• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Fromm Gold

Gotta say,the ingredients list looks more impressive.The one ingredient that might cause mild concern is the dried kelp.Where are they getting it?Instantly makes me think Pacific kelp..radiation.Probably me being a worry wart.
On your rice comment,rice..potato they need a carb source one way or another.IMO,6 of one,half dozen of another.I agree I would rather see rice than corn.Would I rather see potato or rice? I dunno?
See why I am having a hard time deciding? lol. My gut is to go with the Fromm.
 
I honestly like the ingredients in the TOTW much better than the Fromm which is why that's what we feed.

Me too. TOTW has more protein. I like rice better than potato, as it has more complex carbs than a potato.
Carbs are a not so good thing when they are not complex. If you don't utilize them, they turn to sugar than fat.
Protein turns to a more stable energy than to muscle.
 
I started using Fromm's when Justice was a puppy and he did very well on it. I then switched to Orijen as it seemed to be a better food but you will most definitely get some funky gas on Orijen. If your thinking of switching and I know I say this way too much but seriously look at " ZIWIPEAK ".

www.ziwipeak.com
 
Me too. TOTW has more protein. I like rice better than potato, as it has more complex carbs than a potato.
Carbs are a not so good thing when they are not complex. If you don't utilize them, they turn to sugar than fat.
Protein turns to a more stable energy than to muscle.
Thank you!

I'm choosing the Fromm because of it's lower protein, which is what she needs right now due to some issues with the growth in her long bones (pasterns). This was a change of food for health reasons, not for fun unfortunately :(

Sounds like the rice will be the better option. Another pro for Fromm vs. NOW!

I started using Fromm's when Justice was a puppy and he did very well on it. I then switched to Orijen as it seemed to be a better food but you will most definitely get some funky gas on Orijen. If your thinking of switching and I know I say this way too much but seriously look at " ZIWIPEAK ".

www.ziwipeak.com
Thanks! Unfortunately, the Zwipeak is too high in protein for her right now, which is why we are switching off the Orijen. I don't want to switch as I love the Orijen, but due to issues in the growth of her long bones I have no choice. I need a food with a low protein/calcium/phosphorous ratio right now until she grows out of it. Fromm looks like it would be a good option for us as it's the lowest in the three levels.

You definitely get bad farts on the Orijen. Archer did on the Acana too, lol!!
 
Thank you!

I'm choosing the Fromm because of it's lower protein, which is what she needs right now due to some issues with the growth in her long bones (pasterns). This was a change of food for health reasons, not for fun unfortunately :(

Sounds like the rice will be the better option. Another pro for Fromm vs. NOW!


Thanks! Unfortunately, the Zwipeak is too high in protein for her right now, which is why we are switching off the Orijen. I don't want to switch as I love the Orijen, but due to issues in the growth of her long bones I have no choice. I need a food with a low protein/calcium/phosphorous ratio right now until she grows out of it. Fromm looks like it would be a good option for us as it's the lowest in the three levels.

You definitely get bad farts on the Orijen. Archer did on the Acana too, lol!!


We did get bad gas from Orijen, and Acana is the same maker of Orijen, and yes we tried that too with the same results. Acana is just a tad cheaper than Orijen for some reason. I don't mind the higher grade of protein as I work Liberty and Justice pretty hard now that the weather is worthy of being outside, but even then when it's cold, they still run for at least a few hours a day. They are pretty active so that I guess is my justification for feeding such a high protein.

I see on Dog food advisor that it is in deed 10% less protein than ziwipeak. I'm sure it's going to be a great fit for you. They have a great reputation and no recalls that I have ever heard of.
 
We did get bad gas from Orijen, and Acana is the same maker of Orijen, and yes we tried that too with the same results. Acana is just a tad cheaper than Orijen for some reason. I don't mind the higher grade of protein as I work Liberty and Justice pretty hard now that the weather is worthy of being outside, but even then when it's cold, they still run for at least a few hours a day. They are pretty active so that I guess is my justification for feeding such a high protein.

I see on Dog food advisor that it is in deed 10% less protein than ziwipeak. I'm sure it's going to be a great fit for you. They have a great reputation and no recalls that I have ever heard of.
Thank you! I hope it works for her. So far so good. I bought a bag of Fromm last night.

Absolutely. Yeah, like you, I train and exercise mine enough that the higher protein in the Orijen works. It just doesn't work for Aria atm, but I will be switching her back to the Orijen once she is better as I love the food and have seen the results.

Acana is cheaper due to the lower protein ratio. Acana is also not a whole prey diet like Orien. The Acana was created to be a more affordable version of the Orijen. Archer did better on the Acana than Orijen due to the lower protein levels.
 
I bought a bag of Fromm Gold last night and did a cold turkey switch. I KNOW that is not advised, but with the small window of time I have to correct this before her growth plates close, I feel like I am choosing the path of the lesser of the two evils. I picked up some transition powder (basically pre and probiotics) made by Eagle Pack and have been sprinkling 1T on her food daily to help with the transition. So far, so good. No diarrhea and she is wolfing it down.

