Well for me what you failed to answer is this and excuse me but I will be very blunt - It was a misquote (to put it nicely ) about waiting til 3 do know about hips so I should listen to someone who is obviously an AR activitist and will resort to any means to promote their own agenda???? I think not. I at lease want to deal with honesty as I have found you make the best decisions if you are dealing with truthful information.
I really don't know what you're saying. My quote: "
Over 3 years, it'd seem like there's a better chance of being able to evaluate the dog for the first signs of congenital disease such as bad hips or heart defect, know the temperament is settled-in, and the other little things that differentiate "good breeding stock" from "capable of producing offspring". Not hips specifically, but rather hips for example, along with everything else. Kindly don't try to muddy the waters by taking generic examples out of context and trying to make them specific, thanks.
I absolutely do not believe in animal rights, I believe in animal welfare, but not to the point that it interferes with the usual things people do with pets and livestock. I'm trying to illustrate how you are deliberately muddying the waters to try to protect ethically-challenged breeders or potential veterinary malpractice.
Put in the simplest terms, it appears that you're hiding behind a series of incompatible arguments to justify an anything-goes circus.
You can't claim that nobody should second-guess someone who is doing things that are "allowed", and then come up with creative definitions for what "allowed" really means based on suggestions that some clubs put out there, but that aren't enforced at all. Will the AKC register, and the DCPA recognize, litters from a bitch bred on every heat, despite that being a bad practice?
Then it is allowed. It is not a grey area. If it's a bad practice that is technically allowed, but is discouraged, it's worthy of criticism-- criticism is, after all, direct discouragement done by people rather than some guideline written in a booklet.
Is this a wall of mutual protection for breeders to protect yourselves and the practices you hold dear? Is it a professional courtesy? Are you concerned someone is going to second-guess what you do? The first two are pretty bad ideas, you will lose every time if you shield the bad apples. They stink to high heaven and people know they're there and are going to be outraged. It's not like they're even fazed by criticism in the first place, do you really think that z-factor breeder or the kennel that folks were criticizing in a thread a few weeks ago for overbreeding their bitches actually care about their reputations if they're going to publicize their behavior online for all to see? You can't shame someone who has no shame. You're protecting and giving the benefit of the doubt to people who are so bad that they simply don't care.
As for the latter, I'm going to say you have nothing to worry about. You could take a few risks and gambles that might not be universally-recognized best practices and nobody is going to rake you over the coals unless you do it excessively and unrepentantly. That you know what the best, ethical practices generally are and take them seriously would indicate that you aren't anywhere near the same category as the others.
But this is what I don't get; you hold "BYBs" in utter contempt and criticize them up one side and down the other, yet they mostly follow allowed (if not occasionally even good) practices, and you defend allowed practices and say that there are no absolute rules and allowed practices shouldn't be criticized. Sometimes it seems from your statements that the only way you're differentiating "BYBs" who are scum of the Earth from "reputable breeders" who are above reproach, is that the former give their customers a choice between cropping and/or docking, and the latter force the choice upon their customers to "uphold the breed standard", and not necessarily even using the best veterinarians or methods in doing so.