• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Shanoa still behaving badly with cats

Well, the one thing I know is your cats are in a much better environment even with Shanoa in the picture than they were before you took them in. They have a nice warm house to live in free of their normal predators. They don't have to fight for their survival with other un-altered cats. They have their shots so they're protected from disease. They have food on demand and don't have to scrounge for it. And they have someone doing litter patrol for them 24/7. I'd say they pretty much have had their lives improved 200% from what it must have been like for them before your intervention so don't beat yourself up so much over what they're missing since Shanoa moved in with them. Be glad she is a puppy and that she wants to please you. This will eventually work itself out. Think of the two Siamese cats in the Lady and the Tramp movie.
 
Thanks Mary Lou. That's nice to hear and it really helps. I just miss them and hope that the pets can all come to some sort of agreement to live peacefully :) I'm sure Shanoa will get there eventually...I just need to work with my trainer and not let my frustration take over :D
 
I know, I feel the same way sometimes. I had to put my last dog to sleep two years prior to Hercules coming into my life. It was so peaceful with it being just me and the cats. No carpets chewed on. No water slobber by the food dishes. Sigh. No nightly walks in good weather or training classes. Dogs, and dobes in particular, are just a lot more labor intensive. With cats you can fill a mixing bowl with dry food and another with water, set out an extra litter pan and you don't even have to think about going away for a couple of days. They're fine, although they miss you. Not with dobes. You take them with you, along with all their baggage and food or stay home. But somehow you adjust and then can't imagine your life before them; isn't that funny.
 
Gosh, when we lost Otis, or GSP I thought I'd just stay dogless for a while (aside from the Sheltie who you hardly know is here), but every move I made reminded me of the emptiness in the house without a faithful dog to have your life revolve around.
That's when we started looking for a Dobe pup and brought Boris into our lives not too terribly long after that. As stated, I just can't imagine my life without them anymore, even though it was a bit of a struggle in the beginning.
I know Shanoa will come around for you, and she's one of the lucky ones to have found someone as dedicated as you MC. :)
 
You guys are making me feel a lot better about this. I actually did some simple obedience training exercises with her today (I really want to get that nice "heel" position down) for a short time, and it made me feel a lot better for her to be successful at something!

I'm anxious for the trainer to come out and give me her opinion and ideas.
 
Hi Meadowcat,

It's been years since I had a situation where a dog came into my home where there was a cat who had no experience with dogs. But for what it's worth what I've done in the past when this sort of thing happened is pretty much like this.

The dog, who was a puppy--12 weeks old stayed on a leash in the house (the cats were inside only kitties) and was promptly taught an absolute down stay. When a cat showed up in the same room as the dog and I he was put in a down position and stayed that way and was absolutely NEVER allowed to chase or harrass the cat. One of my cats at that time had no experience with dogs and the other cat was substantially older and actually liked dogs and didn't run--that helped a lot.

It was a giant pain in the butt but it did eventually give me a dog and two cats where co-existed very well. Mostly it took a lot of time and attention.

By the time another Doberman came along the cat with no experience with dogs had figured out that dogs were a big giant heat source and when the Doberman puppy was allowed to be confined to a small area instead of to a big crate I used to come home from work to find that cat sleeping with the puppy on his pink blanket. I didn't keep the house very warm when wasn't home and she thought the puppy beat the heck out of sleeping under my quilt on the bed.

Hopefully your trainer will come up with some ideas for you as well but you could always try dropping back to square one and put her on a leash and have her down each and every time she sees a cat.
 
i know i am late on this, but i cant see why the e collar wont work. may i ask WHEN you are (hate to use this word) but when your zapping her?? I would figure the proper time to 'distract' her is when she would first show ANY interest in the cat... like the first second she is like... "oop!! Kitty" the second o. lol... timing is everything with the e collar
 
Good question, hrd. The timing would make all the difference, and once past a certain point I guess no amount of "zap" would have much of a chance, huh?
 
It's kind of hard to describe, because what happens when I "zap" her is that it's like she doesn't know what to do, so she gets even more hyper. Sometimes, she will completely ignore the cats. Occasionally, I'll have one on my lap and she will sit quietly and look at it, sometimes sniff, sometimes lick, then go on with whatever she was doing before. Sometimes, though, she goes into a really high interest mode, and I zap her then, before she even begins the chase. I hate to say this, but I've really, really zapped her, too. With the continuous button held down and it was enough that she yelped, but she still went into the hyper bouncing mode. So...? I don't really know what that means.

I try to down-stay her when she sees the cat, and she will, but she'll be completely not relaxed and ready to jump up. That energy makes the cats nervous, and then it's downhill from there.

