• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

A discussion on Temperament

Dobs4ever

Hot Topics Subscriber
A discussion of the Doberman Temperament - Prior to 1989 you will find working Dobermans and show Dobermans in the Doberman publication - doberman digest.

I have many of those old digest and when I go back and skim through them It always surprises me to see working dobermans right across the page from a show doberman.

So what happened - it has often been referred to as the "BIG Schutzhund debate". That debate let to the split in the DPCA and the forming of the UDC in 1990.

Let's look first at what created the debate - and it goes right back to the AR groups and their efforts to point out all problems including dogs that bite or more accurately from their misconceptions are "Trained to bite" AKC decided in an effort to appease them to drop ALL bite sports. They wanted to hide the fact that our dogs have a bad ass reputation and did not want any examples of dogs biting in Schutzhund on display, in fear it would hurt our dogs image and future. Frank Grover of DPCA went so far as to say that it is not a sport for amateurs but should be left to the police and military to train such dogs. I totally disagree with that reasoning. Football is for professionals but grade school children play the game. As long as there are rules, structure, training and a learning of the dynamics of the drives, instincts and character of a dog then both the dogs and the people benefit. Today we are partly in the mess we are in because we have too many citified folks who were not brought up around animals so they have no understanding of how animals are different from people.

But 70 years later we are still innundated with the reputation of those first Dobermans known as the "Devil Dogs". We have not disspelled those original impressions of the Doberman. Our decisionwas to try to run and hide from it or do we embrace it and maintain our time honored position as a working breed? Do we deny our rich heritage as a "Devil Dog" that saved thousands of lives during the war?? Are we so engrossed in the beauty pagent we have lost the very essense that makes up the Doberman - Temperament?

A working breed should first and foremost be about temperament as that goes to the very heart of why the working breeds were created.

We should seek three charastics in our dobermans - conformation, temperament and trainability -Temperament is paramount to the very being of a Doberman

From the DPCA web site: DPCA.org
TEMPERAMENT -There should be no compromise in temperament it should be excellent
Energetic, watchful, determined alert, fearless, loyal and obedient. The judge shall dismiss from the ring any shy or vicious Doberman.

Shyness: A dog shall be judged fundamentally shy if, refusing to stand for examination, it shrinks away from the judge; if it fears an approach from the rear; if it shies at sudden and unusual noises to a marked degree.

Viciousness: A dog that attacks or attempts to attack either the judge or its handier, is definitely vicious. An aggressive or belligerent attitude towards other dogs shall not be deemed viciousness.

Energetic - electric much like a tight rubber band stretched to almost breaking point - always ready
Alert - totally aware of every movement, sight, sound (but not nervous)
Watchful - On guard and always aware of surroundings.
determined - Not easily detered from the assigned task
fearless - Stands his ground
loyal - The doberman exceeds at this trait better than any other breed - Always faithful
obedient - They love to please their owners and should love to work

From the FCI web site:

Temper and Behavior
The character of the Dobermann is friendly and peaceful. It is devoted to the family and is caring toward children. In dobermann we look for a medium temperament, a medium aggressiveness and a fair tolerance before reaction. The Dobermann is easily trainable and enjoys the work and has good working ability thanks to its decisiveness, braveness and strong temperament. Its self-confidence and its intrepidness are also required considering that this breed is very alert toward its surroundings and reactive toward all kind of events.

What may be a surprise about the FCI standard is that it calls for MEDIUM temperament and sharpness which shoots down the theory that European dobermanns are still bred for thier original purpose. While they follow closer than the American doberman they have still been toned down to make them a better companion and family dog.

In studying temperament I find it interesting that loyal and obedient combined with braveness and fearlessness catapulted the Doberman to it place in history. We must never forget that history.
 
I didn't know there was a difference between Euro and American temperament. I adopted my dobergirl from a local Humane Society, so I don't know her history unfortunately, but I've had some people tell me she looks like she could have Euro in her. Maybe that's why she never keeps her mouth shut lol :p .

