Let me share some of my experiences with our current male pup in hopes it can help.
Our pup, best I can tell so far, hates to be confined when he doesn't want to. That may sound like a "duh" but he is quite content to be crated at night for sleep. He walks up there and cruises right into the crate. In fact a couple times I've left the baby gate open as I got ready and he snuck upstairs into his crate by himself. FYI this is a plastic airline-type crate.
However, in the wire crate we have downstairs which we use for all other crating needs, he acts up. It is getting better, thank God.
I say he hates being confined: He whines and barks when tied out on the porch (we don't do it for long periods). He also does the same when I have had him ride in a child's trailer behind my bicycle for trips to the store, etc. Lest you think he is scared of the ride, he actually goes and jumps in the trailer when he's around it. The barking and carrying on is due to his hatred of being confined, or maybe I should say restrained.
Now, let's talk about his big gun in this war: Peeing in the crate. Fortunately, he has only pooed in the crate a few times – seems to have out grown that fairly quickly, and well, if he doesn't really have to poo and doesn't have diarrhea he won't crate poo. But pee, oh yes. He also pees on the porch when tied there. So, the wonderful thing that is the crate – the thing that affords a frustrated puppy owner a little time and space to blow off steam, well, he sort of takes that away with the pottying.
Bear in mind also that there is no place in our house, including the basement, where we can't clearly hear his carrying on. So it's been difficult.
So I wonder if some dogs like the more sheltered feel of an airline crate? On the other hand, some dogs may be claustrophobic.
One thing that has helped is our putting some items (plastic storage tubs) in the big wire crate to make his space smaller, more sheltered-feeling and of course the theory is dogs don't like to soil their space, so it takes away room for him to mess the other end of the crate.
Also: I agree with the thoughts here that it is good to give a lot of exposure to crate time. I don't mean extended stays in the crate. Rather, many short exposures. We crate our pup every time we leave the house. Sometimes that is only for 15 minutes. You get the idea.
Someone here mentioned an electronic collar, and pinning their dog to the floor for carrying on in the crate. I would just say I hope the dog really understands why they're receiving the corrections. I have a theory that often dogs don't realize they're whining. I started a thread about that here a while ago. Now the more pronounced fits of barking, scratching etc. they probably realize they're doing, however, it may be that they're not in a very lucid state of mind during them.
It will get better. If your pup isn't pottying in the crate, be thankful! If your pup isn't destroying your crate be thankful! I'm thankful for that last one.
Finally, you be in charge. Try not to let them dictate what happens or when. My pup has adapted very quickly to my schedule of sleep. He was able to hold it through the night very quickly. Maybe it's just this particular pup, but I basically won't take no for an answer either. Make sure you don't jump through hoops for them.
Our pup, best I can tell so far, hates to be confined when he doesn't want to. That may sound like a "duh" but he is quite content to be crated at night for sleep. He walks up there and cruises right into the crate. In fact a couple times I've left the baby gate open as I got ready and he snuck upstairs into his crate by himself. FYI this is a plastic airline-type crate.
However, in the wire crate we have downstairs which we use for all other crating needs, he acts up. It is getting better, thank God.
I say he hates being confined: He whines and barks when tied out on the porch (we don't do it for long periods). He also does the same when I have had him ride in a child's trailer behind my bicycle for trips to the store, etc. Lest you think he is scared of the ride, he actually goes and jumps in the trailer when he's around it. The barking and carrying on is due to his hatred of being confined, or maybe I should say restrained.
Now, let's talk about his big gun in this war: Peeing in the crate. Fortunately, he has only pooed in the crate a few times – seems to have out grown that fairly quickly, and well, if he doesn't really have to poo and doesn't have diarrhea he won't crate poo. But pee, oh yes. He also pees on the porch when tied there. So, the wonderful thing that is the crate – the thing that affords a frustrated puppy owner a little time and space to blow off steam, well, he sort of takes that away with the pottying.
Bear in mind also that there is no place in our house, including the basement, where we can't clearly hear his carrying on. So it's been difficult.
So I wonder if some dogs like the more sheltered feel of an airline crate? On the other hand, some dogs may be claustrophobic.
One thing that has helped is our putting some items (plastic storage tubs) in the big wire crate to make his space smaller, more sheltered-feeling and of course the theory is dogs don't like to soil their space, so it takes away room for him to mess the other end of the crate.
Also: I agree with the thoughts here that it is good to give a lot of exposure to crate time. I don't mean extended stays in the crate. Rather, many short exposures. We crate our pup every time we leave the house. Sometimes that is only for 15 minutes. You get the idea.
Someone here mentioned an electronic collar, and pinning their dog to the floor for carrying on in the crate. I would just say I hope the dog really understands why they're receiving the corrections. I have a theory that often dogs don't realize they're whining. I started a thread about that here a while ago. Now the more pronounced fits of barking, scratching etc. they probably realize they're doing, however, it may be that they're not in a very lucid state of mind during them.
It will get better. If your pup isn't pottying in the crate, be thankful! If your pup isn't destroying your crate be thankful! I'm thankful for that last one.
Finally, you be in charge. Try not to let them dictate what happens or when. My pup has adapted very quickly to my schedule of sleep. He was able to hold it through the night very quickly. Maybe it's just this particular pup, but I basically won't take no for an answer either. Make sure you don't jump through hoops for them.


Here is what I did. Maybe it will help you, maybe not. I use an airliner crate with both my dogs, not sure which type you use. I picked a time during the day when we could practice using the crate and I wouldn't be tired in the morning or at night for the training session. I put an electronic shock collar on my dog and put him in the crate. I turned it up a bit more than normal because I was not training obedience for the ring, but rather wanted to knock out a behavior issue. I said nothing and put him in, shut the door, and went just out of sight with the remote for the collar. As SOON as the whining started I zapped him good with the collar and said firmly (not yelling) "no quiet". The first time I did this with him there were several zaps in a row that needed to be given because the whining did not stop and sometimes a temper tantrum insued also. To punish the temper tantrums I would pull him out of the cage by his scruff and pin him to the floor and say NO in a growly voice into his muzzle and stay on top of him till he relaxed. Then I would put him back in the crate and start all over again. These temper tantrums and whining fits have to be my biggest pet peeve (besides adult dogs going to the bathroom in the house) so I try to knock it out the quickest way I know how. I took about a week of this and we are only occasionally whining or barking in the crate. But one zap and then it's quiet for several hours.

But that doesn't mean I let him get away with whining at me. Usually a "Quiet" gets him to lay down and in a few moments I will do something with him. I don't reward his 'demand' but it never leaves my mind. I realize he needs something. Even if it's attention.
.
Zapping them or banging on the crate does nothing but create fear.
)