Other Breeds' Trainability

To bounce off this question to anyone. I see this term used a lot and I wanted to take a moment to ask... What is a Pit? Should we take our experiences with "Pits" when Pit, even Pitbull, isn't a breed? A pitbull is a type of dog and can cover a variety of breeds that are as similar and no more the same as different breeds are to one another that are Hounds, Retrievers, Mastiffs... etc. Knowing that, do you believe it to be fair to lump what one breed does within their type, with another?

How do we even know what breed the dog even is without papers? Each bully breed has common characteristics in temperament and physical looks that they share. And then on top of that, variances in preferred looks or work ethic that fall within each breed's own standard (ex: working dobe, show dobe, na dobe, eu dobe). The line starts to get a little muddy to try and determine what breed a pitbull is based on looks alone. Luckily, the Dobe doesn't have this issue as the next closest that is in the Guardian group is a Beauceron, and they have quite the number of unique differences.


I'm not even sure what this topic is about anymore, lol! but related to where it is going: Something that I've wondered. When looking through shelters and when you see a boxer labeled as a plott hound or something similar, lol. How do they come to that conclusion? I wonder how hard or expensive it would be to use the DNA swab kit to have a more accurate identification on incoming dogs. Maybe this would help set owners that adopt off on the right foot for success if they have an idea of what they may be facing breed wise. I found this link quite interesting! Inaccuracy of Visual Breed Identification


Sadly, such is what happens to a popular breed. 101 dalmatians anyone? Everyone had a Dal and you wouldn't have to go far to hear of someone who knew of an aggressive Dal during those days. Those that do their research, will find the breeders that were there before the boom and are still breeding to their breed's standard. I wish certain breeds didn't become so obnoxiously popular b/c I do agree with you that there are many pitbull mixes out there that are simply a mess due to irresponsible breeding. One thing all pitbull types usually share in common is that, if they take true to their common ancestry's roots, they can be one of the most lovable and human friendly dogs out there.

Edit: I see while typing this, @Tad pretty much said what I wanted to say, but with less words. A downside to women, and me in general, we like to be a little too chatty. :p
I never said they weren't friendly dogs what I said was do to bad breeding we ended up with a bad result. When you end up with a bad result you have to start over. No ones going to convince that they are the greatest most loving dog out there. I'm sure they were very good and stable dogs but do to them becoming so popular breeding wasn't regulated properly and you now have so many BYB inbreeding dogs left and right creating unknowing people getting unstable animals. I have a friend who has a pitbull her name is hazel and she's an extremely sweet dog I think she's just wonderful. She's a rescue and her story is sad she was bred time and time again even with her own siblings till my friend rescued her. This person wanted the blue nose like she is and sold this pups for thousands of dollars. This is what I'm talking about she didn't ask for it but due to this typed of disgusting breeding is why the breed has gone down hill. I'm not blaming dog, further more people just need to understand when they messed up stop and eventually restart.
 
11407296_568123889996496_3798263594663482445_n.png
See, but I hear way too much "It's all in how they're raised!" I think it's a lot of nature and some nurture.
 
The difference IMO being a Doberman can be called off as they aren't as strong willed.
I'm going to assume that someone tried to call those Dobermans off and that the dogs didn't turn off. It could be that no one was around to call them off. I didn't read each story in detail.

The idea that a particular breed is unable to turn off leads to breed specific legislation and often starts incorporating other breeds. If someone legislates against Mastiffs then there will likely be other breeds legislated.
The fact that 49 of the 50 dogs in the Micheal Vick case were rehabilitated shows that even dogs bred for fighting and who took place in fighting can be taught to turn off. It also shows that not every dog can be rehabilitated. Certainly inbreeding can lead to physical and/or mental disorders that can make a dog aggressive or fearful.
 
I think nature can also affect mindset to a certain extent. The truth must lie somewhere in here.

My Dobe naturally has the mindset to be very watchful and alert on strangers. I didn't teach that until after it had already started and started in a big way. Now, I'm trying to help him learn to direct it properly.

I guess we could get into just what constitutes ability and what constitutes mindset.
 
