Even a small action can be rewarded MC. The sooner the better. The more rewards, the better she should behave and for longer periods of time. Like when she first notices the cats in the room before she attempts to 'play' with them, hand her a very small treat. I could be wrong but what I'm picking up on is you've got two babies in the room when Shanoa is there. She is still very much a puppy and probably jealous of your attention to the cats. Once she knows she won't loose you she might settle down more. So maybe some extra positive attention at these times might help her understand that you're always going to love her. I think it's the same with the cats. They got used to being your 'only' children and now they have to contend with a very big new baby sister from mars. So I suspect they're jealous too. Just keep reassuring everybody that your still there for them and work on giving each of them positive attention. Sometimes individually, sometimes when they are altogether in a group setting. I'm telling you catnip works wonders on lowering a cats anxiety level. The younger they are the more laid back they get after the first rush. My now oldest cat, Sash, wasn't around any dogs until he was five years old so he's had the hardest time adjusting to the dogs. He won't, for instance, come in the front door if the dogs are near it. But even he is coming around after all this time. Just yesterday it was really cold outside and he'd somehow managed to be outside all night. When I opened the door to let him in Herc was right there and Sash ignored him and came right in. Normally he will go to the side of the porch and wait until I get the dogs away from the door and reopen it before he comes in. So this was a decision on his part to overcome his fear and come in out of the cold. Cats are like dogs in one aspect. They pick up on our moods and behavior, too. So I've probably been adding to Sash's anxiety level over the dogs by catering to him at the front door. By me not taking the time to make Herc get away and just holding the door open, well he's in the house now and neither dobe went after him once he got inside.
She seems to get the idea to ignore them if they aren't moving, and if they are in the spot she's used to them sitting - on the back of the couch. The trouble comes when they decide they want to go sit with my husband on the lazy-boy, or walk across the room or whatever. If we can just get the movement thing fixed, it might be better.
