My Grim, Fearful Prediction

Oh Little Oji

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
It's been concerning me the amount of Dobermans that I've seen around, and in media. Most of them are uncropped, (not to step on any toes here). Most of them don't look well bred.

My concern is that our breed might be heading the direction of some of the other noble breeds such as Great Dane and Boxer.

Cropping falls out of favor, which makes the breed feel more accessible to the general public. Poor breeding practices abound. Shelter Dobes are plenty.

The breed may wind up increasingly in the hands of those looking for a sweet, goofy, fashionable pet. A trendy pet whether these folks realize it or not.

This week at a doctor's office I picked up a business card for a dog walking service. One one side, not surprisingly, a Boxer (actually a pretty decent looking one). On the other side? Yep. A floppy-eared, small, slinky Doberman.BoxerDogWalkCard.webpFlopDobieDogWalkCard.webp
 
As cropping and docking become less and less favorable and unpopular you will see more and more unethical breeders getting into the game. Because it will be far cheaper to raise a Doberman puppy if they do not have to worry about the extra expenses involved in docking the tales, removing the dewclaws and cropping the ears not to mention aftercare. You have to remember that when you're considering a litter of puppies cropping alone can range in the thousand$. If cropping a puppy becomes illegal in the United States then it will be easy to raise a litter of Doberman puppies as it is to raise a litter of pitbull puppies.
 
As cropping and docking become less and less favorable and unpopular you will see more and more unethical breeders getting into the game. Because it will be far cheaper to raise a Doberman puppy if they do not have to worry about the extra expenses involved in docking the tales, removing the dewclaws and cropping the ears not to mention aftercare. You have to remember that when you're considering a litter of puppies cropping alone can range in the thousand$. If cropping a puppy becomes illegal in the United States then it will be easy to raise a litter of Doberman puppies as it is to raise a litter of pitbull puppies.

So true and many have already taken great advantage of this as they charge just much from uncropped/untitled/ untested parents as we charge for quality puppies.
 
I can tell you that the breeder of our current pup (and if you happen to be reading: I love you – you're awesome) is not into C/D. The reason they give is that they may compete internationally in IPO if one of their Dobes reaches that level. Also they're just a fan of the natural look and, I think, the European aspect to it. Also, the rudder effect of the tail was cited.

My pup has his dewclaws :(.

I was going to accept the natural ears, but that changed when the breeder found someone who could do the cropping for less than the $600 or so it was going to be. When that happened, all the buyers of the males opted for cropping.

The tail is docked, but the females in the litter were not.

Not to make this thread necessarily about C/D, just related information.
 
A had a gentleman ask me if it was legal here to do it. He knew it was illegal in other countries


Lisa Mom of 2 human children and 1 furbaby
 
I believe form follows function. Natural Dobermans work well with families. Cropped work very well as working dogs.

The reason you're seeing more natural Dobermans in the news is two fold. First in several parts of the world cropping isn't legal. Second many owners of pet Dobermans don't want a cropped dog.

Theres several people on this forum that feel very strongly about cropping. That's just how they are and they won't change. But they're not the only ones that can breed dogs and the marketplace will go where consumers want it to.
 
I believe form follows function. Natural Dobermans work well with families. Cropped work very well as working dogs.

The reason you're seeing more natural Dobermans in the news is two fold. First in several parts of the world cropping isn't legal. Second many owners of pet Dobermans don't want a cropped dog.

Theres several people on this forum that feel very strongly about cropping. That's just how they are and they won't change. But they're not the only ones that can breed dogs and the marketplace will go where consumers want it to.
I'm compelled to wonder, then, what are the desires and motivations of those who seek out uncropped Dobermans. I understand yours, or at least I understand what is your stated position. I'm not saying I agree with it, but at least you seem like a good Doberman owner. Not that I'm setting myself up as judge; I just love the breed and want it preserved.

So, if the breed is evolving, my point is I hope it doesn't wind up like what I perceive to be the state of the most commonly seen Boxer – a goofy, awkward ineffectual shell of what it once was.

I continue to ask why people want a Doberman if they don't want what it was intended to be.
 