Very interesting! Thank you for sharing! :)
 
thanks Susan very interesting it amazes me that they keep wanting to fix something that is not broken, they expect every dog to be a carbon copy of each other their uniqueness is why we all love them, it's a shame they are not as interested in the breeding of murderers,rapists, pedophiles and all their offsprings that go on to perpetuate the cycle.
 
Judith - It is not as much that we want carbon copies but the standard allows us to hold on to the things that make this breed so unique. And you are so correct that is what makes them so special. In another thread we talked about them being the only breed created form 4 other breeds - herding, retriever, terrier and molosser. This makes them very unique and the standard is our guide to help us maintain those special qualities unique to our Doberman and temperament is certainly the most important in a working breed if you would have to pick only one.

Working breeds were bred for a specific task so temperament was the one thing that determines the dogs ability to do that task. It is the diversity in the dobermans back ground that allows them to cross over and exhibit traits that are derived from on of the original breeds used. I am glad that Otto Groller who continued on after Herr Dobermann died had a little nicer picture in mind as far as looks. Looks and temperament contribute more to a dog breeds success than anything else.

Unfortunately for the working breeds that has been a problem as conformation took over and folks no longer worked their stock to know that they were perserving the working part. The division has plagued every breed to some extent. For example in some of the toy breeds the beautiful full coats we admire so much are very impractical for actually doing the job that they were bred for.
 
Thanks for posting this. It is good info for people. As I get more involved in the doberman world I run into people that seem to have their own definition of temperament. Being someone who is trying to learn it can get confusing. I know when I was in Denver at the nationals, I walked around listening to different people talking and was amazed to hear all the different opinions. It was interesting to me to see the people with the let's say "abstract" definition were the ones that had a dog fail the WAE. Another interesting observation was there seemed be a different definition on the conformation days than on the IPO days. After I got back home and had time to think about it, I decided that there are 4 kinds of dobe owners 1. the conformation 2 the working dobe 3 the pet owner and last but not least the all around doberman, the own breeders should be striving for...IMHO.
 
Thank Genny - I was not sure when you asked me to start a discussion where the best place to begin was and how to explain this illusive thing we call temperament. The AR groups have gone a long way in trying to destroy all we love about the purebred dog world. They want the dogs gone and the guns gone leaving us with no sense of protection.

Every purebred dog out there was bred specifically to fulfil a purpose. I feel as breeders we are the guardians of those original creations and it is our sworn sacred duty to preserve as best we can what our breed was bred for.....the only breed ever bred specifically to work beside man as his loyal protector. Herr Dobermann died before he completed his work and Groller carried on. I feel had Herr Dobermann continued on he would have softened the temperment himself to make it more manageable and easier to live with so i don't have a problem with it. Not many of us would have wanted one of Herr Dobermanns original dogs not in temperament and not in looks.

Just look at the different classes of dogs - Sporting - non-sporting - herding - hounds - toys - terriors - WORKING.... I personally believe that the working group is the most important group every created. To me they are the REAL dogs ----the Heros. But I did not live back in the 15th centruy with no heat in cold drafty castles so I don't need or want a pekeinese to warm my feet!!! Bt I bet back then they ere highly prized for all that hair.

Purpose - starts and ends with temperament for the working breed. Obviously for the terrior group temperament had to be tough and out of control to follow some rat down into a whole and drag it out and kill it. In a big dogs body they would be very dangerous with their fiesty, firey, no holds barred attitude. That had to be toned down in our dogs and is especially true today in our more urban lifestyles.
 
I agree whole heartedly that the definition of a “good” or “bad” temperament is breed specific and must be tied to the reason a breed exists in the first place.

I disagree with blaming AR groups for the loss of temperament in the protection breeds. The Conformation/Show aficionados have done more to damage the working ability of ALL dog breeds. Far more damage than the Animal Rights groups.

