Feeling Sick

Rach

Hot Topics Subscriber
I have a friend who is very experienced in the Doberman world... She has had them her whole life and has trained them well.... Two years ago she got a firecracker of a pup (Benzi)... Very strong willed, bull headed, dominant aggressive I would say. She then rescued an adult female (Abby) some months later. Abby is just the sweetest thing and is pretty passive. Benzi would always instigate things with her. My friend done her best to control the situation but tonight Benzi attacked my friend, who had to have stitches in her leg, and has Abby in serious condition at the vets.... I'm heartbroken for my friend. I've been told she is going to put Benzi down. Not only is she loosing her baby but she might loose her other one as well... These dogs are her whole world..

She was putting a pair of jammies on the young one and the other girl just walked up to them and the attack was on...
 
Wow. Sorry to hear about that. I can't imagine how confused and heartbroken and the flood of emotion your friend must be experiencing.
 
How awful!! My heart goes out to your friend and her dogs. I can't imagine what it's like to be in her shoes. Thinking of all of you guys and praying for strength for your friend as well as health and healing for Abby. Glad your friend has you for support. Please let her know I'm thinking about her. Situations like this break my heart :(

Keep us posted, Rach.
 
I have a friend who is very experienced in the Doberman world... She has had them her whole life and has trained them well.... Two years ago she got a firecracker of a pup (Benzi)... Very strong willed, bull headed, dominant aggressive I would say. She then rescued an adult female (Abby) some months later. Abby is just the sweetest thing and is pretty passive. Benzi would always instigate things with her. My friend done her best to control the situation but tonight Benzi attacked my friend, who had to have stitches in her leg, and has Abby in serious condition at the vets.... I'm heartbroken for my friend. I've been told she is going to put Benzi down. Not only is she loosing her baby but she might loose her other one as well... These dogs are her whole world..

She was putting a pair of jammies on the young one and the other girl just walked up to them and the attack was on...

Sorry to hear this and I feel bad for your friend.

I wonder if Benzi thought the jammies were prey/toy? I say this because my trainer told me to be careful about holding Sabrina in my arms around strange dogs. The trainer said she saw dogs attack small dogs being held by their owners because they thought they were prey or toys instead of dogs.
 
Sorry to hear this and I feel bad for your friend.

I wonder if Benzi thought the jammies were prey/toy? I say this because my trainer told me to be careful about holding Sabrina in my arms around strange dogs. The trainer said she saw dogs attack small dogs being held by their owners because they thought they were prey or toys instead of dogs.
Interesting point, OB. Hopefully that's all it is.
 
Oh no, I'm so very sorry to read this. :( Interesting points above and I just with there was an alternative to having to put either one down. :(
 
Sorry to hear this and I feel bad for your friend.

I wonder if Benzi thought the jammies were prey/toy? I say this because my trainer told me to be careful about holding Sabrina in my arms around strange dogs. The trainer said she saw dogs attack small dogs being held by their owners because they thought they were prey or toys instead of dogs.

Could be... but I honestly don't think that's the case. She is one who constantly will run at other dogs and nip at them or just bull doze them over... It's not a play thing either... Regardless of the consequence she would keep at it... as would her owner with the consequences.. it just never seemed to get through to her... She is always in bully mode, if that makes any sense. Godric is a pretty laid back dude... and would only take it for so long before putting her in her place. He is the only one that she seemed to respect. Everyone else she would torment relentlessly... I could never figure it out... if she was just bored... but I think she has some serious behavioral issues.
 
Oh no, I'm so very sorry to read this. :( Interesting points above and I just with there was an alternative to having to put either one down. :(

Things may change for her owner in regards to putting her down.. as she will be at the vets for an indefinite amount of time.. as the incident was reported. As for Abby, she got tore up pretty bad... They don't know if she will make it.. she's in bad shape.
 
I'm very sorry for this Rachel. Is Benzi a female? Horrible thing to go through. Thoughts are with your friend. Decisions like this are hard
 
I'm very sorry for this Rachel. Is Benzi a female? Horrible thing to go through. Thoughts are with your friend. Decisions like this are hard

Yes, Benzi is a female... I feel at a loss with my friend... I can't imagine what she's going through.
 
Yes, Benzi is a female... I feel at a loss with my friend... I can't imagine what she's going through.


I am saying prayers for her. Dog fights are horrific and something I don't want to every experience again. It's been a few years here, thank the lord, I've been fortunate enough to read them and am thankfully one step ahead of them.

