Dobs4ever
Hot Topics Subscriber
A discussion of the Doberman Temperament - Prior to 1989 you will find working Dobermans and show Dobermans in the Doberman publication - doberman digest.
I have many of those old digest and when I go back and skim through them It always surprises me to see working dobermans right across the page from a show doberman.
So what happened - it has often been referred to as the "BIG Schutzhund debate". That debate let to the split in the DPCA and the forming of the UDC in 1990.
Let's look first at what created the debate - and it goes right back to the AR groups and their efforts to point out all problems including dogs that bite or more accurately from their misconceptions are "Trained to bite" AKC decided in an effort to appease them to drop ALL bite sports. They wanted to hide the fact that our dogs have a bad ass reputation and did not want any examples of dogs biting in Schutzhund on display, in fear it would hurt our dogs image and future. Frank Grover of DPCA went so far as to say that it is not a sport for amateurs but should be left to the police and military to train such dogs. I totally disagree with that reasoning. Football is for professionals but grade school children play the game. As long as there are rules, structure, training and a learning of the dynamics of the drives, instincts and character of a dog then both the dogs and the people benefit. Today we are partly in the mess we are in because we have too many citified folks who were not brought up around animals so they have no understanding of how animals are different from people.
But 70 years later we are still innundated with the reputation of those first Dobermans known as the "Devil Dogs". We have not disspelled those original impressions of the Doberman. Our decisionwas to try to run and hide from it or do we embrace it and maintain our time honored position as a working breed? Do we deny our rich heritage as a "Devil Dog" that saved thousands of lives during the war?? Are we so engrossed in the beauty pagent we have lost the very essense that makes up the Doberman - Temperament?
A working breed should first and foremost be about temperament as that goes to the very heart of why the working breeds were created.
We should seek three charastics in our dobermans - conformation, temperament and trainability -Temperament is paramount to the very being of a Doberman
From the DPCA web site: DPCA.org
TEMPERAMENT -There should be no compromise in temperament it should be excellent
Energetic, watchful, determined alert, fearless, loyal and obedient. The judge shall dismiss from the ring any shy or vicious Doberman.
Shyness: A dog shall be judged fundamentally shy if, refusing to stand for examination, it shrinks away from the judge; if it fears an approach from the rear; if it shies at sudden and unusual noises to a marked degree.
Viciousness: A dog that attacks or attempts to attack either the judge or its handier, is definitely vicious. An aggressive or belligerent attitude towards other dogs shall not be deemed viciousness.
Energetic - electric much like a tight rubber band stretched to almost breaking point - always ready
Alert - totally aware of every movement, sight, sound (but not nervous)
Watchful - On guard and always aware of surroundings.
determined - Not easily detered from the assigned task
fearless - Stands his ground
loyal - The doberman exceeds at this trait better than any other breed - Always faithful
obedient - They love to please their owners and should love to work
From the FCI web site:
Temper and Behavior
The character of the Dobermann is friendly and peaceful. It is devoted to the family and is caring toward children. In dobermann we look for a medium temperament, a medium aggressiveness and a fair tolerance before reaction. The Dobermann is easily trainable and enjoys the work and has good working ability thanks to its decisiveness, braveness and strong temperament. Its self-confidence and its intrepidness are also required considering that this breed is very alert toward its surroundings and reactive toward all kind of events.
What may be a surprise about the FCI standard is that it calls for MEDIUM temperament and sharpness which shoots down the theory that European dobermanns are still bred for thier original purpose. While they follow closer than the American doberman they have still been toned down to make them a better companion and family dog.
In studying temperament I find it interesting that loyal and obedient combined with braveness and fearlessness catapulted the Doberman to it place in history. We must never forget that history.
I have many of those old digest and when I go back and skim through them It always surprises me to see working dobermans right across the page from a show doberman.
So what happened - it has often been referred to as the "BIG Schutzhund debate". That debate let to the split in the DPCA and the forming of the UDC in 1990.
Let's look first at what created the debate - and it goes right back to the AR groups and their efforts to point out all problems including dogs that bite or more accurately from their misconceptions are "Trained to bite" AKC decided in an effort to appease them to drop ALL bite sports. They wanted to hide the fact that our dogs have a bad ass reputation and did not want any examples of dogs biting in Schutzhund on display, in fear it would hurt our dogs image and future. Frank Grover of DPCA went so far as to say that it is not a sport for amateurs but should be left to the police and military to train such dogs. I totally disagree with that reasoning. Football is for professionals but grade school children play the game. As long as there are rules, structure, training and a learning of the dynamics of the drives, instincts and character of a dog then both the dogs and the people benefit. Today we are partly in the mess we are in because we have too many citified folks who were not brought up around animals so they have no understanding of how animals are different from people.
But 70 years later we are still innundated with the reputation of those first Dobermans known as the "Devil Dogs". We have not disspelled those original impressions of the Doberman. Our decisionwas to try to run and hide from it or do we embrace it and maintain our time honored position as a working breed? Do we deny our rich heritage as a "Devil Dog" that saved thousands of lives during the war?? Are we so engrossed in the beauty pagent we have lost the very essense that makes up the Doberman - Temperament?
A working breed should first and foremost be about temperament as that goes to the very heart of why the working breeds were created.
We should seek three charastics in our dobermans - conformation, temperament and trainability -Temperament is paramount to the very being of a Doberman
From the DPCA web site: DPCA.org
TEMPERAMENT -There should be no compromise in temperament it should be excellent
Energetic, watchful, determined alert, fearless, loyal and obedient. The judge shall dismiss from the ring any shy or vicious Doberman.
Shyness: A dog shall be judged fundamentally shy if, refusing to stand for examination, it shrinks away from the judge; if it fears an approach from the rear; if it shies at sudden and unusual noises to a marked degree.
Viciousness: A dog that attacks or attempts to attack either the judge or its handier, is definitely vicious. An aggressive or belligerent attitude towards other dogs shall not be deemed viciousness.
Energetic - electric much like a tight rubber band stretched to almost breaking point - always ready
Alert - totally aware of every movement, sight, sound (but not nervous)
Watchful - On guard and always aware of surroundings.
determined - Not easily detered from the assigned task
fearless - Stands his ground
loyal - The doberman exceeds at this trait better than any other breed - Always faithful
obedient - They love to please their owners and should love to work
From the FCI web site:
Temper and Behavior
The character of the Dobermann is friendly and peaceful. It is devoted to the family and is caring toward children. In dobermann we look for a medium temperament, a medium aggressiveness and a fair tolerance before reaction. The Dobermann is easily trainable and enjoys the work and has good working ability thanks to its decisiveness, braveness and strong temperament. Its self-confidence and its intrepidness are also required considering that this breed is very alert toward its surroundings and reactive toward all kind of events.
What may be a surprise about the FCI standard is that it calls for MEDIUM temperament and sharpness which shoots down the theory that European dobermanns are still bred for thier original purpose. While they follow closer than the American doberman they have still been toned down to make them a better companion and family dog.
In studying temperament I find it interesting that loyal and obedient combined with braveness and fearlessness catapulted the Doberman to it place in history. We must never forget that history.
.