• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Fromm Gold

Archer

Hot Topics Subscriber
This is another food I am looking into. All of my research is very positive and I feel it is a phenomenal food. Do any of you have experience in feeding it? I have a few friends that feed it and they sing it's praises as well, just wanted to have some more input before making my final decision on what to switch to. I LOVE the Orijen, but it has proven to be a bit too high in calcium and protein/phosphorus for Aria at 7 months. I have narrowed my two choices down to this or the NOW Fresh.

What are your thoughts and opinions.....

Thanks.

a link or two for your reading pleasure
http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/fromm-dog-food-gold-nutritionals-dry/

http://frommfamily.com/products/gold/dog/dry/adult-gold

http://frommfamily.com/products/gold/dog/dry/large-breed-adult-gold
 
I was going to use this, but it is just too expensive for me right now. I know several people that use it and love it and do well on it. If I only had one small dog it would be a no brainer. But I have 3 and 2 eat quite a bit. I hope you like it :)
 
I was going to use this, but it is just too expensive for me right now. I know several people that use it and love it and do well on it. If I only had one small dog it would be a no brainer. But I have 3 and 2 eat quite a bit. I hope you like it :)
I couldn't find any info,what's the price point on this?

Definitely watching this thread,would like to find a food that agrees with both of my pooches.
 
We fed the Fromm Gold puppy formula to Albert and he did great on it. I don't think it was much more expensive than the TOTW we feed now with the Fromm being at about $47 for 30#.
 
The dogs vet, just was telling me, I should switch him to Fromm as she said his coat looked
terrible. Fromm here is $10.00 more dollars per bag, of what I feed him now.
I feed him TOTW($45.00 per 40 pound bag) but have been just giving him salmon. I think maybe I should have been switching flavors???every few months to keep allergies down???
With Fromm how much do you feed your males? Geist is 88pounds now.
 
OOP's after looking at the info it's about the same I feed him now. BUT does anyone think
the carbs are kinda high vs the protein??? In Fromm?
 
The dogs vet, just was telling me, I should switch him to Fromm as she said his coat looked
terrible. Fromm here is $10.00 more dollars per bag, of what I feed him now.
I feed him TOTW($45.00 per 40 pound bag) but have been just giving him salmon. I think maybe I should have been switching flavors???every few months to keep allergies down???
With Fromm how much do you feed your males? Geist is 88pounds now.
From what I have seen with the Fromm, the recommendations for an 88 pound dog would get 4 1/4-5 1/4 CPD. That is the range for 70-90.
 
OOP's after looking at the info it's about the same I feed him now. BUT does anyone think
the carbs are kinda high vs the protein??? In Fromm?

The carbs are a bit higher, but since the protein is lower than what I have been feeding I feel it evens itself out for us. I personally don't mind giving a high drive, active breed a food with a higher carb content. I think of it like this.....as a runner, I load with carbs prior to a big run. With how much my kids run and train I think the carb level is decent for them. Both of my friends that feed it have active breeds (Vizsla and Doberman) and have had zero issues with the carb/protein ratio.
 
It's what Jan quoted. Of course it can vary from region to region.
Puts me in a pickle.
Rocky's food is a few dollars less but for a 37.5 lb bag.Daisy's food is about 10 bucks more for a 30lb bag.
From what I have seen with the Fromm, the recommendations for an 88 pound dog would get 4 1/4-5 1/4 CPD. That is the range for 70-90.
and omg!
4-5+ cups?
My two would be little porkey butts if I fed that much:eek:
 
Puts me in a pickle.
Rocky's food is a few dollars less but for a 37.5 lb bag.Daisy's food is about 10 bucks more for a 30lb bag.

and omg!
4-5+ cups?
My two would be little porkey butts if I fed that much:eek:
Here are my thoughts on this.....if it makes it easier for you to feed both Dobies the same food and the cost is median it's a no brainer.

The amounts listed to feed are of course guidelines. The amount you actualy feed varies on the calorie content of the individual food and from dog to dog.

For example, in order to meet my dog's caloric needs, I would end up feeding more if I went with Fromm due to the high caloric content of the Orijen they were receiving before.
 
Wow I guess it is more expensive than I remember. This place has decent prices and free shipping on orders over $49. http://www.pet360.com/shop/brand/fromm

I feed him TOTW($45.00 per 40 pound bag) but have been just giving him salmon. I think maybe I should have been switching flavors???every few months to keep allergies down???
The salmon isn't one of their best formulas so we stick with the high prairie since it's rated the highest out of all of the formulas. You might want to try switching that that one to see if it helps. That's the only one we feed and Della never has a flake on her, even though Albert has a little, but I think that's more thyroid related than food.
 
I will try high prairie next, before going to Fromm. He was even getting "zits" I think from
the salmon. ??Maybe it was to much oil?? I asked the vet if he needed a thyroid test due to the skin
issues. She said no, he was to young and had plenty of energy in the office!
 
I haven't received any reviews on the NOW! Fresh that I also made a post about, but after looking into both foods, I think I will go with the Fromm. I talked to my Vet today on the phone and he said he has had luck with the Fromm in similar cases as Aria's. The difference in Phos levels between the NOW! and the Fromm is minimal so it really doesn't make that much of a difference. The last thing I struggle with is Fromm Gold is not a grain free food as it has brown rice and barley. I wold rather have that as a grain though than corn any day.

What do you guys think...here is the review on the NOW! Fresh.
http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/now-dog-food/
 
The last thing I struggle with is Fromm Gold is not a grain free food as it has brown rice and barley. I wold rather have that as a grain though than corn any day.
I meant to say that myself. I honestly like the ingredients in the TOTW much better than the Fromm which is why that's what we feed.


What do you guys think...here is the review on the NOW! Fresh.
http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/now-dog-food/
Maybe it was just me, but I tried another quality food that had great ingredients similar to this, but it turns out the potatoes were too high on the list and they did not do well on it at all and both started getting dulling coats and flakes. The food was Merrick BG (before grain) for the record.
 
I haven't received any reviews on the NOW! Fresh that I also made a post about, but after looking into both foods, I think I will go with the Fromm. I talked to my Vet today on the phone and he said he has had luck with the Fromm in similar cases as Aria's. The difference in Phos levels between the NOW! and the Fromm is minimal so it really doesn't make that much of a difference. The last thing I struggle with is Fromm Gold is not a grain free food as it has brown rice and barley. I wold rather have that as a grain though than corn any day.

What do you guys think...here is the review on the NOW! Fresh.
http://www.dogfoodadvisor.com/dog-food-reviews/now-dog-food/
Gotta say,the ingredients list looks more impressive.The one ingredient that might cause mild concern is the dried kelp.Where are they getting it?Instantly makes me think Pacific kelp..radiation.Probably me being a worry wart.
On your rice comment,rice..potato they need a carb source one way or another.IMO,6 of one,half dozen of another.I agree I would rather see rice than corn.Would I rather see potato or rice? I dunno?
 
I would rather see rice personally if I were to feed grains. Potato is the second ingredient in the NOW! and perhaps it is a bit too far up on the list.
 

Back
Top