Male dogs will fight and in my experience get over it. Females are a different story, they can and will fight to the death. In my house the female is always the alpha dog. I have two high drive intact bitches and at this point they can still run together but I think that's going to be short lived, I always think of what might happen, they are fine in the house it's going out for a run. I always try to have them in a calm manor before we go out but they fly and the first five minutes is when I worry.

I hope Abby recovers and your friend is okay. Hard decisions
 
I hope everyone recovers. A horrible situation. Were the dogs spayed? What kind of training and management was done before this occurred? Were there ever any issues when your friend wasn't present? Was your friend bit at the same time as the other dog? It sounds like severe resource guarding that was never brought under control from the info here.

2 pits (mom and son) I rescued straight from the euthanasia room were the only dogs of mine to ever have a bad fight. I was a physical wreck afterwards because I had to claw through packed in snow to move a kennel door and drag 2 fighting pits inside before I could do anything. They wouldn't let go of each other no matter what so I ran around to the garage to get something and there was silence. I came back around scared that one was dead but they were both kind of bloody looking at me with the exact same head tilt like "where did you go?" With me at a distance they began to lick each other's wounds. It was a life changing eye opener for me but really horrific to go through.


Male dogs will fight and in my experience get over it. Females are a different story, they can and will fight to the death

Very true. In my experience intact males have a shorter fuse but get over it pretty quick. Intact females especially can build to a blow out that is way more intense than you will see with males.
 
I'm so sorry for you and your friend, Rach. I've never experienced this nor do I want to. Frankly, it scares the hell outta me! I can't imagine the horror and pain she went through. And you, as her friend, feel it more. I hope and pray that she heals both physically and emotionally. Keep us posted, please.
 
I hope everyone recovers. A horrible situation. Were the dogs spayed? What kind of training and management was done before this occurred? Were there ever any issues when your friend wasn't present? Was your friend bit at the same time as the other dog? It sounds like severe resource guarding that was never brought under control from the info here.

2 pits (mom and son) I rescued straight from the euthanasia room were the only dogs of mine to ever have a bad fight. I was a physical wreck afterwards because I had to claw through packed in snow to move a kennel door and drag 2 fighting pits inside before I could do anything. They wouldn't let go of each other no matter what so I ran around to the garage to get something and there was silence. I came back around scared that one was dead but they were both kind of bloody looking at me with the exact same head tilt like "where did you go?" With me at a distance they began to lick each other's wounds. It was a life changing eye opener for me but really horrific to go through.

Very true. In my experience intact males have a shorter fuse but get over it pretty quick. Intact females especially can build to a blow out that is way more intense than you will see with males.

Yep.. both girls were spayed, both crate trained. When my friend is out of the house they would be in their crates. I think my friend got bit when she went in to break up the fight. I don't think the bite to her was intentional.
 
Crating doesn't teach anything, unfortunately. I'm a bit surprised spayed females went at it so hard but it will happen if the warning signals aren't corrected steadily along the way. The guarding becomes a learned behavior that can be retrained. The same thing with males. I push people to s/n early as needed when there are issues because it makes the issues easier to correct.

It's hard to realize and accept when you are the trigger for the fights. It's way more often taken as the 2 dogs can't get along when they can under stable solid leadership. I had to face that I was the trigger because the dogs stopped fighting immediately when I disappeared. I was sincerely deeply terrified that one of my dogs was dead. It was a horrible thing but in a weird way I was lucky in the way mine happened. Prior to it, absolutely nothing could have convinced me I wasn't a super strong confident leader. I advised rescue groups on training and fairly often got calls to help with problems dogs outside of our group. I worked with dogs for years. I would have laughed or been arrogant and nasty if someone told me I would be the cause of my own dogs fighting because of weakness in my leadership.

I've also been bitten by dogs I was trying to help and know what it feels like. Luckily that's been extremely rare but you don't forget it.

I would have taken the dog before I found Duke. The shelter I took him from was closing him for adoption out of fear even though he was so stressed in the shelter he looked concentration campish no matter what they did. He wasn't even allowed out in the shelter's town in a vehicle without a muzzle as he was considered so dangerous. My Duke-a-bunny has come a very long way but isn't 100% yet. For our family we have a one big rehab at a time rule.

I really hope they all recover. Instead of straight euthanasia I'm hoping your friend will consider trying to find someone who can work with her and the dogs or just someone who will work with the dog as an adoption. I feel terrible for all of them. If I had a training or shelter facility instead of just our home, it would be different.
 
