Albino invited to TT at nationals

"If you would open your mind and pay attention to those with experience and knowledge that are trying to share that with you here you could learn a whole lot. They are taking the time to answer your questions, they certainly don't have to. "

?????????????????????????????????????????
Fine, you are right and the rest of the world is wrong.
 
:) "If you would open your mind and pay attention to those with experience and knowledge that are trying to share that with you here you could learn a whole lot. They are taking the time to answer your questions, they certainly don't have to. "

?????????????????????????????????????????
Fine, you are right and the rest of the world is wrong, and vets all sold out!
 
Eliza - we just asked for some clarification or reference of where you got your info. You seem unwilling to provide it, but you seem to feel I have no understanding of dog breeding.

What does the "Modern Way" mean - I have not heard of it.

What DNA is being manipulated and for what reason if not the ones I mentioned??? I am trying to be open minded and understand.
 
?????????????????????????????????????????
Fine, you are right and the rest of the world is wrong, and vets all sold out!
The rest of the world??? Unless you're at an albino specific board where they don't care about the health or standards, the rest of the Doberman world does not and will not accept them as something that should ever be reproduced on purpose. :shakinghead:
 
I am not aware of any regulations in the US show dog business where "health"is a requirement for showing.
In the US, "people raise dogs to obtain the best qualitites from a given bloodline". (this is confirmed by D4E)
"This includes: shape, coloring, temperament, obedience, and overall APPEARANCE".

If no specific requirements are spelled out in a SHOW dog competition, an albino should be allowed to compete, period.
The breeding of albinos, and related issues are a separated topic. Their position I compare to the Colored Dobies, that were NOT allowed in competition (to my knowledge) then accepted by the AKC. Other countries ban them all, colored and albinos.
This I tried to explain.

I do not even go in details about DNA manipulation, because I see goes beyond what the "experts"here do. Interestingly enough, while the rest of the world is proceeding beneath their own eyes (see legislation on cropping) they are trying to defend the "status quo"by claiming "freedom of choice" and/or making appeal to "standards".

I understand this as they are defending their market. But to bring "morality", or "standards", or "health"in a framework where dogs are used as "sample merchandise" is either disingenous or lacking awareness of the profound ongoing changes.

My personal forecast is that you will have more patents on this. And this will bring about a truly remarkable change,finally clearing the market of those you call "immoral"or "unscrupoulous"breeders (whom, for me. are just "maters")......
 
I am not aware of any regulations in the US show dog business where "health"is a requirement for showing.
In the US, "people raise dogs to obtain the best qualitites from a given bloodline". (this is confirmed by D4E)
"This includes: shape, coloring, temperament, obedience, and overall APPEARANCE".

Eliza - that you for coming back - I will start by addressing the quote above and see if I can clarify or help you understand - The standard does not address health per se - why because it can't be measured and there are no concrete test to tell us what might develop down the line. So how you would regulate or measure something that is an unknown??? I can tell you that there is not a good breeder alive that does not strive to breed the healthest dogs they can - WHY it is to our advantage.

If no specific requirements are spelled out in a SHOW dog competition, an albino should be allowed to compete, period.
The breeding of albinos, and related issues are a separated topic. Their position I compare to the Colored Dobies, that were NOT allowed in competition (to my knowledge) then accepted by the AKC. Other countries ban them all, colored and albinos.

First if it becomes a law which I think is where you are headed in this that health testing be manditory then I think the first thing that will happen is albinos will be eliminted from even being registered and Euro as far as we know has never had an albino mutation show up in their gene pool so that is why it is not an issue there.

So here are the test we have - Vwd - DNA test gives and absolute answer - Are you saying that in showing we should present our DNA resutls every time we show??? Vwd is not fatal 98% of the the time. So what would be your measure of if the dog could show or not?

OFA - hip and elbows - Can't be done til two but you can use penn hip if you can find a vet with the proper equipment to take the needed x rays. Just about every breeder I know OFA's their dogs? It is true young puppies that are showing are not ofa yet.

