• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

Holy shit kaloric,you sound just like one of the bosses at work.I hear him say this to many people there...."failing to plan is planning to fail":DThere is some truth to that.!!

Yeah, I've been to a few "motivational" meetings too many at the place I worked a few years back.

If only the upper management folks would take their own good advice! At least the place I work now is short on the pithy slogans and better at actually getting stuff done.
 
An appropriate response would not be to exclude all carriers, but to only grant them limited registrations so they can't have their progeny registered. Is that really too much to ask?

Since you wern't around you did not know but DPCA fought long and hard to not have them reg at all but AKC said they were purebred and AKC wanted the money for reg as that is their business. DPCA had to settle for the Z designation and started their white out program. So you are blaming them for things that you do not have the correct facts on.

But the majority and especially the members of DPCA are NOT ALBINO breeders - they are very much against it. So I don't get throwing out the albino issue when your statement was breeders don't care about health. I was also breeding and raising Quarter horses and Paints during that time and stood a Reserve World Ch Calf Roping horse who we campaigned his 2nd year and ended his first year campaign as 5th in the Nation in calf roping, heading (7th) heeling 5th and steer stopping 5th. He was also less than 10 points from Superiors in each catagory. While some people did continue to breed Impressive the horses were required to be tested and hhpp neg. While some bred them i was not that involved with it as I did not have any horses that carried Impressive bloodline as ours were performance horses. But I do remember people trying to keep the good things by testing and getting to rid of neg.

It's a difficult situation, since it's hard for anyone to compare notes and determine if there's a problem without theorizing and trying to put together data points that aren't all that easy to find

Kaloric that is the very point much is Theorizing and trying to get data that proves what you say - No on can make solid decisions on theories and rumors. Only cold hard facts will give absolute answers.

Well, back on topic, I'm obviously with DV here-- shrugging off a trivial part of a breed standard isn't as detrimental to the breed we care about as knowingly propagating congenital defects.

I strongly disagree - Compromising on any part of the breed standard is detrimental to any breed and since you admit much of what you are upset about are theories and innuendos I don't see how it can hold much water. The standard is in black and white and its purpose is clear in its mission statement - to protect and perserve. It is about producing the best specimen and show and competing. Health is a completely separate issue and without answer anyones guess is as good as any other but there is plenty of solid statistics to tell us our breed has a very small gene pool and diminishing it further by bad mouthing people for things they have no answers for is not going to help anyone one or our breed.
 
I'm just going to make my quick entry and exit:

YES, dogs are dropping dead left and right in certain parts of the world. When I was looking through a bunch of pedigrees (meaning A LOT) from the European lines while trying to decide on which ones I wanted (and definitely didn't want) in my next pup, it was not uncommon to encounter lines with grandparents, great-grandparents and parents dropping dead at age 4-6. In all three generations. And yet people keep breeding these dogs because they want a beautiful dog first and foremost, who cares if it's only around for 5 or so years. It makes me sick.

From what I've read, the US situation isn't that bad, and I know it isn't in Australia after going through the database and looking at lifespans. Just putting that out there, now I'll leave you all to continue the C&D debate.

The situation here as bad as in Europe. I know the entire Doberman litter (local breeding) dropped dead at age of 5-6 in Calgary.
Unfortunately NA Doberquest database is not complete. Doberman Review gives you much more information.
 
Since you wern't around you did not know but DPCA fought long and hard to not have them reg at all but AKC said they were purebred and AKC wanted the money for reg as that is their business. DPCA had to settle for the Z designation and started their white out program. So you are blaming them for things that you do not have the correct facts on.

Fair enough, but it seems like there's still a problem when the official breed registrar is more concerned with money than a serious health issue, so shame on the AKC. It hurts them in the long run when they fail to do the right thing.

Health is a completely separate issue and without answer anyones guess is as good as any other but there is plenty of solid statistics to tell us our breed has a very small gene pool and diminishing it further by bad mouthing people for things they have no answers for is not going to help anyone one or our breed.

Health is not a separate issue. It's just often not easy to set a functional standard for, so the details are left up to breeder responsibility. Responsible breed studbooks do what is feasible. Several elements of conformation are basically health issues that are visible to the naked eye and quantifiable, such as bad dentition and obvious genetic defects such as albinism being expressed. I also recall something about the German studbook for German Shepherds requiring OFA grade-a hips in all breeding stock, and they require screening so oblivious ignorance was not an option. Branding serious congenital diseases that trace down a specific lineage and imposing registration limitations is somewhat of a health standard, too.

People who choose to run breeding programs are accountable to the breed, they're accountable to their customers, and most importantly, they're accountable to the animals they produce. It's not simple bad-mouthing to notice there seems to be a worrisome trend in the health of a kennel's progeny, or something of concern in a pedigree or breeding record and talk about it. Whether it's a potential DCM issue, a kennel that inadvertently discloses that they're breeding a z-factor (and gets criticized, and then stops disclosing that openly), a kennel that seems to be breeding bitches too young and on every heat cycle, or a kennel which uses a veterinarian who is not following best humane practices with c/d procedures, which are all things that I've noticed popping-up in threads on here in the past month or two. If the evidence shows diligence and competence in the breeder, the worries will be dismissed as unfounded, and actual dirty laundry will be aired-out and cleaned-up.
 
