken the can and SLAMMED it on the crate while the puppy was in the crate. Now the puppy associates the rattling of the pennies with that scary experience - hence his fear of it. I didn't mind the idea of using pennies in a can to distract the puppy from whatever he was doing but I thought it was terrible to hit his crate with penny can (with quite a bit of force right above the puppy's head). He is terrified of the can rattling now... This seemed very cruel to me.

Also, this dog is neither a service or a competition/show dog, he's just a household pet who lives in a home that has no other dogs - just one person. If the dog has no contact at all with other dogs is that still ok?

I should also mention the pup only gets about 40 minutes of walking time (total per day) and 10 minutes of play (total per day). It seems to me that this could also be the cause of the dog's nipping. I own a Yorkshire Terrier and he requires at least two hours of exercise per day before he becomes very calm/tired/compliant so I thought that Dobermans with their athletic physique might need a lot more exercise if they spend most of their time in a crate...

I am not trying to contradict the points you made, I am only trying to see if you still think the same way given these clarifications...

Ok, I'll try to tackle this one thing at a time:
1. Using the can is NOT the method I prefer. I don't think it really teaches the dog anything. In a pack structure of dogs the alpha never uses fear and is almost never angry at the other dogs. To be in control of others you must be in control of yourself. That is why I prefer leaving a leash and chain collar or prong (sometimes hard to put on quickly) near the cage. When the dog barks/whines, you go to the dog and correct them. But on the flip side, when the dog is quiet and calm you reward them. If she is only punishing and not rewarding the system will not work no matter what her punishment is. In a pack structure the alpha dog does not throw things at the other dogs....he/she calmly goes over to the dog in the wrong and corrects them on the neck. Hence the chain/prong and leash being used for the correction when the dog is wrong.

2. Yes, it is still ok that he has no contact with other dogs, BUT he also needs to be worked around other dogs (pet store, park, training class) so he learns from his handler/pack leader what is appropriate and not. I wouldn't say that is is wrong for her dog to play with other dogs....it just isn't what I would suggest doing, and it's not what I do. Even with pet dogs.

3. There needs to be more play. Nipping does not come from exercise and not enough play. In my experience nipping comes from inconsistency on the handler's part and not knowing exactly what they are doing. It can also come from poor pack structure in the litter, the pup being removed too early (before 8 weeks old), or a myriad of other things. It is just too hard to determine without having my hands on the dog. Every dog is different even every doberman is different. All have different activity levels. What I can say is that she needs to set aside at least three sessions a day (morning, noon, and night) where the dog is trained....I like clicker training....and then has a period of 15 min of play. The training sessions should not last more than 15-20 min and should be kept fun, but not be used to get the dog super excited.

Thank you for the extra clarification. Usually I don't answer training questions over text because it is so much harder to get what people are saying, you can't see the dog and or handler, and it is also harder for you to understand what I am saying let alone relay all of this to your friend...LOL. I hope I am making sense.
 
All I want to say on this matter is that I think the penny can is BS. :)

Seriously though. If you make a dog skiddish and fearful and it spends it's life that way, your looking at a dog who is likely to bite out of fear and be perceived as aggressive and dangerous.

The goal in training is to form a happy bond with you and your dog. As stated, Dobermans are eager to please and are very intelligent. If she can form a bond with her dog, he will be eager to please her and can be trained easily for the household basic manners.

Good luck getting through to her

You are so right.....so many people forget that the goal of training is both respect and teamwork. Neither of which can be accomplished or built on fear. Sometimes harsher punishments or larger rewards need to be used from one dog to another, but you teach them NOTHING by making them scared......but to want to avoid you.
 
Ok,
Dobs4ever Caloni Ingrid H
In all 3 examples you're talking about training a dog for performance,what about just a family pet?
No interaction with other dogs?No sniffing butts?
Claims that if they interacted with another dog they would keep their manners?How would you know that if you don't let them interact with others?
I don't let ours sniff or mark while on leash walking,but off leash while we roam the hills I see no problem with it?
We don't do the dog park we do "out in the wild".
I'd be the first to admit we've had a couple of incidents that turned bad in an instant.In those cases it was the other dogs desire to not sniff butts(the doggy handshake) and they chose to go straight to fight mode,Daisy was more than willing to return the sentiment.
She has a genuine willingness to meet and play with others.Recall my thread of a few months back of the experience that went bad.She put herself into a down as the little dog approached her,in an effort to not seem threatening.Once the little dog growled....ugly time.

