• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

I'm saying that more dogs than receive a top breeder's nod (and extra money from the customer) to become "show quality" could be contenders. A good number of animals with undistinguished pedigrees will shine brightly in the right hands, too.

They can shine but does not mean that they can reproduce it. Purebred dogs exist because breeders bred for SPECIFIC traits. It is more accidental than plannned or bred for.

I think you're failing to distinguish between levels of responsible, reputable breeder who does the right thing by their animals, competition breeders, and lastly, hardcore competition breeders who are too focused on an elusive goal to worry about health. I know more folks who got burned by the latter than by BYBs, it makes you sick either way, but more in the latter, because the buyer put in the effort to try to do things right, and got burned badly.

That's because you have no way to track most BYB's, their dogs history or anything else about them and their dogs, while good breeders are out showing, training studying pedigrees and are in the limelight so all the lopsided focus is on us while the "others" skate.

If a breeder was striving to do all things right then you did not get burned. Stuff happens even in the best cases at least you had a breeder who knew what they were doing and was trying. The BYB got lucky -and some days it is the luck of the draw but that in no way excuses the BYB who doesn't even know what they should be doing.


I also find it funny that now you have separated competition breeders from hardcore competition breeders - believe you me the more hard core you are the more important that health is or the dog won't hold up. I think you have been in the clouds too much.
 
They can shine but does not mean that they can reproduce it. Purebred dogs exist because breeders bred for SPECIFIC traits. It is more accidental than plannned or bred for.

And the thing about purebred dogs is that nearly all express those traits. The primary difference is that some express different core traits a little more intensely than others. That's why a lot of us like purebred dogs because you have pretty good consistency across the breed.

If a breeder was striving to do all things right then you did not get burned. Stuff happens even in the best cases at least you had a breeder who knew what they were doing and was trying. The BYB got lucky -and some days it is the luck of the draw but that in no way excuses the BYB who doesn't even know what they should be doing

Getting burned isn't a matter of intent, it's a matter of result. When someone tries to produce a high-quality show puppy, but it breaks-down from health problems before it's time, it's not sufficient to tell the buyer that, whoops, that's their problem. But yeah, everything is a roll of the dice.

I also find it funny that now you have separated competition breeders from hardcore competition breeders - believe you me the more hard core you are the more important that health is or the dog won't hold up. I think you have been in the clouds too much.

By your definition of hardcore, there must not be all that many of them. What I was referring to are the ones that have big names, great facilities, pro trainers & handlers to post the titles, and high-dollar kennel progeny, but who still seem to have poor longevity track records and offer pretty pathetic health guarantees if anything at all. Something's not right with that picture.
 
Getting burned isn't a matter of intent, it's a matter of result. When someone tries to produce a high-quality show puppy, but it breaks-down from health problems before it's time, it's not sufficient to tell the buyer that, whoops, that's their problem. But yeah, everything is a roll of the dice.

There is not a good breeder out there who would say ooooops that is your problem. I work with my familiesI want to know problems that arise as it allows me to make adjustments but regardless I am there. But you see tohave some unrealistic idea about what one is suppose to do if things went wrong somewhere down the line.

Not to mention that no one can honestly guarantee health at all. Too many outside factors play a role or can tip the scales.

So what exactly do you feel a good breeder should do in this case and for long should they be held accountable for the roll of the dice???

By your definition of hardcore, there must not be all that many of them. What I was referring to are the ones that have big names, great facilities, pro trainers & handlers to post the titles, and high-dollar kennel progeny, but who still seem to have poor longevity track records and offer pretty pathetic health guarantees if anything at all. Something's not right with that picture.

It not my definition it was you who used the term hardcore. Buyt I will say no one that I can think of fits your description all the time. What you seem to not fact in is the more your porudce the more you will possibly have that goes wrong but you alos have a decent # that exceed it and go on to contribute great things to the gene pool. So we owuld have to actually have the exact percentage of dog produced against dogs that died young with health problems before we could use that blanket statement.
 
There is not a good breeder out there who would say ooooops that is your problem. I work with my familiesI want to know problems that arise as it allows me to make adjustments but regardless I am there. But you see tohave some unrealistic idea about what one is suppose to do if things went wrong somewhere down the line.

Not to mention that no one can honestly guarantee health at all. Too many outside factors play a role or can tip the scales.

So what exactly do you feel a good breeder should do in this case and for long should they be held accountable for the roll of the dice???

