• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?


  • Total voters
    16
That's my stance, and I'm not budging. But believe me, if there were a realistic setting where these dog were appropriate I would be all for it. The simple fact is that this is not the case. I have no biased opinion towards the sport and this is just my feedback. Take it or leave it.

To us pet owners dabbling in dog sports perhaps these dogs are overkill especially in novices hands but there are definitely realistic scenarios where these dogs excel, as has been mentioned, military dogs for one where a dogs quick decisive confident action could possibly save soldiers lives. Dogs that will fulfil it's training in the field regardless of the extreme pressure they may be under, where a soldier has to trust his own life with his dog.... you can forgive the occasional bite if you have confidence that your dog may save your life when the going gets really tough...

I would imagine that if a less sharp dog that didn't eat it's handler could do the work equally as good, the military wouldn't spend money breeding for and training these ultra sharp dogs. I would think that the military have very different much more serious requirements than pet owners or dog sport participants.
 
So by your definition of a "sharp" dog I personally feel there is no need for this type of dog in any situation.

That dog bit his handler and would not let go. It's unacceptable. No other way to put it.

Wow take it or leave it are you going hostile on us??? - CRD you have not completely understood all the things posted about Sharp- In one post I said that dog aggression and handler aggression are two very useless parts of some dogs. I stated that we preferred to breed out the handler aggression but not loose the sharp temperament. But that does not mean that these dogs don't or can't have a place in the right hands.

I see no difference in a person like yourself having and AK47 or M16 etc than a person who does not mind working with a very sharp dog. If he could find a dog that was all he wanted without the handler aggression great but you usually don't necessarily know that until the dog has started to mature and you have a ton of training in this dog. Often times it is the foundation training that makes it all work. I am not speaking of people like you and me owning these dogs and you are only speaking from yourself and limited knowledge of working dogs at this point.

Both the guns and the dogs are considered very very dangeorus in the wrong hands and that is why the breeders who breed for those groups are very limited and primarily breed JUST for the military or police dogs groups.. Just look at the useless legislation just passed on owning guns. But I will bet you my bottom dollar it will not stop the next movie or school shooting.

What it has to do with AR groups is they are against ALL dog sports of any kind. Sometimes the great danger is in trying to control ony the part you want to control and that is how they work. IT is very dangerous to side with them on anything as then you put all at risk even if you are not on their side. The NRA guys have understood this for years and they organized and have up to this point successfully kept your right to own any gun you want.

We have to celbrate what these dogs bring to the table just as we celebrate what the guns bring but does not mean they are for everyone. But the minute you start to think on the AR side you put ALL dogs in jeporady Dog people can't afford to separate into working vs showing because in the end it will not keep our dogs safe and the AR groups know this and lay patiently in the wings to pounce.

Dobermans are a working breed and trying to hide it and make it a marshmellow won't change the image and that they will soon be gone from the face of the earth if they are deemed not suitable for working.

One of the biggest blows to our dogs was when the DPCA broke away from the working side of our dogs and fell in line with the path to try to appease people who don't care to understand dogs at all.

Again it is not the dogs that are the problem it is the people who own them. It is not the guns that kill but the people who hold them. It is the same argument that will protect both our rights to bear arms and own working dogs.

I don't know how it got so confused as no one has said that handler aggression is a desired part of all sharp dogs but it does sometimes come with the territory in varying degrees and they will challenge you more than certainly a pet dog would.

You have taken one thing and focused on it as the only part of the dog.

I will use Gunner as an example - Gunner was the most socialble dog - loved kids seemed to have a instinct that he had to be gentle with them but at about 18 months he came right up that leash to let me know he did not have to do what was asked of him at that moment. He taught me respect in about 2 seconds flat. I actually had 3 squirmishes with him -nothing near the level of Matrix or police dogs but he was darn serious and he made me get serious real quick. I wish you had known him becaue you would not believe it but look at the awesome dog he became because I understood it was nothing personal. Once the battle was over finally he became the most awesome dog I have ever had the pleasure of being on the end of the leash. Viper in fact was a harder dog than Gunner but Viper never came at me but he did go after my hubby once when hubby did a really dumb thing. Viper was my dog and tolerated Jerry and Jerry pushed his buttons. Viper made it pretty clear to him he would not do that again and so Jerry got bit. I told him not to dare touch my dog he asked for it and Viper did not back down.

As stated there are many facets to the term sharpness and if the dog is totally uncontrollable then that dog needs to be put down but if he is controlable then you have an awesome working and and need to understand for the dogs there is nothing personal about it. We as people want to make it all personal and get all bent out of shape.
 
Suzan you as well as I know you can not read tone over the Internet. One could go crazy trying so please don't insinuate I'm going "hostile". I can assure you I am just as interested in this as everyone else.