Whether it's a potential DCM issue, a kennel that inadvertently discloses that they're breeding a z-factor (and gets criticized, and then stops disclosing that openly), a kennel that seems to be breeding bitches too young and on every heat cycle, or a kennel which uses a veterinarian who is not following best humane practices with c/d procedures, which are all things that I've noticed popping-up in threads on here in the past month or two. If the evidence shows diligence and competence in the breeder, the worries will be dismissed as unfounded, and actual dirty laundry will be aired-out and cleaned-up.

Really??? First I believe 100% in being open and honest but the gripe was that breeders were poluting the pool with unhealthy dogs - so I don't see dragging in the albino factor as NO responsible breeder would even touch the z factor that is a whole different issue. Breeding bitches too young - well I think we have to be very careful here and try to adhere to the COE guidelines - of 18 months and while you and I consider that young it is not wrong per the guidelines.

I do feel there are way too many trying to impose their own personal guidelines on everyone without anything to back it up which for me would be a trust issue. I don't trust people who do not tell you the actual guidelines and then explain why theirs might be different. I usually wait til 3 to breed but that does not mean I can make someone else bad because they breed at 18 months. And it does notmean that there might come the time again that I breed at 2.

Again we were talking about health and how bad breeders are to hide the unknown and unidentifiable prior to the problem raising its head and suddenly now it includes albinos, breeding too young and breeding every cycle and you and I both know the the vast majority of good breeders don't do any of that stuff so when you try to paint a very wide brush you get caught in a trap of misunderstanding and misleading. While I might not like all the guidelines I do not have the right to criticize someone who is within those gidelines.

I certainly know many many great breeders - we don't all agree on everything but we are all working hard to breed the magical mythical dog that you refer to.

I certainly don't want to be blamed for some vet who might still use a strange method to me in posting ears following surgery. While we have challenges and we have things we hope to improve without the proper testing and tools as you stated earlier it is still a lot of luck in breeding. So I feel it is very unfair to paint everyone as bad just because someone is upset about something.

I would like to read the post on poor vet practices. Usually it is a new person who bought from a breeder who did not do their job and crop their puppies and they don't know what they are actually looking at and don't understand the after care of surgery. That certainly can't be laid at vets feet.
 
Really??? First I believe 100% in being open and honest but the gripe was that breeders were poluting the pool with unhealthy dogs - so I don't see dragging in the albino factor as NO responsible breeder would even touch the z factor that is a whole different issue. Breeding bitches too young - well I think we have to be very careful here and try to adhere to the COE guidelines - of 18 months and while you and I consider that young it is not wrong per the guidelines.

I do feel there are way too many trying to impose their own personal guidelines on everyone without anything to back it up which for me would be a trust issue. I don't trust people who do not tell you the actual guidelines and then explain why theirs might be different. I usually wait til 3 to breed but that does not mean I can make someone else bad because they breed at 18 months. And it does notmean that there might come the time again that I breed at 2

I would pretty much unequivocally say that breeding (dog or bitch) prior to 3 is irresponsible. Would the animal have demonstrated itself to be sufficient quality to use in a breeding program by that point?

I'm not necessarily even talking about titles earned, I'm pretty sure you won't be finding an animal to have distinguished itself in any way by 18 months, they're not even out of their adolescent phase at that point. Over 3 years, it'd seem like there's a better chance of being able to evaluate the dog for the first signs of congenital disease such as bad hips or heart defect, know the temperament is settled-in, and the other little things that differentiate "good breeding stock" from "capable of producing offspring". The CoE guidelines may be only considering the health of the bitch, but it surely doesn't consider the health or quality she'll contribute to the breed.

As you say, there's nothing hard-and-fast, some animals can distinguish themselves young, some are mediocre or poor into old age. When it appears someone is running an upscale puppy mill, though, it's worth questioning. People who don't want the scrutiny of their methods or having to answer criticism probably should probably not be in the breeding business/hobby.

I certainly don't want to be blamed for some vet who might still use a strange method to me in posting ears following surgery. While we have challenges and we have things we hope to improve without the proper testing and tools as you stated earlier it is still a lot of luck in breeding. So I feel it is very unfair to paint everyone as bad just because someone is upset about something.

I would like to read the post on poor vet practices. Usually it is a new person who bought from a breeder who did not do their job and crop their puppies and they don't know what they are actually looking at and don't understand the after care of surgery. That certainly can't be laid at vets feet.

You posted to the thread I was referring to ("Should we take them to court?"), it was the one with the willful z-factor breeder who, from the screenshot of her FB page, seemed almost proud and excited she was breeding z-factors as if it's a selling point, and who also continued to patronize the vet who was using the stringing method of posting for litter after litter. Those choices seem to be rather regrettable. I wasn't entirely clear if the breeder in question was even offering any meaningful post-purchase support or advice, or if Sothsenes just didn't trust her judgment enough to ask, which seems fair enough too.