I have a very close friend who has an absolutely BEAUTIFUL red male - Everything you could wish and at 2 he failed OFA - Guess what he was never bred and was neutered - does that count. I have experienced the same thing and I neutered the dog after 2 years of showing training etc. Does that count for anything???? How would you measure that??

Full blood panel and Thyroid - Again good breeders who are showing do this test.

Cardio - PDK4 DNA test - I have done all my dogs but it still does not mean they will not get cardio - What should I do???? How will I know a dog get cardio til it does???? Do you have a crystal ball??? Science doesn't have the answers yet but if you do then please share them with us.

holter - Again gives a reading on the day you do the test - still does not mean the dog will not die of cardio tomorrow.

echo - Shows the working status and picture of the heart and would show any enlargement or ventricular problems if they existed at the time but again not fail proof.

Do you thin that making these things LAW is the answer??? I that what you are trying to say - Science does not always follow a straight path and there seem to be exceptions to all rules. How would you have us proceed???

I do not even go in details about DNA manipulation, because I see goes beyond what the "experts"here do. Interestingly enough, while the rest of the world is proceeding beneath their own eyes (see legislation on cropping) they are trying to defend the "status quo"by claiming "freedom of choice" and/or making appeal to "standards

So since you brought it up and we have asked for details to help us who are so stupid to better understand WHY CAN"T you answer - WE might actually learn something since you seem to know something we don't. BUT cropping and docking has nothing to do with DNA manipulation so trying to time them together is way out of reason. I have a hard time with you guys who throw out stuff then want to skirt issues or just disappear to avoid answering.



I am here. I am trying to understand and I will be here to answer and respond to any and all questions from anyone. I will not leave the thread - disappear and avoid to answer specific questions. I will not throw up fluff to avoid answering the questions either.
 
​
If no specific requirements are spelled out in a SHOW dog competition, an albino should be allowed to compete, period.​
​
​
But....it is spelled out. From the AKC website...

Dog shows (conformation events) are intended to evaluate breeding stock. The size of these events ranges from large all-breed shows, with over 3,000 dogs entered, to small local specialty club shows, featuring a specific breed. The dog's conformation (overall appearance and structure), an indication of the dog's ability to produce quality puppies, is judged. ​

Which Dogs May Participate​
​
To be eligible to compete, a dog must:​
  • be individually registered with the American Kennel Club
  • be 6 months of age or older
  • be a breed for which classes are offered at a show
  • meet any eligibility requirements in the written standard for its breed
​
And, from the Doberman Standard:​
​
Allowed Colors:- Black, red, blue, and fawn (Isabella). Markings :- Rust, sharply defined, appearing above each eye and on muzzle, throat and fore chest, on all legs and feet, and below tail. White patch on chest, not exceeding 1/2 square inch, permissible. Disqualifying Fault : -Dogs not of an allowed color​
 
I do not think this medium is helping me, as I see you keep focusing on phrases and not the meaning of my posts. The reference to the standards is partially valid, as the one you post is valid in the US and UK, not in Italy and France (where colored dobies are NOT allowed). Again, the reference is to the capability to generate puppies (id est their "marketability"), an item that goes along with the existence of dog shows.
Distant from this "market" is the study of creation of dogs (animals, plants) by other means, used to "correct"and avoid common genetic lapses and defects. I simply cannot believe that the "experts"here do not know what I am talking about. I just do not believe it. They do not like it, maybe.
Anyhow: standards have been modified before, like the AKC that includes new colors. I have no doubt they will change again.
P.S. Westminster accepted Xolos in competition. A dog that needs sun protection at all times, that cannot be outside in the sun for more than 20 minutes....and you want me to believe albinos will no longer be "produced"?
 
Eliza - that you for coming back - I will start by addressing the quote above and see if I can clarify or help you understand - The standard does not address health per se - why because it can't be measured and there are no concrete test to tell us what might develop down the line. So how you would regulate or measure something that is an unknown??? I can tell you that there is not a good breeder alive that does not strive to breed the healthest dogs they can - WHY it is to our advantage.



First if it becomes a law which I think is where you are headed in this that health testing be manditory then I think the first thing that will happen is albinos will be eliminted from even being registered and Euro as far as we know has never had an albino mutation show up in their gene pool so that is why it is not an issue there.