I wouldn't say it's necessary to guarantee "health" in general, just a meaningful warranty against heritable defects that adversely affect health. "T&T" guarantees on puppies just don't seem adequate. But if there is a congenital issue diagnosed, while it's hard to place a value on a dog and the time that one puts into it, I suppose a prorated refund (say, 25% for each 2 years that the dog falls short of 10 years old) might be in order to help with any vet bills, or a replacement with a comparable pup might be a good start. Of course, the real point of a warranty is that your "product" is great and you won't be dealing with many claims. It's more of an expression of confidence in the quality of one's work than anything, and also shows that you're thinking about such things. At a psychological level, that kind of warranty, even if it's not much skin off your back, is an expression that your buyer isn't suffering alone, that you're there in the same boat, too.

When you get down to it, warranties are just hedging bets. Of course the person providing the warranty is going to be charging more. The buyer is going to be willing to pay more for the peace of mind, even if it's really unnecessary, because not having doubts is priceless. Most everyone does come out ahead.

It not my definition it was you who used the term hardcore. Buyt I will say no one that I can think of fits your description all the time. What you seem to not fact in is the more your porudce the more you will possibly have that goes wrong but you alos have a decent # that exceed it and go on to contribute great things to the gene pool. So we owuld have to actually have the exact percentage of dog produced against dogs that died young with health problems before we could use that blanket statement.

That's fair enough. Honestly, a fact-based disclosure would work pretty well too, I think being up-front would at least quash suspicions. I'm well aware of the maxim that "if you're lucky, a satisfied customer will share that positive experience with maybe 2 others, and a dissatisfied customer will only tell a couple dozen". People often don't go to forums to bitch about healthy dogs, after all, they go to find answers or complain about all the problems they've had.
 
I'm well aware of the maxim that "if you're lucky, a satisfied customer will share that positive experience with maybe 2 others, and a dissatisfied customer will only tell a couple dozen". People often don't go to forums to bitch about healthy dogs, after all, they go to find answers or complain about all the problems they've had.
That used to be the case.Today,a few people hear about the good,several thousand hear about the bad.
 
I wouldn't say it's necessary to guarantee "health" in general, just a meaningful warranty against heritable defects that adversely affect health. "T&T" guarantees on puppies just don't seem adequate.

That's becasue you have no concept of what goes into purebred dogs, genetics, breeding and working with families.

I think for some reason you feel you got burned in a purchase and now you just paint a wide brush of blame. I read it in your post. But there is a big difference between truly reputable honorable breeders and those that disappear when a problem arises.

The other thing you seem to miss is most breeders don't make a lot of money so a guarantee has to be something everyone can live with. Then factor in the outside factors that can affect health and why should a breeder carry the burden for something the owner might have contributed to???

Even WalMart does not give a lifetime money back guarantee. I suggest you stick with BYB and roll with the punches as the dice hit the table!!! I can tell you stories of actual people I know not just heard about who bought from BYB and lost all their money PLUS had a huge vet bill to go with it. You want to hedge your bets and the best way to do that is to work with a responsible breeder.

It's more of an expression of confidence in the quality of one's work than anything, and also shows that you're thinking about such things. At a psychological level, that kind of warranty, even if it's not much skin off your back, is an expression that your buyer isn't suffering alone, that you're there in the same boat, too.

You might need to come visit earth someday and get a dose or reality and common sense.
 
That's becasue you have no concept of what goes into purebred dogs, genetics, breeding and working with families.

I think for some reason you feel you got burned in a purchase and now you just paint a wide brush of blame. I read it in your post. But there is a big difference between truly reputable honorable breeders and those that disappear when a problem arises

I've never been burned, I generally have a good instinct about people and a good (enough) eye when it comes to animals, and I trust in those senses, if anything feels wrong, I go the other way. I just know some people who have been badly burned, by purportedly reputable kennels. But maybe GSD breeders are scum and they use a different definition of "reputable", who knows. I will probably never, ever own a GSD or GSD-mix after seeing all their experiences.

The other thing you seem to miss is most breeders don't make a lot of money so a guarantee has to be something everyone can live with. Then factor in the outside factors that can affect health and why should a breeder carry the burden for something the owner might have contributed to???

I specifically said "heritable" diseases, which are essentially a breeding defect. If a breeder can't warrant against that even by just replacing or refunding, they should probably get out of the business, they're obviously not competent nor do they have sufficient business savvy.
 