MC
 
I hate to disagree with hrd on this but I've noticed that the zap only sets them into high gear when their in prey drive. Better to save that for recall out in public places. Just my experience with them. The down stay is better in the house. They have to learn the difference between their inside voice and their outside one. I expect mine to behave inside the house. No rough housing's allowed except for brief toss and catch games. The rest of that belongs outside where they can't do any damage. I have a very small house though.
 
Mary Lou, I've been wondering the same thing. I'm about halfway through a book called "How to Behave so Your Dog Behaves" and it's really excellent. It's about classic conditioning, shaping behaviors, etc. and I think with Shanoa, negative reinforcement may have been the wrong way to go. I'm going to try working on rewarding positive behavior with really good rewards (down stays when she sees the cat) and see if we can make some progress that way.
 
I taught my last dobe/sheppard to lay down whenever I was fostering a litter of kittens with no mother cat so she wouldn't scare them. But she really wanted to be a mother and took to this real well. She would lick them you-know-where so they could potty and clean them up afterwords. She'd also lay still with my coaxing and let the kittens climb all over her and even attempt to nurse, although she was spayed and didn't have any milk. It was the saddest thing to see her attempting to lean her head and front paws underneath the couch when they got bigger and would go under there to take their naps. She would be crooning to them begging them to come back to her to cuddle.
 
I hate to disagree with hrd on this but I've noticed that the zap only sets them into high gear when their in prey drive.
I've never used one so I haven't a clue. But I know a lot of people use it for those times when off leash and chasing something unexpected....so if the above statement is true, does it stop them while in the midst of the chase?
 
Not always, MB. Especially not one with high prey drive. Once they get to the tree they've chased a squirrel up, for instance, you can get them to come back once they calm down. MC I don't know what kind you use but mine doesn't emit a continuous shock when you hold the button down continuously; it's intermittent even then. I think it's a built in safety feature to keep from harming the dog.
 
Yeah, the continuous button emits a limited continuous shock. It's still only a few seconds, but it's far more intense than the nick button. I'm definitely starting to think that negative consequences aren't working, and I need to try reinforcing positive behavior. If I can get her into down stays around the cats, hopefully that'll help. I'm really looking forward to the trainer coming in.
 
MC - it sure is worth a shot. People forget sometimes that if one way isn't working, try something different. Such an 'easy' thought but sometimes we keep trying and trying and trying, thinking it's gonna change, but if you've given something adequate time for results and got none....it's time for a different direction. Keep us posted. I'd like to hear what the trainer says. :)
 
well when i mean zap, i didnt necessarily mean shocking her. it was for whatever she has it set on, even if its the vibration. It seems like your using it for more of a punishment instead of using it as a distraction on the initial interest. I remember when Cesar did it with a dog obsessed with tires on a farm (sure ya guys seen that one, its a old one) when the tractor drove off, as soon as the dog pricked its ears, as soon as he even THOUGHT about chasing the tires, Cesar zapped him (think that was on vibration, cant remember)

Thats why i was wondering if you were using it like after shanoa was already in pursuit of chasing the cats. At that point they prob got so much adrenalyn going they cant feel anything
 
That's what I was getting at hrd. Once they're in prey drive they'll take the shock and keep on going. I still, however, would reserve that kind of correction for out on walks or the dog park. That way they don't develop an aversion to the e-collar. Mine get so excited when they see me getting theirs out because they know we're going somewhere and they get to play and run and have fun for the most part. They also know that I'm serious when I give them a command and they'd better listen. Inside the home should be a safe haven free from that. They can't run away from us and that's just as good a deterrent to bad behavior as anything else without the e-collar in my opinion. How can we expect them to be gentle with cats if we don't use gentle correction. I just don't think it conveys the same message in a dogs mind. It takes time but they eventually get it. Yesterday I watched my one year old kitten come back here where I was giving the dogs some peanut butter and cheese crackers. She climbed first up onto my computer chair and then jumped over to the dresser next to me, all the while watching me hand off crackers to the dobes. Then she leaned over to me begging for her piece. I gave her a small corner of it and she ate it but a piece of it fell on the floor where the dobes were. She didn't even hesitate. She jumped down between them and snatched her cracker crumb off the floor an ate it without giving either of them a glance. And, while Herc gave it a thought, he didn't try to take her piece away from her. I praised him for not going after it and gave him another piece for himself and that was that. I just personally think positive reinforcement and time works better to achieve this kind of result in this kind of situation. Now, out on walks, any cat is fair game in my guys mind; just not in the house. They know it's not allowed and they don't get a treat for that.
 
We tried a very mild stimulation - the kind I use for recall, just a little reminder that I'm here and she needs to pay attention. That's the level that gets an ear flick, normally, and certainly isn't painful for her. And yes, I have done that as soon as she looks at the cats. That did nothing. We tried a higher "punishment" level, which did nothing. We've also tried extensive rewards when she behaves around them, but since she doesn't often behave there isn't a lot to reward.

Hopefully our trainer will have some ideas.
 

Back
Top