Something to think about, since this is a c/d thread, why shouldn't the breeder be dinged with criticism over how the vet handled the procedure or how inept the presumably-screened buyer was at after care that resulted in complications, most likely because said buyer just wasn't adequately trained in proper aftercare? If it was the breeder's choice that the crop was performed prior to sale, which vet performed the crop, how that vet performed the crop (after all, it's due diligence to talk to the vet beforehand to know what they're going to do), and who the pup with an incompletely-healed crop & post was sold to, who's responsible for those choices?
 
I would pretty much unequivocally say that breeding (dog or bitch) prior to 3 is irresponsible.
I understand, but if it is s allowed which it is, you can't call someone irrepsonsible without a lot more information. For example a new first time breeder has no clue what they are doing yet a breeder who works, trains and shows their dogs would have a lot more information and background to base their decision on.

In fact a very well know top breeder just did such a breeding of a 7 year old bitch to an 18 month old male. He knows his bloodlines and he knows he is at the window for the bitch - he has the right to make that decision, he must have that right to pursue and match two dogs that he feels are very important to his program. He has the knowledge and history AND freedom to make that decision.

If we were talking about someone new in the breed buying two unknown dogs and breeding them prior to 2 I would say this is definitely rushing and not prudent, but it is allowed.

at 3 years, it'd seem like there's a better chance of being able to evaluate the dog for the first signs of congenital disease such as bad hips or heart defect, know the temperament is settled-in, and the other little things

Kaloric your statement on hips is confusing since we all know you can do OFA at 2 and Penn hip at any age so why are you trying to say 3 for hips???? Many of the things that crops up doesn't crop up til 5 or older. Breeders are like artist - they have to have the freedom to create their visions of the standard. And since c/d is a part of that standard we can throw it in.

But when we try to mislead people with statements like the 3 on hips we begin to tip to the wrong side. Wheter we personally like it or not we do not have the right to try to bind our own personal feelings and opinions on someone else and mislead them.

While you and I might not approve of the stringing of the ears it is not necessarily bad vet practices but we certainly would choose a different method.

why shouldn't the breeder be dinged with criticism over how the vet handled the procedure or how inept the presumably-screened buyer was at after care that resulted in complications, most likely because said buyer just wasn't adequately trained in proper aftercare? If it was the breeder's choice that the crop was performed prior to sale, which vet performed the crop, how that vet performed the crop (after all, it's due diligence to talk to the vet beforehand to know what they're going to do), and who the pup with an incompletely-healed crop & post was sold to, who's responsible for those choices?

The breeder was dinged just for breeding Z factored and not being honest, we all agreed we did not like the stringing of the ears and we all agreed the OP did not know what he was doing. I could have jumped on the band wagon about how terrible the tail dock was but it looked pretty normal with the only problem the puppy obviously popped a stitch so it left a small imperfection that most likely the hair will cover as the dog grows.

Just because I don't like the breeders practices does not mean I should lie and slam her for something that could happen to anyone of our puppies. A cyst on an ear is not totally unusual and it certainly is not indicative of poor ear cropping - Some dogs develop them while most don't. Should I stretch the truth and try to make it sound worse than it is???? The ears were standing nicely so the OP did a decent job of aftercare. Too many times we make a mountain out of a mole hill and are always looking to lay blame where no blame belongs.

Actually I am glad she cropped the puppies - at least that was right and to the standard. The standard describes the perfect Doberman we all want to breed as we eliminated health issues once we have absolute positive ways to do so.
 
I understand, but if it is s allowed which it is, you can't call someone irrepsonsible without a lot more information.

Oh, yes I can. There's a massive difference between "allowed" and a "best practice" or even a "reasonably sensible" practice. After all, it's "allowed" to breed z-factors if it suits you, breed a bitch on every heat, and a host of other things that are simply left up to the breeders' discretion no matter what their level of competence is.

I don't really care what people's rationalizations are for doing wrong things. One poor judgment tends to lead to another. If a breeding program is so ineptly operated that it's going to be breeding immature and undistinguished animals to avoid missing windows, that's haphazard breeding and rolling the dice. It's no different than what BYBs do, except the ego and profit motive involved is much larger than a hobbyist. The results are likely to be about the same, some successes, some failures.

Kaloric your statement on hips is confusing since we all know you can do OFA at 2 and Penn hip at any age so why are you trying to say 3 for hips???? Many of the things that crops up doesn't crop up til 5 or older. Breeders are like artist - they have to have the freedom to create their visions of the standard. And since c/d is a part of that standard we can throw it in.

Hips are only one of the examples I mentioned of things to look for. The earliest onsets of DCM generally aren't until 2 or 3. Also, 18 months is still 6 months short of "2 years old". You can't rush quality, and another component of quality is being quick to discard failures even if you've waited a long time to see if they are going to pan out. Personally, I would probably not consider it proper to put animals into a serious breeding program before the age of 5 or so. A breeding program is a long game. Perhaps the lack of patience in the dog fancy is why purebreds are so diseased and suffer from longevity problems, that would explain much. That's not as much of a problem in animal husbandry for other purebred domesticated species.

While you and I might not approve of the stringing of the ears it is not necessarily bad vet practices but we certainly would choose a different method.

