Whining... Oh the whining..

Dragonborn

Hot Topics Subscriber
Hi guys. So I could really use some helpful advice about our constant problem.

Hemi's persistent whining & temper tantrums are driving me a little bonkers because I don't know what I need to do.

Hemi gets up in the mornings (sometimes very early-6am) and I take her to go poo & pee and I go back to bed. She can handle about an extra 15 minutes of being in her crate in the mornings, but then all hell breaks loose so to speak.

She constantly whines, screams, howls, digs her crates bottom pan to get out. I don't understand her behavior. I don't abuse the crate because she's hardly in it during the day. We exercise for at least about two hours before bed time so this isn't energy related.

I don't let her out when she has these tantrums until she's quiet & I am not exaggerating that I have had to wait 3 hours for her to stop.

I truly don't understand her because she willingly goes into her crate at night without me even asking her so I don't think it's because she hates it.

Any advice? We've been doing this same thing every single day for two months straight.
 
Usually a dog that is good with the crate only behaves shows this behavior if they have to go so are you sure she did both jobs outside? If she did it is also possible that she goes in 2 segments and now that she is back in the crate the urge has hit. If that is not the problem. I would set a schedule Regardless of when SHE gets up you set the time you will get up. Let her have her fit and don't get up to accommodate her. She is doing the training right now.

To start be sure no food after 5 pm and no water after 7 pm. Then take her out about 10 pm for final duty. What time do you want to get up and stay up??? That is the time I would then get up and let her out and when she comes back in she is not right back in the crate. I think she is trying to tell you NO I SAID LET"S GET UP. They are very very smart.
 
I agree that if she's old enough to make it through the night I'd leave her in there until you're ready to get up, then feed her and take her out, then leave her out for some play time. We're used to getting up so early that it's rarely a problem for ours to want to get up or go out until we get up, but it's all the routine they get used to.
 
I went through something very similar with Archer as a puppy. With him it ended up that the crate wasn't the issue. It was where we were keeping it. It has been in the dog room, but once we moved it to our bedroom he quieted down and went to sleep. He just wanted to be closer to us. Makes sense as he is über velcro. His kennel is now back in the dog room and he sleeps in bed with us :)

Do you use special kennel toys for her. It also helped Archer to give him frozen PB Kongs.
 
oh dear lord can i relate.. But its Kali and its different.. I swear the whining she does when she waiting on me to get dressed in the morning is like fingernails on a chalkboard.. I just wanna throttle her.. of course i never do or would i but OMG i can feel my blood pressure rise each and every morning and i just hate starting my days that way.. I also found chucking a slipper at the kennel does little to keep her quiet. ;)
 
oh dear lord can i relate.. I also found chucking a slipper at the kennel does little to keep her quiet. ;)
Amen PREACH :p! Boris is sitting on the floor whining right this minute because he wants breakfast and I am typing lol. It takes time to teach the "Hush". My two sleep in the other room so their demanding is fruitless when I am asleep, James goes to work very early so he lets them out and then puts them back to bed until I wake up. They are downstairs so I can't hear them unless Boris gets to howling which he occasionally enjoys doing when especially wants to annoy me. Just stand your ground and tell them to hush and it will stop eventually as they get older. It was a real problem for us the first year or so but now they get tired of me and go get in their kennel on their own. Do you cover their kennel?
 
We are having the same issue plus bed destroying. Now after letting them out at the crack of dawn to potty, we then put her back in her cage with a kong stuffed with either peanut butter or a frozen mix of tuna and dog food. So far life is good.
 
We are having the same issue plus bed destroying. Now after letting them out at the crack of dawn to potty, we then put her back in her cage with a kong stuffed with either peanut butter or a frozen mix of tuna and dog food. So far life is good.

