Your opinion on ear cropping tail docking?

Because it leaves a bad image on cropping in the public eye. Think of it as an advertisement. You want that ad to look its best. When you hire a poor graphic designer, the results show and reflects a bit badly on your business. I don't want the public to think that is how cropping is supposed to look. Its funny the number of times you hear on here how the public has no idea an adult doberman with cropped ears was actually cropped, while they see the puppy next to it in posts saying "oh you poor thing!" Bad crop jobs and post jobs makes cropping in general look bad.
That makes sense.
 
I knew it would go south. All one has to do is have a strong opinion on it and express that opinion and fighting will ensue.

Did it go south? I have to read back (totally could have missed something!:anonymous :) but this C&D discussion seemed to go better than others! I always enjoy reading your thoughts and opinions Tad!! Truthfully if we all agreed on everything it would make for boring cocktails parties!! :martini::thumbsup:
 
"I LOVE C&D Dobes. I think they're very pretty. I just don't like the fact that it's a medical procedure. The way I look at it is, it's like one of us loosing a thumb."

No it's not like loosing a thumb. Not only is the comparison ridiculous it is a fallacy of category. No sane person chooses to lose a part of their body that is necessary to it's proper function. One might as well suggest that cropping is like putting out an eye, cutting off a foot, or removing one's tongue. (though in the case of the latter that can often be an improvement.) The difference between the thumb and an eye is only a matter of degree. The two are categorically identical.

Odd as well, and though not universally applicable, is the fact that those who are aghast at cropping think nothing of spaying and neutering their Dobermans. Any number of reasons can be given but most reduce to a matter of convenience of one form or another. The idea that removing a part of the ear is horrific but de-sexing by cutting out or cutting off the associated organs, organs that are responsible for considerably more than just reproduction, is an abominable contradiction. How absurd.

And how many of you anti croppers have had your boy children circumcised? Hmm? There is an appropriate comparison.

Someone asked in an earlier post why things are this way? To anyone over 50 it is obvious. Our society is becoming increasingly effeminate. Logic and reason have been jettisoned in favor of an "oh poor thing" emotionalism which dilatory effects extend to far more than just cropped ears but that is subject for another place.

I'll be picking up my Doberman puppy in four weeks and it will be cropped and docked. If I had wanted a flop eared pooch I would have gotten a Bloodhound.

Don't like cropping? Don't do it. But don't bother telling me why because I don't care. And for those who want to see it eliminated who do you think you are? I have another message for you that can't be repeated in a public forum.

Have a nice day.
 
In case anyone was wondering, I won't be clicking on the above link (not just because I have a slight phobia of clicking on links, and my computer seems to be allergic to doing things I want it to do).

This is now appearing like you started this thread to push for your anti-C&D view and agenda. It was fairly masked at first.

This reminds me of another member (whom I don't know if is still around) who came in and quickly pulled out her anti-C&D guns.
 
In case anyone was wondering, I won't be clicking on the above link (not just because I have a slight phobia of clicking on links, and my computer seems to be allergic to doing things I want it to do).

This is now appearing like you started this thread to push for your anti-C&D view and agenda. It was fairly masked at first.

This reminds me of another member (whom I don't know if is still around) who came in and quickly pulled out her anti-C&D guns.
No it's nothing like that. I honestly don't care if you are pro C&D or not. I just felt as if I wasn't making sense, so I posted the link to try to sound less confusing and to try and get pro C&D to understand where we're coming from. But again, I just wanted everyone's opinion and don't care what your opinion is. I mean, I care what your opinion is, other wise I wouldn't have asked, but I don't care what your opinion is lol. Does this make sense?
 
No it's nothing like that. I honestly don't care if you are pro C&D or not. I just felt as if I wasn't making sense, so I posted the link to try to sound less confusing and to try and get pro C&D to understand where we're coming from. But again, I just wanted everyone's opinion and don't care what your opinion is. I mean, I care what your opinion is, other wise I wouldn't have asked, but I don't care what your opinion is lol. Does this make sense?
Well if that's the case...

...I assume the link points to an article that draws on emotion and has cropping as a cruel practice.

I've said this before here, but do we really think that every breeder, every vet, every person down through the history of ear cropping has been ill-informed and cruel? Take breeders for instance: Do we really think that these folks – most of whom really love and care for their Dobermans – are subjecting their pups to a lot of pain and to something that is cruel and wrong?

Or perhaps do these experienced people know what they're doing? Do they perhaps understand that the amount of pain the pup undergoes is not that great and that they handle it just fine? Do they understand that dogs – not just working breeds, but all dogs – are damn tough animals and could care less about a little pain and just move on? A dog's pain tolerance should be higher than that of a human anyway.

Further, dogs don't have emotions like we do. It's a mistake to humanize dogs. There are so many ways to debunk the anti-C&D agenda. @MarkChambers cited one way above when he talked about circumcision of human males, and about spay/neuter – especially early spay/neuter which is pushed hard on the mostly unsuspecting public by vets and the animal "rights" people.
 
"I LOVE C&D Dobes. I think they're very pretty. I just don't like the fact that it's a medical procedure. The way I look at it is, it's like one of us loosing a thumb."

No it's not like loosing a thumb. Not only is the comparison ridiculous it is a fallacy of category. No sane person chooses to lose a part of their body that is necessary to it's proper function. One might as well suggest that cropping is like putting out an eye, cutting off a foot, or removing one's tongue. (though in the case of the latter that can often be an improvement.) The difference between the thumb and an eye is only a matter of degree. The two are categorically identical.