I've heard this argument before on an array of different things, and I just really don't buy it. It is too often used to rationalize not standing-up against wrongdoing and just mind one's own business. Fortunately, there have been many ethicists who have gone out on a limb to criticize the status quo and work to change what's acceptable and what's not. A whole lot of brutality against animals used to be accepted, but we've done better by them (and therefore ourselves) and don't tolerate people abusing them, even when it comes to slaughter, which aside from halal and kosher, we demand is done in a humane manner. Hopefully halal and kosher slaughter will be banned soon, too.

Just because I don't like the breeders practices does not mean I should lie and slam her for something that could happen to anyone of our puppies. A cyst on an ear is not totally unusual and it certainly is not indicative of poor ear cropping - Some dogs develop them while most don't. Should I stretch the truth and try to make it sound worse than it is???? The ears were standing nicely so the OP did a decent job of aftercare. Too many times we make a mountain out of a mole hill and are always looking to lay blame where no blame belongs.

Actually I am glad she cropped the puppies - at least that was right and to the standard. The standard describes the perfect Doberman we all want to breed as we eliminated health issues once we have absolute positive ways to do so.

An infected crop couldn't have happened to my puppy, and a cyst would've been pretty unusual-- just saying. If that sort of botching of procedures "could happen to any one of our puppies", I would say that's evidence of a problem. Either there's simply not a best practice because they're all pretty bad and complication-prone, or the best practice isn't being followed in ear cropping on a larger scale. If Sosthenes' experience with so many problems related to the ears isn't malpractice and wasn't just freakishly bad luck, I'll have to change my tune slightly here and suggest the issue of cropping really does warrant much more scrutiny on the grounds of animal welfare and perhaps Europe is just a few years ahead of us in their exclusions. I am only able to support the choice to crop if it's a humane practice, which means it doesn't inflict excessive or prolonged unnecessary discomfort on the animals.
 
Oh, yes I can. There's a massive difference between "allowed" and a "best practice" or even a "reasonably sensible" practice. After all, it's "allowed" to breed z-factors if it suits you, breed a bitch on every heat, and a host of other things that are simply left up to the breeders' discretion no matter what their level of competence is.

Well for me what you failed to answer is this and excuse me but I will be very blunt - It was a misquote (to put it nicely ) about waiting til 3 do know about hips so I should listen to someone who is obviously an AR activitist and will resort to any means to promote their own agenda???? I think not. I at lease want to deal with honesty as I have found you make the best decisions if you are dealing with truthful information.

And here you go again
- Its allowed to breed z factors -
Not by DCPA - true AKC does not stop it but they do support breeding only genetically healthy animals so they go against their own rules IMHO.

Again you speak as if it is allowed to breed a bitch on every heat cycle when it is not approved in either AKC or DPCA or other breed clubs. It is true people can do it and puppy mills are certainly known to do it but you try to paint everyone in the same corner and that is not right.

If you are so mad at everything then do something about it instead of spouting half truths and innuendos. A good place to start is helping educated people on the basic rules = the real rules not your rules. They will come much closer to listening to you if you are more open and honest about how things really work.
 
Well for me what you failed to answer is this and excuse me but I will be very blunt - It was a misquote (to put it nicely ) about waiting til 3 do know about hips so I should listen to someone who is obviously an AR activitist and will resort to any means to promote their own agenda???? I think not. I at lease want to deal with honesty as I have found you make the best decisions if you are dealing with truthful information.

I really don't know what you're saying. My quote: "Over 3 years, it'd seem like there's a better chance of being able to evaluate the dog for the first signs of congenital disease such as bad hips or heart defect, know the temperament is settled-in, and the other little things that differentiate "good breeding stock" from "capable of producing offspring". Not hips specifically, but rather hips for example, along with everything else. Kindly don't try to muddy the waters by taking generic examples out of context and trying to make them specific, thanks. :)

I absolutely do not believe in animal rights, I believe in animal welfare, but not to the point that it interferes with the usual things people do with pets and livestock. I'm trying to illustrate how you are deliberately muddying the waters to try to protect ethically-challenged breeders or potential veterinary malpractice.

Put in the simplest terms, it appears that you're hiding behind a series of incompatible arguments to justify an anything-goes circus.

You can't claim that nobody should second-guess someone who is doing things that are "allowed", and then come up with creative definitions for what "allowed" really means based on suggestions that some clubs put out there, but that aren't enforced at all. Will the AKC register, and the DCPA recognize, litters from a bitch bred on every heat, despite that being a bad practice? Then it is allowed. It is not a grey area. If it's a bad practice that is technically allowed, but is discouraged, it's worthy of criticism-- criticism is, after all, direct discouragement done by people rather than some guideline written in a booklet.

Is this a wall of mutual protection for breeders to protect yourselves and the practices you hold dear? Is it a professional courtesy? Are you concerned someone is going to second-guess what you do? The first two are pretty bad ideas, you will lose every time if you shield the bad apples. They stink to high heaven and people know they're there and are going to be outraged. It's not like they're even fazed by criticism in the first place, do you really think that z-factor breeder or the kennel that folks were criticizing in a thread a few weeks ago for overbreeding their bitches actually care about their reputations if they're going to publicize their behavior online for all to see? You can't shame someone who has no shame. You're protecting and giving the benefit of the doubt to people who are so bad that they simply don't care.