Kuranda.. The last dog bed you will ever need.. if you have an XL wire crate the Kuranda will fit right inside it if you get the right size bed.
Kuranda-Dog-Chew-Proof-Bed.webp
I put mine in the crate without the legs and put a blanked underneath of it for padding.. This was for Mars since he ate everything in his crate at night.. this put an immediate end to that.. Except now hes trying to lick his way through the vinyl. ;) http://kuranda.com/
 
Last edited by a moderator:
@Dragonborn

What would happen if after you let her out for her morning business you just left the crate open?
Would she settle down?
Try to jump in bed with you?
Destroy the house?

Our male,if he wants or needs something he just barks.As close to my head as he can,then sits,then barks again and stares at me expecting me to read his mind.
Daisy,she whines.She only does it if there's something or some one she can't get to...Velcro issues;)
For instance,yesterday,deconstructing the Christmas lights.I was out front up and down the ladder,can't correct a dog or contain off leash in the yard from 8 feet up so they were left inside.
She whined,yelped,and dang her blues song the whole time.
Walk inside and she's done.
Same noises she makes when a ball or toy rolls under something and she can't get it.She parks herself at the cabinet or what ever and whines.
Hemi wants something,maybe like the others have said she's not done doing her business,maybe she wants to run off some energy(don't under estimate the energy of a young dog;)),maybe she just wants to cuddle:)
Try leaving the crate open one time to see what she does with a little freedom to express herself.
 
@Dragonborn

What would happen if after you let her out for her morning business you just left the crate open?
Would she settle down?
Try to jump in bed with you?
Destroy the house?

Our male,if he wants or needs something he just barks.As close to my head as he can,then sits,then barks again and stares at me expecting me to read his mind.
Daisy,she whines.She only does it if there's something or some one she can't get to...Velcro issues;)
For instance,yesterday,deconstructing the Christmas lights.I was out front up and down the ladder,can't correct a dog or contain off leash in the yard from 8 feet up so they were left inside.
She whined,yelped,and dang her blues song the whole time.
Walk inside and she's done.
Same noises she makes when a ball or toy rolls under something and she can't get it.She parks herself at the cabinet or what ever and whines.
Hemi wants something,maybe like the others have said she's not done doing her business,maybe she wants to run off some energy(don't under estimate the energy of a young dog;)),maybe she just wants to cuddle:)
Try leaving the crate open one time to see what she does with a little freedom to express herself.
Hemi gets up very early to potty. I don't want her to get used to the fact that I give in to every one of her requests. She has to get used to handling being in there after she wakes up. I'm harsh I guess, but shes getting more dominant as she gets older so I have to put my foot down. She goes poos & pees every morning. I thought maybe she needed something as well & that's why she was whining. But when I take her back out, she just plays. She's not hungry either because she barely eats right when she gets up.
 
She constantly whines, screams, howls, digs her crates bottom pan to get out. I don't understand her behavior. I don't abuse the crate because she's hardly in it during the day. We exercise for at least about two hours before bed time so this isn't energy related.
Actually in reading this again i was reminded of Daemon who could not be crated.. He has literally chewed his way through them and dug his way under them to get out.. and the behavior was exactly as you described in the piece i quoted above.. Sadly if thats the case your gonna have to figure out something different.. Apparently Daemon was just claustrophobic and had some very real and intense meltdowns in their.. THis made crating and rotating between Mars and Daemon a nightmare.. But to be clear Daemon never behaved in a crate day or night there was something about them that his mind just couldn't handle.. Ive always kind of blamed the Importing process from Slovenia, God only knows how he was treated on a flight with layovers that took a better part of the entire day..
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Whining, barking etc are the beginning of them learning to train you. You set the schedule of when you give attention and when they are to be calm. If you give attention even negativie it is attention and gives them more courage to persist louder. It is a good way to make them needy and Dobermans should be confident not weak. JMHO

Make sure she gets lots of outside activities - trips to town and different places to challenge and build confidence.
 
Kris can spend hours in her crate in my Van when I am travelling somewhere. The only time she whines is the minute I head down the short road to the Fairgrounds. She seems to be able to tell no matter what way I come and whines and carries on as she knows she is going to have a run and go to the Arena for training. I do make her stop before I let her out. The only time she does it in her crate at home is when she has to go out. She puts herself to bed in it at night and I just go and close her crate before I go to bed and she sleeps till morning.
 
because she's hardly in it during the day.

