Dogs reaction to different human races

jazzies mum

Hot Topics Subscriber
This is probably going to be a difficult subject to deal with in a politically correct way, so I apologise in advance. Rest assured that there is no disrespect or offence intended.

Jazz has a dislike of Aboriginal people, for no reason at all! :scratch: I have no personal feelings that she is picking up and she has never had a bad experience with anyone at all, of any race! Not that I know of anyway.

When she was 8 months old she took great exception to a couple of Aboriginal men that were waiting for a taxi near the gate of a friends house. The full back up angry Dobe rave, and I saw that they were only talking and not all that close to the gate either. Since then we haven't been anywhere where she has been around any Aboriginies, but has been around many other races and ethnic groups in our travels with no reaction at all.

On our recent camping trip I noticed she was grumbling low in her throat while we were all sitting at an outdoor cafe. Her gaze was locked on and her back was up. When I followed her gaze I saw that there was an Aboriginal man talking to someone in a gateway.......50 to 75metres away! I told her to leave-it and she detuned. But the most astonishing reaction was at one of the caravan parks where a young man came straight up to our camper and the two dogs barked, but Jazz went into the most serious barking I've ever seen. She was standing in front of me and barking herself off her feet with her whole back standing from base of ears to base of tail! My friends, who had the better view, said that she was making a full show of her teeth and jaws with each volley and looked serious about it! When he stopped and my friends dog went to be patted, Jazz instantly changed to desperately wanting to get in close for an investigation, without aggression. Luckily this man had the sense to just wait until I had Jazz calm before the introductions were made, after which she totally lost interest and went and lay down on her bed. Afterwards I was expressing confusion at her reaction and my friend Jenny said he had looked part Aboriginal. It hadn't crossed my mind that that could be the trigger!

This seems a bit far fetched to me. Is it a different smell? A different sound to the voice? Obviously not the skin tone as we all come in such a variety and this is so specific! I'm not too worried as the way things have been handled I suspect that the issue will become less with time and more experience, but have any of you heard of such a thing before?
 
My non expert opinion is that she just isn't used to them and it's a socialization piece. I wouldn't rule out skin tone because it is still a factor and might appear differently to her. We did our best to get Red around as many things and people as possible when he was younger but sometimes demographics in Maine left us limited. Sometimes dogs can be skittish to new things that are as simple as a beard or a hat.

Hopefully Jazz will come around with time and positive experiences. Every now and then Red will randomly pick a person in public that for no reason at all, in my mind of course, he's not okay with and there isn't a rhyme or reason sometimes.
 
Ragnar is very cautious about anything that is outside of his everyday norm as am I.

He is around whites for the most part but when we go to the soccer fields, he is exposed to all the other races- blacks, oriental, Hispanics, etc...

I do find that because I tend to act cautious around certain societal groups that Ragnar does too. There is that- intimate training feel being projected from handler through the leash.

People just look different and even some look rougher than others. If we see it then he feels what we perceive. And then, I also think it is the confidence being portrayed from the person in question to Ragnar. A couple of black guys at the fields love Ragnar and always look forward to working the ball with him. Then there are others that will walk around this little hill to avoid him. Ragnar sees and feels all that....

My question to @jazzies mum is- has Jazz spent any time or had any positive interaction with Aboriginal folks? If not, then I would figure it is a circumstance that is out of her norm or she is not socialized to these circumstances. The same way Ragnar is not socialized to horses/cows, he goes off when he sees them. Just not around them enough.
 
it is a circumstance that is out of her norm or she is not socialized to these circumstances
Agree. And exposing puppies to as many different things at a young age (and being non-reactive to them) is so important. I had a list somewhere, but beards, hats, strollers, raincoats, black white brown people, it went on and on, but the idea was to just walk on by with you always being the focus of the puppy, and not the "different" things/people, so that later in life it's not a thing.
 
First dog we had when I was a kid from 4 years to 14, the male mutt we got from the pound at 8? Weeks old? Tiny!