I continue to ask why people want a Doberman if they don't want what it was intended to be.
Your question is a good one. And opens a can of worms. :confused-alt:

I'm not even sure I want to answer it. lol But my stab at an answer is that some people might say they want a Doberman for all the other qualities in a Doberman 'package'. Regardless of C/D being restricted. I've heard it said here on DCF many times over the years.

While that's all well and good and well intended, I come from the 'old school' of Doberman standard. I am appalled that standards on ALL breeds are being torn down and people are letting it happen. I find it a shocking, sad state of affairs and something that I never thought would happen.

As far as I'm concerned, in 20 years there will be no 'breeds' anymore. All dogs will resemble each other. :(

There's your opened can of worms. :biggrin:
[DOUBLEPOST=1422879524,1422879157][/DOUBLEPOST]Oh boy, the next thread I go to really said it all here:
https://doberman-chat.com/community...e-comments-at-the-dog-show.22973/#post-395424
Archer posted my thoughts very well. (post #11)
 
Sad to me that some people think a natural Doberman is like a leper and to be avoided at all costs. I believe this attitude is what turned me from pro crop and dock to neutral. It's almost like being natural is worse than being Z factored. I find the vanity personally sad when I know what a fantastic awesome dog the Doberman truly is on the inside.
 
Sorry, Von. I don't feel they are lepers at all. I just hate the standards are changing for all breeds. What's left if we don't have a standard?
 
Sorry, Von. I don't feel they are lepers at all. I just hate the standards are changing for all breeds. What's left if we don't have a standard?
I dont advocate a standard change. I advocate for choice.. I don't think anyone should be deprived of the greatest companion on earth simply because you believe C/D is mutilation. I think if my neighbor wants a natural doberman he should be able to get one.. Particularly if he has no intentions of competing in any KC events.. I know my opinion isnt popular but i dont hold KC's in high regard.. Just because the Doberman has a moderately healthy standard in comparison to other breeds, (in reality they are not) all breed standards are not created equal so i dont hold the standard in the same regard as some others here.. Its Just my opinion.. I really try not to force it down anyones throat others want to push down my throat.. How is this standard ethical in any way? And why should i regard it as gospel? Show me the ethics in this standard that produces a dog that cant even conceive without a surgery..
Official Standard of the Pug
General Appearance: Symmetry and general appearance are decidedly square and cobby. A lean, leggy Pug and a dog with short legs and a long body are equally objectionable.
Size, Proportion, Substance: The Pug should be multum in parvo, and this condensation (if the word may be used) is shown by compactness of form, well knit proportions, and hardness of developed muscle. Weight from 14 to 18 pounds (dog or bitch) desirable. Proportion square.
Head: The head is large, massive, round - not apple-headed, with no indentation of the skull. The eyesare dark in color, very large, bold and prominent, globular in shape, soft and solicitous in expression, very lustrous, and, when excited, full of fire. The ears are thin, small, soft, like black velvet. There are two kinds - the "rose" and the "button." Preference is given to the latter. The wrinkles are large and deep. The muzzle is short, blunt, square, but not upfaced. Bite - A Pug's bite should be very slightly undershot.
Neck, Topline, Body: The neck is slightly arched. It is strong, thick, and with enough length to carry the head proudly. The short back is level from the withers to the high tail set. The body is short and cobby, wide in chest and well ribbed up. The tail is curled as tightly as possible over the hip. The double curl is perfection.
Forequarters: The legs are very strong, straight, of moderate length, and are set well under. The elbows should be directly under the withers when viewed from the side. The shoulders are moderately laid back. The pasterns are strong, neither steep nor down. The feet are neither so long as the foot of the hare, nor so round as that of the cat; well split-up toes, and the nails black. Dewclaws are generally removed.
Hindquarters: The strong, powerful hindquarters have moderate bend of stifle and short hocks perpendicular to the ground. The legs are parallel when viewed from behind. The hindquarters are in balance with the forequarters. The thighs and buttocks are full and muscular. Feet as in front.
Coat: The coat is fine, smooth, soft, short and glossy, neither hard nor woolly.
Color: The colors are fawn or black. The fawn color should be decided so as to make the contrast complete between the color and the trace and mask.
Markings: The markings are clearly defined. The muzzle or mask, ears, moles on cheeks, thumb mark or diamond on forehead, and the back trace should be as black as possible. The mask should be black. The more intense and well defined it is, the better. The trace is a black line extending from the occiput to the tail.
Gait: Viewed from the front, the forelegs should be carried well forward, showing no weakness in the pasterns, the paws landing squarely with the central toes straight ahead. The rear action should be strong and free through hocks and stifles, with no twisting or turning in or out at the joints. The hind legs should follow in line with the front. There is a slight natural convergence of the limbs both fore and aft. A slight roll of the hindquarters typifies the gait which should be free, self-assured, and jaunty.
Temperament: This is an even-tempered breed, exhibiting stability, playfulness, great charm, dignity, and an outgoing, loving disposition.
Disqualification - Any color other than fawn or black.

