Emergency: Newborn Pup Screaming

Caloni - the steps above are what I meant by 'intervention' and the more I think about it, the more I'm sure I'd see if intervention could be staged - starting with local shelters/rescue groups, then maybe law enforcement or local politicans, then (very) last resort an AR group.

Quee This is the problem, she is not breaking the law, you don't have to have animals health tested to breed them, sell them and the such. As long as she is meeting local/state law according to vaccines and care then she is free to be a bad breeder as long as she finds people to buy them then she will continue.

Though it is a travesty the only way there is a legal stop to this is to lose the rights of legitimate breeders which is PETA's goal. They are never the answer, they use any good they might use as ammunition to reinforce that NO ONE should be breeding.

The only thing we can do is educate ignorant breeders, as in Cal situation force her to care for the situation and stand back and let her experience the work that goes with sick puppies, of course if they are being legally neglected then action should be taken but she has had them to the vet so proving legal neglect is probably not going to happen, lastly don't help by selling or helping sell these puppies. It is all we can do because we live in a free country and people can buy, breed and own animals without accountability to anyone but themselves as long as they are providing minimal of care.
 
I would probably call an AR group and probably PETA, to see if they could mobilize an intervention group. They are very good at doing that, and have a wide-ranging reach into communities that can be useful.

Quee - you can never win by getting in bed with the devil. PETA does not rescue dogs they simply make horrifying commercial to see the bleeding hearts. There is not always a good answer to these problems without loosing WAY TOO MUCH. Hopefully she gets stuck with some puppies and it puts her little money scheme out of business.
 
The way I look at it is that you are saving this little girls life by helping out as much as you can when the pup needs it Caloni.
If you step in too far about her breeding practices and jeopardize your friendship at this point there may not be the opportunity to help this pup or the owners at this critical time. I do agree that something needs to be said before they think about trying to breed any more, but I don't think the timing would be good to do it right now.
 
Quee - you can never win by getting in bed with the devil. PETA does not rescue dogs they simply make horrifying commercial to see the bleeding hearts. There is not always a good answer to these problems without loosing WAY TOO MUCH. Hopefully she gets stuck with some puppies and it puts her little money scheme out of business.

Respectfully disagree on that one D4E. Just like we don't want the AR groups throwing everyone under the bus with some of their outrageous statements about breeders, meat eating, fur wearing and the like, I don't think we should do the same to them.

Having worked with some of the local PETA resources on common, on-the-ground issues around animal abuse, I can tell you that not all PETA people are the nut jobs that they appear to be on the national level. Some joined PETA for the sole reason that locally we have lots of animal abuse issues, and they wanted some way to help and this vehicle worked for them. The ones I know personally are passionate about saving animals from true animal abuse issues, and that is their sole focus. There is no end to animal abuse issues here in Chicago, and we need all the help we can get.

I'm very cautious about working with them, but in the last-resort issues where I've had no option but to reach out to them, they have come through and with no other agenda than working with me to resolve the suffering and abuse of the animals involved. If we could just take these PETA folks and clone them to replace the rest of them, it would be a 1000 times better of an organization.
 
Refrained from posting in here so far but I have been following along.
I have to agree with the others here.Without trying to sound harsh or uncaring,if you don't do something about this you will probably be in the situation again.
Some serious soul searching,you must do as to who this person really is and why they're your friend.
Is your friendship worth the bad health of what sounds like dozens of pups already produced as well as the dozens more that will probably be produced?
I don't envy your position,and wish you good luck how ever you decide to deal with it.

She will breed dogs wether I am there or not. There are other people she will call and they will run to her aid either physically or monetarily.
 
Quee This is the problem, she is not breaking the law, you don't have to have animals health tested to breed them, sell them and the such. As long as she is meeting local/state law according to vaccines and care then she is free to be a bad breeder as long as she finds people to buy them then she will continue.

Though it is a travesty the only way there is a legal stop to this is to lose the rights of legitimate breeders which is PETA's goal. They are never the answer, they use any good they might use as ammunition to reinforce that NO ONE should be breeding.

The only thing we can do is educate ignorant breeders, as in Cal situation force her to care for the situation and stand back and let her experience the work that goes with sick puppies, of course if they are being legally neglected then action should be taken but she has had them to the vet so proving legal neglect is probably not going to happen, lastly don't help by selling or helping sell these puppies. It is all we can do because we live in a free country and people can buy, breed and own animals without accountability to anyone but themselves as long as they are providing minimal of care.

