Most breeders barely break even, and do not have the funds to pay for your vet bills. They do it for the love of the breed and to improve the breed, not for cash. That would be the byb's. Who cut costs by not cropping or docking.
It costs a ton of money to have a litter that is appropriately cared for from high quality tested parents and titled parents.
As I said, I wouldn't expect anyone to be on the hook for "incidental" expenses, such as all the vet bills. It's just basic ethical behavior to compensate someone
up to the original purchase price if you sell them something that has serious defects. Most breeders seem to whine about how there's no money in something, how they're essentially doing something to "better the breed", but the best thing for the breed is to run a kennel like an ethical business-- a business that does the right thing, can stand behind what it produces, and refuses to leave the customer holding the bag.
Maybe that's just me. That's how I ran my business. I took an occasional hit where I lost money making a situation right in which I or my product simply missed the mark. I just refused to put myself in a situation where I'd be breaking-even, even if it meant losing a bid or having a customer go elsewhere. I was of the mind that low-bidders who sell themselves short were not my competition. If you want integrity, you're not going to find that by scraping the low-price, low-bidder sludge at the bottom of a barrel. You're not going to find it in someone who breaks-even most of the time, they're either incompetent or selling themselves short and have no margin to make anything right, so you're still too close to the bottom of the barrel. You're only going to find it with someone who charges a fair price that provides enough of a margin to handle unfortunate circumstances.
If a customer can't understand that and won't pay a fair price, they're not a good customer. If you can't make a go of an endeavor without excluding all the shoppers who are not good customers, you are doing something very wrong.
If you were to adopt out a baby would you pay for the medical bills if that baby were to say have extremely high blood pressure, something they inherited. Life happens and we can only do our best to avoid these situations, but they do happen. Asking for someone to pay for your bills is silly and it will never happen.
Really? You'd compare an orphan to a purebred puppy? I'm sure the orphanage would be happy to refund the original purchase price, less all the adoption fees. Since it's technically illegal to sell humans in all civilized countries, I believe the total would come to $0.00.
While I can't put a price on any of my animals or think of them as "products", that's exactly what a purebred animal is. If you're going to pay a small amount for a purebred puppy, or adopt one for free from a shelter, it's obvious you're completely on your own. If you're paying a couple thousand bucks or more for a puppy, and that kennel won't stand behind it enough to refund all or part of the purchase price for a genetic defect, and instead come up with excuses how their breeding practices somehow aren't responsible for said genetic defect, they're unethical or otherwise doing something very, very wrong. The customer should not be on his or her own when paying a fair price for a purportedly quality product, and genetic health is at the core of quality.
For the lifetime of the dog??? Especially when you have no way to identify "inheritable or genetic disease" in advance. If you could you would not do the breeding but find another pair. You don't seem to understand how life works and Doberman breeders are way advanced over GSD breeders so can't compare as each specific breed has its own set of inherited diseases.
The only problem with your statement is that most predispositions to genetic diseases are noticeable, or should be, in previous generations. It's really, really rare for such a disease to not manifest consistently, and proper outcrossing or removing genetically-troubled individuals from a breeding program, regardless of how expensive and awesome they are otherwise, generally mitigates them. A breeder really should have an idea if several generations of a tree seem to be dying young, even at a glance, which is a strong indication of some issue lurking. But as you say, it could be an acceptably small percentage of animals from a pairing that suffer issues. If a breeder would suffer a net loss on a litter by issuing prorated refunds on all the progeny of a pairing who suffered from a defect, obviously it's not an acceptably small percentage (the "product" is too defective) or the price was not fair enough to allow them to do the right thing.
Kennels who are practicing linebreeding and using lines with high inbreeding coefficients should just assume they're playing with fire; if their lines and goals are so awesome that they feel it's worth the risks, they should either make full disclosure that they have longevity problems (but super awesomeness!) or raise their prices to be able to keep from burning customers. Kennels who start their animals into breeding programs too young to notice when a lot of genetic diseases manifest enough to be diagnosable are playing with fire. Kennels who just don't care about the health or longevity histories of their pedigrees going back several generations are playing with fire.
But again, an ignorant buyer should NEVER be burned because the kennel is playing with fire. If the buyer receives the disclosure up-front and knows what they're getting themselves into, that's their choice to play with fire too.
When you get right down to it, I think we can agree that this is why BYBs are ultimately unethical, because they may be playing with fire (like the z-factor breeders), failing to give meaningful disclosure as to what that means to ignorant buyers, or they don't know what they're doing, and those buyers are getting burned. True, those buyers should realize at some level that they're getting what they paid for, but the failures with BYBs are mostly in ignorance, business practices, and incompetence, and people who do business with bad businesses should expect to have problems.