Albino invited to TT at nationals

So if we have a rescue that we dont know the history of, and is horribly not a good example of a doberman... yet looks like a dobe thats black or red, they can get an ILP and do it?? Thats like saying NO Z dog should be allowed to do anything AKC wise at all. Not only that, how many CH dogs have genetic problems as well, at least this dog has a reason! I understand no acceptance in conformation, thats 'suppose' to be based on the form of the dog. But I do not see any reason why it cannot be in the performance events. I think any dog, despite its color should be worked and given a job. I am sure thats all she is concerned about, and even if its not... good for her to show that a white doberman is just as smart and can be taught and trained like any dog. If its white, if it has papers, if its Z... it may not be acceptable for conformation, but as long as she is not breeding it, let her get her titles.
 
i agree... very well said.. i give her alot of credit... she drove from Texas to Mass because she was invited.. she ( im sure ) knew there would be looks, stares and whispers... but she went anyway .. to quote John Wayne..." Courage is being scared as hell, and saddeling up anyways"..
 
Leatha....Please,understand that I am not knocking ANY forum members canine companions.I want to believe this woman is enjoying her companion animal and genuinely rescued it.However,I have my doubts.There are politics in sanctioned sport that can be very unsettling.This competing owner and her dog are a very clear case of it.
Hello123 I understand what you are saying. It's a shame politics have to be played.
 
I am glad that we can agree that AKC and other venues have to make money or we have no where to compete. We have to think logically and take the emotions out of it as that is when we make bad statements and bad decisions.

There is a rule that fell through the loop hole that allowed this to happen but again no one KNEW that Karen was showing a white but Karen. There might not have been any Dobermans showing in obedience in her part of the country and since I don't thank half of DPCA members even realize there is a problem I certainly would not expect JQP to have a clue.

A person working with her rescue dog is a good thing. Really, I think that since was an invitational, the DPCA should've known who they were inviting, ILP# be damned. They should refund, apologize, and make their rules explicitly clear.

If you can tell us how people sitting somewhere else who just get numbers and rankings could have known I am sure we would all love to hear about it. ILP's do not include the Z as to get and ILP the dog must be spayed or neutered.

I do believe in future the entry invitation should state in bold letters - Albinos not allowed and excluded making this invitation null and void. Please notify DPCA within 10 days of your acceptance of the invitation or rejection. If we do not here from you within that time frame to confirm you qualificiation the next person on the list will be invited and your invite recinded.

To accomplish TT status you MUST keep track of everyones standings to know if you are in the running through out the year or not. It requires extra showing and numerous entries to achieve this status it does not just fall out of the tree and that is where I struggle. I do believe that for whatever reason Karen set the goal and went for it.

At best I feel she was naive in not considering the pandora's box she would open up and the controversy she would create at worse based on the time, effort and money required to achieve the standings I feel she could have had an agenda misguided or not. I also do not think she could not know that the albino breeders would jump on it and use it as a advertsing campaign to promote their "highly successful trainable "white" dobermans" GAG and they are.

Plus even worse they are using it to slam DPCA for having HIGH noble principles to preserve and protect the Doberman Pinscher.

Who among you would intentionally breed a genetic defect KNOWING it causes photo sensitivity, skin sensitivity and possible deafness - then couple that along with the much higher rate of numerous other problems . We take about the problem with the small gene pool for the Doberman just imagine how small it is for the albino dogs. That carries its own set of problems that again cause a higher rate in genetic defects in puppies. Does that sound honorable or honest to anyone????

Karen educates people to no end on the health issues of whites... she is a vet tech... she trained Sprite herself .. she has pamphlets she hands to people who ask about her dog... i commend her on a job well done and on Educating people ... she was invited and qualified.. there was an error somewhere but .. DPCA needs to let it go and move on.. if there is an issue fix it for next time..

Heidi's mom - she did not qualify - By color alone she was disqualified. We need to get it and understand this issue or the breed is lost. DPCA members and founding fathers have fought long and hard to preserve this breed as herr doberman intended - a cropped and docked breed with certain approved colors only allowed.

Never has any breed club ever allowed in its COE a genetic defect to be bred. It is against every shred of common decency. We fight hard for our right to maintain this breed meticulously by every single breed trait and type.