Not one instance where the other dog reciprocated the sniff was there an issue.Even the 2 GSD's and Daisy all off leash and we just happened upon each other.The potential was there but did not escalate.
Daisy's only experience with a pitbull,also a female and her elder,butt sniffing,then ran around playing like pack mates...it was a beautiful experience.

Just trying to figure out the responses,it was very much not what I expected to read.
There will almost always be a time when they,for one reason or another have to be in close quarters with another dog.Without any experience would they not be a little lost of exactly how to handle it?
Rocky,he's had next to no contact with others.Now we're in a situation where any other dog he see's he wants to eat,or at least be aggressive.I perceive this as stemming from his lack of socialization with others.Am I wrong?
I'm not saying I disagree with you guys,I just don't understand.This is where I'm all ears as I know you all have WAY more experience than I.
Ok....I'll do my best again to answer these....lol...getting kinda late here, so forgive me if I go astray:
1. On off leash walks, AFTER the dog is trained to stay with you, no, I don't see an issue. But that is for pet homes. I mainly train for competition obedience and Service dog work, so that is how I structure my training. I would not be so concerned for a pet home, other than walks on leash should be focused no matter what the dog is being used for. Play time with my dogs and off leash time in the house....sniffing is fine, I have no problem with it. But leash on, work time, training time, walk time....noses UP.

2. I have taken extensive classes in dog body language, how to "read" your dog, and other similar training classes. All I can tell you is that I am very experienced in reading dog body language. And my dog does not need to sniff another dog's butt or otherwise to act civilized and controlled in a class or in a store. Just like you don't go walking up to every person in a store loudly saying "HI", shaking their hand, and giving them a hug....my dog doesn't need to do the same in dog land. But if he/she were to bark, wine, give a dirty look, lunge, etc you bet your bottom dollar he'd get a correction that would send him through the roof! A correction strong enough that he wouldn't want to do it again. And if the little booger did try it again, all that tells me is that the first correction was not strong enough.

3. Once the little dog growled.....yeah, other people's dogs and my need to NOT socialize my dog with them is the #1 reason we don't do dog parks. I would much rather meet up with someone somewhere with their dog and go for a walk. It teaches the dogs so much more. I guess my question to people that go to dog parks is "why would you purposely put your dog in a situation of potential danger?".

Again, hope this helps.
 
It does not matter if it is a pet or competition dog - BUT certainly for competition I would not use such techniques. it could ruin a great dog... Part of training is to teach the dog to TRUST you, build confidence and instill good judgement and anyone who creates fear or intimidation is not properly training.

She obviously does not understand or care to understand why the dog is misbehaving in the crate - obviously she has not taught crate training correctly so her solution is to create more fear and intimidation which has already proven it is not working for her. SAD.

Anything I use I want to give the dog a positive experience. She is way off base in some of her assessments and is headed for problems. Dobermans do not take this kind of training well. They are strongly geared to work with their humans and that needs a bond of trust. She is breaking trust with her dog as he can't feel secure even in his own crate.

ALL dogs need to be socialized - Socialization does not mean however they have to "run" with dogs at large. In a home they need to get along. If they meet a dog on a walk they need to know to behave by sitting and observing and not jumping, growling or lunging at other dogs. Good dog behavior and not afraid or reactive around other dogs is socializaton. She is setting her dog up to failure big time. JHMO
 
I agree. She needs to start crate training all over like you would with a puppy. Try a peanut butter kong or a nylabone. Also one thing I never asked, just assumed, was; is the crate properly sized for the dog? Has she tried a wire crate, an airliner, or both? She needs to start over with this. BUT if my dog is demand barking or barks back after I tell him quiet then he gets a punishment (spray bottle, muzzle grab, or leash correction) whatever is effective and appropriate for the dog.

I also agree that with any dog, no matter the breed, that building teamwork is essential...for pet or competition dogs. This cannot be done through any fear based tactics. But with that said...If my dogs blow me off on something that they know solid or have innapropriate behavior, you can bet that I will be correcting them. No "positive only" training works.
 