Approved April 8, 2008
Effective June 3, 2008
English Bulldogs
English bull dogs are another breed which have been bred to produce an aesthetically pleasing dog. This means that it has suffered in terms of the breed’s health. Many of the problems can be observed in these breeds although there will always be exceptions. All very uncomfortable problems, English bulldogs can experience patellar, elbow and hip dysplasia. Due to the folds of skin around an English bulldog’s muzzle, it can have an infectious disease of the skin known as Muzzle Pyoderma. Additionally, the hair follicles may become infected and this is called folliculitis. Other problems include cherry eye, cleft lip and a condition which leads to ingrown eyelids and thus eye problems. Bulldogs may be prone to mitral valve defects as well as Circulatory Arteriovenous fistula.
Pug
As a short nosed, or flat nosed dog, the pug has been seen to be susceptible to related problems such as an elongated soft palate and having a greater risk of heatstroke. Due to the shape of a pug’s head, their soft palate is relatively longer than those in a normal dog. This can lead to problems with breathing and thus making exercise stressful for the affected animal. The function of the soft palate is to prevent food being swallowed the wrong way and so if it is elongated, swallowing can become difficult leading to what appears to be regurgitation. Pugs can also be affected with hemi vertebrae and Pug Dog Encephalitis.
Some British veterinarians are hoping to see an end to certain breeds of dogs – not pit bulls – but flat-faced ones, because of the respiratory ailments and other health problems they suffer as a result of not having normally elongated faces.

A survey conducted amongst delegates at a Royal Veterinary College conference on the welfare of dogs bred particularly for their “flat-faced” features found that one-fifth of veterinarians believe these breeds should be banned completely. Though no specific breeds were listed on the poll, the most well-known breeds would be boxer, Boston terrier, bulldog, Cavalier King Charles, Pekingese, pug and Shih Tzu.

“There was general agreement that the dog buying public need to put dog health above appearance, whether choosing pure or crossbred dogs,” said Dr. Charlotte Burn. “Our desire for ever more baby-like flat faces and larger eyes is fueling welfare problems in the very animals we love.”

These “brachycephalic” dogs suffer from numerous ailments. They have narrowed nostrils and windpipes, leading to respiratory issues. It can be more difficult for them to cool down in high temperatures and while exercising, because it is harder for them to pant.

Their eyes tend to bulge because of shallow sockets. They do not close properly, and cases have been reported of dogs having their eyeballs pop out if they receive a blow to the back of the head or strain too hard against their leash.

With less room for all of them to fit, many of these dogs have problems with their teeth and jaws. They can also experience infections in their numerous skin folds.

BBC even stopped covering the Crufts dog show, which it had aired for 42 years, because not enough was being done to resolve the health issues for pedigree dogs.

A third of the vets who participated in the survey said a ban on brachycephalic dogs should be introduced unless significant health improvements are made in the next ten years, which would come by breeding such dogs with other breeds.

I highly recommend anyone who believes a breed standard is the end all be all for Dogs should read the following... Rosettes to Ruin:
 
I dont advocate a standard change. I advocate for choice.. I don't think anyone should be deprived of the greatest companion on earth simply because you believe C/D is mutilation. I think if my neighbor wants a natural doberman he should be able to get one.. Particularly if he has no intentions of competing in any KC events..
Exactly!! Then we totally agree. :D That is my point too !

Back in the 'day' (like 30 years ago or more maybe?) Everything was 'ok' on this front. Doberman standard was c/d and it was just a fact. If someone didn't want to do it, so be it. No big deal! I like it this way. You like it that way. And Vets still would crop if one wanted it. No one ever spoke of banning it, or that it was cruel or that the standard should change. If they didn't like it c/d, they just didn't do it and no words were ever exchanged. I love your dog and you love mine! Just a difference of opinion on what we like. But the standard was always the standard.
 
