Hi Everyone,
I am sorry to appeal to everyone for help like this but I don't know what else to do to convince my friend that what she is doing to train her doberman not good for her puppy I have a friend who recently acquired a Doberman and she does things that I consider unacceptable in her training. I myself have a small dog who has some issues (separation anxiety and can be bratty) because I probably coddle him too much. Because of this she refuses to listen to anything I have to say about her methods, though I have read about dogs and dog psychology pretty extensively. I thought that if I appealed to a community of Doberman owners and got some feedback she would be more likely to listen to me. She says that it is essential to use fear in training your dog and she does things to scare her dog into submission (not physically harm him but scaring him in a way I consider unacceptable), I will list the problems I have with her methods below. She doesn't want to have her dog neutered and says that to weed out aggressive behaviors she will NEVER let her dog sniff/smell (she believes this makes him less obedient) and that she will NOT let him interact with other dogs (she believes this also makes him less obedient). I told her that socialization is essential for a dog's training, well-being and also happiness. They are social/pack animals and they need interaction with members of their own species. She is taking the dog to puppy class next weekend and I told her to talk to the dog trainer about it - I also hope that the trainer will tell her these methods are terrible. She responded that he was socialized (though it does not sound like he is and she he is only a few months old). To summarize:
* She scares her dog by filling a jar with pennies and hitting the jar of pennies on the dog's crate while he is in it to stop him from whimpering/crying/barking.
* She says that sniffing/letting the dog smell things makes him less compliant and that she will therefore not let him smell AT ALL when she takes him on walks. It is my impression that smelling/sniffing is how dogs take the world in and that it is important to make time to let them do it during a walk, that you don't have to let them do it the whole time but that they need SOME time to be allowed to smell things.
* She says socializing with other dogs increases his propensity to nip and takes focus off her as "the boss/the alpha" and she will therefore no longer allow him to socialize (I think she means for the duration of training, ie, months -I mean I hope she doesn't mean for the dog's lifetime because it seems to me that this would be cruel and insane).
Am I completely wrong? Are these acceptable things to do when training a dog? Please help!! She is a good person at heart and someone irresponsible dumped this dog on her - it wasn't her choice and she is doing the best she can, I know that she THINKS she is doing the right thing because she is quite easily swayed and one of her neighbors told her about these methods and told her that dogs are happier with a "firm" owner and "set" boundaries. PLEASE HELP ME SHOW HER THAT THIS IS NOT THE WAY TO GO!
I thank everyone for their time and their input.
Best,
Linda
I am sorry to appeal to everyone for help like this but I don't know what else to do to convince my friend that what she is doing to train her doberman not good for her puppy I have a friend who recently acquired a Doberman and she does things that I consider unacceptable in her training. I myself have a small dog who has some issues (separation anxiety and can be bratty) because I probably coddle him too much. Because of this she refuses to listen to anything I have to say about her methods, though I have read about dogs and dog psychology pretty extensively. I thought that if I appealed to a community of Doberman owners and got some feedback she would be more likely to listen to me. She says that it is essential to use fear in training your dog and she does things to scare her dog into submission (not physically harm him but scaring him in a way I consider unacceptable), I will list the problems I have with her methods below. She doesn't want to have her dog neutered and says that to weed out aggressive behaviors she will NEVER let her dog sniff/smell (she believes this makes him less obedient) and that she will NOT let him interact with other dogs (she believes this also makes him less obedient). I told her that socialization is essential for a dog's training, well-being and also happiness. They are social/pack animals and they need interaction with members of their own species. She is taking the dog to puppy class next weekend and I told her to talk to the dog trainer about it - I also hope that the trainer will tell her these methods are terrible. She responded that he was socialized (though it does not sound like he is and she he is only a few months old). To summarize:
* She scares her dog by filling a jar with pennies and hitting the jar of pennies on the dog's crate while he is in it to stop him from whimpering/crying/barking.
* She says that sniffing/letting the dog smell things makes him less compliant and that she will therefore not let him smell AT ALL when she takes him on walks. It is my impression that smelling/sniffing is how dogs take the world in and that it is important to make time to let them do it during a walk, that you don't have to let them do it the whole time but that they need SOME time to be allowed to smell things.
* She says socializing with other dogs increases his propensity to nip and takes focus off her as "the boss/the alpha" and she will therefore no longer allow him to socialize (I think she means for the duration of training, ie, months -I mean I hope she doesn't mean for the dog's lifetime because it seems to me that this would be cruel and insane).
Am I completely wrong? Are these acceptable things to do when training a dog? Please help!! She is a good person at heart and someone irresponsible dumped this dog on her - it wasn't her choice and she is doing the best she can, I know that she THINKS she is doing the right thing because she is quite easily swayed and one of her neighbors told her about these methods and told her that dogs are happier with a "firm" owner and "set" boundaries. PLEASE HELP ME SHOW HER THAT THIS IS NOT THE WAY TO GO!
I thank everyone for their time and their input.
Best,
Linda
So I see eye to eye on that with your friend.
We are having a neutering party