We have handed them the golden goose and now the albino breeders are running wild with it and promoting the heck out of the superior GAG albino defects and damning DPCA for being the big bad wolf and discriminating against a genetic defect which was so detrimental to the breed that even AKC agreed to help us protect our breed through the Z registration. Unfortunatley it does not stop the unethical from breeding them for their own personal glory and may common decency be thrown out the window.
 
So if we have a rescue that we dont know the history of, and is horribly not a good example of a doberman... yet looks like a dobe thats black or red, they can get an ILP and do it?? Thats like saying NO Z dog should be allowed to do anything AKC wise at all. Not only that, how many CH dogs have genetic problems as well, at least this dog has a reason! I understand no acceptance in conformation, thats 'suppose' to be based on the form of the dog. But I do not see any reason why it cannot be in the performance events. I think any dog, despite its color should be worked and given a job. I am sure thats all she is concerned about, and even if its not... good for her to show that a white doberman is just as smart and can be taught and trained like any dog. If its white, if it has papers, if its Z... it may not be acceptable for conformation, but as long as she is not breeding it, let her get her titles.

Hrd2gt- I am not sure I understand your first part - An ILP number just says the dog is at best guest purebred and is allowed to compete in all venuse except the breed ring. Conformation is NOT just about the conformation it is about the dog have strong enough conformation by their standards to be breed worthy on this one part of the dog. Its failing is it does not take into account temperament or worablility for a working breed. So I somewhere I am missing the leap to Z factored should not be allowed to show in any venue.

The albino's are disallowed on color alone genetic defect of being albino can't be hidden. Although I think maybe you have fault and genetic defect confused as I don't know any good breeder who would ever waste their time showing any dog that had a genetic defect. The COE covers this.

A defect would be 2 missing teeth - eyes to close set or too light in color - too low a tail set etc which are not disqualifying but would be something a breeder would want to work to breed out. I hope that helps make it a little clearer.

The problem with her getting her titles is the albino breeders are already using it to promote their disreputable breeding programs and making MORE. She can enjoy showing all she wants but don't take it to DPCA Natls.

i agree... very well said.. i give her alot of credit... she drove from Texas to Mass because she was invited.. she ( im sure ) knew there would be looks, stares and whispers... but she went anyway .. to quote John Wayne..." Courage is being scared as hell, and saddeling up anyways"..

John Wayne would have only saddled up to fight wrong NEVER to support those doing wrong. He would never have supported bringing the US Calvery to its knees nor would he approve of throwing a bone to a genetic defect.
 
If you can tell us how people sitting somewhere else who just get numbers and rankings could have known I am sure we would all love to hear about it. ILP's do not include the Z as to get and ILP the dog must be spayed or neutered.

Unfortunately, I don't have that answer. But, they knew the dog was a Doberman, didn't they, for the purposes of the DPCA invite-only event (or were dogs other than Dobermans invited to this?) I don't know. It just seems weird to me that it was such a surprise. Pictures get taken at obedience competitions, especially of winners, one would think. Sprite would have had to win a bit, to be invited. Maybe I'm just displaying my ignorance here, I don't know. It just doesn't make sense that "nobody knew".
 
GG - ILP # do reg the dog as a breed - Ex Doberman - but do not indicate color of the dog. They do not take win pictures at obedience shows like they do for coformation. So unless I take my camera and remember to have someone take a picture I don't get one.

Your statement was "ILP's be damned" To say that if you do not know how it works is making a decision without enough facts to be correct. Even if a Doberman comes into rescue with AKC papers they will not go with the dog most likely. The dog goes as unregistered, BUT being a Doberman alone qualifies it for an ILP # and that makes it eligible to compete in AKC events except conformation.

So there is no way anyone unless DPCA sends a reg to each and every show areound the country to know what COLOR the dog is. Z factors can show if they can show proof of spay/neuter in any obedience events because their genetic defect is not glaringly obvious. As far as JQP is concerned they are just another doberman although without as nice a conformation. But an albino sticks out like a sore thumb and therefore gives the albino breeders a picture that is worth a 1,000 words. They don't have to prove anyting except that a "white" doberman show and did well at our own Doberman Natl. It therefore, appears as if DPCA supports the breeding of albino's and Z factored which it does not.
 
GG - ILP # do reg the dog as a breed - Ex Doberman - but do not indicate color of the dog. They do not take win pictures at obedience shows like they do for coformation. So unless I take my camera and remember to have someone take a picture I don't get one.