So here are the test we have - Vwd - DNA test gives and absolute answer - Are you saying that in showing we should present our DNA resutls every time we show??? Vwd is not fatal 98% of the the time. So what would be your measure of if the dog could show or not?

OFA - hip and elbows - Can't be done til two but you can use penn hip if you can find a vet with the proper equipment to take the needed x rays. Just about every breeder I know OFA's their dogs? It is true young puppies that are showing are not ofa yet.

I have a very close friend who has an absolutely BEAUTIFUL red male - Everything you could wish and at 2 he failed OFA - Guess what he was never bred and was neutered - does that count. I have experienced the same thing and I neutered the dog after 2 years of showing training etc. Does that count for anything???? How would you measure that??

Full blood panel and Thyroid - Again good breeders who are showing do this test.

Cardio - PDK4 DNA test - I have done all my dogs but it still does not mean they will not get cardio - What should I do???? How will I know a dog get cardio til it does???? Do you have a crystal ball??? Science doesn't have the answers yet but if you do then please share them with us.

holter - Again gives a reading on the day you do the test - still does not mean the dog will not die of cardio tomorrow.

echo - Shows the working status and picture of the heart and would show any enlargement or ventricular problems if they existed at the time but again not fail proof.

Do you thin that making these things LAW is the answer??? I that what you are trying to say - Science does not always follow a straight path and there seem to be exceptions to all rules. How would you have us proceed???



So since you brought it up and we have asked for details to help us who are so stupid to better understand WHY CAN"T you answer - WE might actually learn something since you seem to know something we don't. BUT cropping and docking has nothing to do with DNA manipulation so trying to time them together is way out of reason. I have a hard time with you guys who throw out stuff then want to skirt issues or just disappear to avoid answering.



I am here. I am trying to understand and I will be here to answer and respond to any and all questions from anyone. I will not leave the thread - disappear and avoid to answer specific questions. I will not throw up fluff to avoid answering the questions either.

Oh, I agree with you 100%, you want to sell your puppies, otherwise why would you go through all that work. My point (that I am not sure why was mis-interpreted) is that (as you concede) to re: health is a very tricky proposition. But bear with me (and I see your posts are always very intense, but do not take it personally!): if A=black+rust are allowed, B=blue, fawn,red, sometimes allowed (as long as coat is intact), by cartesian sillogism (under the assumption that A and B are true) we should have C=any color is allowed as long as intact. If I were "upset"(?) with anything, it would be the lack of logic of the system.

As for biotech goes, too long for this site.
 
Oh, I agree with you 100%, you want to sell your puppies, otherwise why would you go through all that work.





Are you kidding me?? You don't know D4E and to make a statement like that is completely out of line! If you look around this site you will find that she is one of the more knowledgeable people here. She could go toe to toe with the most informed doberman experts anywhere. She does not just sell puppies. She strives for quaility and has dedicated her life to this breed. If she she wanted to sell puppies you would see her kennel on sites where you can put a pup in your cart and be done with it. She takes the time to interview potential family will not sell to people that are not qualified.
She has been trying to have a debate with you, at your request, and your way of doing that is too assume she is a BYB! I did not see anywhere that she insulted you, so really was that necessary?
 
As for biotech goes, too long for this site.

I tell you what Eiliza - I am not that smart for sure but you might be surprised what I can understand with just a little info. I have studied genetics and breeding and how they relate to one another. I may not know all the techinical slang but I darn well know Dobermans. I did not start this discussion - you did and then when asked to explain some things so we can understand what point it is you are actually trying to make you claim it is too long for this site so I will be blunt - I call that a cop out.

And just so you know - cartesian sillogism is correctly spelled cartesian syllogism which Pertains to the French philosopher René Descartes.

So because you think it, does not make it so as you misunderstand the basic principles which make it all work and makes perfect sense to anyone who is actually involved in the system.

I am sure I am not the only one interested to learn about this "modern way" you talked about.
What manipulation of DNA are your referring to - searching for better health or ????

Those are not really technical questions and should not take much to explain what you mean when you throw it out. As you say I write long intense responses so a simple explanation will do.

