I'm sorry but this is not something I will budge on.
If any dog is aggressive to his handler then that is extremely undesirable. No matter the circumstances. I'm not talking about confused reactive nips. I'm talking about dogs who bite and attack.
So by your definition of a "sharp" dog I personally feel there is no need for this type of dog in any situation.
That dog bit his handler and would not let go. It's unacceptable. No other way to put it.
I also don't see why this has anything to
Do with AR groups at all. Please don't associate me with them, you know I am completely against that thought process, and I am a little offended you would even make that association to me. I also don't see how my constitutional right to own a gun has anything to do with a dog that is handler aggressive.
This has to do with the advocating with out of control dogs, and it's disgusting to be honest.
If anything promoting these dogs just gives more fuel to an already blazing AR fire. Because to any average person watching that video it is considered unacceptable no matter what adjective we use for what's happening.
I feel there is more to a sharp dog than handler aggression, and i personally believe that has nothing to do with a sharp dog, and if it does that word needs to be abolished from the bite sport dictionary.
That's my stance, and I'm not budging. But believe me, if there were a realistic setting where these dog were appropriate I would be all for it. The simple fact is that this is not the case. I have no biased opinion towards the sport and this is just my feedback. Take it or leave it.
I understand that you have your stance and refuse to budge on your "perceived Ideals" and that is your right.
But let me ask you a few very simple questions. Now you state with an absolute certainty that there is no place for these type of dogs in ANY situation. You stated that its unacceptable. You state that handler aggression in absolutely not acceptable and dogs with that trait need to be eliminated from any bite sport dictionary.
My question is very simple.
Have you ever been in any single one of the situations that I have spoken of personally???
Have you ever been in national or world level bite sport competition?
Have you ever been in law enforcement?
Have you ever worked one on one with a Law enforcement K9?
Have you ever been a Military working dog Handler?
Have you ever worked one on one with a Military working dog?
Have you ever been in a shootout, or firefight?
Have you ever been on a team that went in and took out terrorist targets?
Have you ever been on a team that takes down bad guys?
Have you ever spent any time whatsoever with any of these people and these types of dogs in any of the above mentioned scenarios?
If you cant answer an absolute yes to these atleast three of these questions, then you dont have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general, much less these types of dogs, to be able to make a knowledge based statement like what you have said.
What you are doing is giving a general opinion on what you think personally, without having any real understanding of what it is your talking about and that is your right, but I will guarantee you that if you ask any of the types of people I have mentioned above in my questions that have worked with and put their lives on the line with one of these types of dogs, I think you would get a very different answer than what your John Q Public opinion is.
Please dont take any of this as negative or belittling it is not meant that way at all. It is a simple to the point concise set of questions and statements that are intended to make you and others think a bit more before putting your foot down on a subject you dont truly have the experience to understand.