Your statement was "ILP's be damned" To say that if you do not know how it works is making a decision without enough facts to be correct. Even if a Doberman comes into rescue with AKC papers they will not go with the dog most likely. The dog goes as unregistered, BUT being a Doberman alone qualifies it for an ILP # and that makes it eligible to compete in AKC events except conformation.

So there is no way anyone unless DPCA sends a reg to each and every show areound the country to know what COLOR the dog is. Z factors can show if they can show proof of spay/neuter in any obedience events because their genetic defect is not glaringly obvious. As far as JQP is concerned they are just another doberman although without as nice a conformation. But an albino sticks out like a sore thumb and therefore gives the albino breeders a picture that is worth a 1,000 words. They don't have to prove anyting except that a "white" doberman show and did well at our own Doberman Natl. It therefore, appears as if DPCA supports the breeding of albino's and Z factored which it does not.

Sorry, I should have worded it more maturely and said "regardless of ILP's, it seems like this sort of information should be available to and sought after by the people who send the invitations for events as prestigious as these are meant to be."

Thank you for the info on obedience shows and on whether ILP designates breed or claimed breed.
 
ILP's # are really a good thing as it does allow resuces and even Z factored dogs of allowed color to compete in obedience events. I know a lot of people who got stuck with a Z factored because of course the breeder FAILED to mention that they would be almost branded and an outcast. So the person goes to buy a doberman and sees a precious little black, red, blue or fawn and buys it.

I know I get the calls occassionally of people who have a Z factored who are looking for stud service. I patiently explain the white out program and Z factored and then give them the link to the DPCA white out program info. I explain that if they truly care about doing things the right way that they spay the bitch and find a good breeder to mentor them with a new approved puppy. Some listen and some don't but at least I did my part to help educate them. I ask them does it make you wonder why your breeder did not expalin all this to you before you bought your puppy???

I think it is like many things - before it happens we don't think about it. How could anyone ever come up with all the things that might happen and how to avoid them. But this cat is already out of the bag and much damage has been done. For anyone involved in Dobermans, rescue and education against the albino problem to claim not to have immediately realized that this would be a big problem is something I have a hard time buying. My first thought was now the white breeders have something to really brag about and they are shouting form the rafters about how great the albino defective gene is.
 
I dunno, bottom line its a doberman. It may be hugely genetically flawed doberman, but regardless its a doberman. If she is putting the time and effort into it, which anyone who knows OB it its takes a lot, and she qualifies, good for her. She is not promoting breeding white albinos (least i dont think so, if so correct me!) she is just showing her dog. If I had a dog that made it to the TT... i be DAMNED if anyone is going to tell me not to go because my dog is not acceptable by breed standard (even if its flat out not allowed). Thats a helluva a honor no politics would keep me from. If they didnt set a firm rule against it, and invited her fine.

Mind you, my current super star IG is 2x his breed size and has food triggered seizures... he is nipped... genetically flawed... but he is an awesome dog and I will show him as long as he loves agility.

but on a very very side note... if DPCA was SO strict against it... why not set a harsh ruling. I mean look at the border collie club... if any BC gets a AKC championship... they are automatically kicked out of ABCA. talk about tough.

Fate is also Z factored, and she probably has the most dramatic heel you have ever seen... OB is something for when my dogs retire, but I will probably compete with her as well, so look out... a lil brown Z dog will be up there too day... thats why i love performance... you can only hate me if i make a mistake... cant hate me cuz of my looks.
 
WELL... I met Karen MYSELF this weekend at the agility show. And as far as I am concerned she is a LOVELY LADY!! She was running the same classes as Karma and I heard her dogs name and I approached her and asked if she was the one in the TT causing all the commotion (i know, i am such a smartazz). I actually spoke to her quite a bit, Sprite is a rescue and she has another albino she fostered and decided to keep because she did so well with therapy work (for seniors). And of course she knew she would get hell from the fanatics about this but she dont care, she is doing it for herself and the dog. GOOD FOR HER!! And not only is a nice lady, she is a great advocate for the breed, I think all dobe people should be grateful for her. Because of course, people are drawn to her dog, as they are with any of us when we are out with our dobes, and she takes that opportunity to educate people and teach them why you wouldnt want a white dobe. She even gave me a lil hand out on white dobes that gives details on all the extra responsiblity and advises against breeding... Which to me... the way its written is quite nice, as it encourages people not to buy, not beats the hell out of them and threatens them not to buy... which we all know if you tell someone NO, they are going to want to do it more.

