• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Shanoa still behaving badly with cats

Even a small action can be rewarded MC. The sooner the better. The more rewards, the better she should behave and for longer periods of time. Like when she first notices the cats in the room before she attempts to 'play' with them, hand her a very small treat. I could be wrong but what I'm picking up on is you've got two babies in the room when Shanoa is there. She is still very much a puppy and probably jealous of your attention to the cats. Once she knows she won't loose you she might settle down more. So maybe some extra positive attention at these times might help her understand that you're always going to love her. I think it's the same with the cats. They got used to being your 'only' children and now they have to contend with a very big new baby sister from mars. So I suspect they're jealous too. Just keep reassuring everybody that your still there for them and work on giving each of them positive attention. Sometimes individually, sometimes when they are altogether in a group setting. I'm telling you catnip works wonders on lowering a cats anxiety level. The younger they are the more laid back they get after the first rush. My now oldest cat, Sash, wasn't around any dogs until he was five years old so he's had the hardest time adjusting to the dogs. He won't, for instance, come in the front door if the dogs are near it. But even he is coming around after all this time. Just yesterday it was really cold outside and he'd somehow managed to be outside all night. When I opened the door to let him in Herc was right there and Sash ignored him and came right in. Normally he will go to the side of the porch and wait until I get the dogs away from the door and reopen it before he comes in. So this was a decision on his part to overcome his fear and come in out of the cold. Cats are like dogs in one aspect. They pick up on our moods and behavior, too. So I've probably been adding to Sash's anxiety level over the dogs by catering to him at the front door. By me not taking the time to make Herc get away and just holding the door open, well he's in the house now and neither dobe went after him once he got inside.
 
On Saturday we were home all day, and we took all the cats into our office and shut the door. Then we brought Shanoa in and put her in her crate with it uncovered, so they'd all be in the room together and she wouldn't be able to get them. For hours, I rewarded her for being quiet, for watching me instead of a cat, etc. I'm not sure how much progress was made, but that's what we're trying, at least until we talk with our trainer.

I want to say that her drive to go after them is strong enough that she will literally throw herself at the front of her crate to try to get them when she first sees them. She did eventually settle some, but as soon as a cat was walking near she was back to high alert. I tried to get her to "watch me" to break the fixation...sometimes successfully, sometimes not.

MC
 
Don't forget the towel trick. Find something the cats lay on and put it in her crate when you're doing this. That way part of her curiosity will be satisfied by being able to smell them up close and personal. Then when together time is over put what ever it is back where the cats will lay on it so they'll get used to her smell in their space. This is about breaking down natural barriers. Kind of takes the unknown out of the equation. That's what they're all afraid of.
 
I just had another thought MC. My dogs sometimes eat a little catnip. Not sure exactly what effect they get out of it but it's supposed to be a 'mild' tranquilizer for people according to my herbal dictionary. This might do them all some good when they're together. I wouldn't let Shanoa eat more than a teaspoon, though, until you see how she reacts on it, and never more than a tablespoon if it does some good. It might help to calm her down a little and curb some of that prey drive. If she doesn't readily eat it you could try making it into a tea. Just a teaspoon steeped for no more than 7 to 10 minutes. Then put this in a small amount of drinking water and see if she'll drink it. Or you could just try sweetening a cup of it and letting her have that in a soup bowl after it's brewed.
 
Mary Lou, it's a good idea but I probably won't risk it with her sensitive stomach. I try to control everything she eats so that we don't get diarrhea.

I'll try the towel thing, too. Although, the scent of the cats is really all over the house :) She seems to get the idea to ignore them if they aren't moving, and if they are in the spot she's used to them sitting - on the back of the couch. The trouble comes when they decide they want to go sit with my husband on the lazy-boy, or walk across the room or whatever. If we can just get the movement thing fixed, it might be better.

Maybe I should try the Rescue Remedy again on Shanoa? Maybe that would calm her enough to have her relax around them. I haven't tried it since she was a lot younger.

I am seeing occasional signs of her "settling down." Just now, she went into her crate and laid down (the door is open). That's pretty unusual, so I'm hope it's a sign that she's starting to be calmer in the house. It's hard, too, with all the snow and cold, because we can't do as much outside to help tire her out.