Most breeders barely break even, and do not have the funds to pay for your vet bills. They do it for the love of the breed and to improve the breed, not for cash. That would be the byb's. Who cut costs by not cropping or docking.

It costs a ton of money to have a litter that is appropriately cared for from high quality tested parents and titled parents.

If you were to adopt out a baby would you pay for the medical bills if that baby were to say have extremely high blood pressure, something they inherited. Life happens and we can only do our best to avoid these situations, but they do happen. Asking for someone to pay for your bills is silly and it will never happen.
 
I specifically said "heritable" diseases, which are essentially a breeding defect. If a breeder can't warrant against that even by just replacing or refunding, they should probably get out of the business, they're obviously not competent nor do they have sufficient business savvy.

For the lifetime of the dog??? Especially when you have no way to identify "inheritable or genetic disease" in advance. If you could you would not do the breeding but find another pair. You don't seem to understand how life works and Doberman breeders are way advanced over GSD breeders so can't compare as each specific breed has its own set of inherited diseases.
 
I don't think breeders can be held accountable for everything. Buyers have a responsibility too, to understand that when buying an animal there are no guarantees. Breeders do everything they can to ensure the health and longevity of their pet. As a buyer you should recognise this and accept some things are beyond the control of the breeder. Do I think breeders should offered refunds or exchanges? No. If indi developed anything inherited it wouldn't be her breeders fault as I know she does everything to ensure her dogs are as healthy as she can. When buying her I understood that. A dog is not an object with a warranty. Some dogs become ill, sometimes there is no explanation. You can't blame a breeder for that if they have.done their job correctly.
 
Honestly a fact-based disclosure would work pretty well too, I think being up-front would at least quash suspicions.

What facts are your referring to - Vwd clear - DNAabsolute test
PDK4 - DNA absolute test
OFA Hips and elbows - info reg in OFA database on line
Blood panel normal levels at time of test
Thyroid - T3 and T4 levels at time of test
CERF - pretty accurate
Cardio echo done??? at time of test
Cardio holter done??? at time of test

So what suspicions do you think people have when there is paperwork that you did or did not - who have you specifically dealt with who was not honest??? That is the point you are going on what the rumor mill cranks out.
 
Most breeders barely break even, and do not have the funds to pay for your vet bills. They do it for the love of the breed and to improve the breed, not for cash. That would be the byb's. Who cut costs by not cropping or docking.

It costs a ton of money to have a litter that is appropriately cared for from high quality tested parents and titled parents.

As I said, I wouldn't expect anyone to be on the hook for "incidental" expenses, such as all the vet bills. It's just basic ethical behavior to compensate someone up to the original purchase price if you sell them something that has serious defects. Most breeders seem to whine about how there's no money in something, how they're essentially doing something to "better the breed", but the best thing for the breed is to run a kennel like an ethical business-- a business that does the right thing, can stand behind what it produces, and refuses to leave the customer holding the bag.

Maybe that's just me. That's how I ran my business. I took an occasional hit where I lost money making a situation right in which I or my product simply missed the mark. I just refused to put myself in a situation where I'd be breaking-even, even if it meant losing a bid or having a customer go elsewhere. I was of the mind that low-bidders who sell themselves short were not my competition. If you want integrity, you're not going to find that by scraping the low-price, low-bidder sludge at the bottom of a barrel. You're not going to find it in someone who breaks-even most of the time, they're either incompetent or selling themselves short and have no margin to make anything right, so you're still too close to the bottom of the barrel. You're only going to find it with someone who charges a fair price that provides enough of a margin to handle unfortunate circumstances.

If a customer can't understand that and won't pay a fair price, they're not a good customer. If you can't make a go of an endeavor without excluding all the shoppers who are not good customers, you are doing something very wrong.

If you were to adopt out a baby would you pay for the medical bills if that baby were to say have extremely high blood pressure, something they inherited. Life happens and we can only do our best to avoid these situations, but they do happen. Asking for someone to pay for your bills is silly and it will never happen.

Really? You'd compare an orphan to a purebred puppy? I'm sure the orphanage would be happy to refund the original purchase price, less all the adoption fees. Since it's technically illegal to sell humans in all civilized countries, I believe the total would come to $0.00.