I won't always agree with you, but that's what makes a debate, a debate. So lets attempt not to make this personal anymore. I have clearly stated in a previous posts there is nothing personal about what I am saying. I just wholeheartedly disagree with it.

You missed one solid thing about guns....they don't turn around and shoot you in the face.

I am focusing on the handler aggression because according to those whom are explaining this that is part of what defines a "sharp" dog, which is what this thread is all about .

There are many things about this dog that I like. The handler aggression is enough for me to completely disagree with painting a positive light on a sharp dog. Since that apparently is part of what defines one.

If you want to breed out the handler aggression in a sharp dog would that still make a "sharp" dog?

So what would be the word that describes a "sharp" dog without the handler aggression. Since we can all agree that this is extremely undesirable as you have stated in your prior posts.

That is a major flaw in this dog. Not one to be ignored. Are we saying that we cant get these same results without the dog attacking the handler?

I'm also not going any further into the AR nonsense it is so incredibly off topic and I believe it has nothing to do with what defines a "sharp dog". I'm not AR so I ask again please don't compare me to that.
 
So what would be the word that describes a "sharp" dog without the handler aggression. Since we can all agree that this is extremely undesirable as you have stated in your prior posts.

Are my posts not being read? sigh... it's been mentioned before by myself, Susan and overs that there are several degrees of sharpness, read my post here for example. The desired level of sharpness in the Korung is a medium sharpness with a very quick recovery, similar language to the US Doberman breed standard. The FCI Dobe standard 'In dobermann we look for a medium temperament, a medium aggressiveness and a fair tolerance before reaction'...' has good working ability thanks to its decisiveness, braveness and strong temperament. Its self-confidence and its intrepidness are also required considering that this breed is very alert toward its surroundings and reactive toward all kind of events.'
 
Are my posts not being read? sigh... it's been mentioned before by myself, Susan and overs that there are several degrees of sharpness, read my post here for example. The desired level of sharpness in the Korung is a medium sharpness with a very quick recovery, similar language to the US Doberman breed standard.

Good info Marko, didn't see that post. Thank you.
 
I'm sorry but this is not something I will budge on.

If any dog is aggressive to his handler then that is extremely undesirable. No matter the circumstances. I'm not talking about confused reactive nips. I'm talking about dogs who bite and attack.

So by your definition of a "sharp" dog I personally feel there is no need for this type of dog in any situation.

That dog bit his handler and would not let go. It's unacceptable. No other way to put it.

I also don't see why this has anything to
Do with AR groups at all. Please don't associate me with them, you know I am completely against that thought process, and I am a little offended you would even make that association to me. I also don't see how my constitutional right to own a gun has anything to do with a dog that is handler aggressive.

This has to do with the advocating with out of control dogs, and it's disgusting to be honest.

If anything promoting these dogs just gives more fuel to an already blazing AR fire. Because to any average person watching that video it is considered unacceptable no matter what adjective we use for what's happening.

I feel there is more to a sharp dog than handler aggression, and i personally believe that has nothing to do with a sharp dog, and if it does that word needs to be abolished from the bite sport dictionary.

That's my stance, and I'm not budging. But believe me, if there were a realistic setting where these dog were appropriate I would be all for it. The simple fact is that this is not the case. I have no biased opinion towards the sport and this is just my feedback. Take it or leave it.

I understand that you have your stance and refuse to budge on your "perceived Ideals" and that is your right.
But let me ask you a few very simple questions. Now you state with an absolute certainty that there is no place for these type of dogs in ANY situation. You stated that its unacceptable. You state that handler aggression in absolutely not acceptable and dogs with that trait need to be eliminated from any bite sport dictionary.
My question is very simple.

Have you ever been in any single one of the situations that I have spoken of personally???
Have you ever been in national or world level bite sport competition?
Have you ever been in law enforcement?
Have you ever worked one on one with a Law enforcement K9?
Have you ever been a Military working dog Handler?
Have you ever worked one on one with a Military working dog?
Have you ever been in a shootout, or firefight?
Have you ever been on a team that went in and took out terrorist targets?
Have you ever been on a team that takes down bad guys?
Have you ever spent any time whatsoever with any of these people and these types of dogs in any of the above mentioned scenarios?

If you cant answer an absolute yes to these atleast three of these questions, then you dont have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general, much less these types of dogs, to be able to make a knowledge based statement like what you have said.

What you are doing is giving a general opinion on what you think personally, without having any real understanding of what it is your talking about and that is your right, but I will guarantee you that if you ask any of the types of people I have mentioned above in my questions that have worked with and put their lives on the line with one of these types of dogs, I think you would get a very different answer than what your John Q Public opinion is.