AR groups are certainly contributing to the problem, but “we” are the root cause of the lost working ability. Doesn’t matter if the breed is Standard Poodles, English Mastiffs, Golden Retrievers or Dobermanns.

Breeding for looks without an established, confirmed ability to work damages breeds. Breeding for nice, easy to manage pets damages breeds.
 
I understand why you feel the way you do but if you know the history prior to 1989 AKC supported and held Schutzund events. As the AR pressure grew and more and more people did not understand about country life the fear whether justified or not led them to ban the working dog sports. It is hard to breed for temperament if you are not exposed to it and conformation is your only option. I know because we lost our helper and for 4 years we really struggled to work and test our dogs.

I do agree that as conformation grew and became very popular that it did make a difference but not having working dog sports supported by AKC did far more to harm than all the conformation in the world. Vic Monteloene of DPCA was one of the creators of the WAE which is an excellent tool for breeders to use to test temperament. Vic was a big conformation person but he understood the importance of conformation folks having a way to test temperament.
 
“not having working dog sports supported by AKC did far more to harm than all the conformation in the world”

We agree and disagree at the same time on this. Yes, lack of support by the AKC has been the major roadblock to holding working trials and/or working title registration requirements. On the other hand, the reality is that conformation/show people ARE the “the AKC” and it’s been that way since before I was born.

I’ve stopped simply blaming “The AKC” because it’s comprised of people and their attitudes; it’s not some computer or god-like entity. “The AKC” and Show/Conformation aficionados are for all intents and purposes the same thing.

I was unaware that the AKC has ever supported or held Schutzhund events (for any breed). Are you certain about your historical claim? It’s only very recently that the AKC has even allowed working titles on registrations.

My history knowledge comes through German Shepherd Dogs. As far as I’ve ever learned, the GSD clubs in USA never had a working title requirement for registration or breeding. As far as I know NO working breed has ever had a working title requirement for registration/breeding in the USA. Historically “The AKC” has gone to great efforts trying to derail working trials.

Sometime in the late 1960’s some GSD enthusiasts began organizing Schutzhud trials. By the 1970’s the “AKC” (or rather people who influence the AKC’s direction and decisions), threatened and manipulated trying to stop the GSD club from holding working trials.

When I first learned of the WAE, I thought “Better than nothing”. Now though, I’ve come to the conclusion that it really doesn’t provide a meaningful evaluation of a working (protection) dog.

If an IPO/SchH title is perceived as too much effort for American breeders, then at least a ZTP type evaluation should be used.

In some respects, the WAE does more harm than good because it can give breeders (and customers) a false belief regarding a dog’s temperament.
 
What may be a surprise about the FCI standard is that it calls for MEDIUM temperament and sharpness which shoots down the theory that European dobermanns are still bred for thier original purpose. While they follow closer than the American doberman they have still been toned down to make them a better companion and family dog.

I would like to know the source of your above claim..(highlighted text)
It would be more correct to say,temperament (and structure wise), Dobermann in Europe is more suitable than NA Doberman for protection work, but no where near the original dogs!!

Herr Karl Friedrich Louis Dobermann did not lay down any of the temperament standards of today..All he wanted was a sharp dog that would be loyal & protect him at all costs..
Lets face it, as much as we love the breed, how many of us would be able to handle such a dog? have him fit our domestic lifestyle? NONE!!

In the second half of 20th century, they started laying down breed standards that would tone down the original temperament to acceptable levels, so that the dog could be integrated to our present life stile..
I believe that's where we lost the original temperament..
 
Ice - I don't think a "sharp" dog equates to medium temperament and the FCI source came from Dobermann Review. No one ever said that Herr doberman laid down any temperament standards- he created it and then as time passed and they became a recognized breed the Breed club was formed first in Germany in 1899 by Otto Groller. The original dogs were much sharper and harder to live with so changes had to be made - we agree on this. Even in Germany today they are not as sharp as those original dogs.

