Won't stop marking... Need advice

IMHO it is all about balance and depends on what other time you have with your dog. I walk my dog for miles each day. During our walks I will switch up between heeling and loose free walking. I start out making him heel for a few blocks and then release him to be a dog for a block or so. I allow him to sniff and zig zag a bit. I use a 6-way lead and drape it over my shoulder. There's not much lead left for him to roam. When he hits the end he always corrects himself. He has never been a "puller". He's more of a lagger. He lags behind me and wants to investigate. It just gives me a weird feeling to have him on my right side, so I always keep him on the left. After a block of freedom it is back to heeling. I keep that up through our walk always starting and ending with heeling. When we start or end I always make him sit - to put on or take off his collar.
 
So, I'm curious: When Ares spots a squirrel or rabbit or deer or other dog, he does not lunge toward them? Does he even seem like he is struggling to fight back that urge? I know you mentioned that you may do Schutzhund with him, so I know he has to have ample prey drive.
He will look but anything other then that is no. Whe we are on the field he can go after the"prey" but on a walk no he's never lunged not once :)
[DOUBLEPOST=1437283297][/DOUBLEPOST]
IMHO it is all about balance and depends on what other time you have with your dog. I walk my dog for miles each day. During our walks I will switch up between heeling and loose free walking. I start out making him heel for a few blocks and then release him to be a dog for a block or so. I allow him to sniff and zig zag a bit. I use a 6-way lead and drape it over my shoulder. There's not much lead left for him to roam. When he hits the end he always corrects himself. He has never been a "puller". He's more of a lagger. He lags behind me and wants to investigate. It just gives me a weird feeling to have him on my right side, so I always keep him on the left. After a block of freedom it is back to heeling. I keep that up through our walk always starting and ending with heeling. When we start or end I always make him sit - to put on or take off his collar.
I don't walk him that far due to growth plates I heard over exertion can hurt their growth so he gets shorter walks with tons of praise when he's doing right. I don't believe in sniffing marking or zig zag. The leash is always loose and he stay where he should. The only time sniffing is for tracking IMHO
 
I don't walk him that far due to growth plates I heard over exertion can hurt their growth so he gets shorter walks with tons of praise when he's doing right.
I don't think walking would fall under the over exertion category. We go on 8-10 walks through out the day that totals up to about 8 miles. When we don't get to walk enough, he will want to run around inside the house. Inside the house he doesn't get to be a dog. There's no ball or rope or other toys inside.
What’s now commonly referred to as “loose leash walking” works well for most dog owners who don't compete with their dog. Rather than maintaining a precise position, the dog is expected to walk within an area defined by an imaginary circle by the owner’s side. When done correctly, the dog is neither pulling nor lagging.
I think it also depends on location. If I lived in a city with busy streets and many people, I would probably want a more precision heel. If I'm out in a more rural area then LLW would likely be fine, again not taking any competition into account.

This thread has gone off topic but certainly has me thinking more about LLW. I'm going to ask both of my trainers next week and get their opinions.
 
What I feel about loose-leashed walking is that it's a Goldilocks situation, that either too long is not OK, too short is not OK, you have to find a happy medium for it to be just right.
Once again to each their own
 
Yeah to each their own. My LLW isn't a circle because I always keep him on my left. It's more of a rectangle on my left side lol. I don't know if it is true but I've read the left side came from the military when the rifle being held in the right hand necessitated the dog being on the soldier’s left.
 
Yeah to each their own. My LLW isn't a circle because I always keep him on my left. It's more of a rectangle on my left side lol. I don't know if it is true but I've read the left side came from the military when the rifle being held in the right hand necessitated the dog being on the soldier’s left.
We keep pies on the left as well
 
IMHO it is all about balance and depends on what other time you have with your dog. I walk my dog for miles each day. During our walks I will switch up between heeling and loose free walking. I start out making him heel for a few blocks and then release him to be a dog for a block or so. I allow him to sniff and zig zag a bit. I use a 6-way lead and drape it over my shoulder. There's not much lead left for him to roam. When he hits the end he always corrects himself. He has never been a "puller". He's more of a lagger. He lags behind me and wants to investigate. It just gives me a weird feeling to have him on my right side, so I always keep him on the left. After a block of freedom it is back to heeling. I keep that up through our walk always starting and ending with heeling. When we start or end I always make him sit - to put on or take off his collar.
Interesting – a more similar approach to mine. The major difference is I do not allow mine to walk at my left side when not on a heel. I never want him to think or feel that he is getting away with breaking a heel. I don't even let him walk past my left side after being behind me sniffing something – well, that is, without my telling him "ok" and/or giving a hand signal that he is to proceed ahead. I believe in drawing a crystal clear and unmistakable distinction between when a dog is on heel and when they are not.

As for your Dobe not being a puller: Again, so different than anything I've yet experienced.
 
@AresMyDobie I like your approach. I have pretty much the same set up with my dobe. Layla is allowed to walk next to me but not in front and she can not pull. She too caught on quick she also is a drivey dog but does not lunge after birds, cats other dogs etc on our walks. However in bite work training she is more then capable of giving a good solid bite and not letting go. We lifted her off the ground a few times yesterday with the practice sleeve whilst she was biting it, this was the first time she saw a practice sleeve we have only be using tug toy ropes up to this point. I agree a walk is not a free for all. I give her lots of play dates and off lead fun time but when we are walking there are rules she must follow. I don't use anything more then a flat collar on her when we walk now. Occasionally if I know we are going into a very busy environment i switch that up with her harness and short lead. I have started rudimentary tracking with her and I think we underestimate our dogs, by telling them they can't lunge after cats whilst we walk or sniff whatever they like doesn't mean they won't do it when we teach them the right place and time for that behaviour. In fact i feel bite work teaches a dog exactly that how to control its prey drive.
 
