Other Breeds' Trainability

Tad - sorry I was not clear - I was actually agreeing with your statement on the bullmastiff. And I will add the pit bull breeds are not bred to maul either they are bred to bite and hold on for dear life which is why you should have a break stick on hand if you own one. They clamp done and don't let go which is very important if you are fighting a 1500 lb bull.

The mauling happens more usually when more than one dog is involved and of course the person who is actually trying to escape from them.
Thanks, D4e, for the clarification. I thought maybe that was the case, but I think it looked differently, so I felt I needed to speak on it.
 
That's all fine and dandy but I'll be honest here I wouldn't own a pitt. I think they have some serious mental issues from years of bad breeding/ inbreeding that have caused many to become red zone cases. I don't care how sound someone tries to claim they are I don't care for them. I know someone might say it's hypocritical but a Doberman and a Pitt are very different in my book. Statics don't lie and that news story of that poor child getting mauled to death by two of them and no one helped ? Granted human error but a dog shouldn't just run around mauling people. I know my dog wouldn't do that. Undoubtably human error has happened with dobes and other breed but you don't have fatalities like you do with Pitts. I also think they have become over popularized creating more issues with the breed. Not saying they were always like this but bad people + bad breeding = a dangerous animal.



Not saying that I agree or disagree. Just saying it makes my point. It's the other end of the leash that is the problem, not the dog.
Bad breeding, over breeding, selling to someone that is not up to the task.. Lack of training and proper socializing and just a flat out lack of responsibility for their dog are all human error that dogs are paying for.
 
I want to reply quickly as they are cracking down about internet usage at work.

I never said BM are prone to attack I said they "lack an off button". I don't have time to locate articles but just google and I'm sure you'll find plenty. After living with 2 mastiffs I stick to that, it's not articles or lack of info. it's ACTUAL experience from myself and 2 other IPO people from different states. Yes, they do hold down prey, they don't bite to take down like dobes would. They hold down and then maul. Seen it myself with the Italian mastiff. Google bull mastiff and you'll find plenty of articles. I can say both of our mastiffs were very sweet, they def. weren't prone to attack but if they did, there was no stopping once it started. Took two of us to pull the Italian off one of my dogs, luckily she had a muzzle on and we were only 2 steps behind her.
 
You shouldn't use own personal experience to generalize? I'm pretty sure that's what most people do.

With a quick google search this was the first article I pulled:

Bullmastiffs: What's Good About 'Em? What's Bad About 'Em?

Pretty much states exactly what I was saying. It's just not personally a dog I would own. Too strong willed with a mind of it's own and a lot of dog to control. I'm sure the right person could probably do very well with one though.
 
You shouldn't use own personal experience to generalize? I'm pretty sure that's what most people do.
That's probably true but it doesn't make it right.

If someone was bitten by a poodle, they might generalize that into all poodles are vicious. It doesn't make it true.
Many people have the same view of Dobermans and I think everyone in this forum would agree, it isn't true.
 
From the game keepers dog

"Not recognized by the Kennel Club as a breed until 1924 - but used previously by gamekeepers - these dogs have the mastiff instinct to pin their quarry rather than to bite, and to attack a man and throw him to the ground every time he tries to get to his feet - without ever using their teeth to savage him."

The description in this second paragraph reignites my coveting for the breed, especially when contrasted with my loudmouth maniac:

"These two famous breeds gave the modern Bullmastiff three priceless qualities, ideal in combination for a guard dog: superb temperament - even tempered, level-headed, magnanimous and never excitable: a silent, steadfast, almost arrogant bearing: and most importantly, the instinct to pin the quarry rather than to bite."
 
@Tad a dog that doesn't bite is like a cat that doesn't scratch.

NJ boy dead after gruesome bullmastiff attack

Dog maul horror: Family shocked as dog savages toddler's face in horrific attack

46-year-old Livonia man dead after being attacked by two Bullmastiff dogs in Metamora Township

Just reiterating that I don't think these are out of control, human stalking animals. I just think that mastiff are innately protective, weary of strangers, and lack an "off" button. I also think with the right trainer and environment they are good dogs. Just not dogs that I personally trust to be around.

I only used bull mastiffs as an example, that's what I quickly googled before going to bed.
 
Again, it comes down to the owner, not the breed.

