Need Your Help/Opinion

Dobiegirl

Novitiate
Ok so you all know Logan loves to chase the buggies, and he also like to chase the neighbors cats....( the Mom cat is prego all the time so their are constantly kittens around) we have had problems with these people before, they got nice and today started up again....:o:mad::(

We have the electronic collar on Logan who listens most of the time on it, but when he is focused on the cats or the buggies he is gone.....:run: We have a total of 2 1/2 acres my husband it not crazy about a fence so do any of you have the underground electric fence??? Seeing as the collar does not effect him when focused do you guys think he would run right thru the fence??? We have to do something soon, I can't deal with these neighbors again biatchin at us all the time..... With the electronic fence we could do the entire yard instead of just the back....thoughts opinions PLEZE.....
 
Theres no way the underground fence will contain him if a collar and handler together dont work.
 
I Suppose it could work with good training. But, and this is a big but, all it takes is breaking thru one time. And all that time and money will be for nothing.
 
Yes, I was going to say the same thing, and if he's bolting even with the E-collar now, the underground fence won't work either. I considered it for us as well, but I also don't like the fact that even if your dog does stay in it, other dogs and critters can cross it freely and it could put the dog in the fence at risk with no escape.

I know regular fencing can be a little costly, but I think it might be well worth it for you in the long run. And you'll have it for years to come, so when you factor that into the cost, it really is a nice investment. I don't know if you've caught the threads with our fence in it, but I'm pretty sure we paid about $30 - $35 for a 50' roll of 5' high fencing, so really you could get a pretty good sized fence for not a horrible amount of money.
 
Yes, I was going to say the same thing, and if he's bolting even with the E-collar now, the underground fence won't work either. I considered it for us as well, but I also don't like the fact that even if your dog does stay in it, other dogs and critters can cross it freely and it could put the dog in the fence at risk with no escape.

I know regular fencing can be a little costly, but I think it might be well worth it for you in the long run. And you'll have it for years to come, so when you factor that into the cost, it really is a nice investment. I don't know if you've caught the threads with our fence in it, but I'm pretty sure we paid about $30 - $35 for a 50' roll of 5' high fencing, so really you could get a pretty good sized fence for not a horrible amount of money.

No I did not catch that thread....where is it and where did you get your fence???????? We have decided to go with fence but we are not going to do the entire property.....
 
Jan and Von Doom have said everything I would have said. Electronic fencing is just not the answer for a situation like this.

I'd bite the bullet and fence at least in the back--I'd rather fence and be a good neighbor than have my dog in trouble with the neighbors, buggies passing on the road (didn't he get hurt in a collision with one?) or anything else that happened to catch his attention.
 
If he still keep going with electric collar on, the collar is not powerfull enough. There are special collars made by Dogtra for stuborn dogs. It has up to 1 mile range and VERY powerful. It stops hunting dogs from chasing the game. I am pretty sure he will not like the highest level on it.
My girl had entry level E-collar before and chasing the cats even with that collar top level of correction. Now she wears Dogtra 282 NCP Platinum. This collar is WAY powerful than the previous one and it worked for her. It is funny that now, when she sees the cat or bunny, she turns her head away of them, lol! I trully believe that if correction does not work, it is not powerful enough to convince your dog to obey. Good luck :)
 
I think what Hamuda said about your collar not being powerful enough could be alot of your problem. We have always used the electric invisible fence and our dobes have been excellent with it. You can adjust the correction level on the colllar from low up to a stubborn dog level, we have never had to go beyond the low level. We used to have the fence with the buried wire and finding breaks in the wire was a real pain at times so we repalaced it with a new wireless one, really easy just plug it in and start training. It won't do your entire 2 1/2 acres but it will do almost an acre, and no wires to break or bury!!
 
We used to have the fence with the buried wire and finding breaks in the wire was a real pain at times so we repalaced it with a new wireless one, really easy just plug it in and start training. It won't do your entire 2 1/2 acres but it will do almost an acre, and no wires to break or bury!!

Really? I've never heard of this one! I've never looked into them either so I don't know what's out there.

But our old neighbor had the underground one (this was like 15 years ago) and their Jack Russels' would bolt through it all the time! Yipping the whole way! Or the battery was dead...or the broken wires....it did not give me a good feel for it at all! I don't even like electric fence for horses. I want something that I can feel confident is working! Like a good old fashioned fence! More money, I know, but putting my mind at ease is more important to me. If I have to keep worrying, "Is he still in the yard?" than it ain't worth it. I gotta enough things to worry about.
 
No, it's way powerful it's the sport dog, reaches up to a mile, we have had it on 8 and like I said he is chasing and yippin all the way!!!! He is a stubborn tuff boy!!!!!

I had been reading allot about the underground fence before I posted this thread that is why I wanted opinions about it....My confused brain could not justify if the e-collar does not work how would the fence do....

I have heard allot of negative about the underground fence, like the dog gets out, can't get back in, other dogs get in...yadda yadda yadda.....

We are getting the same fencing we had at our other house, cattle fencing from TSC works great and it's not really that bad in price. We are just going to fence in the back 1/2 where we spend allot of time....At least this way like MB said my mind will be at ease that I always know where he is.....
 