The best way to successfully train a dog to the crate is to ignore bad behavior - If you acknowledge it with a spay bottle, muzzle grab or leash not to mention that you can't grab the muzzle fast enough if they are in a crate and the leash would be dangerous to leave on in the crate. Even negative attention is still acknowledging them and giving them attention. For an anxious dog any attention is better than none so they become more determined to carry on more til they get a response.

Through the years I have found ignoring is the best method of addressing crate issues. For nipping I do grab the muzzle if they don't listen or you can use a leash as stated.

I agree ALL positive training can and will fail with more dogs than not. They have to know you will follow through with commands. It is why most pet training does not work. If sit mean sit then it means SIT the first time asked not the 5th time asked. The correction does not have to be harsh - correction and harshness are not always the same thing and there should be NO correction if you are doing it out of anger.
 
Through the years I have found ignoring is the best method of addressing crate issues.
I agree. If you even give them as much as a glance when they're fussing they're going to know it got your attention so it pays to do it. If ours were fussing when I got home from work or something I'd walk directly into another room and as soon as they settled and weren't raising a fuss I'd go in and we'd go about our business of going outside and such.
 
I agree ALL positive training can and will fail with more dogs than not. They have to know you will follow through with commands. It is why most pet training does not work. If sit mean sit then it means SIT the first time asked not the 5th time asked. The correction does not have to be harsh - correction and harshness are not always the same thing and there should be NO correction if you are doing it out of anger.
YEA!!!!!! Suzane your my hero:D

It is point less to train your dog if it is more of a suggestion than a command. I think the difference is some people teach their dogs to do tricks and some train them to obey, big difference.

Just before we left New Braunfels I had gone over to my daughters to spend the night and as we were leaving SNAP Boris' leash was not hooked on the right link and as we headed to the car I didn't have him at a heal so he is going for the back of the Hummer in front of a busy highway at 5:00, I should have had him at my side but I had my arms full and him and Tash both on the leads so I was being careless. My heart jumped into my throat as I let out the firmest heal I could and he stopped turned around and came to my side because he knew my tone, he never hesitated just came to my side as if he was on the lead and sat down. They must know your voice and obey it!
 
Ok,
Dobs4ever Caloni Ingrid H

I'm a bit confused?

In all 3 examples you're talking about training a dog for performance,what about just a family pet?
No interaction with other dogs?No sniffing butts?

I can't speak for the others, but I meant that no dog interaction was OK for pet dogs too. The human family is all a dog really needs to have for a "pack". Dogs need to be taught not to go crazy, bark, and pull on the leash or froth at the car window when they see a strange dog, but they don't have to socialize with strange dogs.
 
When Kris is on leash I do not let her go up to other dogs and do not let them come and sniff her. Whether you are going to compete or not I do not think it is a good idea for your dog to look at all other dogs as something to play with. She gets to play with other dogs when they are off leash and it is playtime.
 
Thanks Mel - it is a life saver. It builds confidence in the dog and strengthens the bond. Far fewer dogs would end up in the pound if people just knew how to train correctly and book learning does not get you there. Dogs are our best teacher and once we get on their page we can correctly work with them and achieve great success. Pet or competition the dog needs to understand what a command is and obey it. It is in their best interest - They are so easy to manipulate we need to use that to guide them and then reinforce once they know the commands.
 
I think the biggest need for socialization, whether we're showing or not is the fact that we still need to take them out in public to the vet and other places and I don't want it all to be a new experience for them when they're not used to it.
 
I think the biggest need for socialization, whether we're showing or not is the fact that we still need to take them out in public to the vet and other places and I don't want it all to be a new experience for them when they're not used to it.
And on that note.
Lets face it,sometimes things happen.If our dog has had no interaction with other dogs besides it's pack,should another dog come up our dog wouldn't know how to handle it.
I've been on both ends if this deal,had my dog get loose and approach another just to say hi.
Also had some strange dog do the same with the owner in hot pursuit with leash in hand,collar still attached because the dog got out of it.
Is it not a learned social skill to interact with others?
 

Back
Top