My Grim, Fearful Prediction

How sad - that you misunderstand that in fighting for c/d it preserves your right to choice. The standard does not ban leaving a dog uncropped or undocked. BUT Once we loose our right to c/d your right to choice will soon follow. Sad that you will not fight to protect my right which guarantee's your right to do as you choose. But to just fight for choice and now to embrace not cropping will guarantee the loss of all our rights to choice. I still respect your right to choose your own side. I can only hope your respect my right to stand on a standard that allows us all to exist in harmony and gives you your choice. Changing it will forever will lead to the loss of both our rights and our standard. What everyone seems to miss is that our standard protects BOTH our rights - A ban forever steals all our rights away and destroys our breed.

I certainly apologize as I have certainly said something the wrong way or it was perceived the wrong way to change your stand and support of our breed and our right to maintain what we both have at this point which is a choice. The standard allows all so the only change being proposed is the loss of a choice.
 
I certainly apologize as I have certainly said something the wrong way or it was perceived the wrong way to change your stand and support of our breed and our right to maintain what we both have at this point which is a choice. The standard allows all so the only change being proposed is the loss of a choice.
Take my word for it im not the only one your rhetoric has swayed away from your cause.. My love for the Doberman goes far deeper than skin. It is my personal opinion that people like you are doing as much damage as you believe you are doing good.. But i know because im not a member of the DPCA im not entitled to my opiniion.. In this day and aga ive had about all i can take of any extremists.
 
Good Lord, I go off to the hospital and miss a few days on the forum and I come back to see all hell breaking loose over cropping again. I had no idea that it was my solomn duty to crop my dog's ears, or as a consequence be given a name, or be categoried somehow. I thought just having a doberman was noble in itsself, but now I can't help but feel like I should bear some regret and /or maybe even a little shame because I failed to crop my dog's ears and spend every waking minute of life training for shutzhund or whatever. When I looked into the 2 breeds of dogs the VA said would suit me for the help I need, all I kept hearing was how great a doberman would be instead of the other breed suggested. I had no idea I would wind up either a Hatfield or a McCoy depending on wether I cropped or not. In my case, an AKC breeder had a son who'd gotten a TBI from serving in Afganistan...and she was sympathetic enough to sell me her fine puppy for only $300 as a result of my service, and my TBI, compliments of Iraq. Many times I just sit on the couch with my boy, petting him to sleep, and verbally out loud apologise to him for wasting him instead of saying something like "there's a good boy" because I failed to crop, and I dont have him in training or in the ring. I'm poor in the sense that I cannot hold any job post surgery, or even think about returning to a prep-room, so I have little/no money. I cannot drive due to my condition...hell, I don't even have a car anymore. Makes it damn tough to consider spending several hundred dollars on cosmetic ear surgery instead of paying a mortgage...and to my knowledge, there are no shutzhund or any other structured training sites to take my dog to anywhere around here even if I could drive. Seeing all my new friends on here bickering so depresses me. I have nothing but gratitude for all the help I got from people here when Crutch was in a health crisis somehow. I'm really, really sorry guys. Sorry I chose a breed of dog unknowingly to me surrounded with such controversy that I would be led to feel this way. Should'a got the BMD instead...maybe next time? :2cents
 
Just to remind folks: This thread wasn't specifically or solely about C/D. It was about what I am concerned is happening to the breed. This is related to an increase in popularity, but not the popularity of well-bred Dobermans. I am seeing a lot (in person, and in the media) of that sort of not so great looking Dobe – usually too tall, not put together well. And yes, most of the time they are not cropped, and sometimes not docked.

It just seems to me to be the same thing as what I have perceived to have happened to the Boxer. Almost all Boxers I see are just sort of goofy, slinky and in the hands of a younger set – sometimes what I would call Hipsters. It's a popular pet for some reason, but it seems to have lost its nobility and seriousness.

So I do believe C/D plays a role in this, and I explained it in this thread if I recall.

Poor, irresponsible breeding, however, I think is the closest thing to the root cause that I can find.

We all know Dobes are loving and goofy and sweet. But if most of the other aspects of the breed are stripped away, well, you've got a popular pet and that's about it. I believe the thing that has kept the Doberman from returning to popularity is that still retains some of the image of a fierce, even dangerous dog. Does anyone here view the Boxer that way? It's my understanding though, that the breed was originally a good watch dog and guard dog, capable of doing that work.