I don't know enough about BMs but from Tad's quote it seems that a stable BM should be like what is expected of a stable Doberman. Seeing children as a threat is not stable. I agree with you that a BM should have an appropriate home fit for the breed. One that understands the training, time and commitment needed in owning such breed...which we both know starts as soon as you begin looking for a breeder or rescue. Buying a BM from a breeder that doesn't test stable temperaments? ...risky! All breeds should require research from the prospective owner; but with protection and guardian breeds - the importance of being a responsible owner and doing things right, intensifies. This isn't unique to BMs.

We should be careful in the words we choose to use. The term maul just sounds horrific. I'm sure enthusiasts of the breeds they so love which are on the BSL list would never want a term like that to be on the forefront of describing their breed. This only adds fuel to the fire of those that support BSL. We can't expect to break the public's ill-perceived perception of our breeds by putting down others.
 
@Tad a dog that doesn't bite is like a cat that doesn't scratch.

NJ boy dead after gruesome bullmastiff attack

Dog maul horror: Family shocked as dog savages toddler's face in horrific attack

46-year-old Livonia man dead after being attacked by two Bullmastiff dogs in Metamora Township

Just reiterating that I don't think these are out of control, human stalking animals. I just think that mastiff are innately protective, weary of strangers, and lack an "off" button. I also think with the right trainer and environment they are good dogs. Just not dogs that I personally trust to be around.

I only used bull mastiffs as an example, that's what I quickly googled before going to bed.
I for one can understand where you are coming from. I would never own a Pitt they have to many mental problems. People like to say human error or whatever yes in some cases it is but when a person creates an unstable animal it doesn't mean we need to be persuaded that it's ok to have. The Pitt was a good breed not anymore and needs some serious help. I know most won't agree with me on that but it's truth. I agree with your off button to a point it can be achieved when taught. Key word taught.
 
@Tad a dog that doesn't bite is like a cat that doesn't scratch.

NJ boy dead after gruesome bullmastiff attack

Dog maul horror: Family shocked as dog savages toddler's face in horrific attack

46-year-old Livonia man dead after being attacked by two Bullmastiff dogs in Metamora Township

Just reiterating that I don't think these are out of control, human stalking animals. I just think that mastiff are innately protective, weary of strangers, and lack an "off" button. I also think with the right trainer and environment they are good dogs. Just not dogs that I personally trust to be around.

I only used bull mastiffs as an example, that's what I quickly googled before going to bed.
That's true of course. In fact if someone asks if my dog bites, I may say "All dogs bite." In that story iconic to the Bullmastiff breed that chronicles the challenge to any man who thought they could escape the dog it is noted that the dog was "securely muzzled."

Characteristics a breed had back near when it was developed might not be as present today as they should be. Breeding true to the standard physically and mentally is the only hope to maintain adherence to what the breed is supposed to be. So if the Bullmastiff as a whole is in good shape as a breed, I'd say they are not all that likely to maul people. But examples of such incidents can be found of course.

I know dogs deviate from the ideal and the standard. Why else would I have to be working so hard to rid my Doberman of fear of other dogs if the breed is "fearless?"

Now, I know you were not only referring to the Bullmastiff. You were referring to, I think, all Mastiff-type dogs. That seems to be painting with quite a broad brush. I consider the different types of Mastiffs to be pretty different from one another.

In my mind, an English Mastiff – the breed that I think of when only the word "Mastiff" is used, is pretty slow to wrath. I wouldn't consider it any more dangerous than a Great Dane. Both breeds used to be far more ferocious than they are today. Of course that's a strange comparison as the Dane is only about as old as our breed, while the Mastiff is ancient, though I don't know if the current incarnation of the English Mastiff is the same type we read of as being ancient.
 
I for one can understand where you are coming from. I would never own a Pitt they have to many mental problems. People like to say human error or whatever yes in some cases it is but when a person creates an unstable animal it doesn't mean we need to be persuaded that it's ok to have. The Pitt was a good breed not anymore and needs some serious help. I know most won't agree with me on that but it's truth. I agree with your off button to a point it can be achieved when taught. Key word taught.

To bounce off this question to anyone. I see this term used a lot and I wanted to take a moment to ask... What is a Pit? Should we take our experiences with "Pits" when Pit, even Pitbull, isn't a breed? A pitbull is a type of dog and can cover a variety of breeds that are as similar and no more the same as different breeds are to one another that are Hounds, Retrievers, Mastiffs... etc. Knowing that, do you believe it to be fair to lump what one breed does within their type, with another?