MC
 
I doubt the catnip in that small amount would upset her digestion but you know better than me what upsets her tummy. I was just thinking it wouldn't do any more harm than if she ate a little common yard grass. Has she ever eaten that? If she has and it's upset her than maybe your idea on re-trying the Rescue Remedy might be a better idea to try once in a while and see how it goes. I was thinking about you this afternoon. I had just made some popcorn that I'd seasoned with extra butter, shredded mozzarella cheese and a little brown sugar and I was tossing each of the dogs pieces of it when in walks my youngest cat, Sweet Pea, who walked right past the dogs and climbed up on my chair because she'd smelled the popcorn and she wanted some. I gave her a piece and she finished it. All the while she was eating it I was tossing pieces of popcorn to the dogs one at a time and some of it was missing their mouths and falling on the floor; Herc's much better at catching it mid air in his mouth than Chloe is. As soon as Sweet Pea finished the piece I'd given her she was on the floor, without any hesitation, grabbing some of the pieces the dogs were missing and bringing them over here by my chair and sitting down there eating them. I wish I had a video of this to show you. I just know in time things will settle down at your house between Shanoa and your cats because they all have one very important thing in common, you.
 
Well, 2 days until the trainer. Thank goodness. I've been rewarding calm behavior, but it's few and far between. The other problem is that Shanoa's food drive isn't that strong, so for her, the best treat in the world is still less of a reward than the chasing or the nosing or the harassing of the cats.

The most successful approach so far seems to be redirecting her to her favorite tug toy when she shows interest in the cats. Her prey drive is really, really strong, and she has some working lines in her background. Her favorite game of all time is to play tug with a certain toy. I never get snappier responses to my commands, longer down stays, etc. than when the tug game with that toy is the reward. So I've been trying to immediately tell her to "get her tug" when she looks at the cat, then I do a little play with her. I'm hoping this will redirect the drive in a productive way. She is excellent with "drop it" and waiting to get the toy on command. She will go at this toy full force across the entire yard and leap for it in your hand if you give her the command.

Our trainer has done some preliminary sort of "tests" with her to see what her drive might be like for either Ringsport or Schutzhund. She shows a lot of promise in the bite work area, not sure about the rest. So I'm wondering if some more work on redirecting this prey drive in productive ways might be a way to help out the problem.

I'd be really interested to hear from any trainers or anyone who works with high prey drive dogs on how they've handled the cat thing. Von, I know you've trained for a long time. Anyone else have any insights for me? MLR has been really helpful, but I think Shanoa's chase desire might be stronger than her dogs.

MeadowCat
 
I have no training experience but just wanted to say that her favorite toy is just as good a reward as a treat is to other dogs. I watched a 'home made' video that someone made and she used a toy as the reward and the results were amazing! Everything she did was in a very 'happy voice', short (very short!) sessions, sometimes 5 minutes! And the MOMENT that dog did as she wanted, the flung the toy! I mean, she had it ready and her timing was Immediate. I was really impressed and found that this was a very good training tool. Also, the toy was kept only for training to really keep the interest! Like putting away a child's toy...it makes it all the more 'new'!
 
Hooray! The trainer came out today. First off, of course Shanoa was on her best behavior..."cats? what cats? I don't see any cats!" was her attitude. Of course she wouldn't be her normal self. But it was still great. First, she confirmed for me (after we did get some more typical cat reactions by manufacturing situations) that Shanoa has an extremely high prey drive. We're going to talk about some ways to channel that positively. My trainer is considering doing some lure coursing, and I don't know much about it but I'm planning to look into that. Also, it's amazing how much more respect Shanoa has for the trainer than me. She's much more submissive and more responsive to commands, and just looks to our trainer constantly to see what's expected of her. It's kind of like how she behaves with my husband, so maybe I need a little more work in being more of a leader to her and a little more firm and aloof with her. It was very much like watching the dog whisperer, where the dog pretty much immediately does what he wants :D

Anyway, she said first off that she would never leave Shanoa unsupervised with the cats. That's how we operate now - I don't have to be in the same room or anything, but we wouldn't leave the house or leave her downstairs for an extended time if we're upstairs. It's not necessarily that she'd try to kill them, but of course she's powerful enough to do that pretty easily, and the way that she reacts to them means we need to be very careful.