So you can take my impression or not, I am not an easily influenced person, and i tend not to trust people til i get to know them, but I do look forward to seeing her at future shows.

On a side note, Sprite is quite beautiful and has some serious potential in the agility ring if she had a better handler (just kidding Karen if this gets back to you, LOL) I never seen a white/fawn/or blue with a nice a coat. THAT is a very well taken care of dog. Good for Sprite to be so lucky to find such a great mom.
 
Hrd2gt - no one is saying she is not a lovely hard working lady. DPCA does have a ruling in place that got misplaced that albinos can't be shown in DPCA events. It was a horrible mistake all the way around. The biggest problem is everyone congratulates Karen and Sprite on their accomplishment. But the mistake should not have happened and the problem is that being actual albino and being Z factore are two very different problems. Z factored dogs of approved AKC color do not make a glaring statment when seen on the web site that they are from a line of dogs that have been disqualified from breeding by their own breed club.

You don't have to take anything personal if you are showing Fate beacuse except for the WZ# no one would know or care and she is spayed. So you did the responsible thing.

Sprite while spayed and a rescue who did an awesome job unfortunately through no fault of her own or Karen's makes a glaring statement that the Albino breeders have already jumped on to try to justify thier breeding genetically defective dogs.

While you IG might be oversized that is a far cry from a genetic defect. And regardless of any genetic defects he has not been banned from breeding by his own breed club. These are two very different issues that people who have not been students of the breed and tis history often misunderstand.

Do you think it a good think to hand the Albino breeders a golden goose so they can justify breeding more genetically defective dogs???? There is not way to stop the flood waters now that they are rushing in on us.
 
No matter what... bad breeders are going to do what they are going to do for money and grab onto any propaganda to try and support their cause. Honestly, I dont see why the DPCA would ban albinos, bottom line... they are dobermans... even if they are not accepted because they are white. I dont see what the difference between a white dobe vs a colored dobe thats a Z. Where do we draw the line.

Only thing we can do is stop the demand to stop the supply. Educating people who are drawn to them is the first step to stopping that.
 
Hrd2get is is hard to understand it all sometimes. But DPCA stands for the standard and it disqualifies certain faults and certain a genetic defect like albinoism is even worse than any genetic defect. If they had not taken a stand then the entire population would be contaiminated and we would all be trying hard to breed it out. By taking the stand they did they protected the breed from complete decline and kept the problem from spreading. It is not that they are not accepted becasue they are white but that they are albino and albino is a genetic defect that leads to death. the fear with the Z factored is that some have the power to produce albinos. But we have a way to identify it and for anyone to knowling breed it goes straght to the heart of common decency and moral obligation to protect and preserve.
 
I confess, being an outsider and quite critical of any "political establishment", my total lack of understanding of all those "show"rules. I see beautiful dogs, and well educated dogs, period.
So, why D4E, are you referring to albinos as "genetically defective"? The blue, fawn, red, are diluted too.
I mean no disrespect, but from my point of view, it seems like the Pope trying to stop trials on embryos. Breeding is now done in a lab, right? So why stop the breeding of any other color? I bet in 50 yrs we could have blond dobies...is variety a defect?
 
I mean no disrespect, but from my point of view, it seems like the Pope trying to stop trials on embryos. Breeding is now done in a lab, right? The claim of moral (? maybe ethical, but moral?) decency and standards and the "need to preserve" may have righteous grounds, but cannot be used to stop the natural progress of science, which is most ethically always been fed by human curiousity (although I concede that in the US the green god is most powerful)...
 
Eliza -It is all very confusing to those who are not very closely involved in all that dogs shows are all about.First there is a huge difference in the dilute gene and a gene that mutates of and is albino by nature. Albino even in humans is a major issue. We don't ban humans because well because they are humans so fall under completely different guidelines. BUT in the world of the purebred dog only the best should be considered. In the studies done first and foremost a guard dog should be hard to see at night and white is pretty easy to spot so therefore it would be a negative and against the standard for taht reason along. Then you add in the health issues associated with albinoism and I woul dhope anyone could see why breeding something that has more health issues thean a normal populations would not be good for any breed. It has nothing to do with a color. It has to do with the health issues and the lack of ability to do the job either under bright sunlight or to remain unseen in dark circumstances.