Went with the LB adult food because it had the lowest levels of concentration that I could find in the line. She ate it with gusto last night and this morning. It was nice to pay $49 per bag instead of the $80 I usually pay for the Orijen.
 
Well, it's been a month since the switch and no change. Her foot still turns out. Even with placing her foot when stacking. She acts starving on the Fromm and even though I have upped the amount fed, she looks too lean for my liking.

Thinking seriously of switching back if she doesn't improve in a few weeks.
 
Well that's too bad it isn't working out for her. :( Is the calorie content similar to the orijen?
 
Well that's too bad it isn't working out for her. :( Is the calorie content similar to the orijen?
Thanks! No, it's much lower so I am having to feed her waaay more to make up for what she is used to getting. The increased amount of the Fromm is causing diarrhea so the I have to back off. With the lower calories, she's too skinny for my taste, although her stool is good. Total double edged sword.
 
Thanks! No, it's much lower so I am having to feed her waaay more to make up for what she is used to getting. The increased amount of the Fromm is causing diarrhea so the I have to back off. With the lower calories, she's too skinny for my taste, although her stool is good. Total double edged sword.
:( poor Aria :(
 
Thanks! No, it's much lower so I am having to feed her waaay more to make up for what she is used to getting. The increased amount of the Fromm is causing diarrhea so the I have to back off. With the lower calories, she's too skinny for my taste, although her stool is good. Total double edged sword.
Is it possible she needs more fat content?I know you want to limit protein but sounds like she needs a more fatty diet?
 
Is it possible she needs more fat content?I know you want to limit protein but sounds like she needs a more fatty diet?
I agree :)She does and you need a 12% fat ratio for this too on top of the protein, calcium and phosphorous reduction.

See what I mean, screwed either way so might as well go back to what was working.

*sigh*
 
I agree :)She does and you need a 12% fat ratio for this too on top of the protein, calcium and phosphorous reduction.

See what I mean, screwed either way so might as well go back to what was working.

*sigh*
Actually I'm a bit surprised you didn't get diarrhea issues earlier considering the cold turkey switch.
I thought that (while not having diarrhea) the original food was too high a protien?
If the only issue is the runs from over feeding trying to keep the weight,what about sticking with this food and giving some extra fat?
 
Actually I'm a bit surprised you didn't get diarrhea issues earlier considering the cold turkey switch.
I thought that (while not having diarrhea) the original food was too high a protien?
If the only issue is the runs from over feeding trying to keep the weight,what about sticking with this food and giving some extra fat?
Thanks, Gel.

I didn't get the diarrhea because of the Eagle Pack pre/probiotic transition powder I used when I switched. It's awesome stuff.

Protein isn't the most important factor in the switch. In fact, it's more the calcium phosphorus ratio. I have read tons of veterinary journals on nutrition related growth issues and having compiled that on what I already know medically I have found reducing the protein level to be controversial anyway. There's no real proof that reducing the amount fed has any effect on the growth related issues. When Archer had pano two years ago, everything I read said lower protein, lower calcium. Now the protein aspect is debatable.

I emailed the GreatDaneLady who is an expert on things like these and she said to keep on doing what we are, plus trying to keep the fat % under 12% right now, so I am back to the research drawing board to figure out what I can add if any to keep her on the Fromm if that's what she needs.

Besides the diarrhea, her coat is also looking dry and is flakey for the first time. She is also scavenging and grass eating like a monster, leading me to believe this food isn't doing it for her. Faustus is having the same issues too.

I also am making a vet appointment for the week after next (she's at the breeders for a week for training) to get a film on her leg and to see if she needs anti-inflamatories.
 
Thanks, Gel.

I didn't get the diarrhea because of the Eagle Pack pre/probiotic transition powder I used when I switched. It's awesome stuff.

Protein isn't the most important factor in the switch. In fact, it's more the calcium phosphorus ratio. I have read tons of veterinary journals on nutrition related growth issues and having compiled that on what I already know medically I have found reducing the protein level to be controversial anyway. There's no real proof that reducing the amount fed has any effect on the growth related issues. When Archer had pano two years ago, everything I read said lower protein, lower calcium. Now the protein aspect is debatable.

I emailed the GreatDaneLady who is an expert on things like these and she said to keep on doing what we are, plus trying to keep the fat % under 12% right now, so I am back to the research drawing board to figure out what I can add if any to keep her on the Fromm if that's what she needs.

Besides the diarrhea, her coat is also looking dry and is flakey for the first time. She is also scavenging and grass eating like a monster, leading me to believe this food isn't doing it for her. Faustus is having the same issues too.

I also am making a vet appointment for the week after next (she's at the breeders for a week for training) to get a film on her leg and to see if she needs anti-inflamatories.
Do you mind if I ask why 12% fat?
And when we say 12% we're talking of total intake of the day?Or?
What should the phosphorous/calcium ratio be?
I see some big time variance between the foods we feed here.
I find this kind of stuff genuinely intriguing.
 

Back
Top