Albino invited to TT at nationals

Dobs4ever

Hot Topics Subscriber
This is the dicussion on just about every doberman list right now so don't think I am revealing an deep dark secrets about an Albino making the TT this year.

This year a very hard working woman and her rescued albino Doberman achieved high rankings and was invited to the DPCA Natls to perform in the Top Twenty. They did very well and from pictures made a striking team. I congratulate them on an outstanding performance and great accomplishment.

However, this never should have happened - Up until this time there is not a single white doberman that has achieved anything to speak of so all the bragging by the albino breeders had to be way back in the pedigree.

Now that Karen and Sprite have been highly publicized the albino breeders will jump right on it and start a campaign about how wonderful their dogs are as they were recognized at DPCA Natls in the TT.

This is very unfortunate for first Karen and Sprite who deserve the recognition and earned it - BUT at what cost???

In 2004 the DPCA did move to excluded albinos from competiton specifically mentioning the WAE and Longevity program specifically. Somehow this was overlooked and now the cat is out of the bag and you can't unring a rung bell.

This issue is not about the rescued dogs, it is not about disqualifying faults - albionism is a genetic defect and has been banned by its own breed club. It is about the DPCA following through with the program they worked so hard to establish - the white out program.

There is a huge difference between a disqualifying fault and a banned genetic defect that should not be bred to begin with. If we require "responsible breeders" to maintain a high level of integrity then how can intentionally breeding a genetic defect be acceptable in anyones book???
 
Now that Karen and Sprite have been highly publicized the albino breeders will jump right on it and start a campaign about how wonderful their dogs are as they were recognized at DPCA Natls in the TT.
Oh dear, that's exactly what's going to happen and it's really a shame....
There is a huge difference between a disqualifying fault and a banned genetic defect that should not be bred to begin with. If we require "responsible breeders" to maintain a high level of integrity then how can intentionally breeding a genetic defect be acceptable in anyones book???
You said it right there....

Kudos to the lady who rescued and for achieving what she did, but it's too bad the club didn't work things a little differently so the albino breeders didn't think they have a new merit to work from.
 
Oh great, ya I know of a breeder around my area that was selling white dobies... I was looking for a dobe and I called her only to find out she had a couple of white ones. She went on to tell me how great they were and how rare it was to have one. However, after her babble I told her I didn't think they were healthy and did not want to purchase one. She insisted her dogs were AKC and all had perfect health...anyways I turned her down because I believe the only way to stop this practice is to not buy from the breeders that practice it.
 
Tunnelrat you made the right decision but as long as there are breeders who do not care about the standard and there are people who like something just because it is rare of different they will continue. I understand AKC position on registation but they could have at least required limited reg so any resulting puppies could not be reg AKC that would have helped.

Unfortunatley the limited reg was not in place when the albino issue first came up.
 
<--------And the result from not buying from this breeder is that I got a healthy, adorable, CGC certified, and best of all such a loving cuddle bug! OH and you gotta agree he is very handsome in the picture...haha! Working on our therpy cert..... it is funny seeing people react to a dobe walking the hallways of a hospital.... they are soooo misunderstood!
 
pftt AKC... I don't see it being too long before they "paper" cross breeds as well. Infact they are doing something of the type now. But I expected more from DPCA. The hard truth is, all shoulders should be turned on this white dog and it's accomplishment. DPCA has set the rule that all white colored dobermans should be excluded as a Doberman per breed standards, and therefor this one should not have been permitted to enter against Dobermans. They set these rules they need to follow them. And it sucks because this lady did a good thing by rescuing and working with her dog. But why confuse people? This dog will showcase for the white breeders just wait and see. I really hope this lady stands as anti white and educates people on the standards set for the Doberman breed. But since DPCA made this mistake I can only wish them luck. Sighhhh.
 
Well, you know what they say.... one step forward, two steps back. I am REALLY sad about that. All the hard work good responsible breeders do just got sucker punched.

<--------And the result from not buying from this breeder is that I got a healthy, adorable, CGC certified, and best of all such a loving cuddle bug! OH and you gotta agree he is very handsome in the picture...haha! Working on our therpy cert..... it is funny seeing people react to a dobe walking the hallways of a hospital.... they are soooo misunderstood!