Then there are the health issues in the silly, popular, but poorly bred dogs.
 
Evolution of any particular "thing" is inevitable until that thing is no more. All things will evolve.

Thing = person, place, animal, idea, standard, philosophy, planet, political model, solar system, universe, practices, beliefs, etc.....................................

Change can be very frightening, but once accepted, maybe not such a bad thing.
 
Is it maybe that more of the younger people are not taught about how to find the right breeder? Is it becoming harder just to track down good breeders since it does seem like there is less of them and so people are going to what they think is an ok breeder but in actuality they're not? Most of these people are looking for pets and while they might have researched what they are looking for (size, activity level and weather they're good for a family) how many are studying what the actual standard calls for an animal to really look like? So is it possible they find someone who has dogs with good temperments (for a pet) and looks like the breed (to someone who hasn't studied the standard) and thinks well they're AKC or CKC registered so they must be ok. Personally I think this is part of what is happening to a lot of our breeds so the question becomes what can we do to change that?
 
Just to remind folks: This thread wasn't specifically or solely about C/D. It was about what I am concerned is happening to the breed. This is related to an increase in popularity, but not the popularity of well-bred Dobermans. I am seeing a lot (in person, and in the media) of that sort of not so great looking Dobe – usually too tall, not put together well. And yes, most of the time they are not cropped, and sometimes not docked.

It just seems to me to be the same thing as what I have perceived to have happened to the Boxer. Almost all Boxers I see are just sort of goofy, slinky and in the hands of a younger set – sometimes what I would call Hipsters. It's a popular pet for some reason, but it seems to have lost its nobility and seriousness.

So I do believe C/D plays a role in this, and I explained it in this thread if I recall.

Poor, irresponsible breeding, however, I think is the closest thing to the root cause that I can find.

We all know Dobes are loving and goofy and sweet. But if most of the other aspects of the breed are stripped away, well, you've got a popular pet and that's about it. I believe the thing that has kept the Doberman from returning to popularity is that still retains some of the image of a fierce, even dangerous dog. Does anyone here view the Boxer that way? It's my understanding though, that the breed was originally a good watch dog and guard dog, capable of doing that work.

Then there are the health issues in the silly, popular, but poorly bred dogs.

All those concerns you have, have to do with education. A lot of people simply just have no idea that buying a puppy from the neighbor next door probably isn't the wisest idea. The neighbor next door believes their sweet Bella NEEDS to "experience being a mom" and have puppies. They have no idea the costs or health risks they are possibly putting mom under (being pregnant is tolling on the body!) or the health risks of unknowingly breeding possibly poor genetics into the offspring. People are simply naive, but that can be changed! We have to educate the public - educate the buyers - what to look for, at least minimally, in a proper breeder. Educate the public - new breeders - how to get started breeding, where to go to learn and what should be done, at the least, to produce healthy pups.


Interesting enough a study done in the US on shelter dogs has shown that a good majority of the dogs relinquished, were obtained from a friend.
http://www.naiaonline.org/uploads/WhitePapers/CharacteristicsOfShelterRelinquishedAnimals.pdf
The study determined that 3.9% of surrendered [dogs] came from a pet shop; 10.6% of surrendered animals came from a breeder; 2.9% of surrendered animals were received as a gift; 9.3% of surrendered animals were found by the owner as a stray; 6.0% of surrendered animals were offspring of another pet in possession of the owner; 22.5% of surrendered animals were originally acquired from another shelter; and, 30.8% of surrendered animals were acquired from a friend.

This, exactly this.
Conversely, dogs obtained at no cost and with little effort are at increased risk of relinquishment. This might reflect a lack of value to the owner or a lower level of attachment or commitment


Toes may be stepped on but that is simply because of people's flawed perception of critique. For some reason people look at critique as a bad thing, a hard pill to swallow. But good critique is someone wanting to help you! An enemy would never give helpful advice to an enemy. Only a friend would. Those that are critiquing also must be very careful in the way we present ourselves and word our advice. It does no good to offer help when your message is tainted with a negative overtone.
 
@Dobs4ever you may find me sad, amusing, confusing or whatever, but it is because you really do not understand my opinion. I was going to write a long discourse trying to explain my position more clearly, but I feel it is of no use.
I do support the standard and all it stands for as an ideal, but it is not Law.