Not knowing German it could be that the term medium temperament really should have been translated to "Balanced" temperament. All of which I agree with. When I said shoots down the theory that they are still bred for the original purpose I should have made it clearer and as I read it I have to agree with you- What I was trying to say is .....They are not still bred with the original temperament that Herr Dobermann bred - I think his dobermanns were more man killers and we want man stoppers.

As I read you text I really think we are saying the same thing. All Doberman's have been changed in both looks and temperament for the betterment of being able to handle them and live with them .....I agree 100% the working Dobermans are much better suited for protection work but regardless very few are used today for that purpose. Sadly show dobermans are not respected much anywhere by the working folks.

I believe they are not used more by police because the Doberman(n) must have a personal relationship with man to bond and protect. So they are not as at good changing handlers and working with different people or living in a kennel environment. They want to sleep in your bed and eat your breakfast....... It is part of what makes them so unique and most police dogs today are put thru a crash course so they can get them out on the field working. Doberman's mature slower.

I think to some extent that the lack of good Schutzhund clubs and trainers is our biggest draw back over here. Where over there I think you have a much more supportative community towards the working dogs and it is more popular over there. Unfortunatley conformation became almost the sole focus over here and most of the dogs that are working dogs were imported. But we do have AKC CH Schutzhund dogs so all is not totally lost.

Breeding for looks without an established, confirmed ability to work damages breeds. Breeding for nice, easy to manage pets damages breeds.
Adhan I agree - Breeding for only on part of the standard is wrong regardless of what it is. It is just as wrong to only breed for working with little regard for conformation and/or balanc or to breed for health with the exclusing of the other parts of the program.

But all agree that regulation is not good for the dogs, for breeding programs or for the future of the purebred dog world.
 
I tried to find some links that show the history of AKC vs. Schutzhund. Interestingly, the long, sordid history of the AKC’s efforts to prevent Schutzhund from gaining a foothold in the USA is not well documented online.

Back when I first became interested in working dogs, it was common knowledge that the Conformation/Show people (through the AKC) were very much against working trials. It was common knowledge that “the AKC” had engaged in shenanigans towards the German Shepherd Dog Club over Schutzhund.

At that time, it was no secret that the United Schutzhund Clubs of America came into existence because of the threats and pressure exerted on the German Shepherd Dog Club of America by Show/Conformation folks (aka “the AKC”).

The information readily available on the web today is a very mild, watered down version of events.

This article gives some history, but again it minimizes the extent that the “AKC” has gone to in their attempts at quashing Working Trials.
THE AMERICAN WORKING DOG FEDERATION

A couple exerpts-

“In 1969 there was a short lived National Schutzhund Association formed under the leadership of Herb Preiser in Illinois. In 1971 Alfons Ertelt, Kurt Marti and a few others launched the North American Schutzhund Association. Although they almost immediately changed the name to the North American Working Dog Association, the NASA abbreviation was maintained. NASA’s goal from the beginning was to differentiate themselves from the Europeans and work toward mainstream acceptance, with AKC affiliation a goal of many. Much to their credit, the American Doberman Pincher Club was a charter NASA member and held out to become last ditch supporters in the end. (The American Working Doberman movement has been a most interesting saga in and of itself, but that’s a story for another day.) ……………..”

“During the middle seventies some Schutzhund activity was going on under the auspices of the German Shepherd Dog Club of America (GSDCA). In 1975 the displeasure of the AKC made the GSDCA back off and lead directly to the formulation of the United Schutzhund Clubs of America, which in spite of its name is specifically a German Shepherd organization. (Although other breeds have always been allowed to participate in its Schutzhund trials, conformation events and breed surveys are for German Shepherds only.) USA quickly became the predominant working dog sport organization in America and within a few years was larger, and certainly more influential, than the AKC shackled GSDCA………………………….”