Funny story I have to share. I took my dogs over to the hospital the other day, it was sort of a therapy dog in training practice day. Everyone thought that Drake was just beautiful but I noticed people kept thier distance. They were loving all over Greta, being a fawn no one ever think she is a doberman. One guy was petting her saying what a great therapy dog she was going to make because she was so sweet. Then he asks what kind of dog is she? I say a doberman and he stops petting her and steps back like she was going to eat him. Funny, she was sweey until he found out she was a dobie.
 
Some additional thoughts - As this issue grinds on. First and foremost let me say DPCA has done a wonderful job in keeping this genetic defect OUT of the general population. A motion was mady in 2004 to exclude albinos from competing in any AKC event - some how the manual which is always behind in updates was dropped and not included. So the current chair of the TT could have no idea of its passing.

2nd the dog was shown with a ILP number which does not indicated a Z - color etc. So for someone to realize that this ius an albino progressing through the ranks DPCA would have to have a representative at every single show around the country to check the color of dogs entered in AKC obedience. AKC events are different from DPCA events.

In AKC any dog can show with an ILP # and now even mixed mutts can show. Here is the problem I have with that - For years AKC has been about showing the purebred dog. It has been the place that breeders could showcase their stock and test their trainablity against other purebreed dogs. Even if you have a spayed or neutered pet purebreed you spent the money for a reason. You want to compete against other purebred dogs. That is the entire purpose of the AKC registry program.

Honeslty how many mutt owners will ever train a dog to high level of competition??? They usually have a far different mind set and so they would be the exception.

It is an unfortunate event all the way around for everyone concerned. I personally think DPCA should reimburse Karen and Sprite for all her expenses in attending and showing and send her a big apology for causing her so much hurt and frustration not to mention the embarassment of all the mess this has caused and revoke her standing since it was disallowed anyway. It is unfortunate - it is a terrible and unfortunately regardless of what they do the white breeders I am sure are already promoting the heck out of the fact that a white doberman actually made it to the DPCA Natls. GAG.

Remember - this is not about the team and the job they did - this is about it appearing that DPCA supports a dog that was not suppose to have been bred to begin with and should not even exist - there is no breeder who cares about a breed who would ever intentionally breed a banned genetic defect - Not ever.
 
We have MAJOR problems in Canada because of the federal legislated 'Animal Pedigree Act'.Basically this federal law is used by the disreputable to not only register animals,not just dogs,but IMHO only,outright fraud the public.Studbooks take the registrations because they have to.And the disreputable refuse to join the kennel clubs because they don't have to by law.

There is a big difference between registered and registered titled breed stock.Dog sport is NOT for the enjoyment of people.It is to 'prove' breed stock.Hence the animals worthiness to breed.

I was just at the University of Guelph.Huge veterinary school and facility here in Canada.There was a Bulldog in the waiting room.refined look about him,but he had DQ colour.They paid 3500 for the animal.I asked what colours the litter was.The breeder explained it to them as they all had DQ colour because 'sometimes that happens'!Remember this is a vet they are showing the dog to that is supposed to LOVE Bulldogs.Would you not think she would know their standard?Apparently not.

So there is another breeder in N.America breeding registered culls for vets and stupid people.Lovely.

I just had opportunity to speak with a woman doing fostering for rescue.We got talking and she had not one knowledgeable word to say about reputable breeding.She actually told me that she had just met a Mastiff breeder that 'knew his lines' and was selling his puppies altered.She approved of that!

Sire and Dam titled?......no,of course not.But he's going to sell them for 1500 a piece.If the general public ever takes a notion that they could housetrain horses,something might get done.I doubt it,but I have hope.

Why is it so hard for judges to dismiss a dog from the ring?It's not their breed so they don't care.That's one of my biggest PO's!
 
Wait... I am confused. TT for conformation?? (i am used to the agility and obedience world) I agree if its for conformation, but for performance ones i dont see a big deal since is not really breeding related activities. i seen maybe 2 albinos that do OB here, and they are very impressive.
 
Wait... I am confused. TT for conformation?? (i am used to the agility and obedience world) I agree if its for conformation, but for performance ones i dont see a big deal since is not really breeding related activities. i seen maybe 2 albinos that do OB here, and they are very impressive.
I am under the impression that is was for OB. No judge would have passed an albino through for conformation. The concern is that those promoting the albino breedings will use this dog and his success to further their incorrect thoughts and bad breeding practices.
 