My Dobe naturally has the mindset to be very watchful and alert on strangers.
My family had poodles that were the same way. Dogs pick up on the mindset and emotions of their owner. If you're watchful and alert of strangers, your dog will likely be the same. If your accepting of strangers, your dog will likely be the same. They can also pick up on the emotion of the stranger. So even if they're normally accepting to strangers, if a stranger approaches with bad intent a dog will likely pick up on that and react accordingly.
 
My family had poodles that were the same way. Dogs pick up on the mindset and emotions of their owner. If you're watchful and alert of strangers, your dog will likely be the same. If your accepting of strangers, your dog will likely be the same. They can also pick up on the emotion of the stranger. So even if they're normally accepting to strangers, if a stranger approaches with bad intent a dog will likely pick up on that and react accordingly.
Interesting theory. I know with this pup I intentionally did not promote him alerting because I wanted to err on the side of him not being overly aggressive until we got to see how he was going to turn out. You know, a small child in the house. But if your theory is correct, he picked up on very sublet cues.

Or, it could be that it was in his nature to be watchful and suspicious. That wouldn't be too big a stretch with or breed.
 
There's an episode of Dog Whisperer where a woman was a nervous wreck and her dog was also nervous. Just having the woman relax with meditation was enough to calm the dog down. Of course nothing is 100%. I think most dogs are alert by nature but how they react is different. Small dogs may look at a child as a threat because to a small dog, a child looks big and could actually do harm to the small dog. I think that would be considered nature but how they react to that perceived threat is nurture. A larger dog doesn't perceive any threat because they know 'that small person can't hurt me'.
 

This is a very good point but you also have to take in to consideration not everyone should have a working breed dog. I know the Malinios is actually in the shepherd class, but most of the breeders I know that breed them will not sell to an inexperienced dog owner. So the other end of the leash has to know what the hell they are doing. Again don't blame the dog. Are there dogs that sometimes have a screw loose? Yes, but not as many as dogs not properly trained or not trained at all. That is why this site is excellent for newbies to come learn and ask questions before they buy a dog that may be more than they bargained for.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I want to reiterate that I never said the breed was aggressive.

Also, the difference between dobes and mastiffs are I believe a dobe can be trained to turn off. The dobes who attack people most likely did not have that training or any, I think we all can agree to that.

I'm happy to continue talking about this subject with someone that has owned a mastiff and has had it attack and called it off and who disagrees. Feel free to PM message me, otherwise we're just discussing opinions, like Republicans and Democrats and we're never going to agree or see the others side.
 
I'm happy to continue talking about this subject with someone that has owned a mastiff and has had it attack and called it off and who disagrees.
My grandfather owned mastiffs, had it attack a badger, called it off. That however is more anecdotal evidence and means nothing. There are probably millions of mastiffs and the experiences of a single person are irrelevant
 
I never said they weren't friendly dogs what I said was do to bad breeding we ended up with a bad result. When you end up with a bad result you have to start over. No ones going to convince that they are the greatest most loving dog out there. I'm sure they were very good and stable dogs but do to them becoming so popular breeding wasn't regulated properly and you now have so many BYB inbreeding dogs left and right creating unknowing people getting unstable animals. I have a friend who has a pitbull her name is hazel and she's an extremely sweet dog I think she's just wonderful. She's a rescue and her story is sad she was bred time and time again even with her own siblings till my friend rescued her. This person wanted the blue nose like she is and sold this pups for thousands of dollars. This is what I'm talking about she didn't ask for it but due to this typed of disgusting breeding is why the breed has gone down hill. I'm not blaming dog, further more people just need to understand when they messed up stop and eventually restart.

Couldn't the same be said for any ill bred dog? I don't understand how this relates to or is the fault of breeders who health test and breed to standard? I'm talking about reputable breeders and you are referring to BYB bred dogs or dogs of unknown origins. That would be like blaming reputable doberman breeders for the irresponsible breeders who create unstable dobermans out there.
 