Believe it or not, I think this may be your problem. Short training sessions of being in the crate during the day can be good for her. Just for a few minutes or however long it takes for her to be quiet, then treat and release. Abbey would do the same so I spent the day over at my parents and we did crate mini sessions so she could learn that her being quiet = let out. The repetition and short periods definitely helped.
 
We are going through a similar problem. Ours is 5.5 monte old now and has been a chronic crate whiner/barker/howler.

I will think on this and maybe have something to add after I do a little work around the house.
 
Our puppy is in and of his crate all day long and it definitely helps. He recently started getting grumpy when I would put him in. Our trainer had me throw some highly loved treats in there. I was using shredded chicken. Now when he sees the treats he runs right to his crate.


Lisa Mom of 2 human children and 1 furbaby
 
I have encountered this before...so I know where you are coming from and it does seem like hell sometimes. :( Here is what I did. Maybe it will help you, maybe not. I use an airliner crate with both my dogs, not sure which type you use. I picked a time during the day when we could practice using the crate and I wouldn't be tired in the morning or at night for the training session. I put an electronic shock collar on my dog and put him in the crate. I turned it up a bit more than normal because I was not training obedience for the ring, but rather wanted to knock out a behavior issue. I said nothing and put him in, shut the door, and went just out of sight with the remote for the collar. As SOON as the whining started I zapped him good with the collar and said firmly (not yelling) "no quiet". The first time I did this with him there were several zaps in a row that needed to be given because the whining did not stop and sometimes a temper tantrum insued also. To punish the temper tantrums I would pull him out of the cage by his scruff and pin him to the floor and say NO in a growly voice into his muzzle and stay on top of him till he relaxed. Then I would put him back in the crate and start all over again. These temper tantrums and whining fits have to be my biggest pet peeve (besides adult dogs going to the bathroom in the house) so I try to knock it out the quickest way I know how. I took about a week of this and we are only occasionally whining or barking in the crate. But one zap and then it's quiet for several hours.
 
I have had two years no with mine, what I find is my militant repetitious demands seem to work the best. Training them is a 24/7 job much like an small child. People are always amazed at their behavior and obedience and want to credit it with the breed and for much of it it is the breed but the response is the training, my dogs are not allowed to wander the house, they have beds they lay on in the open room, they are given commands for everything from meal time to pee time, they have to earn treats and can only have one toy at a time, I never use toys for bribes, they are never given scraps or allowed to beg, get on the furniture uninvited, behave aggressive towards one another or people. We don't make barking at a noise a game, they are with me or in the kennels or outside playing. tie out has been a valuable tool. They are too smart to treat like ignorant animals but they require great discipline in all areas or you will find things that you can't control again much like a small child. During the winter when they are in the house for the most part they lay down for a nap in the afternoon for 2-3 hours. They eat at the exact same time each day everything you would do to build routine with children so they are confident in the world they live in, mine do not run out the door or run in when it is open, they have to sit at the door and wait for a command, now that it is so cold when they are ready to come in they sit and wait at the door when they have done heir business, we haven't had an accident in over a year, when the cover goes down on the crate they are asleep because they know when my feet hit the floor they are out for their morning pee and breakfast. I am not saying all this to blow my horn I am saying it is possible for a novice like myself to train a good obedient doberman that is mannerly and well adjusted to your life. Repetition is the key. For the crate it is like a child that doesn't want to sleep in its crib just put them in cover the crate and tell them to hush, if you go take them out just like the child in the crib they will continue to use it to get your attention, just keep doing it and they will learn that kennel is sleepy time and after a bit they will run right in and go to sleep, it may take a week or two but you will train them with patience and time and tenacity. I have had some great teachers here on DC over the years so listen to their advice and work work work your pup will get there.
 

Back
Top