Odd as well, and though not universally applicable, is the fact that those who are aghast at cropping think nothing of spaying and neutering their Dobermans. Any number of reasons can be given but most reduce to a matter of convenience of one form or another. The idea that removing a part of the ear is horrific but de-sexing by cutting out or cutting off the associated organs, organs that are responsible for considerably more than just reproduction, is an abominable contradiction. How absurd.

And how many of you anti croppers have had your boy children circumcised? Hmm? There is an appropriate comparison.

Someone asked in an earlier post why things are this way? To anyone over 50 it is obvious. Our society is becoming increasingly effeminate. Logic and reason have been jettisoned in favor of an "oh poor thing" emotionalism which dilatory effects extend to far more than just cropped ears but that is subject for another place.

I'll be picking up my Doberman puppy in four weeks and it will be cropped and docked. If I had wanted a flop eared pooch I would have gotten a Bloodhound.

Don't like cropping? Don't do it. But don't bother telling me why because I don't care. And for those who want to see it eliminated who do you think you are? I have another message for you that can't be repeated in a public forum.

Have a nice day.
Welcome to Doberman Chat, Mark!



"Our society is becoming increasingly effeminate" :)

That's the polite way of saying what Eastwood has been calling for years "The pussification of America" ;)

I hope you get a chance to check in at the political section we have here. :thumbsup:
 
"I LOVE C&D Dobes. I think they're very pretty. I just don't like the fact that it's a medical procedure. The way I look at it is, it's like one of us loosing a thumb."

No it's not like loosing a thumb. Not only is the comparison ridiculous it is a fallacy of category.
Thanks for addressing the thumb! (Typed on my phone by both my thumbs.)
 
Welcome to Doberman Chat, Mark!



"Our society is becoming increasingly effeminate" :)

That's the polite way of saying what Eastwood has been calling for years "The pussification of America" ;)

I hope you get a chance to check in at the political section we have here. :thumbsup:

Thanks. I probably will resist the urge to head over to the political forum. I don't do well with emotionally charged anti intellectual do gooders and social justice warriors. Panties (especially when worn by boys) tend to get all knotted up, their feelings get hurt and their limited lives get disoriented when their touchy feely world views are assaulted.
 
Since Canadian legislation is being mentioned in this article, I would like to point out that there are still places in Canada that will do the cropping. For Western Canada, the majority of Dobe breeders are in BC and that is less than a one hour flight away from reputable crop vets here in neighboring Alberta. It's the same deal for Eastern Canada. You have the option to crop but only from the best vets which ensures good results with adequate pain management.
 
So many things in this article that worded to feed the AR and bleeding hearts out there. Statements like having to tightly wrap the ears, as if to cause discomfort or pain. The statement about nerve endings and the dog go thru life feeling it had lost an appendage or becoming disfigured. All scare tactics and false. I have been around multiple litters after a crop and they romp and play giving no notice to the cups on there heads or showing signs of pain. I hate it that people try to push there side by posting false info, whether they are Drs., vets or whatever. They just spew there opinion as if it is facts. Most vets know very little about after care or best methods of taping ears, other than immediately after the surgery.
Yes there are some botched ear crops and flopped ears by inexperience cropped and people that don't stick to posting or know how to post correctly but very few compared to the number of beautiful cropped ears out there.

This argument just seems to keep coming up. My concern is more on the health of the breed or the number of breeders breeding away from the proper temperament and what the breed was originally breed for. Isn't that part of the breed standard as well? But as long as they breed for the look they can take away everything else. The GSD, Rottweiler and even the showline Malinois are also being dumbed down. Maybe this should be a completely different discussion though.
 
"Labrador in a Doberman suit".

Oh, I really, really hope the breed never gets to that point. I own a field lab (think working vs show, with field being working) but he is still a FAR cry from what a Dobermann should be.

Which is another topic all in its own. I have serious issue with "pet" breeders. I fully believe dogs should have the ability (both physically and mentally) to do the job they were intended for and that if people can't handle the breed, they should find a different one. It's a reoccurring issue and it always ends up pretty much the same - dumber than a box of rocks dogs that are neither mentally or physically fit to perform the tasks once demanded of them. Want a pet? Get a breed that is naturally a pet type - not a high drive working breed.

That said - while I don't care if others get their dogs c/d, I do believe everyone should have the right to choose. At the end of the day, my dog is my property and I should beable to do with it as I wish as long as it's not actively killing the animal. I may not always agree with how some are cared for, but they are not my dogs and it's none of my business. If we continue on this path of we can't do anything that might possibly hurt the dog, cause discomfort, etc we might as well not own dogs anymore. I've seen everything from agility to weight pull to keeping your dog lean and fit come under attack and it's absolutely ridiculous. Dogs are dogs, not humans. They do not have the emotional or mental capacity that we do and people seem to be completely forgetting that.

C/D is akin to piercings in my book. Very short term discomfort. Or maybe tattoos. Whatever. I think you guys get my point. It is not akin to amputating an organ or appendage.

And I'm brought back to - why is it that so many of the hardcore anti c/d folks are the very same ones who push pediatric spay and neuter?! It's completely mind boggling to me.

I'm also with Oji in that if c/d were to be banned, I would likely find a new breed. I like standing ears (despite owning two floppers currently). And while no other breed is exactly like the Dobermann, there are several that are close enough that have naturally prick ears. The Dobermann just has everything I like and look for, when c/d, in one breed. Most others have atleast one attribute that I'm not too keen on - be it coloring or coat or size or whatever.
 

Back
Top