As for the latter, I'm going to say you have nothing to worry about. You could take a few risks and gambles that might not be universally-recognized best practices and nobody is going to rake you over the coals unless you do it excessively and unrepentantly. That you know what the best, ethical practices generally are and take them seriously would indicate that you aren't anywhere near the same category as the others.

But this is what I don't get; you hold "BYBs" in utter contempt and criticize them up one side and down the other, yet they mostly follow allowed (if not occasionally even good) practices, and you defend allowed practices and say that there are no absolute rules and allowed practices shouldn't be criticized. Sometimes it seems from your statements that the only way you're differentiating "BYBs" who are scum of the Earth from "reputable breeders" who are above reproach, is that the former give their customers a choice between cropping and/or docking, and the latter force the choice upon their customers to "uphold the breed standard", and not necessarily even using the best veterinarians or methods in doing so.
 
Is this a wall of mutual protection for breeders to protect yourselves and the practices you hold dear? Is it a professional courtesy? Are you concerned someone is going to second-guess what you do? The first two are pretty bad ideas, you will lose every time if you shield the bad apples. They stink to high heaven and people know they're there and are going to be outraged. It's not like they're even fazed by criticism in the first place, do you really think that z-factor breeder or the kennel that folks were criticizing in a thread a few weeks ago for overbreeding their bitches actually care about their reputations if they're going to publicize their behavior online for all to see? You can't shame someone who has no shame. You're protecting and giving the benefit of the doubt to people who are so bad that they simply don't care.

This is one thing that really pisses me off concerning breeders. I know it's unprofessional to purposely badmouth other breeders, but sometimes you've got to just call an orange an orange. If you start to call it a quasi-orange or something like that, people start to get confused and the line between reputable breeder and BYB becomes ever so fine. It is especially the big name breeders who have produced a few famous dogs that get let off the hook when it comes to criticism. That is wrong, because it tells people that if you're famous you can get away with anything (much like in any sphere... ahem). For example, kennels such as Altobello produce many famous dogs and sell their dogs to infamous BYBs as well. But do they get the rap for it? No, the entire blame goes to the BYB. Why would a famous kennel like Altobello sell dogs with full registration (or sell dogs at all) to these kinds of people? For profit. Pure and simple. There seems to be a pattern: a kennel gains some fame after producing a particular dog, and starts to expand. Eventually, they're producing the at the same rate as regular puppy mills (or close to it), but they are excused because they've produced some famous dogs. And then there's some kind of unspoken censorship that starts to come into effect.

Why should there be a difference made if we're talking about animal welfare? Reputation seems to be at times confined to name. What ever happened to caring about all aspects of the dog (or product, in their case)? The aspect of health might not be written in the standard, but these standards were written years ago, when the technology did not exist. That does not mean that practices established in the early 1900s are acceptable today. We could relate this to slavery and the Apartheid and so on, and get really anal... but the point is, if the breed clubs care, and if the kennel clubs care, then there should be rules enforced. Not by the general public/government - by the organizations involved themselves. I know that, for example, a bitch bred more than a certain amount of times and over a particular age cannot have litters registered in some countries, but these rules do not apply for example, to imports. Breed the bitch in a country with lax legislation, and then bring the litter back and register it as normal, because technically the pups were not whelped in the country. Quite a few well known European kennels only test hips (probably because it's the only thing required, if at all, just like the ZTP...how is that in any way acceptable? I don't care if they produced sire x, dam z etc. I'd like a dog that has a chance of living at least an average lifespan.

And don't even get me started on how the ZTP is a joke in terms of conformation... I posted some disgusting examples of "breeding stock" on the American vs Euro thread who had all passed the ZTP. If all the dog needs to do is have decent hips, an acceptable temperament and be identifiable as a Dobermann (even if it looks worse than a BYB specimen), then where exactly is this "breed standard" going?
 
Over 3 years, it'd seem like there's a better chance of being able to evaluate the dog for the first signs of congenital disease such as bad hips or heart defect

Hips again can be OFA'd at 2 and young if you use Pen Hip so are you saying wait til 3 to OFA??? Many heart murmurs can be detected in a young puppy before it ever leaves for its home. Not all but you certainly don't have to wait til 3. According to Dr. Meurs most cardio manifest itself after 4 - 5 years of age so I do not put a lot of fait in a test that might not be accurate as far as the reall info I need. I do feel there are some breeders that use it as a marketing tool to make people think their dog is cardio clear and they advertise as such.

Then it is allowed. It is not a grey area. If it's a bad practice that is technically allowed, but is discouraged, it's worthy of criticism-- criticism is, after all, direct discouragement done by people rather than some guideline written in a booklet.

Would you agree there is a big difference between what a knowledgable involved breeder might do occassionally and what a BYB does on a regular basis??? And believe you me we have critized many for things that are allowed and certainly the Z breeders are shunned by everyone, But I don't think we can blame everyone or make it sound like all are bad just becvause there are some bad apples.