The behavior that I thought was pretty good and that I had rewarded was not good enough. She pointed out that Shanoa's mindset when she was in that mode was still very aroused and focused on the cats, and that even though she wasn't actively chasing we couldn't accept that as the behavior we want. Additionally, we decided that looking at the cats is fine, if her mind is correct. So if she's relaxed and casual (ears up but not "super alert" if that makes sense), resting on her side instead of ready to leap up, etc, she can be rewarded. We used her pinch collar and her e-collar to correct her, but the strategy is to give her a command (pretty much "leave it") and then the correction is for not following the command. She will be corrected for intense looking at the cats, or moving towards them in any way. She's allowed to look if relaxed and not fixated, but not allowed to touch at all (she's doing some nudging and licking and that is very much seeing them as prey).

The trainer is going to write up a week by week plan for us. We're basically going to have to set up artificial situations so that we can be I ready to correct immediately and get the timing exactly. That will also allow us to control what's happening better.

I'm feeling better about the situation, even though it confirms to me that it's unlikely that the cats will ever be friends with her. If we can get to just the point where she ignores them that will be a success for me. If we can all be in the same room peacefully I'll be happy.

I thought you guys would be interested to hear what she said.

MeadowCat
 
Thanks for the update MC! It sounds like you have a good plan now with the trainer and can work from there.

I can never get our dogs to do some of the annoying things I want them to when the trainer is out either, but we can usually set up the situations like you did so they do whatever they're doing and the trainer gives us great tips to work from.

Keep us posted on the progress!
 
Sounds like when the car is making a noise and you take it to the mechanic and the noise is gone, HA! Well most dogs sense the energy in a good trainer and fall into line easily, they know their the followers from the start. I didn't want to comment until your meeting with your trainer, I would have suggested compulsion because of the dogs focus on the cats. I don't like prongs on a Dobermann but if it works for you do it,I also don't like E-collars and I've NEVER used one. It's up to you now to READ her and don't let her fixate, once she does a vocal command is given ONCE if she fails the correction is given and make it a good one. Your success will be sooner if you give meaningfull corrections. VON.
 
It's up to you now to READ her and don't let her fixate, once she does a vocal command is given ONCE if she fails the correction is given and make it a good one. Your success will be sooner if you give meaningfull corrections. VON.

What do you consider to be a good or meaningful correction vonC???
 
When the dogs focus is brought back to the handler, I would also work some quick OB and then praise her behavior. It's going to happen again thats why the quick sharp corrections at the beginning should be meaningfull so your not correcting her for 4 years HAHA!! I'm going through this right now with Viho and Abagail, he's not stalking but wants to play and she's still a kitten (11 weeks) he knows leave it, stop, quit it and cut the crap HAHA!! Point is if he were more intent I'd need to be firm and I wouldn't tolerate chasing. It's hard to evaluate over the internet, it's unethical in many ways, your guessing to a degree and if you offer advice you don't no if the handler can actually deliver it. I try to refer people to trainers in their area if it's serious problems. So go with the trainers advice thats evaluated both dog and handler and trust their judgement. VON.
 
Yeah, basically our trainer put her in a down, I brought the cat in, and when she got excited she got an immediate correction with the prong - a pretty sturdy correction. She already respects our trainer, but after one physical correction with the prong she responded immediately to every verbal correction the trainer made.

I'm hopeful that we're off to a peaceful existence, but I know it's going to take a lot of work with the level of prey drive she's exhibiting with the cats. I don't think I'll ever completely trust her, but if we can get to the point of the cats being able to safely cross the room without being harassed, I'll consider that success. She's definitely not looking at them like dogs to play with, but as things to chase and possibly eat. I'm not saying she'd intentionally kill a cat, but it doesn't take much for a Doberman to harm or kill a cat. As some of you know, we've had a few issues at the dog park with her being a little too focused on the small dogs there, so I think it's all in the same vein. I also do think channeling her drive into something productive will help. My intent has always been to get her into some sort of "work"; I've just been waiting for her to be mature enough and now for the weather to be a little less frigid.