“Finally, on June the 17th of 1989 a foundation meeting was held in St. Louis. Present at the creation were Paul Meloy, Vernon Crowder, Erik Houttuin, Jim Engel, Eckart Salquit, Jacqueline Rousseau and Ray Carlisle, all familiar names on the American working dog scene.
After lengthy discussion, the American Working Dog Federation (AWDF) came into existence as an alliance of national breed organizations dedicated to the preservation and advancement of the protective heritage working breeds. Charter members were clubs for the German Shepherd (USA), Doberman, Bouvier (NAWBA) and Rottweiler………….”

“The original AWDF Doberman member club was the AKC affiliated Doberman Pinscher Club of America. This affiliation, the increase in Doberman Schutzhund activity and the growing acceptance of the membership panicked the old guard.
This precipitated the infamous AKC dictate of June 18, 1990 forbidding Schutzhund and all of the traditional protection sports and trials. By this action the AKC demanded that its member clubs for these breeds repudiate their heritage. This has formalized the already emerging rift in these breeds, with the AKC clubs moving to the solidification of their concept of working dogs as mere “pets” and “show dogs” and the emergence of clubs with the traditional European point of view in each breed.
As a result of the withdrawal of the AKC Doberman club, there was an immediate formation of the United Doberman Club, which became a full AWDF member in January of 1991…………………..”

The Show/Conformation dominated AKC has been vehemently against working trails from the get-go. If AR groups have had any influence on Schutzhund in the USA, it’s been relatively insignificant.
 
“It is just as wrong to only breed for working with little regard for conformation”

I used to believe that too, but I’m not so sure any more. It’s very difficult to argue with the success of the Belgian Malinois, a breed whose conformation has been considered somewhat irrelevant. It’s also difficult to argue with the success of various other breeds throughout the world from hunting to herding dogs whose conformation is more or less a non-consideration.

The more experienced I become, the more I start to think that it’s detrimental to place more than a minimal amount of emphasis on conformation.

At this point it seems like we are trying too hard to appease those whose primary goal or concern is looks. How much does some ideal vision of head shape, back arch or angles really matter to a Coon Hound? To a Cattle Dog? Or a Protection Dog?

Perhaps it’s time to stop the appeasement & sugar coating and bluntly state that breed specific temperament needs to trump everything else?
 
I agree we are working way too hard trying to appease people who want our dogs gone. And that could certainly be its own thread on all the clubs and how the politics and power ebb and flow. You could put in a thimble what I know about the GSD clubs. I am a Doberman person through and through. DPCA is one of the very few breed clubs that is member club of AKC. Tony Di Nardo and his wife Shelia and Daughter Gina all are high up in AKC. So due to that relationship AKC had a good relationship with DPCA and the working Dobermans up until 1989. That is when it all fell apart.

But this is about temperament and how it realtes to The Doberman. How each dogs drives, instincts and training play out. It is about breeders reaching that ultimate balance in temperament that brings a strong, confident dog that is sociable and stable.

We all agree that temperament has changed and in the beginning it was necessary for the breed to become popular. Few people would have wanted that original "pinscher" which means terrier..............It is the doberman temperament that emerged that made this dog the Cadillac of dogs. His strong willingness to please and work for his master. His incredible loyalty and devotion are unequaled in the dog world. Velcro is often used to describe our dogs. If you move they move if you try to leave the room they are coming even if you are coming right back.

The War dog memorial on Guam really says it all about this breed - Always Faithful.

You will not legislate good temperament. It all rest with the breeder to breed the best they can to develop a strong stable line. Good breeders strive for this because of their love and passion for the breed. Legislation only brings about corruption and has no place in the development of a good dog. We have some excellent programs to help us learn about our dogs strengths and weaknesses and then we use those to make good breeding decisions.

So as you look at your dog and work with your dog you are going to be evaluating the parts that make temperament

Drives: Pack Drive - Prey Drive - Food drive - Defense drive- fight drive

Pack drive is simply put the desire of the dog to work within its pack and be a part of the pack

Prey drive is how the dog responds to chasing a moving object - a good tool for motivating the dog

Food drive - is a base line survivall instinct but does allow us to motivate the dog though food

Defense drive - The dogs instinct to defend itself and it's pack and nerves will pay a part in shaping the defense drive -
a very nervy dog will overreact to things and we would refer to that more as a fear response.