But this is what I don't get; you hold "BYBs" in utter contempt and criticize them up one side and down the other, yet they mostly follow allowed (if not occasionally even good) practices, and you defend allowed practices and say that there are no absolute rules and allowed practices shouldn't be criticized.

First I don't hold BYB's in utter contempt - some are on their way to learning as as they join groups or get to know people some have gone on to correct things and get more involved and work to do things more correctly. What I hate is the when people are told lies about the puppies they purchase that are not true because the person breeding does not know what they are doing, the Albino breeder who does not tell a new person up front what Z factor means and that it is banned by its own breed club. I think it is a slap in the face that they often charge more for puppies and they don't even crop them but dump it on the new person to sturggle with. I bet if the albino breeders did explain things they would not be able to sell their wares. It is dishonesty on any level that I don't like and the person referred to earlier has said the same thing on several forums over a couple years and did not make the changes she said she would make. I think now she has stopped breeding her Z dogs, but once you openly lie about things I am not sure you ever can repair the damage because I think lying goes to the heart of character.

Is this a wall of mutual protection for breeders to protect yourselves and the practices you hold dear? Is it a professional courtesy? Are you concerned someone is going to second-guess what you do? The first two are pretty bad ideas, you will lose every time if you shield the bad apples.

I persoanlly have not experienced this. I have many top breeder friends I e mail and ask questions and for their opinon on certain things when stuff like this is said and we all openly share info. I have never had anyone refuse to respond or answer my questions. As in all things there will be "some" who give everyone a black eye. Idon't see it any worse than the rumor mill who has convinced everyone that breeders are bad. That is AR agenda all the way and we must stick together to better educated JQP on sound breeding practices and why it is how it is. Not feed the grapevine with our own personal dislikes and opinions.

In the end we probably agree on moer than we disagree on but we approach it very differently and I don't think to quote something as the only way is good for the public understand as they understand way to little about the world of the purebred dog and they know even less about genetics and breeding.
 
. Eventually, they're producing the at the same rate as regular puppy mills (or close to it), but they are excused because they've produced some famous dogs. And then there's some kind of unspoken censorship that starts to come into effect.

Ataro this is a very hard question and I can only give you my take on it. First and foremost Altobello - shows, trains and test his dogs - Puppy mills don't. Their dogs are well cared for and the biggest problem with puppy mills is the don't take good care of their dogs. So it is wrong to try to lump them together as you hurt the purebreed dog world when one feels that way. It really should not be ab out quanity but quality and care.

Numbers of dogs produced is not the problem but quality of care - that is where the puppy mills fall down big time. So you are comparing your quasi-orange and painting the wrong picture. That is another big point on how the AR groups are turning us all against one another and they are winning on misrepresentation becasue JQP who does not understand even the bare basics of breeding bases their info on false info.

If you start to call it a quasi-orange or something like that, people start to get confused and the line between reputable breeder and BYB becomes ever so fine. It is especially the big name breeders who have produced a few famous dogs that get let off the hook when it comes to criticism.

So I do not see the line blurring when you understand the vast differences between how things are done between the two.

And don't even get me started on how the ZTP is a joke in terms of conformation... I posted some disgusting examples of "breeding stock" on the American vs Euro thread who had all passed the ZTP. If all the dog needs to do is have decent hips, an acceptable temperament and be identifiable as a Dobermann (even if it looks worse than a BYB specimen), then where exactly is this "breed standard" going?

Ataro there will always be those who try to circummvent the system. But truly good breeders work to stay focused on the standard as their guide in what they produce. Because they work and show their dogs they have a much better understanding but there will always be the Johnny come latelies that blow in and then just as quckly disappear.

There is no system that is perfect and unless you come up with a better system then what would you have everyone do??? We all know that there are flaws in breedering, breeders, trials, ZTP, health testing and on and on but should we destroy the entire world of purbred dogs to solve the problems or should we try to work with what we have and do our part to make it better???

What is the answer - education - look at all the avenuse that JQP has right now at their finger tips and then read the threads on is this a good breeder??? Look at all the folks who come on forums and have problems and bought from someone who did not know what they were doing. So education is not working evidenlty but does that mean we should give up??? I think not.

I think we have to use a little common sense and I think we have to be reasonable. I do not think it helps anyone and certainly not the dogs when we try to shove everyone into the same small square box. Breeding and genetics is not a black and whte sport and that is why I say it is not for the faint of heart.

What no one seems to ever want to talk about is all the genetic research breed clubs and breeders are supporting. Why not, because it is much easier to sit back and scream foul without any info or to buy into the rumors and innuendos. Honesty goes both ways.
 
Hips again can be OFA'd at 2 and young if you use Pen Hip so are you saying wait til 3 to OFA??? Many heart murmurs can be detected in a young puppy before it ever leaves for its home. Not all but you certainly don't have to wait til 3. According to Dr. Meurs most cardio manifest itself after 4 - 5 years of age so I do not put a lot of fait in a test that might not be accurate as far as the reall info I need. I do feel there are some breeders that use it as a marketing tool to make people think their dog is cardio clear and they advertise as such.