He hated Mexicans.
We could not figure out why.
Neighbor kids 2 houses down (of Mexican heritage) we’re not allowed over. Too risky.
The other kids in the neighborhood were fine? Japanese blood was ok I guess? :D
Indonesian blood was ok I guess?
Heck, even the kid who was 1/2 Native American. No problem.
But not Mexican.

My dads best friend in the world, straight out of Guadalajara as a kid, was a US Army medic in Nam, and a very large man.
This dog would growl, show teeth, and if he attempted to try and interact with the dog, give a treat, anything, Sam the dog would turn aggressive.
 
I had a similar concern some time ago. One way to objectively observe the dog is to go people watching. Can do this on a park bench or even standing outside a grocery store like we did. I took notice of the body language of people walking into the store past us and then monitored the dog. One guy gave Kaiser the side eye because he seemed afraid of him. He also went wider around us even though he was already far enough from us. K noticed this and stood up semi alert. I say semi because he didn’t do the stance where he looks like he’s going to launch himself forward lol, but he gave attention in that direction. The guy was no threat, an older black guy, well dressed - not that you can judge a book by its cover, but sometimes it’s all we’ve got to go on. K stayed neutral with people who walked by ignoring us or even when they smiled at us. If they are so ‘sensing and feeling’ with us, I have to believe they can pick up the same vibes off others.
 
Well, interesting that it isn't unheard of! There is a very, very small chance that Jazz may have had an upsetting encounter on the few occasions when she has needed to be kenneled, or maybe when she had to do that long, long trip to meet me at the other end of Australia last year. But I don't think so.

I'm pretty sure it isn't being generated by me as on two of the three times she has reacted I haven't noticed the people until after she made we aware. The man who came into our camp I didn't even realise was of mixed race until it was pointed out. There could be something in the idea that she is picking up something unsettled from these people, or even the tone of their voice, which often seems harsher and louder even when there is no anger. No worries, we'll just treat it as another training opportunity until it is all ho-hum.

On the other hand, I'll also always look to see what she is seeing. Her awareness of undercurrents and potential threats is what makes her such a wonderful traveling companion for me who likes to head off on my own at times! Not much point in having a guardian and not let them guard! :)
 
On the other hand, I'll also always look to see what she is seeing. Her awareness of undercurrents and potential threats

Really kinda cool that you bring this up because Ragnar is NOT a barker at all. He may bark 5times in a week. He will only bark at certain people and I cannot really discern the why or which.

My wife has commented to me multiple times that Ragnar did not bark at the UPS/mail guy today but then get a text from her saying that he just lit up the Amazon guy.

Like you, when we are in public I am usually cool and aloof but will admit that I do increase my sentry mode in certain situations. Neat to see that when I do, so does Ragnar. No, he is not a barker but a Dobermans “look” stops them pretty quick.
 
Does Jazz seem to dislike other types of black people too? Is there something markedly different about the appearance of the Aboriginal people? Is their language pretty far from the sound of English?

Diet can lend an overall scent to people, as mentioned.

@Nutz ? Any input?

Oji has shown that he treats black folks the same as white – this despite that I don't have any black friends (Don't worry. That's just because I don't have any friends at all :rofl:) A good example occurred one day when Oji and I were on a walk/run and a black man was sitting on a low retaining wall. The man vocalized toward us and is was clear he wanted to meet Oji. So I let Oji walk on up to him. In seconds, he was leaning into him for the petting. Too bad it turns out this guy was a salesman and went into his pitch, then got mad when I said no.

Another time, I was walking Oji pretty late at night and as we passed an all-black apartment complex (It literally is all black, but of course it's not on a sign or anything) and a tall man came out toward the sidewalk and seemed to want to meet Oji – or maybe he just said nice dog or something. On this occasion, Oji was standoffish. I suppose I did not let him get all the way to the man, which of course is a huge sign to a dog. It could also be that Oji gets quite defensive at night and if I don't give him the okay, he will assume the worst about all passersby. It could also be that I was indeed uneasy about getting too close to the man in that situation, and Oji picked up on that. I'm not sure on that last part, but people say over and over that Dobes can read our feelings about people.
 