Please dont take any of this as negative or belittling it is not meant that way at all. It is a simple to the point concise set of questions and statements that are intended to make you and others think a bit more before putting your foot down on a subject you dont truly have the experience to understand.
 
Is it not true that in a military dog's working lifetime they may go through multiple handlers? Could that be a factor in why the dog was so quick to bite and hold on to the handler so long? There are too many questions to judge the dog on the small amount of video seen. Perhaps the current handler had been a decoy at one time, so in the heat of the moment it was game on!

Just trying to see it from all angles.:)
Tammy
 
My question is very simple.

Have you ever been in any single one of the situations that I have spoken of personally???
Have you ever been in national or world level bite sport competition?
Have you ever been in law enforcement?
Have you ever worked one on one with a Law enforcement K9?
Have you ever been a Military working dog Handler?
Have you ever worked one on one with a Military working dog?
Have you ever been in a shootout, or firefight?
Have you ever been on a team that went in and took out terrorist targets?
Have you ever been on a team that takes down bad guys?
Have you ever spent any time whatsoever with any of these people and these types of dogs in any of the above mentioned scenarios?

If you cant answer an absolute yes to these atleast three of these questions, then you dont have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general,

That's pretty harsh :)

And as D4E "likes" that statement, I can only assume by your list that 99% of the people she sells to don't "have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general" but hey if it sells.....

All I got from your sharp Dobe was dominance/ handler issues - anyways I don't want to go on as this forum is a friendly forum with lots of friendly members...but please drop this holier than thou attitude of unless your dog caught Bin Ladin you don't know much.

And I still don't get what AR and gun control have to do with anything but it's your show :)
 
Marko at what point on that scale do you feel a dog could be an extremely great asset to a k9 team, but be able to react accordingly or recover as you say.

Those are the dogs I would love to see videos of.
 
That's pretty harsh :)

And as D4E "likes" that statement, I can only assume by your list that 99% of the people she sells to don't "have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general" but hey if it sells.....

All I got from your sharp Dobe was dominance/ handler issues - anyways I don't want to go on as this forum is a friendly forum with lots of friendly members...but please drop this holier than thou attitude of unless your dog caught Bin Ladin you don't know much.

And I still don't get what AR and gun control have to do with anything but it's your show :)
I liked it too,Sammy,and I tell you why.Like CRD has said,it's hard to gauge one's tone through the keys.So,I read it with an open mind.He did close with a note about not trying to sound belittling.
I keep in mind here he's very experienced (much more than me)with this level of working dog.Like I also said in an earlier post,a professional.As with any topic,be it plumbing questions,auto finish,wood working,you name it,there are skills and knowhow people gain from doing it every day.Trying to explain all the ins and outs of anything like this doesn't happen in a few paragraphs.
He hit some good examples there most of us can't imagine unless we have been there.

I'm keeping an open mind and trying to absorb as much as I can.
 
That's pretty harsh :)

And as D4E "likes" that statement, I can only assume by your list that 99% of the people she sells to don't "have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general" but hey if it sells.....

All I got from your sharp Dobe was dominance/ handler issues - anyways I don't want to go on as this forum is a friendly forum with lots of friendly members...but please drop this holier than thou attitude of unless your dog caught Bin Ladin you don't know much.

And I still don't get what AR and gun control have to do with anything but it's your show :)
Sammy,
actually it wasnt intended at all to be harsh, and since you lose the ability to inflect tone and vocal patterns through internet postings, I can see why it could seem as though it is and why I stated it was not meant to be.

The entire series of questions has nothing to do with a holier than thou attitude, the questions are to show that those are the types of people who work with, train, and handle these types of dogs, and there is absolutely a place in the world for them. Now that is not in a pet home, and it isnt even in 90% of working homes. But they do have a place.

As for D4E, she doesnt breed sharp dogs, her dogs are actually very well balanced, they are truly a pairing of form and function, as her dogs have great conformation and have the working apptitude that is inherent in the Doberman breed. I know this because I have seen many of her dogs up close and personal as I have taught several K9 seminars with her club, and have worked with her personal dogs, and the results of her breedings as well. She is a big advocate for balance in the breed and I believe she works tirelessly to achieve exactly that. I can also say, she is one of the pickiest breeders I have ever known when it comes to "selling" a puppy to someone. Its more like a CIA background check and security clearance to have one of her dogs.

As for AR and gun control, I can only think she is stating how they both are bodies that want to take something away from the public, whether that is by breed specific legislation, or by the new feinstein gun control laws that our government is attempting to put into place.

Now I have to say this, I do not in any way have a, as you put it, " holier than thou attitude of unless your dog caught Bin Ladin you don't know much".
I was simply trying to convey to my friend and fellow staff member CRD, who happens to be new to the bite sport world, and the world of working dogs in general, exactly in what situations and what avenues these types of dogs are used for and why they are bred. Nothing more and nothing less, I have the utmost respect for my friend CRD and we have even talked off this thread to be sure anything we said was not taken wrong by the other, and we both know that it is a discussion and a chance to help create more education on the subject of working dogs in the world.