Again, I was generalizing with examples. I could use other examples, like epilepsy, which often doesn't manifest within the first few years. There are even some things that aren't technically health problems that sometimes you have to just keep an eye on and it takes some time, such as being accident-prone. Anyway, I see that the AKC allows litters to be registered from dams over 8 months and sires over 7. Even though that's allowed, it's beyond a horrible practice. 18 months is what you noted the DCPA recommendation is. That's more reasonable, but still on the short side. 2 years as you mentioned is better, but as I said, if I was in the business, I"d probably wait until after 3, and more likely even longer simply because that's proportional in age to what I felt best practices were in horses.

Would you agree there is a big difference between what a knowledgable involved breeder might do occassionally and what a BYB does on a regular basis??? And believe you me we have critized many for things that are allowed and certainly the Z breeders are shunned by everyone, But I don't think we can blame everyone or make it sound like all are bad just becvause there are some bad apples.

I'm not blaming or criticizing everyone, I was only saying that it's reasonable to call-out folks who seem to be behaving badly, treating their bitches & puppies badly, treating their customers badly, and treating the breed badly. Harkening back to Sosthenes' thread, I think one of the take-aways is that sometimes breeders don't realize what they're getting into with a new vet, like the one whose photo was borrowed for the illustration of stringing. The reason that photo was there was because that particular breeder was apparently horrified by it and wanted advice. In the case of Cato's breeder though, she completely ignored Sosthenes' request to use a different vet who wouldn't string the ears, but she did anyway, just as she was doing for all the litters, including, as I understood, some willful z-factor ones. That's not a broad brush, that's one particularly terrible breeder.

First I don't hold BYB's in utter contempt - some are on their way to learning as as they join groups or get to know people some have gone on to correct things and get more involved and work to do things more correctly. What I hate is the when people are told lies about the puppies they purchase that are not true because the person breeding does not know what they are doing, the Albino breeder who does not tell a new person up front what Z factor means and that it is banned by its own breed club. I think it is a slap in the face that they often charge more for puppies and they don't even crop them but dump it on the new person to sturggle with. I bet if the albino breeders did explain things they would not be able to sell their wares. It is dishonesty on any level that I don't like and the person referred to earlier has said the same thing on several forums over a couple years and did not make the changes she said she would make. I think now she has stopped breeding her Z dogs, but once you openly lie about things I am not sure you ever can repair the damage because I think lying goes to the heart of character.

I couldn't have said any of that better myself, and I agree completely. While I don't approve of a Wall of Silence and think it's every customer's right to ask questions publicly about specific breeders (even asking if rumors are true), I think we also agree that education is the best medicine. Whether that comes from discussion over what a particular breeder or vet is doing when someone is concerned, or dispelling rumors and explaining why something that might sound bad is really not a problem, it's all educational.
 
I think you're reading incorrectly into what I said. Because it is quite obvious that I am not for the banning purebred dogs or anything like that; I am for the betterment of breeding practices and the breed in general. What I dislike is that some kennels seem to reach a stage where they are exempt from following the rules or guidelines to being an ethical breeder or a reputable/respectable breeder, whatever you want to call it, and that's seen as okay. Of course there are no perfect systems etc. but I am talking about breeders not even looking into what they CAN do, they choose not to do it, and to ignore basic genetics. As for the genetic research, many breeders aren't into it. Good on the breed clubs who do it, and support it, but this again is useless if nobody is using it.

My point is, with the blurring of lines is that it gives off the wrong message to new breeders, and to new owners - they expect to be given a quality dog, because people have been pointing them in that direction. Altobello sells to BYBs, that in itself paints them in a bad light. I am not saying they don't produce quality dogs, but what good breeder sells dogs to BYBs? Or to anyone who just has the cash? Besides that, there's the health issue to touch on with their dogs. Yes, Maxim is tested. But what about their dams? What about their other dogs? I do not consider HD to be sufficient proof of health testing. Sure, you can argue that never know about cardio but there are other things that they should be testing for such as vWD, eyes, thyroid etc.

And it's not just them, many, many breeders in Europe follow suit and only HD test their dogs, if that. But because they're pairing dogs from famous kennels they have no problems finding buyers for their puppies. They don't advertize oversized etc. so they don't fit the typical BYB trying to play up their dogs (as defined in any "description of a BYB"), but are they on the same level as an ethical breeder? In my opinion, no. But these are the little people, and they just follow what the big people do. There are famous kennels that do health testing along with all the other things e.g. Teraline, but they are in the minority and I am tired of hearing that the majority of breeders just do their best because that is plain bullshit. If that were true, people wouldn't be coming on to forums with their problems, there wouldn't be so many threads about ethical vs BYB. And I could just walk up to practically any kennel in Europe and get a pup.

Then there's the whole dishonesty part, where they send people the worst of their stock just because they're from outside of Europe etc. Or they get the dog and the pedigree papers aren't quite what they should be. Do you consider this to be good breeding practices? Again, I am not saying that there aren't good breeders, or that good breeders aren't truly good, and that the whole thing is useless etc. I am saying: don't try to cover up the facts. Maybe in the US there are a hell of a lot of great breeders, and of course as an ethical breeder yourself you know many others. But we're talking about the whole picture, not just the US, and not just the breeders' circle. The bad breeding practices have to be pointed out, regardless of whether the kennel has produced famous dogs. If they don't hold themselves to ethical standards, why should any one else?