People who do not believe in breed standard or upholding any kind of standard have all the options in the world. NO on forces them to "JOIN" our breed club. A breed club is a group of people who form with a single minded purpose to breed dogs to a specific standard. Do we have that right??? If not why not??? For those who for what ever reason can't or won't follow a standard can create their on breed and set their own standard. I certainly have no problem with that. Even in Nature God made animals for certainly purposes and many of them have very clever coat patterns which makes it harder to see them NONE of them are white or albino.
 
Thank you for your message. I hope you are "open"to discuss this, even if clearly you have a vested interest. I cannot deem anything you wrote as "reason"to exclude albino from competing. I see that the "purebred association"is like those "only male clubs", destined to either open their membership or disappear.
1) the dobermann has to be "hard to see": once upon a time. Even Miss USA changed their guidelines;
2) albino health issues= there are other breeds (the ugly dogs with all the extra skin? cannot remember the breed's name) who are aborts of nature, but were developed nevertheless.

This said, I recognize your right to think otherwise, and "protect"your ideals. I just personally think they are no longer defendable...... Like the docking (cropping of ears/tails, which is almost universally banned now). The future will tell.
 
<--------And the result from not buying from this breeder is that I got a healthy, adorable, CGC certified, and best of all such a loving cuddle bug! OH and you gotta agree he is very handsome in the picture...haha! Working on our therpy cert..... it is funny seeing people react to a dobe walking the hallways of a hospital.... they are soooo misunderstood!
I can TOTALLY relate to the whole doberman in the hospital thing! My Mysti was a registered therapy dog and visited our hospital every Monday. I got so many mixed reactions to her, alot of shock at first seeing this big doberman walking into the hospital. Alot of people tried to stop me and tell me she wasnt allowed in and I had to show them her ID card, which was always firmly attached to her collar. It got so bad at one point I went and bought her the red service vest that clearly stated "Therapy Dog" on it. After that people stopped hassling me about trying to bring her in, but were still surprised to see a doberman doing that kind of work.
 
I appreciate your desire to discuss the issues - But if a club forms and sets rules does that club have the right to even exist is kinda what I get from your post- please correct me if I am wrong. But just because one person does not approve of something does not mean everyone else who does appreciate the finer things can't enjoy them. Since they were banned by their own breed club which is compltetly within their right as the breed club due to the increased issues that they have which are specific to their DNA mutatation is within our club rights, rules and Regulations.

A society must have rules and laws for people to follow or we have chaos and crime. If you ever had to talk to a distraught client who unknowingly bought one of these dogs only to spend thousand of dollars on the health issues and then still loose the dog at a young age you might feel differently. The world of the dog fancy is a speciality, trying to set higher standards and follow it to maintain and protect the overall form and function of a specific breed.

So I don't like the roughness of football - should I proceed to try to do away with a sport that I think is grossly overpaid, support convicted felons and holds them in high esteem because they can win a super bowl??? No I feel those people have rights jsut as I do.

Go sit at your vets office for a while and look at the dogs that come in. Even the "purebred" but lowbred dogs.
Compare their over all appearance to the dogs that compete and show - Do you usually see a big difference???

I agree if you want a pet it might not matter but if you are IN THE FANCY you should care about the quality you produce. And Albino is not quality it is a handicap. Are you really saying we need to produce more handicaped dogs so vets cam make more moeny????

We are a dog fancy - a dedicated groups of folks who for whatever reason have a passion about our purebred dogs. From that passion we formed a breed club and we swore to preserve and protect the breed we love. We hold competitions, events, breed fairs to try to help educate others. We strive to set a standard and I think if you read threads on any forum you will see that most people expect breeders to uphold a very high standard and they feel that BYB let people down. Albino breeders are not about quality or even much on honesty. So even if the albino is from reg Doberman stock it was a mutation that occured ONLY once and was maintained from that time on. So just like the freak shows of old hopefully they too will pass.

If none of this matters to you then why did you choose the Doberman breed??? How do you think that breed cointinues to go producing dogs consistent with forma nd function??? Because if all dogs were just turned loose to breed with whatever dog was closest you would within 10 years have no purebred dogs. That is what you are advocating because you can't have it both ways - purebred dogs - and no standards = mutts

So quality breeders in the dog fancy take their passion very seriously - it is not your passion - I get it. What I don't get is evidently you want a Doberman for some reason but don't understand the complexity of what makes a Doberman a Doberman and what keeps it a Doberman - A Standard to follow.
 

Back
Top