@AresMyDobie I like your approach. I have pretty much the same set up with my dobe. Layla is allowed to walk next to me but not in front and she can not pull. She too caught on quick she also is a drivey dog but does not lunge after birds, cats other dogs etc on our walks. However in bite work training she is more then capable of giving a good solid bite and not letting go. We lifted her off the ground a few times yesterday with the practice sleeve whilst she was biting it, this was the first time she saw a practice sleeve we have only be using tug toy ropes up to this point. I agree a walk is not a free for all. I give her lots of play dates and off lead fun time but when we are walking there are rules she must follow. I don't use anything more then a flat collar on her when we walk now. Occasionally if I know we are going into a very busy environment i switch that up with her harness and short lead. I have started rudimentary tracking with her and I think we underestimate our dogs, by telling them they can't lunge after cats whilst we walk or sniff whatever they like doesn't mean they won't do it when we teach them the right place and time for that behaviour. In fact i feel bite work teaches a dog exactly that how to control its prey drive.
Yes 100% I agree with you.
 
Things I have learned from this thread:

1) cats are the root to all that's evil, even house training a dog.

2) Males must be harder to house train. How old are they when they begin to mark?

3) belly bands exist and can be used on animals. What do they do? Keep them from pottying? I want one for myself!!!

4) if ever on a deserted island just need vinegar it can be used for anything! Flavoring, pickling, cleaning, masking odor,.,, have I missed any?
 
Things I have learned from this thread:

1) cats are the root to all that's evil, even house training a dog.

2) Males must be harder to house train. How old are they when they begin to mark?

3) belly bands exist and can be used on animals. What do they do? Keep them from pottying? I want one for myself!!!

4) if ever on a deserted island just need vinegar it can be used for anything! Flavoring, pickling, cleaning, masking odor,.,, have I missed any?
he is almost 7 months now so I guess when they find their manhood is when they start markinglol
This whole thing made me laugh hahaha
Happy to report no incidents since hahaha
[DOUBLEPOST=1437434176][/DOUBLEPOST]We have belly band and he has to wear it when he's in the bedroom lol it's covers his weewee and I think discourages marking and doesn't let the tinkle go everywhere so you don't have more to clean up and more stink but he hasn't been lifting his leg so yayyyyyyy ! We aren't letting him mark outside anymore either we keep him on leash for potty time :)
 
he is almost 7 months now so I guess when they find their manhood is when they start markinglol
This whole thing made me laugh hahaha
Happy to report no incidents since hahaha
[DOUBLEPOST=1437434176][/DOUBLEPOST]We have belly band and he has to wear it when he's in the bedroom lol it's covers his weewee and I think discourages marking and doesn't let the tinkle go everywhere so you don't have more to clean up and more stink but he hasn't been lifting his leg so yayyyyyyy ! We aren't letting him mark outside anymore either we keep him on leash for potty time :)
Okay, what? I thought by "belly band" folks were saying to leash your dog around your waist.
 
Okay, what? I thought by "belly band" folks were saying to leash your dog around your waist.
Someone on here suggested the belly band lol it's looks pretty funny so I don't keep him in it lol I only use it in the bedroom where he marked but I don't really think he needs it anymore. I don't leash him inside anymore he's usually glued to my hip unless it's nap time and the no marking in the backyard is working great :)
 
Things I have learned from this thread:

1) cats are the root to all that's evil, even house training a dog.

2) Males must be harder to house train. How old are they when they begin to mark?

3) belly bands exist and can be used on animals. What do they do? Keep them from pottying? I want one for myself!!!

4) if ever on a deserted island just need vinegar it can be used for anything! Flavoring, pickling, cleaning, masking odor,.,, have I missed any?
Yes, and fleas are actually all cat fleas, aren't they?

I've not really had a problem in my experience with a male dog marking in the house even when they start to mature. But then again, I haven't had a very diverse household of animals.

Vinegar: I got turned on to apple cider vinegar by @DreamingDoberman here. I looked it up online and the claims are amazing in terms of health benefits. So I've been on it since. You want the unfiltered stuff, not the filtered you may commonly see in the grocery store.
 
I don't mean to steal this thread but Willow my 9 and a half week old girl just stood over my cat and marked him, I couldn't believe it and them I noticed that she didn't ask for the door like normal and peed on the floor. Is this normal behavior? And did you find your pup stopped marking once you cleaned up the cat marking?
 
Willow my 9 and a half week old girl just stood over my cat and marked him
I don't think you will see marking yet with a 9 week old. I'm guessing there was another odor there that triggered her to pee and the cat happened to be there. Is your cat marking around the house?
 
I don't think you will see marking yet with a 9 week old. I'm guessing there was another odor there that triggered her to pee and the cat happened to be there. Is your cat marking around the house?
Not that I'm aware of, she likes to stand above our other dog, the cat and my daughter when they are on the floor playing I didn't think anything of it until I noticed when she went over my cat she left less than half a teaspoon of urine on his back. He's a very laid back cat. She got her 2nd shots yesterday and we had a problem the day after her first shots where she started peeing on her bed which was out of character for a few days after. Then today she's had 2 accidents have you ever heard of this before. Sorry for all of the questions. It's been 10 years since I've had to do the large dog puppy training thing
 
She may have a UTI. My girl had a slight one when we got her and she dribbled a bit. She may also just be excited, many times their urinary muscles are still under developed and it gets better with age.
 

Back
Top