I have accomplished much in my career by maintaining a attitude of "kill them with kindness" and keeping an open mind. This is the position I choose to fight from to maintain my right to C/D my dogs. You may not like it, or understand it, but there it is. I do not ask you to change your position, and to think that is what is being said is a total misperception. It is just my opinion that by not listening to what others have to say, and I do not mean AR folks, that you distance yourself from them and this usually will close the door to positive discourse. None of us here are asking for the standard to be opened and changed.

I truly want to keep C/D for all our dogs, and to think it could be taken away is a thought I do not like. I also believe it has nothing to do with good breeding, as there are a number of great Dobermann lines in Europe that I would import in a heartbeat that have not been C/D for some time now. But I also feel that if a Doberman owner wants to own a dog with natural ears that they should have that right without being put down like an infidel.

I fight for the right to keep C/D -- I just take a different position than you do. Does that make me wrong? I don't think so!
 
Is it maybe that more of the younger people are not taught about how to find the right breeder? Is it becoming harder just to track down good breeders since it does seem like there is less of them and so people are going to what they think is an ok breeder but in actuality they're not? Most of these people are looking for pets and while they might have researched what they are looking for (size, activity level and weather they're good for a family) how many are studying what the actual standard calls for an animal to really look like? So is it possible they find someone who has dogs with good temperments (for a pet) and looks like the breed (to someone who hasn't studied the standard) and thinks well they're AKC or CKC registered so they must be ok. Personally I think this is part of what is happening to a lot of our breeds so the question becomes what can we do to change that?
I believe you have a really good point.

I intimated here a while back something embarrassing about myself which is when I bought my first Doberman, I was sorely clueless about the important issues surrounding dogs. Like most people, I had had a few dogs growing up. I had also had a girlfriend with a Doberman.

Where did I go to get my Doberman? The classifieds. What's more, I didn't have much money at all, so while I knew there were expensive dogs out there, they certainly weren't for me – just like any other expensive thing wasn't for me. No way I could afford it.

Fortunately, it turned out my first Doberman lived to about the average lifespan, was smart, trainable, protective, strong and capable, and just a fantastic companion. But you really nailed it when you mentioned the AKC registration. I thought that the fact he was AKC meant he measured up to a certain level of quality. I ordered a copy of his pedigree, framed and hung it up. I thought it was pretty cool. There was only one champion in his lines anywhere in the four generation pedigree.

I pretty quickly began to read up on the breed (I already knew I wanted one, so reading prior to purchase wasn't necessary). I learned about the breed standard, and saw myriad photos, all of which told me my Dobe didn't meet the standard very closely. I mean, he was certainly purebred and wasn't butt ugly, but still. It happens that he wasn't that sort of overly tall, deep chested, clumsy type of Dobe I see. No, he was sort of the opposite. Standard height but stocky – 95 lbs – with big hips and a blocky head. I got a short crop on him because that is what the vet chose to do. I got asked a couple times if he was Pit Bull / Doberman.

So I think you're right. The level of dog knowledge that the average person possesses is not enough.

The one major aspect you didn't mention is shelter dogs. I think the vast majority of the Boxers that I see (not that I revel in ripping on Boxers) that are in the hands of hip, younger folks came from shelters. That is, after all, the thing to do these days if you're enlightened and a good person.
[DOUBLEPOST=1423083619,1423082371][/DOUBLEPOST]
All those concerns you have, have to do with education. A lot of people simply just have no idea that buying a puppy from the neighbor next door probably isn't the wisest idea. The neighbor next door believes their sweet Bella NEEDS to "experience being a mom" and have puppies. They have no idea the costs or health risks they are possibly putting mom under (being pregnant is tolling on the body!) or the health risks of unknowingly breeding possibly poor genetics into the offspring. People are simply naive, but that can be changed! We have to educate the public - educate the buyers - what to look for, at least minimally, in a proper breeder. Educate the public - new breeders - how to get started breeding, where to go to learn and what should be done, at the least, to produce healthy pups.


Interesting enough a study done in the US on shelter dogs has shown that a good majority of the dogs relinquished, were obtained from a friend.
http://www.naiaonline.org/uploads/WhitePapers/CharacteristicsOfShelterRelinquishedAnimals.pdf


This, exactly this.