Couldn't the same be said for any ill bred dog? I don't understand how this relates to or is the fault of breeders who health test and breed to standard? I'm talking about reputable breeders and you are referring to BYB bred dogs or dogs of unknown origins. That would be like blaming reputable doberman breeders for the irresponsible breeders who create unstable dobermans out there.
I didn't blame reputable breeders you missed my point. I didn't say anything about them. Anything from good stock creates good stock. Unfortunately they are out numbered by greeders. Yes it could be said about any breed but not every breed has nearly as many human fatalities or mauling or someone getting bit.
 
I didn't blame reputable breeders you missed my point. I didn't say anything about them. Anything from good stock creates good stock. Unfortunately they are out numbered by greeders. Yes it could be said about any breed but not every breed has nearly as many human fatalities or mauling or someone getting bit.
Just to play devils advocate,and I'm sure we can find a poll somewhere to dispute,but I found this on a quick search.
Guess what #2 is?



With 59 fatalities, this breed comes at the second position. They were originally used as gun dogs because of their strong sense of smell and were used to track down birds for hunting. Cocker Spaniels are basically of two origins, England and America. Though the two Cocker Spaniels from two different countries have differences in their appearances, they are yet called cousins. The American one is smaller than the English spaniel though.
Pits were #1 with 66.


Top 12 Dog Breeds that Bite the Most - The Aggressive Dogs List - Listovative
 
Just to play devils advocate,and I'm sure we can find a poll somewhere to dispute,but I found this on a quick search.
Guess what #2 is?



With 59 fatalities, this breed comes at the second position. They were originally used as gun dogs because of their strong sense of smell and were used to track down birds for hunting. Cocker Spaniels are basically of two origins, England and America. Though the two Cocker Spaniels from two different countries have differences in their appearances, they are yet called cousins. The American one is smaller than the English spaniel though.
Pits were #1 with 66.


Top 12 Dog Breeds that Bite the Most - The Aggressive Dogs List - Listovative
It makes me sad honestly
 
Just to play devils advocate,and I'm sure we can find a poll somewhere to dispute,but I found this on a quick search.
Guess what #2 is?



With 59 fatalities, this breed comes at the second position. They were originally used as gun dogs because of their strong sense of smell and were used to track down birds for hunting. Cocker Spaniels are basically of two origins, England and America. Though the two Cocker Spaniels from two different countries have differences in their appearances, they are yet called cousins. The American one is smaller than the English spaniel though.
Pits were #1 with 66.


Top 12 Dog Breeds that Bite the Most - The Aggressive Dogs List - Listovative
Surely you know that article is pathetic. But I get your point. Pretty bad that they couldn't even produce a picture of a Cocker. They used a pic of a Cavalier.
 
Surely you know that article is pathetic. But I get your point. Pretty bad that they couldn't even produce a picture of a Cocker. They used a pic of a Cavalier.
Thank you,Tad. You did get the point.
 
Just to play devils advocate,and I'm sure we can find a poll somewhere to dispute,but I found this on a quick search.
Guess what #2 is?



With 59 fatalities, this breed comes at the second position. They were originally used as gun dogs because of their strong sense of smell and were used to track down birds for hunting. Cocker Spaniels are basically of two origins, England and America. Though the two Cocker Spaniels from two different countries have differences in their appearances, they are yet called cousins. The American one is smaller than the English spaniel though.
Pits were #1 with 66.


Top 12 Dog Breeds that Bite the Most - The Aggressive Dogs List - Listovative

I'd like to see the actual stats they are using. The wording is strange when you look from breed to breed
#10 Doberman: and till date this dog has bitten about nine people, study shows.
bitten 9 people? How does that qualify for #10?
#5 Bull Mastiff - no mention of a number
#3 Rottweilers, with 39 attacks recorded till date
 
I'd like to see the actual stats they are using. The wording is strange when you look from breed to breed
#10 Doberman: and till date this dog has bitten about nine people, study shows.
bitten 9 people? How does that qualify for #10?
#5 Bull Mastiff - no mention of a number
#3 Rottweilers, with 39 attacks recorded till date
And you got the point too,even if you didn't realize it;)
 

Back
Top