I've been looking to rescue a male dobie around 2-3 years old. What I've learned is that about 90-95% of them are natural and they are some of the poorest bred dogs I've ever seen, in ANY breed! I know most champion breeders don't allow the dog to leave that way, which tells me, more than likely, that these are coming from crap breeders and going to homes where there shouldn't be a Doberman in the first place.

I personally don't really care if someone wants a natural look but We are fighting an uphill battle for C/D so I'd prefer no breeder let a dog leave unC/unD. If you want a Doberman you should also want the look they're known for. Who cares if it looks scary or unwelcoming or w/e it is that you don't like. Like someone else said, by a lab, or a weimaramer, or a hound or something.

I do know that my trainer says they've been seeing more and more Dobermans, they're making a come back and most of them are unC/unD. .
 
I know most champion breeders don't allow the dog to leave that way, which tells me, more than likely, that these are coming from crap breeders and going to homes where there shouldn't be a Doberman in the first place.
I wonder how the other 3/4 of the worlds population feels about their natural Dobermanns being called crap bred dogs. People tend to forget the world isnt comprised of the USA solely.. as a matter of fact the C/D standard will be the Minority Defecto Doberman standard, if it isnt already.
 
One of the many problems of pet Dobermans in the US is that most of the pet owners do not want to take the time to learn how to post the ears correctly, they want the easy way of ownership, and do not want to have to deal with the ears possibably not standing correctly. They also do not want to spend what a correctly bred Doberman will cost. They want a Doberman without the responsibility of all that goes with the Doberman standard.

I do feel that "choice" is important in the C/D issue, but not at the loss of quality breeding. Poorly bred non-C/D Dobermans beget more of the same, and the whole "look" of the dog is degraded as a whole. And I also feel that if C/D is banned that the breed will suffer in the long term, as the standard Doberman "look of eagles" will be lost, and that "Doberman image" is one of the major traits that made the breed what it is today.

A natural born Doberman is fine to own as a personal choice, but the C/D Doberman will always stand out in the crowd and should remain a choice of those that wish to choose to continue with the standard. Thus, the standard should not be changed for any reason.
 
I wonder how the other 3/4 of the worlds population feels about their natural Dobermanns being called crap bred dogs. People tend to forget the world isnt comprised of the USA solely.. as a matter of fact the C/D standard will be the Minority Defecto Doberman standard, if it isnt already.

I wasn't saying they all were crap bred. I was saying the ones in the rescues, most of who were natural, appeared to be crap bred. There are some very good breeders who will allow for natural.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422894075][/DOUBLEPOST]@Dobie Wan Knobie said much better what I was trying to say :thumbsup2:
 
I wasn't saying they all were crap bred. I was saying the ones in the rescues, most of who were natural, appeared to be crap bred. There are some very good breeders who will allow for natural.
[DOUBLEPOST=1422894075][/DOUBLEPOST]@Dobie Wan Knobie said much better what I was trying to say :thumbsup2:
Fair enough.. But wouldnt that be typical? who goes to a breeder, pound or rescue and asks for the poorest example af a breed to take home.. I would assume it be fairly obvious why a rescue would be stuck with the worst of the worst. What i do find interesting is that most people are leaning towards natural dogs nowadays because of the AR agenda convincing Joe Schmo that Clipping ears is cruel and unusual.. but rescues still to this day find it more difficult to rehome natural Dobermans. Which leads me to believe @Dobie Wan Knobie is on to something.
 
I'm compelled to wonder, then, what are the desires and motivations of those who seek out uncropped Dobermans.
I can tell you my "reasons" for having them.
Ignorance.Plain and simple.
I didn't "seek" an uncropped dog but bought one,had she been cropped from the breeder I would have bought her anyways.
Now,my reason for not getting her done,ignorance.
It was my thought process she would be better off with natural ears considering the type of terrain and foliage we walk in with dogs,very high,foxtails,etc.I never even considered the "my neighbors will be scared of her with cropped ears" aspect,in fact I would prefer that.
The old saying good fences make good neighbors is amplified by good fence with pointy eared dog behind it.;)
 

Back
Top