What’s so “weird” about it?And honestly your dogs going to be 2 and is still on puppy food. The situation, the toy, all sounds weird. Good luck.
Most members here would tell you to go to an all stage food and get off the puppy food. Even at a young age. But at 2 years old I would think she should certainly be off puppy food. And sometimes it takes a while and several different foods to hit on that one that works for your dog. There are a lot of threads on here about diet change and diarrhea. I can't say it's an easy task. And some dogs are more sensitive than others. What is her stool like now?She’s 1 she’ll be two in the coming year. I’ve read that she should eat puppy food until two. Believe me I’ve tried switching her from what the breeder gave me (science diet) but she has such a sensitive stomach. I’ve tried slowly switching her food but still horrible diarrhea.
You know what you’re right. The toy is boring and weird. But thank you & good luck to you.