I had a white given to me. The litter was a total of 9-11 pups, both parents were white. The girls neighbors started complaining about all the barking. I had looked at them, and one sort of picked me. I didn't take her. There was no plans for breeding, I knew better. About 2 weeks later she called and asked if I would take her she kept getting out of the fence at the girls aunts. And boy could she jump the fence. From a 'sit' she could just fly over the farm fence at the back of my yard. She got out once picked up a toy and jumped back. It was pretty funny to watch. She always behaved and was easy to train. She had the best personality and was just happy go lucky. About 1 1/2 years ago, a week shy of her 10th birthday, she had to be put down because of cancer.

No they shouldn't be bred or compete in confirmation, but she was a great pet.
 
I can understand how people could think to themselves.....it's only OB.....only.

Here's where I get annoyed.This person obtained an ILP# for her rescued albino Doberman.Pursues it to the ends of the earth.People notice.She such a good sportsmen,right?I don't think so and I'll tell you why.

I have greyhounds that were bred on the AKC recognized NGA studbook and I have to either get a dual registration and allow judges to check their ears for tattoos in conformation or send them into only...agility,OB,coursing.They still get their ears checked.Or I can get an ILP# and still have the entire AKC ignore their recognized studbook.A registered greyhound is persona non grata?

To me both options are positively insulting.Adding insult to injury.....

This woman gets an IPL# for a dog she KNOWS full well is not recognized by the national breed club.To make a point?I would like to know.

Exhibitor must display good sportsmanship at all times or be dismissed from competition.My NGA greys and I would have been dismissed before we even got on the field.Her and her Z-FACT is welcomed with open arms.I don't like it.
 
No they shouldn't be bred or compete in confirmation, but she was a great pet.

Leatha....Please,understand that I am not knocking ANY forum members canine companions.I want to believe this woman is enjoying her companion animal and genuinely rescued it.However,I have my doubts.There are politics in sanctioned sport that can be very unsettling.This competing owner and her dog are a very clear case of it.
 
Guys this is not about what we like or don't like in judging breekding etc. It is about following rules. We are not talking about disallowed colors we are talking about a genetic mutation that produced a defective albino gene. And after a study the DPCA said thise dogs are not fit for breeding period.

The worked hard with AKC to have their reg denied but because they met the AKC requirement of coming from two reg parents they reg them. So as long as AKC gives them reg # then we will continue to have those breeders who will take advantage of JQP.

Yes some are good pets but far to many have serious issues, Eye sensitivity, skin sensitivity to sun light which makes them ore susceptible to cancer, and numberous other genetic problems that crop of far more frequently than in the general population - eplipsey, poor temperaments etc. All this is compounded again because there is such a small gene pool of Z factored,

I do believe that dog sport is for anyone and everyone who enjoyss competiton and I fully support pet owners competing with their dogs they are far better people for it and just like horse showing it is a great family activity.
Conformation is considered the "Breed ring" reserved primarily for those who want to compete intact dogs. I believe everyting else should be open to any and all reg dogs so people can enjoy the sport. Having a hobby of activity helps keep people focused, gives them a great sense of accomplishment and builds self confidence in both the person showing and the dog being shown.

Why is it so hard for judges to dismiss a dog from the ring?It's not their breed so they don't care.That's one of my biggest PO's!

Often times if someone has never been heavily involved in the show ring I can see how they would not understand this. There are faults and there are disqualifing faults - Excusing a dog from the breed ring has nothing to do with a judge not caring because it is not their breed. If we consider facts it is hard to be a judge especially if you are certified to judge a # of breeds from your group. Most judges I know are much harder when judging their own breed because they know everyone will think it is prejudice on their part. But a judge is going to understand his breed far better than other breeds unless he goes and spends some time with each breed observing them, studying their standard and then comparing that standard back to a wide range of that breed to get a general idea of the best of that breed.

However, it is economics pure and simple. If they started excusing dogs right and left from the ring because they did not like that particular dog - who would ever want to enter their dog to show?? It is a competiton - for those who enjoy it and it is a good tool for judging the quality of a breeders program if we are talking about conformation which is the Breed Ring. Thats why there are faults and there are disqualifying faults.

Obedience, agility, rally do give a breeder a broader understanding of their dogs but is not considered which is why we have seen a decline in working ability and temperament. The breed ring was not devised to judge temperament or working ability for working breeds. We have other avenues for that.

AKC has very strict rules about what can be reg - You can get and ILP # for a reg dog and it happens all the time with rescues who often times do not come with their papers but are obviously purebred dogs and people who rescue sometimes like to enter programs and compete with their dogs but an ILP # says the dogs correct parentage can't be verified but the dog can still compete among its peers. I think the ILP # is a great program and allows people to enter the wonder world of dog sports with their rescued or pet puppies.