That's sounds reasonable, Sally. I think you will find it to be much more relaxing and you can work on some training within the boundaries of an enclosure. I think this will be good for everyone.:) Now someone should spay that cat..................:eek: lol
 
That's sounds reasonable, Sally. I think you will find it to be much more relaxing and you can work on some training within the boundaries of an enclosure. I think this will be good for everyone.:) Now someone should spay that cat..................:eek: lol

I know there are so many unwanted, they take them to the Amish who you know don't spay/neuter so it's a vicious circle.....

Thanks Sharon I am already feeling a calm knowing we are going to fence in now......:)
 
Really? I've never heard of this one! I've never looked into them either so I don't know what's out there.

But our old neighbor had the underground one (this was like 15 years ago) and their Jack Russels' would bolt through it all the time! Yipping the whole way! Or the battery was dead...or the broken wires....it did not give me a good feel for it at all! I don't even like electric fence for horses. I want something that I can feel confident is working! Like a good old fashioned fence! More money, I know, but putting my mind at ease is more important to me. If I have to keep worrying, "Is he still in the yard?" than it ain't worth it. I gotta enough things to worry about.

Yes MB the broken wires were a pain. I guess we were just lucky or maybe the Jack Russels han't been properly trained on it. Our 3 different dobes have all been excellent on it and our neighbors got one for their 2 golden labs with great results also. But I could see a dog like Logan might not work out as well. The new wireless one will do almost an acre turned all the way up, and if you wanted to go on vacation you can take it with you and dial it down to 30 foot radius for a campsite if you wanted to. We have always had good luck with ours but we live in the country with nobody living close by with dogs to come into our yard, but if I lived in town I think I would opt for a regular fence to keep mine in and others out.
 
Well we just got done walking our property and figured out where we are fencing in, by the end of next week hopefully the fence will be done!!!! I am so excited for this to finally happen....too bad it took Logan getting hurt to make my hubby realize we needed this....
thanks everyone for your help and support....I love you all....
 
The new wireless one will do almost an acre turned all the way up, and if you wanted to go on vacation you can take it with you and dial it down to 30 foot radius for a campsite if you wanted to.
Oooow, now that's a great idea for camping!

Well we just got done walking our property and figured out where we are fencing in, by the end of next week hopefully the fence will be done!!!! I am so excited for this to finally happen....too bad it took Logan getting hurt to make my hubby realize we needed this....
thanks everyone for your help and support....I love you all....

Oh, Sally, I am so glad! This will make a difference, I just know it. And now that you've made the decision, even THAT helps, doesn't it? I know when I'm undecided about something, sometimes it's the indecision itself that is making me crazy. When I finally make the choice, I feel so much better! :)

How's Logan's injuries doing?
 
Oooow, now that's a great idea for camping!



Oh, Sally, I am so glad! This will make a difference, I just know it. And now that you've made the decision, even THAT helps, doesn't it? I know when I'm undecided about something, sometimes it's the indecision itself that is making me crazy. When I finally make the choice, I feel so much better! :)

How's Logan's injuries doing?

Logan got a clean bill of health today.....:) The lump on his side should eventually go away or he said it may never, time will tell.... His missing tooth is completely healed and most of the leg is healed, still one spot that is still raw.

He was sooooooo good today too, he went into Tractor & Supply with us and he was a PERFECT gentleman.....everyone was commenting on how he was such a good boy....made us feel good.....But he always is a good boy when we are out...lil stinker.....:o
 
Oooow, now that's a great idea for camping!

Only if your dogs are trained to understand the consequences. Alot of training is involved to make these systems successful.
.
~~~~~~~
99722f7e.gif
"Double Post Auto Merge"
99722f7e.gif
~~~~~~~
.​
Logan got a clean bill of health today.....

Great News Sally. :)
 
Von we have used this type of fencing for years and the intsructions were to train for 2 weeks on leash, then go to a long lead after that until you are sure of your dog. With all three of the dobes we have had over the years we have only had to take them out and show them the flag boundry and usually getting shocked 2 times they have had it down pat!! We do continue to watch them closely until we are sure, maybe we have just been lucky with all three but it has been very easy to train them and our neighbors who got one recently for their 2 golden labs found it the same with their dogs.
.
~~~~~~~
99722f7e.gif
"Double Post Auto Merge"
99722f7e.gif
~~~~~~~
.​
So glad to hear Logan got a clean bill of health:woohoo1:
 
Oh, I'm sure that "training first" on this is utmost. I'm talking about one (maybe like Bree's) that are trained to respect it. Once they are, taking something like this remote one might be pretty cool for camping and such. It's the same with horses. I know someone who camps with their horses and they bring along a smaller version of an electric fence to keep the horses in overnight. It runs on solar with a battery and I thought that was pretty cool too. But my horses haven't been around an electric fence in a while (the Appaloosa's were raised in electric with the guy I bought them from) and I would be very cautious about just taking them camping and putting up this small square of electric and dumping them in! lol Most definitely would practice it at home first. Same with this remote for dogs. They better be very respectful of it before I take it to a far away camping site! :eek:
.
~~~~~~~
99722f7e.gif
"Double Post Auto Merge"
99722f7e.gif
~~~~~~~
.​
He was sooooooo good today too, he went into Tractor & Supply with us and he was a PERFECT gentleman.....everyone was commenting on how he was such a good boy....made us feel good.....But he always is a good boy when we are out...lil stinker..
This is great, Sally! You are able to bring a dog into TS!? That's cool and a very good way of doing more socializing! Good Boy! ;)
 

Back
Top