Also, as my trainer reminded me today, she's leaps and bounds ahead of most dogs her age with her training. The fact that I can get a 15 minute down-stay out of her (in a low distraction setting) is a great thing. She's a great dog, we just need to make her reasonably safe around the rest of the pets.

Von, I'd love to hear your opinion on some of the sports that I started the other thread about. I know you're a big advocate of providing your Dobe the job that they are bred for, and I'd love to hear your thoughts on some of the non-protection sports. If I had the time, money, and dedication, I'd start training her in Ringsport or Schutzhund. Even if she wasn't incredibly successful I think she'd love it. But right now it's just not realistic.

MC
 
I believe you should participate in what ever venue the dog is capable of performing well in. I never had an interest in agility or sport events because when I started in training I basically worked with the working breeds and there was no interest in sport. There were virtually no Dobermanns in Sch. because it was designed for GSD. Plus the amount of time involved in training in the three phases wasn't worth it for me compared to earning a living with protection work. My expertize is in OB leading into PP and Attack work, also problem solving. I've done scent detection and bought dogs for security companys and worked with Jack Healy (k9 command) preparing Area dogs for estate security. Back then if there wasn't good money in it I couldn't afford to put time in it. I was a full time trainer with a family to provide for so training for sport wasn't a very good business opportunity. Today theres a big interest in it and I'm glad Dobermann owners are open to all the different venues avalible to them. I wish more would temperament test there dogs even if it's a WAC exam, I would prefer a good PP trainer evaluating them even if there was no interest in a training program. VON.
 
Oh, MC, I am so excited reading all this that I can hardly sit still to read EVERY word!! I am such a Cesar fan and YOUR trainer is excellent in showing you Cesar's way...Just the fact that Shanoa immediately displayed attention and obedience in front of her, shows me that she has the same energy and Pack Leadership as Cesars! AND it proves his ways work!!!! I have always agreed with his training and his way of showing leadership. Most times he can get the desired results in a soft, undemanding way (sometimes just his "shhhs") because he is also showing leadership in his posture and mental outlook. But I agree, when the dog does not respond, he is QUICK to respond and as Von said, makes it a 'good one'. You saw how once she did that to Shanoa her response to your trainer was even better! How freaking cool is that?? AND as I was reading what your trainer said about Shanoa still being fixated and alert, it reminded me of Cesar saying that too...he always is talking about catching them before they get to the' red zone' and learning to recognize that 'look' , that fixation, the ears. etc ...all that people miss and the dog reacts to the 'red zone' and they wonder what happened! Because in that zone sometimes nothing works beyond removing the dog.

Von, I am in complete agreement with your post. READING a dog, (horse, child!lol works everywhere) is a key element. It takes some practice to learn that but it works. Learning to be a leader is having confidence and control. I have always given the example of leadership or pack leader this way...

When you are in a store and need help, how many times have you looked around for someone and passed by several employees because they 'just didn't look like they knew what they were doing'?? We pick someone with the look of authority, confidence, a happy nature, etc. Right? I think it's the same thing for a dog (who does not know the human language and only relies on your body language and demeanor for his understanding) They naturally follow someone who looks like they will lead. That's why Shanoa's trainer gets that immediate response. She oozes "Pack Leader" ! I think it's so cool that you have a trainer like her to rely on!! :thumbsup:
 
MB - I love my trainer, too :) The fact that she really understands the breed helps, too, I think. I love that the training methods in general are really focused on positive training, but that she understands that sometimes, with some dogs, a negative reinforcement is necessary. She's very physical with the dogs; I don't mean that she hits them or anything, but when Shanoa was really acting up in class one time she had me pretty much put her in a bear hug, get her down, and just sort of hold her until she settled. It worked great, and I wouldn't have thought of doing that. They always try to train with the method that works best for each dog.