Crating doesn't teach anything, unfortunately. I'm a bit surprised spayed females went at it so hard but it will happen if the warning signals aren't corrected steadily along the way. The guarding becomes a learned behavior that can be retrained. The same thing with males. I push people to s/n early as needed when there are issues because it makes the issues easier to correct.

It's hard to realize and accept when you are the trigger for the fights. It's way more often taken as the 2 dogs can't get along when they can under stable solid leadership. I had to face that I was the trigger because the dogs stopped fighting immediately when I disappeared. I was sincerely deeply terrified that one of my dogs was dead. It was a horrible thing but in a weird way I was lucky in the way mine happened. Prior to it, absolutely nothing could have convinced me I wasn't a super strong confident leader. I advised rescue groups on training and fairly often got calls to help with problems dogs outside of our group. I worked with dogs for years. I would have laughed or been arrogant and nasty if someone told me I would be the cause of my own dogs fighting because of weakness in my leadership.

I've also been bitten by dogs I was trying to help and know what it feels like. Luckily that's been extremely rare but you don't forget it.

I would have taken the dog before I found Duke. The shelter I took him from was closing him for adoption out of fear even though he was so stressed in the shelter he looked concentration campish no matter what they did. He wasn't even allowed out in the shelter's town in a vehicle without a muzzle as he was considered so dangerous. My Duke-a-bunny has come a very long way but isn't 100% yet. For our family we have a one big rehab at a time rule.

I really hope they all recover. Instead of straight euthanasia I'm hoping your friend will consider trying to find someone who can work with her and the dogs or just someone who will work with the dog as an adoption. I feel terrible for all of them. If I had a training or shelter facility instead of just our home, it would be different.

There was something wrong with this girls temperament from the get go... It didn't matter if my friend was around or not.... I have a hard time believing that it's some type of learned behavior...

There are many on this site that I consider amazing pack leaders and trainers and I think this would have happened if they were to own this girl. It's hard to explain but I hope that makes sense.
 
Update... Abby was able to leave the vets today.. however she does have 5 drain tubes in..... Benzi got her pretty good... My understanding is that Benzi had no injuries. She is still in quarantine due to the incident being reported. As soon as that ends, she will be put down. My friend is heartbroken but can't take the chance of it happening again or worse yet Benzi attacking a person.
 
It's just better to get help or give the dog to someone who can before things escalate to this. Any situation where the dog is the leader and the person is the follower is dangerous and will progress if not corrected. there is no risk of repeat when the behaviors are corrected. The owner never really gets the full confidence needed and the dog never has the opportunity to change when people don't get the help they need to make it a safe situation.

Not condemning because I have been there. I was lucky to get a clear picture of what the problem was or I never would have believed it was me. You would have had better luck convincing me I was part Martian than getting me to believe I wasn't the confident leader that I and many other people thought I was. I know how hard it is for us to see we are the source of the issue and not the leader. I felt humiliated asking for help to see what I was doing wrong. I never would have done it if not for being presented with such a clear picture of me being the source of the problem.

Sorry it really makes me sad and frustrates me when things don't ever have to reach this level. Just glad 2 of them will be ok.
 
I believe some dogs can not be trained... we need good breeders who does a temperament testing besides health/conformation/etc.
Unfortunately uncontrollable aggression is a very serious problem and it has nothing to do with spaying/neutering.
Very sad indeed...
 
I honestly haven't encountered a dog that can not be trained. Breeding will only go so far. I imagine there are some breeders with a great "what did you do?" frustration with people wanting to return or surrender dogs as problems when they have had no other issues with that litter or several litters.

It's nature vs nurture. Small problems grow to great ones by a series of many little communications that go unaddressed or improperly addressed. It's even worse when people do things they think are cute or ok with puppies that would make them pee their pants to try with an adult dog. My cousin must still disassemble and hide parts of his vacuum because he thought how his pup would fight with the vacuum was fun play as a baby.

Still not condemning anyone. I know how almost impossible it is to change perception from "I'm a great confident leader" to "I am the cause of the problem". I'm not being flippant when I say it was a life changer for me. It would be like a teacher who believes they are the best most devoted teacher going realizing something they've done for years is not beneficial/is harmful to a handful of students. Very difficult for people to see and admit to themselves. Even harder when you really care about the dogs but not really identifying the problem ensures you never really correct the problem.

Spay/neuter does have an effect if done early enough because hormones do help fuel the fire. Leave unaddressed dominance + hormones to spark fires and the aggression more easily becomes a learned behavior when it is repeatedly successful in many small different ways. Hormones alone are not the cause or the total solution but they do make a difference.

I feel terrible for the people involved and the dogs too.
 

Back
Top