While I can't put a price on any of my animals or think of them as "products", that's exactly what a purebred animal is. If you're going to pay a small amount for a purebred puppy, or adopt one for free from a shelter, it's obvious you're completely on your own. If you're paying a couple thousand bucks or more for a puppy, and that kennel won't stand behind it enough to refund all or part of the purchase price for a genetic defect, and instead come up with excuses how their breeding practices somehow aren't responsible for said genetic defect, they're unethical or otherwise doing something very, very wrong. The customer should not be on his or her own when paying a fair price for a purportedly quality product, and genetic health is at the core of quality.

For the lifetime of the dog??? Especially when you have no way to identify "inheritable or genetic disease" in advance. If you could you would not do the breeding but find another pair. You don't seem to understand how life works and Doberman breeders are way advanced over GSD breeders so can't compare as each specific breed has its own set of inherited diseases.

The only problem with your statement is that most predispositions to genetic diseases are noticeable, or should be, in previous generations. It's really, really rare for such a disease to not manifest consistently, and proper outcrossing or removing genetically-troubled individuals from a breeding program, regardless of how expensive and awesome they are otherwise, generally mitigates them. A breeder really should have an idea if several generations of a tree seem to be dying young, even at a glance, which is a strong indication of some issue lurking. But as you say, it could be an acceptably small percentage of animals from a pairing that suffer issues. If a breeder would suffer a net loss on a litter by issuing prorated refunds on all the progeny of a pairing who suffered from a defect, obviously it's not an acceptably small percentage (the "product" is too defective) or the price was not fair enough to allow them to do the right thing.

Kennels who are practicing linebreeding and using lines with high inbreeding coefficients should just assume they're playing with fire; if their lines and goals are so awesome that they feel it's worth the risks, they should either make full disclosure that they have longevity problems (but super awesomeness!) or raise their prices to be able to keep from burning customers. Kennels who start their animals into breeding programs too young to notice when a lot of genetic diseases manifest enough to be diagnosable are playing with fire. Kennels who just don't care about the health or longevity histories of their pedigrees going back several generations are playing with fire.

But again, an ignorant buyer should NEVER be burned because the kennel is playing with fire. If the buyer receives the disclosure up-front and knows what they're getting themselves into, that's their choice to play with fire too.

When you get right down to it, I think we can agree that this is why BYBs are ultimately unethical, because they may be playing with fire (like the z-factor breeders), failing to give meaningful disclosure as to what that means to ignorant buyers, or they don't know what they're doing, and those buyers are getting burned. True, those buyers should realize at some level that they're getting what they paid for, but the failures with BYBs are mostly in ignorance, business practices, and incompetence, and people who do business with bad businesses should expect to have problems.
 
What facts are your referring to - Vwd clear - DNAabsolute test
PDK4 - DNA absolute test
OFA Hips and elbows - info reg in OFA database on line
Blood panel normal levels at time of test
Thyroid - T3 and T4 levels at time of test
CERF - pretty accurate
Cardio echo done??? at time of test
Cardio holter done??? at time of test

So what suspicions do you think people have when there is paperwork that you did or did not - who have you specifically dealt with who was not honest??? That is the point you are going on what the rumor mill cranks out.
For whatever reason I felt I should quote this.:D;)
 
it's obvious you're completely on your own. If you're paying a couple thousand bucks or more for a puppy, and that kennel won't stand behind it enough to refund all or part of the purchase price for a genetic defect, and instead come up with excuses how their breeding practices somehow aren't responsible for said genetic defect, they're unethical or otherwise doing something very, very wrong. The customer should not be on his or her own when paying a fair price for a purportedly quality product, and genetic health is at the core of quality.

ALL and that is 100% of the breeders I know stand behind their dogs but we can't be held responsible for genetics that can go back many generations and suddenly pop up. If you reseaerch most pedigrees long enough they are has been a little of everything in every pedigree as they all came from the same foundation stock.

If a breeder would suffer a net loss on a litter by issuing prorated refunds on all the progeny of a pairing who suffered from a defect, obviously it's not an acceptably small percentage (the "product" is too defective) or the price was not fair enough to allow them to do the right thing.

Again it is clear you need to study genetics for a little while - There are dogs that lived to 10 and out of many litters proudced ONE litter that all died by two and there are dogs out of dog that died early that the majority of the litters lived to 10 - so when you figure it out exactly please let us know.

If breeders had a crystal ball - if we had a gene pool that was not already small then some of what you say could happen. Have you ever considered that you can try hard to outcross and run into something you had never seen before??? It happens. That is why breeding is not for the arm chair quarter back or the faint of heart.
 