How do we even know what breed the dog even is without papers? Each bully breed has common characteristics in temperament and physical looks that they share. And then on top of that, variances in preferred looks or work ethic that fall within each breed's own standard (ex: working dobe, show dobe, na dobe, eu dobe). The line starts to get a little muddy to try and determine what breed a pitbull is based on looks alone. Luckily, the Dobe doesn't have this issue as the next closest that is in the Guardian group is a Beauceron, and they have quite the number of unique differences.


I'm not even sure what this topic is about anymore, lol! but related to where it is going: Something that I've wondered. When looking through shelters and when you see a boxer labeled as a plott hound or something similar, lol. How do they come to that conclusion? I wonder how hard or expensive it would be to use the DNA swab kit to have a more accurate identification on incoming dogs. Maybe this would help set owners that adopt off on the right foot for success if they have an idea of what they may be facing breed wise. I found this link quite interesting! Inaccuracy of Visual Breed Identification


Sadly, such is what happens to a popular breed. 101 dalmatians anyone? Everyone had a Dal and you wouldn't have to go far to hear of someone who knew of an aggressive Dal during those days. Those that do their research, will find the breeders that were there before the boom and are still breeding to their breed's standard. I wish certain breeds didn't become so obnoxiously popular b/c I do agree with you that there are many pitbull mixes out there that are simply a mess due to irresponsible breeding. One thing all pitbull types usually share in common is that, if they take true to their common ancestry's roots, they can be one of the most lovable and human friendly dogs out there.

Edit: I see while typing this, @Tad pretty much said what I wanted to say, but with less words. A downside to women, and me in general, we like to be a little too chatty. :p
 
To bounce off this question to anyone. I see this term used a lot and I wanted to take a moment to ask... What is a Pit? Should we take our experiences with "Pits" when Pit, even Pitbull, isn't a breed? A pitbull is a type of dog and can cover a variety of breeds that are as similar and no more the same as different breeds are to one another that are Hounds, Retrievers, Mastiffs... etc. Knowing that, do you believe it to be fair to lump what one breed does within their type, with another?

How do we even know what breed the dog even is without papers? Each bully breed has common characteristics in temperament and physical looks that they share. And then on top of that, variances in preferred looks or work ethic that fall within each breed's own standard (ex: working dobe, show dobe, na dobe, eu dobe). The line starts to get a little muddy to try and determine what breed a pitbull is based on looks alone. Luckily, the Dobe doesn't have this issue as the next closest that is in the Guardian group is a Beauceron, and they have quite the number of unique differences.


I'm not even sure what this topic is about anymore, lol! but related to where it is going: Something that I've wondered. When looking through shelters and when you see a boxer labeled as a plott hound or something similar, lol. How do they come to that conclusion? I wonder how hard or expensive it would be to use the DNA swab kit to have a more accurate identification on incoming dogs. Maybe this would help set owners that adopt off on the right foot for success if they have an idea of what they may be facing breed wise. I found this link quite interesting! Inaccuracy of Visual Breed Identification


Sadly, such is what happens to a popular breed. 101 dalmatians anyone? Everyone had a Dal and you wouldn't have to go far to hear of someone who knew of an aggressive Dal during those days. Those that do their research, will find the breeders that were there before the boom and are still breeding to their breed's standard. I wish certain breeds didn't become so obnoxiously popular b/c I do agree with you that there are many pitbull mixes out there that are simply a mess due to irresponsible breeding. One thing all pitbull types usually share in common is that, if they take true to their common ancestry's roots, they can be one of the most lovable and human friendly dogs out there.

Edit: I see while typing this, @Tad pretty much said what I wanted to say, but with less words. A downside to women, and me in general, we like to be a little too chatty. :p
Not all! I love to read thoughtful ideas of our members. I was gonna comment this morning on how long my writings sometimes are.
 
Just a thought: Strong-willed? Or a different kind of drive?

One thing most Dobermans have in spades is prey drive. I would call it extremely hard to call off my Dobe when he's locked onto some prey. Locked on meaning on the chase, or about to spring into the chase.

This is the closest thing I'd liken in my Dobes to having no "off-switch."

I don't know Mastiff type dogs well enough to speak to the matter of their drives. Well, besides guarding.
 
11407296_568123889996496_3798263594663482445_n.png
 

Back
Top