Each registry wether we are talking AKC, IABCA, UKC, UDC, DVG, FCI - every single one requires you to meet their criteria for registration and if you are going to complete in their events you must reg you dog with their reg even if he is reg withy AKC. They all accept AKC reg - AKC does not necessarily accept their reg for reg with AKC.

Again we are not talikng about the entir AKC program but the fact that a dog slipped through and was invited to the DPCA natls which is a specialty club and does not fall under AKC rules. Breed clubs can set their own rules as long as they follow AKC requirements - they can be more restrictive but not less restrictive.

I have greyhounds that were bred on the AKC recognized NGA studbook and I have to either get a dual registration and allow judges to check their ears for tattoos in conformation or send them into only...agility,OB,coursing.They still get their ears checked.Or I can get an ILP# and still have the entire AKC ignore their recognized studbook.A registered greyhound is persona non grata?

This is a prime example of the requirements above - If you do not meet the AKC requirements you can get an ILP # but not compete in the breed ring because the requirements were not met. So I would tatoo the ears and get dual reg if that is the requirement as I understand your statement. If you choose not to then they are not reg with AKC as they do not meet the AKC guidelines for reg in their reg.

As we can see it is all very complicated so we can't just jump off and say AKC is the problem. Rules are in place to protect the integrity of their registry. Breed clubs have rules to protect the integrity of their specific breed - they all have to work hand in hand and AKC holds certified copeis of each breed club standards and they shows are required to judge to those standards. But if you play ball on someone else's homefield then you have to follow their rules. DPCA's rule is albinos are not allowed to compete in DPCA sponsored events.
 
This was for Obedience, yes. There's at least one picture floating around; Sprite, in addition to her Albinism, is not conformationally correct, even at a glance. And that's to me. I'm torn on this issue; people breeding and promoting Albino Dobermans is a bad thing. A person working with her rescue dog is a good thing. Really, I think that since was an invitational, the DPCA should've known who they were inviting, ILP# be damned. They should refund, apologize, and make their rules explicitly clear.
 
from what i have read.. Karen educates people to no end on the health issues of whites... she is a vet tech... she trained Sprite herself .. she has pamphlets she hands to people who ask about her dog... i commend her on a job well done and on Educating people ... she was invited and qualified.. there was an error somewhere but .. DPCA needs to let it go and move on.. if there is an issue fix it for next time..
 
If the AKC could only solve all the ills of the Dog World!

An AKC registration is a passport for dogs and they can go places with it.Wonderful places.It is a huge accomplishment for both owner and dog to succeed in any sanctioned sport.Controversies of this nature,like an albino at a DPCA sponsored even,will happen from time to time.I don't really know how ILP# registration could be changed to stop this type of thing happening.ILP# are not, in and of themselves ,a bad thing for sanctioned sport or breeds that are in need of expanding genetically.In this case the ILP# just might save a breed on the AKC studbook.I can't argue with that.

I think this case highlights national club responsibilities to their breed,in such a glaring way,it's very hard to keep an open mind.You can get very jaded and disheartened when things go awry.One thing happens and it feels like a Pandora's Box has opened up and taken over.

When a breed has controversial sanctions,as many do,it does tend to make you take a strong stand.Even if it appears irrational because your already making hard choices and having to explain your decision with people who might just as strongly disagree.Many times they are devoted to the same breed!Factor in people who think all sanctioned sport is looney and you can start to feel defeated and pessimistic.

Thanks Dobs4ever for expanding on recognized studbooks and AKC registration.I tend to make the assumption people know all about it and then just go OFF,like a rocket, from there.I do think at this point in time,encouraging people to come out and participate in sanctioned sport,can only be a good thing ,in my rational mind.

I hate sullying anything with money.The sanctioned events are so expensive to put on,I can't be too damning about collecting fees of any kind.Canada just lost a prestigious sanctioned event because it became too expensive to put on.I've seen published material that claimed the event was costing in excess of $50 ooo.

What can the DPCA do?Is there any word of a decision on their part yet?
 
Karen educates people to no end on the health issues of whites... she is a vet tech... she trained Sprite herself .. she has pamphlets she hands to people who ask about her dog....

This is exactly as I suspected.She knew going into a DPCA event that her dog was going to be controversial.She went anyways because she knows more than the DPCA?

If this is true,for me,there is something in her behavior that puts me to mind of people who do knowingly breed albino.
 

Back
Top