I believe that is the ideology our current government has. Why on earth should I pay more so the people that have problems get a free ride? We are seeing the detrimental effects of that in government, and I would hate for the same thing to be applied in this situation. In order for that to work you would be looking at kimbertal prices 4k+ a dog. Even "pet" quality. Even then it may not be enough. You think we have a problem with byb's now, I would love to see how many people turn to them when they find out a dog from a good breeder is 5 grand.

If I have a problem with my dogs in the future I will handle it myself financially, and I'm sure my breeder will be there for me emotionally. That's all I can ask for, and I think her giving me that is more than enough. Just my two cents.
 
If a breeder has done everything in their power to ensure healthy pups then that's all I can ask for. Why should they be penalised for something out of their control? it's your own choice how.much you are prepared to.pay for a pup. Your own choice who you buy it from. Genetic defection is something a buyer has to take into account when choosing a pup. It can happen to any dog, pure bred or not. I don't.think the choice to.refund.or.exchange reflects on the breeder at all. Dogs are not products like a tv or stereo with a warranty.

I.agree.with crd, if indi were to suffer from any of those things, she is my responsibility to care for financially, her breeder is.always there for lifetime support. Im more than grateful for that.
It doesn't matter how much I paid for her, the thought of refund or exchange.wouldn't cross my mind, im honoured her breeder let me have.one of her.dogs.
 
ALL and that is 100% of the breeders I know stand behind their dogs but we can't be held responsible for genetics that can go back many generations and suddenly pop up. If you reseaerch most pedigrees long enough they are has been a little of everything in every pedigree as they all came from the same foundation stock.

Again it is clear you need to study genetics for a little while - There are dogs that lived to 10 and out of many litters proudced ONE litter that all died by two and there are dogs out of dog that died early that the majority of the litters lived to 10 - so when you figure it out exactly please let us know.

If breeders had a crystal ball - if we had a gene pool that was not already small then some of what you say could happen. Have you ever considered that you can try hard to outcross and run into something you had never seen before??? It happens. That is why breeding is not for the arm chair quarter back or the faint of heart.

Breeding also isn't for those who have no understanding of the math behind genetics. I happen to have pretty good knowledge of genetics, both the theory and the math. This is science and statistics, not gambling and magic.

So, I thought the whole point of a planned breeding program was consistency and improvement, not rolls of the dice and wildly randomized results. If the best you can say about your confidence in a litter's longevity is what you state above, wow...

Flukes always can happen, but their frequency is somewhat predictable. Statistics tell you what is typical, where you're trending, and thus quantify how well you're doing in an area that's quantifiable like longevity, which is the most readily measurable indicator of health. If longevity is a factor you're serious about, you should have some idea about things like the average lifespans of previous litters, the size of your standard deviation, and from that you will have a reasonably clear picture of your success in the area in terms of both consistency and proof that you are doing more to promote breed longevity than a haphazard BYB who rolls the dice and does little more than cross fingers and hope for the best.

In order for that to work you would be looking at kimbertal prices 4k+ a dog. Even "pet" quality. Even then it may not be enough. You think we have a problem with byb's now, I would love to see how many people turn to them when they find out a dog from a good breeder is 5 grand.

Unless someone is doing things very, very wrong, you would barely notice the increase in their prices, probably 10-15% at the most. If 50+% of a kennel's progeny are being diagnosed with congenital defects, as would be the case if doubling the price was necessary to hedge against those defects, that's simply a failure and it'd be ruining the breed. In the past, I've set prices to reflect my confidence in what I can provide for someone, whether it's something like contract snow removal (gambling on the weather, how often and how much it snows) or guaranteeing a product that has a chance of failing unexpectedly, like a computer. Puppies aren't much different aside from the fact they're cute and living things. Also, don't confuse the concept of insurance, mandatory or otherwise, with a business making a pledge to its patrons.

I think one thing you're not understanding about what I'm saying is who this sort of policy is all about. I see refund or replacement guarantees as a way for the vendor to willingly share the pain. They're completely token, if my prices are good, they mean nothing to me. In the case of a pet, a buyer is coping with the impending loss of a beloved pet, that little bit of money itself isn't going to mean much to the buyer. Only people who are bad at budgeting think the initial purchase price is significant when it comes to a pet or to livestock. It's not a penalty, it's not punishment, it's just being ethical and foregoing a profit when your customer has suffered a loss due to a defect.