I hope this clarifies some of the statements for you, and I apologize if you or anyone else took any of it incorrectly, or to be negative.
 
And as D4E "likes" that statement, I can only assume by your list that 99% of the people she sells to don't "have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general" but hey if it sells.....

Sammy since you know nothing about me I will take that as a personal slam but I can tell you I will stand soundly on my reputation as a breeder, handler and trainer and the wonderful families that share my passion and dogs and I would appreciate it if you left my families out of it as they were never part of this discussion and you certainly know nothing about them except for the ones on this list. Thank you for the insight.

We were discussing "sharpness" in a dog and now it has gone personal and some have their feathers ruffled. The point is if you have never worked a dog that came at you you would not and do not understand that for the dogs it is not personal at all. It survival, drives and instinct. I like how Dale put it because it reminds me of the old Indian saying - Unless you have walked in a mans moccisans 3 moons you don't know his inner thoughts and why he does what he does. Unfortunatley we can't walk in a dogs paws for 3 months. We have to try to understand with our very limited human reasoning but when we let our emotions rule we loose all rational thought and understanding of what is being said.

It is no different from the people who shout guns are bad are mostly the same people who shout a working dog is bad. We tend to fear and want to eliminate what we don't understand. Dale and I are not advocating ALL dobermans should be sharp we just say there is a time and a place and it is not for us to judge who has the right to work and own one anymore than anyone has the right to say you can't own a gun. I will say and you might have missed it that as breeders we have to know what we are doing. Working them gives us a lot of insight to help us make the right placement so we can make all that money Sammy - and spend countless hours trying to help educate a public that has lost most of its touch and understanding with/of nature and animals.

I
 
I'm really busy with Jala right now guys, but I watched the video Dale and I really like how that dog is working. More detailed post to follow tonight.

I understood what your meaning behind it was, and I did not take offense to it. They were all true statements, and I am new to this type of training, and everyone involved with bite sports. My questions are merely to understand all of this and why it is appropriate. More to follow on that though.
 
I hope this clarifies some of the statements for you, and I apologize if you or anyone else took any of it incorrectly, or to be negative.

I was going to post earlier but couldn't log in (not because I'd been banned it seems :D) - no need to apologize at all and certainly we're here to learn things ...water under the bridge and let's keep going forward :)

And D4E, without going back, what I meant was the irony of a statement....if you look at the context again, you'll see what I mean ;) I don't do personal :)

Anyway, enough of me being a distraction and let's keep this thread moving :martini:
 
And as D4E "likes" that statement, I can only assume by your list that 99% of the people she sells to don't "have the knowledge or understanding of dogs in general" but hey if it sells.....




Completely uncalled for. I am someone she sold a puppy to. I may not have had ALL the knowledge and still don't but she knew I was willing to learn. Hence, I am here trying to learn from this thread. I totally respect D4E breeding skills and opinion on this subject as well as Pitts. These 2 people are probably the most knowledgeable about this subject on this forum so could we stop this nonsense of making unsubstantiated comments and get back to the topic.
 
Marko at what point on that scale do you feel a dog could be an extremely great asset to a k9 team, but be able to react accordingly or recover as you say.

Those are the dogs I would love to see videos of.

Sorry the forum has been down for me for the last day, don't know if it affected everyone or just a few, judging from this continued thread I'd say just a few...

As regards your question about K9 units I can't really answer that but I'd think that depends on what the K9 unit was put together for, a domestic K9 unit may not want a really sharp dog in say a crowd control situation whereas a military K9 who are basically training 'war dogs' may do. I'm like you in experience when it comes to this topic, with limited experience, experience gleaned from a years worth of Schutzhund participation and observation and what I've learned from reading about this sort of stuff. The people who have real world experience, the likes of Dale are the ones that who have far more insight than I.

I'm going to trawl YouTube and try and find examples of dogs that I think show a dog that can recover quickly but I think that all I will find are dogs in Schutzhund etc. ;)
 
Completely uncalled for. I am someone she sold a puppy to. I may not have had ALL the knowledge and still don't but she knew I was willing to learn. Hence, I am here trying to learn from this thread. I totally respect D4E breeding skills and opinion on this subject as well as Pitts. These 2 people are probably the most knowledgeable about this subject on this forum so could we stop this nonsense of making unsubstantiated comments and get back to the topic.

It's OK PTG, Sammy and D4E are sorting this out for themselves, I know you are defending her as a personal friend would, but lets not take this thread away from the educational discussion we were having and get it locked ;)
 

Back
Top