Toes may be stepped on but that is simply because of people's flawed perception of critique. For some reason people look at critique as a bad thing, a hard pill to swallow. But good critique is someone wanting to help you! An enemy would never give helpful advice to an enemy. Only a friend would. Those that are critiquing also must be very careful in the way we present ourselves and word our advice. It does no good to offer help when your message is tainted with a negative overtone.
In my opinion, you nailed it too, along with @Rex's mom. The public needs to be educated. I hope you read my reply to Rex's Mom for a picture of what I was like when I bought my first Doberman.

That study on the source of shelter dogs is really revelatory. As I said a moment ago, I think most of the Boxers that I see are from shelters, and I think it's the case for Dobermans too – talking about the ones I see out there and in the media.

So you've got a lot of sub-par dogs winding up in shelters. I don't really blame those who choose to get a dog at a shelter. That's fairly noble. Now, could those people instead support an ethical breeder who is working to better the breed? Sure. I think that would maybe be better. Sucks for all the shelter dogs, but what can we do? We can't fix all the problems in the world.

So how do we educate? I know of a handful of issues about which the public sorely needs to be educated. One being freaking look for, and stop for, people at crosswalks. Pardon me, I walk take my daughter to preschool and folks just intentionally fly on by as we wait there. Okay, I digress. But the point is, how to educate?

I can think of only a few public education campaigns out there:
Give 'Em A Brake.
Don't Drink And Drive.
Just Say No.
Never Shake A Baby.
Have Your Pets Spayed Or Neutered.
Be Kind, Rewind.

How about:
"Don't Goof Up. Research Your Pup!"
"Don't Be A Lurch. Research Your Pup Search!"
"Stop For Me At The Crosswalk Or You're In For A Shock!"
 
Seriously so much of this is propaganda perpetuated by the AR movement. The problem really isn't as bad as they would have you believe and obviously do have you believing.
 
Seriously so much of this is propaganda perpetuated by the AR movement. The problem really isn't as bad as they would have you believe and obviously do have you believing.
If that was in reference to what I wrote:

I'm not feeling or thinking any thing because of AR. It's simply based on observations I've made.
 
Let me ask you this. How often have you learned from other people's mistakes to the point that you avoided making that mistake your self, versus making your own mistakes and learning from them? In other words how many times have you made the same mistake twice in comparison to how often you have repeated mistakes previously made by others? Just saying.
 
So I think you're right. The level of dog knowledge that the average person possesses is not enough.

So how do we educate? I know of a handful of issues about which the public sorely needs to be educated. One being freaking look for, and stop for, people at crosswalks. Pardon me, I walk take my daughter to preschool and folks just intentionally fly on by as we wait there. Okay, I digress. But the point is, how to educate?

I can think of only a few public education campaigns out there:
Give 'Em A Brake.
Don't Drink And Drive.
Just Say No.
Never Shake A Baby.
Have Your Pets Spayed Or Neutered.
Be Kind, Rewind.

How about:
"Don't Goof Up. Research Your Pup!"
"Don't Be A Lurch. Research Your Pup Search!"
"Stop For Me At The Crosswalk Or You're In For A Shock!"

I believe @paintinsthegame is one great example of educating the public with her newest program she is starting up. Even if you can only help in a small way, share what you know far and wide. Forums, a family member, a neighbor, an acquaintance at work, someone you meet at training. Even these small parts can help. I love what Paint is doing and hope to see more campaigns like this big/small...its something!

https://doberman-chat.com/community/threads/the-i-need-a-name-contest.22477/
https://doberman-chat.com/community/threads/i-think-we-are-making-a-difference.21938/
 
Poor, irresponsible breeding, however, I think is the closest thing to the root cause that I can find.

I would agree with your estimation, as this is true of all breeds of any sort of animals.

I can think back to the 70's and early 80's in So. Calif. and remember all sorts of poorly bread Dobermans. It was difficult to find a well bread Dobe back then...for the pet owner that is. I now see many more well bread Dobermans for sale than I did back then. I just think with the media explosion we have today that we are exposed to more photos and whatnot that gives the impression things are getting bad. Hopefully it will not take the same route as it did in the 70's with all the poorly bread Dobermans that were around. This is why education is so important.
 