When I offer guarantees, it's all about me. It's me saying, "Look, I know I have something great here because I know my business. I'm confident that I won't let you down, but if it's not our lucky day & things go wrong, I want you to know that it really isn't normal and not the way I do things." It also really only works if the vendor volunteers the refund upon learning of a situation before the customer has to demand it. That's the sort of attitude a reputation is built on, it's the sort of care that keeps people from spreading ugly gossip about your business practices and quality.
 
I think it is also comparable to pledging to take one of your puppies back, regardless of the age. The chances of it happening (if you're doing things right and screening new homes properly) are low, but it does give the buyer confidence even if she or he will never have to return the dog.
 
That would be an example of handling things in a really ethical way.

But what about how z-factor was handled? I didn't have Dobermans at the time, but from what it sounds like, there were epic tantrums thrown. I'm betting that putting those "z" designations on papers of Shebah's progeny met with much resistance. At least that's what happened with the HyPP crisis that hit the AQHA in the 90s when I was most concerned and involved with the breed and the organization (I dropped my membership out of disgust for the way they handled the matter). Horses did start dropping dead left and right. Mendelian genetics fingered a particular prolific sire, and a genetic test was made for the disease's genetic marker. Since the risk factor and genetic test are so conclusive, and the disease is so serious, you'd think it was a slam-dunk for everyone who loves the breed and the defect would've been eliminated from breeding programs within a single generation. Not so. People hollered over having the risk factor (descent from the sire "Impressive") identified conspicuously on their foals' registrations, so that action was debated for years. An exclusion was adopted only for homozygous positive horses. Carriers are still permitted to be registered and bred, and numerous halter class (this is essentially conformation showing for those not familiar with horsey things) breeding programs continue to breed verified carriers because the organization just won't crack-down on them. An appropriate response would not be to exclude all carriers, but to only grant them limited registrations so they can't have their progeny registered. Is that really too much to ask?

It's unbelievable to me that anyone would even consider, for a second, breeding an HyPP carrier, and from what I've read about albinism in Dobermans, why would anyone consider breeding a z-factor? Also, it seems that there are plenty of Dobermans that do not get diagnosed with DCM, so it should be entirely possible to minimize that defect through conscientious breeding, but that's obviously a bit more complicated due to how and when it's diagnosed, regardless of how it got into the breed.



I would definitely not claim that all (or even most) breeders are delusional and reckless. :D Those who are this conscientious are truly reputable and quality breeders. But it often seems to be the exception than the rule, or maybe the unethical breeders are just the most vocal when it comes to being told that they're wrong. I suppose it's like politicians-- the breeders who are most "successful" at fielding popular sires and dams and gaining fame and fortune for their programs are the most morally-bankrupt and shameless when it comes to doing the right thing even when it's a bitter pill and not expedient for them or their ambitions.



It's a difficult situation, since it's hard for anyone to compare notes and determine if there's a problem without theorizing and trying to put together data points that aren't all that easy to find. Now here is an area where I'll admit that I'm bad. Of my two deceased horses, I returned neither of their registration certificates for cancellation, including the one who died young. Without folks all reporting back to the breed organizations when their animals die, and not providing causes of death if the death was premature, it's pretty difficult to determine if there's a trend. You're mostly going to hear from the folks who are mad that their animal died prematurely of natural causes such as a congenital defect, but not about the ones who didn't die horribly or prematurely. There's most definitely cause for concern if an inordinate number of people are having their dogs die prematurely.

Well, back on topic, I'm obviously with DV here-- shrugging off a trivial part of a breed standard isn't as detrimental to the breed we care about as knowingly propagating congenital defects. I wouldn't even say it's moral relativism, because there are no moral downsides from not cropping or docking. Opting-out of the cosmetic surgery is a personal choice with no ramifications beyond the individual dogs, which many folks won't even identify as Dobermans. Knowingly propagating diseases may not be against a breed standard, but it hurts us all.

I owned several American Quarter Horses during the 70's thru the early 90's. We were not in the halter class, but in the cutting and reining class. I do remember that every time I opened an AQHA Journal, Impressive's big ass and gaskin(sp) muscles were plastered on every other page. He was a handsome rascal, but couldn't scatter his own scats. Even those who never competed in halter class wanted a piece of this guy.
 

Back
Top