Fight drive - the opposite to fight is flight so fight drive is the dogs willingness to say hey I am fine but cross the line and I am going to take you on. The dog does not back down or run from the fight.

Drives are there when the sperm hits the egg so you will not change the basic make up of the dogs drives. You can shape them to try to reach maximum potential or you could squash it but it is still there underneath and will come out depending on the stimuli or situation.

Where does avoidance come in??? How do you work with your dog to accomplish a task if the dog uses avoidance?? Most people cave in and say He doesn't like that so we won't do it anymore and the dog learns that by using avoidance he wins and doesn't have to do what he is asked.

Temperament is a very complicated, complex set of drives and instincts that can be shaped by training to help us accomplish whatever task we set out to accomplish with the dog. How much does environment influence the outcome??? When you look at your trainign with your dog do you see these drives in action and if so how???
 
I don't agree with breeding dogs with little concern for conformation. I don't think that conformation is just looks alone. It is also about function. Let's say you have a dog with everything you need to be an outstanding working dog...except correct conformation. When you start breeding dogs like that, what do you end up with? A hot mess! A good breeder strives for the standard which includes conformation.
 
“It is just as wrong to only breed for working with little regard for conformation”

I tried to add this but missed it - Breeding a totally balanced dog is like a 4 legged stool - Conformation, temperament, trainablity and health - remove any leg and you have an unbalanced dog.

So let's look at the Mals...... Mostly bred for temperament - and that brings about dogs that are frantic and over the top. I have seen Mals turn on the handler and bite them out of frustration if the handler tries to hold them back. When you only breed for temperament then you have dogs that are unstable. It takes balance in a great working dog. Plus I hate that half starved scrawny look. I have seen some nice Mals but not as many I see the other kind. Even a lot of police have stopped using the Mals and that has to say something.
 
Dobs4ever How would you go about building food drive ? I clearly see the other drives in Drake and understand how to build on them. However, I would say that he is flat out picky when it comes to food. Has has gotten better and will work for food now. Just wondering how that happened. I started working before feeding him so he would be hungry and he learned that the treats I was giving him were not so bad. Did that do it or was it something else? Just asking because we still have days where he is not so food motivated.
 
Just as working breeders are destroying conformation and function, one dog at a time in the US.

This is a very one sided argument.

Not one person is at fault more than the next.
The reason workability is dying is not because of conformation people. Its because no one wants to spend 10k on a dog that may never protect them. Let alone put in all that time and effort.
 
Where did you come up with the $10,000 figure??? I know a lot of great Schutzhund breeders and their puppies don't cost $10,000. Are you speaking of a fully trained dog??? I do agree today most are too lazy to put in the time and effort it takes to train one.

Paint - I would always work with the dog is hungry. Find a food they LOVE and only use it for training. You might even go so far as to not feed the dog the night before so they are really hungry.
 
Where did you come up with the $10,000 figure??? I know a lot of great Schutzhund breeders and their puppies don't cost $10,000. Are you speaking of a fully trained dog??? I do agree today most are too lazy to put in the time and effort it takes to train one.

Paint - I would always work with the dog is hungry. Find a food they LOVE and only use it for training. You might even go so far as to not feed the dog the night before so they are really hungry.

You yourself have told me that figure at Nationals in Colorado.

When you figure not even a breeding dog. Between seminars, trials, training expenses, equipment, original purchase of the dog it comes very close.

Im not saying people are lazy in the Doberman world. I am saying less and less people (by your own words) are joining the sport. That's a lot of time and energy to put into a dog, for you to not even know if he would bite in this situation, unless the attacker had a jute sleeve on.

My main point is not to diss conformation, or schutzhund. Just to point out that BOTH parties are at fault for the state of todays Doberman.
 

Back
Top