If you are talking about the new show on TV cloning beloved pets for $50,000, those people did not have show dogs and were not breeding. They are just obsessed with one dog and unable to move forward. But your thoughts have been so random and never seem to come back to the same place except you are hung up on color which I find hard to understand since we have far more important things to concern ourselves with in the purebred dog world.

So let me try a simpler approach - If you are against color and showing then don't do it. That way you don't have to worry about what we do. It will not concern you and you can relieve your mind of worrying about what we do in the show world.

It has nothing to do with selling puppies - It has to do with a community of Doberman lovers who love to share our passion. You will not find anywhere anyone I have tried to "sell" a puppy to. Not one. BUT if you breed quality dogs, honor the standard, know your business and truly care about the dogs and the families - the sales will come has been my experience.

to Add: I never said albinos would not be produced I said they would not be approved by the breed club. And who the heck is this dog that needs sunscreen and what does that have to do with this discussion.

PS I don't live in Italy or anywhere else but the good old USA and those are the only rules I follow.
 
It is very sad that my attempts to logical and civil debate on a very serious topic have found insults to contend.
"Cloning"involves transfer of "identical, unadulterated"genetic material. It is a very different (but yet another issue) from what I mentioned.
The "Old good USA" is not a planet of its own, but a country that interacts with the rest of the world. A country that, in the last 20 yrs, has been subscribing and signing International Treaties, mostly implementing rules and standards born abroad.
I will cease now any interaction with this group, since it does not foster any personal growth .
All the best to you all.
 
Excuse me.... could someone help me with my personal growth and point out the insults? Cause I sure can't find them.

What a shame... this could have been an interesting debate that perhaps we all could have learned something new from. And that is the point of this forum, right? Or do I need more help than I thought with my persoanl growth?
 
Eliza - I pointed out the spelling to help you see that I did know something since you seem to feel I don't. I had hoped it would show you that I could hold my own in this debate if I can get your to clarify exactly what you are getting at I can understand. Now we are on international treaties when I thought we were talking about dog shows and breeders and what a terrible world it is because of some Modern Way you refer to as well as the mainipulation of DNA but refuse to clarify.

There is somnething you dont' like about albinos, blues, fawns and reds either that or you think they should be allowed, again you have not been clear and tend to try to bait and switch - When people start something and then won't answer questions as I have said regarding another poster is if you can't answer and continue the debate so all can learn or can't defend your position then why start it? It makes one look like they either know they were wrong or they are embarassed at being caught or possibly are trying to hide something.

You have some strong opinions - We have asked for more info so we can understand and debate. Does not mean one is right and one is wrong - we could both be right or we could both be wrong but just crying foul does not show conviction on the things you are so upset about.
 
OMG!!!!
You wrote this:
"So let me try a simpler approach - If you are against color and showing then don't do it. That way you don't have to worry about what we do. It will not concern you and you can relieve your mind of worrying about what we do in the show world".

I have nothing further to say to you, as I said many times now is pointless even try to talk.

All the best.
 
Why is ttat bad - if you don't show and don't compete then why does it concern you??? I think that is a reasonable question since you refuse to answer any other questions. You are not presenting yourself as a rational person when you bring something up and refuse to answer it. Instead you through back that you are being insulted when that is not the case.

How complicated is it to explain to us what this Modern Way of breeding is your refer to and give us the scientific study, report - web site whatever to read about it. Can we just pick one subject you brought up and discuss it - I would really like to understnad what the modern way you refer to is exactly. Surely there is a reasonable definition that even I could understand.
 
Eliza, I am not sure why you included biotechnology in this thread... Suzan isn't in league with Monsanto! Biotech has nothing to do with white Dobes! Some of us are well aware of the dangers of gmo's, however I still FAIL to see what biotech has to do with purebred dog breeding, white Dobermans, sprite at the Nationals, or Suzan's breeding philosophies. You have me scratching my head here.

It seems like you joined this forum to stir up conflict. I haven't seen any content by you that isn't over the top and confrontational... I hope I just missed some of your nice posts with something useful added to a thread. There are some forums out there that might appreciate your wandering logic, but I'm not sure this is one of them. :)
 

Back
Top