And about quality of care - there are many BYBs who breed their family pets. Sure, they take care of their pets, but are they worth breeding? Can they be classified as ethical breeders just because of that? No, they are still BYB. They don't have to have half-dead dogs in tiny cages to be classified as BYBs.
 
Some great posts by Kaloric, D4E, and Ataro on this page - put them together and one can see the points being put across are all meant for the betterment of the breed :)

Sadly certain facts do exist and keep repeating themselves ie Ataro going back decades ago, the same thing you're saying about Albotello could be said about Laney except that in this computerised age we can dig up the facts in a couple of minutes on the 'net ....and your point about rather iffy pedigrees doesn't even confine it to Dobes - when every other GSD was going through hip dysplasia how did the breeders manage to "fix" the issue....by bringing in new blood via the Belgian Shepherd even though the pedigrees never showed that. A success in some ways but that's when the GSD's intelligence went south. Of course no one will admit that and instead they'll say look at the pedigree.

Some of the Neos' pedigrees were just as dubious but just look at where the breed is today - no one in their right mind will touch them with a bargepole due to the health problems :confused:

People go on about the fact that Danes, Rotties, Dobies, and GSD's don't have that temperament they had in the 80's - probably because even the most psycho breeders reached a point where they literally had to watch their own ass so they gave up and went for a softer temperament which they could actually place in a normal home. No matter what ;)

At the end of the day I'm into breeding the perfect Mastiff, the reason I'm interested in Dobes is that having two, I'd like to have some of the cognitive intelligence that Dobes have which none of the mastiff breeds seem to have.

And @ Kaloric, was your pup a product of a 5 year old sire and dam ? If so well done to you. If not, it's rather easier to preach than do :)

I love both the look of the C/D Dobe and the natural look but I've yet to see a serious reply on why C/D shouldn't be done due to health/pain grounds.....it's a matter of choice unless someone can prove me wrong:)
 
I am saying: don't try to cover up the facts. Maybe in the US there are a hell of a lot of great breeders, and of course as an ethical breeder yourself you know many others. But we're talking about the whole picture, not just the US, and not just the breeders' circle. The bad breeding practices have to be pointed out, regardless of whether the kennel has produced famous dogs. If they don't hold themselves to ethical standards, why should any one else?

I think in many of these discussions we get the term ethical confused with sound breeding practices. - It is not unethical to breed dogs it is an ethical issue to lie, cheat or steal, misrepresent etc. No one has said don't point out bad breeding practices but they have to be wrong by some standard not what each one wants to impose on everyone else because they think it should be one way when it allowed as another.
 
And @ Kaloric, was your pup a product of a 5 year old sire and dam ? If so well done to you. If not, it's rather easier to preach than do :)

I love both the look of the C/D Dobe and the natural look but I've yet to see a serious reply on why C/D shouldn't be done due to health/pain grounds.....it's a matter of choice unless someone can prove me wrong:)

You have a bunch of interesting line-specific tidbits there, it's quite a minefield.

Kira's momma was nearly 3 and her poppa was nearly 5 when they were bred, so not quite in line with what I'd consider ideal, but I figured that was close enough since I don't plan on breeding her or anything. That takes a bit of the weight of the decision off since I'm only worried about her own lifespan and not generations away.

I think you sum it up, as long as good practices are followed for c/d and the aftercare is diligent, it's obviously no big deal.
 
See Kaloric that is the problem with trying to make it only one way. Breeders must have the flexibility to do what they feel best to maintain their lines. If you follow the hard cut died in the woll philosophy you promote then you would have to be considered irresponsible if I understood your previous words. And you just can't go there.
 
See Kaloric that is the problem with trying to make it only one way. Breeders must have the flexibility to do what they feel best to maintain their lines. If you follow the hard cut died in the woll philosophy you promote then you would have to be considered irresponsible if I understood your previous words. And you just can't go there.

Well, only if I had been the breeder. I wasn't, so that factor isn't one I had a huge amount of influence over. I also don't plan to breed her but if I did, that would be under my control and I'd most certainly uphold my own ideals. Standards don't need to be as lofty for a pet, and health/longevity and geographical proximity were my primary considerations. In that there is negligible inbreeding in the generations preceding Kira, the detrimental factors of linebreeding that would be amplified and possibly cause serious health issues also are much lower risk. That's how I rolled the dice.

Of course, if I had been dealing with a breeder with loftier aspirations, of course my standards would've been more stringent, even for a pet, due to the increased risks. I'm just hard pressed to find a reason why I should've put in several times more time to research, spent several times the $$$, taken a substantially higher risk, and probably would've had no choice in ear cropping/contract spaying (both things I wanted choice in), for approximately the same type of dog. Obviously, the equilibrium of risks vs. rewards does shift if the fulcrum of "goals" is moved, so if I had title-chasing ambitions, I might've looked to a hardcore breeder.
 

Back
Top