Hi,

I think there has to be some middle ground here, although it may not exist today. I'm not in favor of taking anyone's rights away to operate a safe breeder's operation where the animals are well taken care of. But there really should be better regulations in place to not only prevent these BYB's from operating in horrible conditions, but to take animals away from breeders who don't demonstrate a minimum standard of care for the animals or where the operation declines into a truly abusive situation for the animals.

I just don't think letting them suffer until death is a good or ethical option when we know a situation is taking place that we all agree is abusive and causing unnecessary pain and suffering. PETA's draconian stand is not the answer as a whole, but PETA has divisions within it's organization, and at least given those who I've worked with locally, I see a modicum of hope that PETA can change in the long-term and become an organization that works with people and not against them, to get animals the care that they need.

I passionately disagree with PETA on issues like meat-eating, hunting, and fur/leather wearing, but do agree that animals should not be abused and when they're suffering should be helped out of that abusive situation. Yes, it's overkill and unethical to appeal to bleeding hearts in national ads featuring suffering animals, only to use that money for endeavors to outlaw any animal use of any sort, but that's a national level campaign, and I've found at least where I live, the local agenda is very different.
 
She will breed dogs wether I am there or not. There are other people she will call and they will run to her aid either physically or monetarily.
All the more reason that I see this like JanS. You walk a fine line here and I hate to think where this pup would be if you were not able to be there to help. It sucks that you have to play this game with your friend but that seems to be what it will take to properly care for this baby for now. Once all this is settled I'd definitely recommend that serious heart-to-heart.
 
I just discovered this website today...just wondering, what happened to the puppy they named Angel?

Hi and welcome to the forum. We'd love to meet you so please say hi and introduce yourself by creating a thread in the Introduction Section of the forum. :) We are a nice bunch here and like to get to know one another and their furry friends!
 
Update: Angel is 8 weeks TODAY. She was supposed to be placed in a forever home, but without going into details, that fell through. She will be a lot of responsibility for the new owner whoever that may be. Hopefully it will be someone with special needs dog experience....but that is up to my friend. Her care is out of my hands at this point. I have taken the advice of many an experienced dog owners from this site to back off helping out and leave my friend to care for the pup on her own. As much as it burns a hole in my heart to not help out this puppy I understand the lesson that will hopefully be learned in doing so.....to be a responsible breeder :(

Angel is still having some troubles walking with getting wobbly when she is tired or first waking up. But she can RUN across the room and dive for toys when she really wants to get going. She does much better on carpet or rug areas than the hard wood floors....but that's self explanatory. She finally started eating canned puppy food this past week and is dabbling a bit here and there with the hard food in between feedings.....but she is eating it all on her own which is a HUGE step for this pup. No more syringe feedings...THANK GOD!

It is now up to my friend, the breeder and current owner of Angel to decide what happens. If you would like to give her a good home and can come and get her there will be no charge, but you must provide vet references and at least 2 personal references please. She has been to a vet 1-2 times a week. So you will get all that paperwork along wtih her and her things. Preference is that she goes to a home with doberman experience at the LEAST, but hopefully we will be able to find someone that has some experience with special needs dogs.

PM me if you want more information and I will put you in touch with the breeder.
 
so glad to hear this little angel made it this far, and I hope that she finds her way into a new home with someone that understands and can provide for her needs!
 
If you would like to give her a good home and can come and get her there will be no charge, but you must provide vet references and at least 2 personal references please. She has been to a vet 1-2 times a week. So you will get all that paperwork along wtih her and her things. Preference is that she goes to a home with doberman experience at the LEAST, but hopefully we will be able to find someone that has some experience with special needs dogs.

Cal I didn't mean to be harsh to you, I know your going above and beyond trying to help. I am serious about taking her. We have another couple of months on this lease then we will be in a regular house and if she is still needing a home I will take her. I cringe at the thought of her going to a shelter because she needs special care and we already live with Tasha's issues so one more will just make it a party.
If T & B mom is still able to, I can't think of a more qualified person to give this girl the special care she needs.
 
If T & B mom is still able to, I can't think of a more qualified person to give this girl the special care she needs.
She backed out last night and I have not got a reason from her why, but I understand that it is her decision. Again, I am not the breeder so I don't have all the information. I have enough going on, I would completely loose my sanity if I had to deal with breeding! LOL
 
It was the only way to get her the continued medical care she needed. They are also able to provide someone all day to watch and take care of her....so no more leaving her at home while someone is at work all day. This particular rescue has a lot of experience with special needs and a lot of contacts with specialists....and the budget to pay for them. They may have already found a vet tech to adopt her.

Her first visit was to a general vet, then she will be going to a Neurologist, Orthopedic Surgeon, eye specialist, and x-rays just to check everything out. They really cover their bases.
 

Back
Top