And yeah, she totally has a presence that I don't. Everything about her body language, tone, just...everything. It's amazing to watch her work with dogs. The other thing that she always emphasizes is knowing what you want out of your dog. I was pretty frustrated trying to train "front" for Shanoa, and she pointed out that I didn't intend to do any obedience showing with her, and that the reason Shanoa was struggling with it was the work we'd done to condition her not to jump. As she said, "front" is really a nice, showy thing but it's not necessary for what I do with her. If I can eventually get it, great. But don't sweat it, because other things are more important.

Last night, hours after she had left, one of the cats was out in the living room with us. Shanoa was already responding much better to "leave it", I think because we'd worked on it with the trainer that day. I'm feeling good about this, and can't wait to get my outline of exercises from her to start working on it in a more structured way.

I love Cesar, too. I know there's controversy about his methods, but I've never witnessed anything that made me think he was hurting a dog. And, when you get some of those dogs with the aggression issues, the alternative is putting the dog down. I think if you can get results and the dog can live a happy, healthy life, that's what needs to be done. Additionally, I've never seen a dog that responds to him as if they are scared of him. It's easy to tell if a dog has been abused. Plus, if we'd do a better job of treating dogs like dogs instead of people, we wouldn't have all these issues.

Von, if I could find someone nearby who offered training in PP, I would be all over it. The way it is, people who train in Ringsport or Schutzhund around here all do it on their own. I wouldn't even know where to start with that. I'd LOVE to have her evaluated by someone, but I haven't found anyone to do that. The only thing I've been able to find has been places where you send your dog away to be trained, and I'm not sure I'd want to do that. I'd like to be involved in the training, and it's hard to evaluate places without watching their training methods. If you know anyone in the Twin Cities, MN area... :)

MC
 
I love Cesar, too. I know there's controversy about his methods, but I've never witnessed anything that made me think he was hurting a dog. And, when you get some of those dogs with the aggression issues, the alternative is putting the dog down. I think if you can get results and the dog can live a happy, healthy life, that's what needs to be done. Additionally, I've never seen a dog that responds to him as if they are scared of him. It's easy to tell if a dog has been abused. Plus, if we'd do a better job of treating dogs like dogs instead of people, we wouldn't have all these issues.

Exactly, I realize people think that all that cannot be accomplished in that short a period of time, but what they don't understand is, the dog is not necessarily 'cured' in those moments...there is still weeks or months of work to KEEP it that way, but, yes, CESAR got those results in that short period of time! Because of his energy, posture and calm assertive manner. ( Ever notice how he stands erect, shoulders back and sometimes with one hand on his hip? It's an authoritative stance. ) Did you ever watch Victoria Stillwell or The Super Nanny?? They also will get results like Cesar and once they leave the family on their own, some problems creep back. And thats because they have not perfected the pack leader role. Or they are not being consistent. Believe me, I'm not perfect! But I so "get him"! It's just that we are emotionally tied to our pets and sometimes it's hard to not give in or give up. Him, hard on a dog? Ha, yea, I'm sure he in some instances with some aggressive dogs! As it should be! But have you ever heard him yell and scream at a dog like some people do? Have you ever seen him strike a dog out of anger or frustration? Never! But a lot of people do. I've hardly heard him utter a word in most cases. IMO, the people who think the worst of him, are envious that he can get results that they can't. It's easier to say "oh he probably beats the crap outta them" than to try and learn what he is teaching.

Sorry, Off the soapbox......gawd! :p
 
Glad to have another Dog Whisperer lover here. I've learned a lot from him. But yeah, it's so hard not to treat Shanoa like a person sometimes. I even find that since it's just the two of us home during the day (except the cats), that I talk to her a lot! Probably makes it less effective when I give her commands :D But sometimes I swear she understands what I'm saying. That doberman head cocked to the side as if they know exactly what you're saying...

I know I can do more to be a better pack leader for her. It's evident in the way she reacts to my husband compared to me. Sure, partly he has physical advantages...bigger, deep voice, etc., that make him automatically already more dominant in her mind. But he's also pretty aloof with her most of the time (not really a dog guy). So even though there are times when he's loving up on her, many times he's pretty much ignoring her. And of course, to her, he's God :D He also wrestles her a lot, so he's far more physical with her in that way than I am. Hmmm....maybe I'll just start laying on her all the time :D

MC
 

Back
Top