TBH the only other people I can think of that our dogs have met are Native Americans and they treated them the same as everyone else. Of course that was at a dog show so everyone there knows and loves dogs.

I see people from nearly every culture and country at work on a daily basis but of course I don't have the dogs with me then. LOL
 
Does Jazz seem to dislike other types of black people too? Is there something markedly different about the appearance of the Aboriginal people? Is their language pretty far from the sound of English?
It seems to be only our native Aboriginals. Australia is becoming very mixed race in the more urban areas and Jazz has been around enough so she has had some exposure to many different ethnic groups. One theory that is bounced around when I ask people about this is that they have noticed the same with some of their dogs and they think that there is a cultural fear of dogs in Aboriginals. Things out west are even now pretty raw and I imagine there are instances where dogs are sicced onto these people, and Jazz is big, black and can be serious looking!

That theory falls apart when she is reacting and the other party doesn't even know! Or, as in the case of the man who walked into our camp, seemed to be not too fazed. (although appearances can be deceptive) The most likely reason is, as you say, the harsher and more gutteral tones in their language and accent. (to our ears anyway)

Makes me laugh to hear that other dogs have hangups about different races too! It could well be diet and a different smell in the case of Mexicans and Indians, although I think most people have a good go at those lovely curries and hot chillie beans!

As Jazz is maturing she is getting her confidence, but still very obedient to me which I think is about optimum. I don't foresee any occasion when she would be out of control unless the situation is dire, and then it is appropriate!
 
. It could also be that I was indeed uneasy about getting too close to the man in that situation,
I think that’s absolutely it, Tad.
One of the few times Daisy went full on Doberman, was in a split second at the front door.
I was faced with someone somewhat familiar, but I had an uneasy feeling because it was after dark and didn’t instantly recognize him.

That split second thought of “I’m not sure what this persons intent is here”
Was all it took.
Before I could internally finish the thought, Daisy was at the end of my arm, holding her collar, her chomping, snarling fangs about 8 inches away from that guy’s face.
Had I not had ahold of the collar, that guy would have bled. A lot.

She picked up on a fraction of a second of unsureness in me. And responded.
She scared the everloving shit out of that guy. He was white as a ghost.
 
Does Jazz seem to dislike other types of black people too? Is there something markedly different about the appearance of the Aboriginal people? Is their language pretty far from the sound of English?

Diet can lend an overall scent to people, as mentioned.

@Nutz ? Any input?

Oji has shown that he treats black folks the same as white – this despite that I don't have any black friends (Don't worry. That's just because I don't have any friends at all :rofl:) A good example occurred one day when Oji and I were on a walk/run and a black man was sitting on a low retaining wall. The man vocalized toward us and is was clear he wanted to meet Oji. So I let Oji walk on up to him. In seconds, he was leaning into him for the petting. Too bad it turns out this guy was a salesman and went into his pitch, then got mad when I said no.

Another time, I was walking Oji pretty late at night and as we passed an all-black apartment complex (It literally is all black, but of course it's not on a sign or anything) and a tall man came out toward the sidewalk and seemed to want to meet Oji – or maybe he just said nice dog or something. On this occasion, Oji was standoffish. I suppose I did not let him get all the way to the man, which of course is a huge sign to a dog. It could also be that Oji gets quite defensive at night and if I don't give him the okay, he will assume the worst about all passersby. It could also be that I was indeed uneasy about getting too close to the man in that situation, and Oji picked up on that. I'm not sure on that last part, but people say over and over that Dobes can read our feelings about people.

I've had Grumble at the shopping centres for socalisation quite a lot over the past year or so, and the only reaction I had was when a waiter at an outdoor Wimpy lent over to serve me. The waiter was a person of color, but I don't think that was the problem, I think it was the proximity thing.

There is an anicdotal theory that I've heard that dogs see people of color differently to the way they see caucasians... So dogs in neighbourhoods where there are predominantly people of color the dog is very reactive to caucasian and visa versa.
 

Back
Top