@Dobs4ever you may find me sad, amusing, confusing or whatever, but it is because you really do not understand my opinion. I was going to write a long discourse trying to explain my position more clearly, but I feel it is of no use.
I do support the standard and all it stands for as an ideal, but it is not Law.

I have accomplished much in my career by maintaining a attitude of "kill them with kindness" and keeping an open mind. This is the position I choose to fight from to maintain my right to C/D my dogs. You may not like it, or understand it, but there it is. I do not ask you to change your position, and to think that is what is being said is a total misperception. It is just my opinion that by not listening to what others have to say, and I do not mean AR folks, that you distance yourself from them and this usually will close the door to positive discourse. None of us here are asking for the standard to be opened and changed.

I truly want to keep C/D for all our dogs, and to think it could be taken away is a thought I do not like. I also believe it has nothing to do with good breeding, as there are a number of great Dobermann lines in Europe that I would import in a heartbeat that have not been C/D for some time now. But I also feel that if a Doberman owner wants to own a dog with natural ears that they should have that right without being put down like an infidel.

I fight for the right to keep C/D -- I just take a different position than you do. Does that make me wrong? I don't think so!
A+ quality post.:thumbsup:
I would agree with your estimation, as this is true of all breeds of any sort of animals.

I can think back to the 70's and early 80's in So. Calif. and remember all sorts of poorly bread Dobermans. It was difficult to find a well bread Dobe back then...for the pet owner that is. I now see many more well bread Dobermans for sale than I did back then. I just think with the media explosion we have today that we are exposed to more photos and whatnot that gives the impression things are getting bad. Hopefully it will not take the same route as it did in the 70's with all the poorly bread Dobermans that were around. This is why education is so important.
i have not educated myself enough on breeding from that time period,but you are probably right.
At the same time,the first Doberman I knew was in the 70s.I was a kid then so I can't remember the form so to speak as far as skull,chest,etc,I do well remember her actions and her sleek appearance and of course those telling pointed ears.
A better example of dog as far as training and loyalty I have yet to meet.
 
Interesting enough I've taken notice of the amount of " attention " the Doberman has had in the last 6 months. I recently saw one on a Lexus Commercial. I've seen more and more in my area which has me concerned in some manner. I've enjoyed being the " only " one around to have Doberman's, I guess. I don't have to worry about another biting someone and giving bad raps around the area, I enjoy the majestic site seeing most give us when we pull into the parking lot. I've also enjoyed " Boy you just don't see Dobermans' around anymore " when we walk into a store. Maybe that's just my selfish side, but it's the way I feel. Less the better I see things as.
 
Interesting enough I've taken notice of the amount of " attention " the Doberman has had in the last 6 months. I recently saw one on a Lexus Commercial. I've seen more and more in my area which has me concerned in some manner. I've enjoyed being the " only " one around to have Doberman's, I guess. I don't have to worry about another biting someone and giving bad raps around the area, I enjoy the majestic site seeing most give us when we pull into the parking lot. I've also enjoyed " Boy you just don't see Dobermans' around anymore " when we walk into a store. Maybe that's just my selfish side, but it's the way I feel. Less the better I see things as.

They have indeed moved up considerably on the list and are akc's 12th most popular breed. https://www.akc.org/reg/dogreg_stats.cfm
[DOUBLEPOST=1423107818][/DOUBLEPOST]When I first got Mars the vet told me that he Was only other doberman he was seeing at the time. Today I see them often even when visiting the vet. As a matter of fact my neighbor around the corner has a pair himself. Actually I believe the male just passed away last summer but his female is still around I'm almost certain of it. As a sidenote though I believe both of those were older than mine.
 
Interesting enough I've taken notice of the amount of " attention " the Doberman has had in the last 6 months. I recently saw one on a Lexus Commercial. I've seen more and more in my area which has me concerned in some manner. I've enjoyed being the " only " one around to have Doberman's, I guess. I don't have to worry about another biting someone and giving bad raps around the area, I enjoy the majestic site seeing most give us when we pull into the parking lot. I've also enjoyed " Boy you just don't see Dobermans' around anymore " when we walk into a store. Maybe that's just my selfish side, but it's the way I feel. Less the better I see things as.
Was the Doberman in the Lexus commercial cropped? I'm just curious. Not a loaded question. :)
 

Back
Top