• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?


  • Total voters
    16
D4E I was going by what the United States Police Canine Association was saying; obviously you know better - please excuse :)
The USPCAK9 is actually a similar to schutzhund as it is an organization that holds trials for the sport aspect of police K9 work, and is not a governing body for actual police canines.
D4E is correct in her statements, and yes today a sharp dog is not seen as often, and usually a sharp dog is not even known when seen, as they are usually in the hands of a good handler who is aware of the dogs "markers" and can control and redirect the dog as needed to create what they want from the dog.

I can show you countless videos of sharp dogs used in military and police work that during work or training they bite the handler, this is many times out of frustration or due to their fight drives being over the top, and so they grab the closest thing they can and that is their own handler. It happens all the time, but these same dogs can be seen being overly affectionate and loving to their handler once the work is over. It is just an aspect of working canines.

here is one of those funny caption pics showing exactly this.
nipples_zps017c480a.jpg
 
I would define a "sharp" dog as one who can tie his own shoes! LOL, sorry bad humor I guess!
 
I saw sharp dogs trained with a dominant dog collar. When dogs become submissive to a trainer they are pleasure to watch but going though an initial stage... omg... that's too much to handle!
Thanks Dale for your great description of a sharp dog and videos. That's amazing results of your training.

Crow instable dog is a dog with weak nerves. They are not trainable. Most of those dogs are dangerous.
 
I hear sharp being referred to a dog I think of intelligence not a dog that flys off the handle.

CRD that is part of what makes the dogs so misunderstood. If you don't have a strong knowledge of "Dog" people language or slang then you relate words to what you have known them to mean outside the dog world. But belive you me it does not apply to what dog poeple call "sharp".

Unstable comes from weakness - weak nerves, lack of confidence, unsure, fear etc. are all examples of unstable. A sharp dog is very clear about how he feels about things and you just need to know how to deal with it and work with it to survive. An unstable dog is almost impossible to work with because it is ruled by fear and insecurity and finds it difficult to perform or move forward. Hence unstable. I would see it as almost the opposite of sharp. That is why you can't have sharps shyness - shyness again comes from the fear driven dog not the over confident "sharp" dog.
 
Another valid question.....
At what point is a dog considered unstable, and not "sharp"
According to the explanations I heard I hear a lot more instability than sharpness.
You know several days ago I would have thought the same.The explination given by some here sounded like a dog just hell bent on making something bleed.
I had to stop and evaluate my position.I am not a dog pro,nor a handler of military or police dogs,people like Pitts are.I realise his is an opinion,but it is a professional opinion.I came to the understanding he and Suzan know more than I do about this,so I just read,learn,and try to understand.
It's become pretty clear the "sharp" dog is much different than most,and not something for everyone.In fact,it's for very few.Like they have both said,a sharp dog in the hands of someone who knows the dog,and is keen to it's markers is a great thing.In the hands of someone like me and most JQP(who don't know S#!T about this kind of dog) it could(probably) end not so good for someone and the dog.
So,I will jump out now,and continue reading and learning.
 
CRD that is part of what makes the dogs so misunderstood. If you don't have a strong knowledge of "Dog" people language or slang then you relate words to what you have known them to mean outside the dog world. But belive you me it does not apply to what dog poeple call "sharp".

Unstable comes from weakness - weak nerves, lack of confidence, unsure, fear etc. are all examples of unstable. A sharp dog is very clear about how he feels about things and you just need to know how to deal with it and work with it to survive. An unstable dog is almost impossible to work with because it is ruled by fear and insecurity and finds it difficult to perform or move forward. Hence unstable. I would see it as almost the opposite of sharp. That is why you can't have sharps shyness - shyness again comes from the fear driven dog not the over confident "sharp" dog.

Be that as it may. Explain why there would ever be a need for a dog to be bred that has the chance that it will bite his handler/owner. That could not be more unstable to me.

I get the words are different in the "bite" sport world. Just like they are in conformation. But using those words in their actual place in the world most people would define a dog turning on its owner/handler as an unstable dog, and definitely not one to be bred.

I think the wording in itself was poorly chosen.
 
You know several days ago I would have thought the same.The explination given by some here sounded like a dog just hell bent on making something bleed.
I had to stop and evaluate my position.I am not a dog pro,nor a handler of military or police dogs,people like Pitts are.I realise his is an opinion,but it is a professional opinion.I came to the understanding he and Suzan know more than I do about this,so I just read,learn,and try to understand.
It's become pretty clear the "sharp" dog is much different than most,and not something for everyone.In fact,it's for very few.Like they have both said,a sharp dog in the hands of someone who knows the dog,and is keen to it's markers is a great thing.In the hands of someone like me and most JQP(who don't know S#!T about this kind of dog) it could(probably) end not so good for someone and the dog.
So,I will jump out now,and continue reading and learning.

I'm just trying to fully understand why there is even a need for these "sharp" Dobermans anymore. If next to no one can handle them then why would we paint a positive light on a "sharp" dog.
 
I'm just trying to fully understand why there is even a need for these "sharp" Dobermans anymore. If next to no one can handle them then why would we paint a positive light on a "sharp" dog.
Well,speculation on my part.In an intense military scenario,I would want the sharpest dog I could get.Same would go for police work(not a beat cop,talking swat scenario here),we wouldn't want a dog to hesitate for even a fraction of a second.Like Pitts explained,the dog is such a state of focus,its mouth is in overdrive.God help the sob that dog gets turned loose on.
 
CRD you are asking such good questons and very valid. As a breeder I do not want to breed a "sharp" dog. BUT with some of the poor temperaments we have today a sharp dog can fit very well into a breeding program as a way to bring back more fight drive and defense drive. Then you pick a nice med sharp dog out of the litter and continue to breed on that.

You want to keep the confidence, alertness and assertiveness in while eliminating the handler aggression. While we talk about sharpness we have to understand that there are different facets of sharp and two things I would love to see bred out for all time is handler aggression and dog aggression. Neither are drives that are that productive. But sometimes you can't have one without the other so it is always a roll of the dice.

A doberman above all is suppose to be a balanced dog in conformation, square, angulation etc and balanced in working drives. A sharp dog tips the scales too far one way but can easily be used to bring more drives in to puppies proudced if you have the right bitch and understand what you are trying to accomplish.

That is exactly how we bred the "sharpness" out. Now as working breeders we strive to bring a little more back without tipping the scales to far. But a doberman should never be like a golden retriever temperament. That is just as incorrect as an overly sharp dog.
 
The only answer I have for why we try to paint a positive light on a sharp dog is that they are dogs - and we forget that in today's AR driven world where we wand everything fluffy fluffy and nothing bad ever happens. As Gel said if I was in combat situtation I would want the most bad A.... dog out there where there was no doubt he would rather die than surrender or show fear.

We need those dogs as the true working dog and keeping that spirit alive in the dogs. As of today we have way too many with weaker temperaments and can't even do basic bite sport work. I believe in our dogs as working dogs and is one reason I set out to learn as much about it as possible and I found out how little I really new or understood about dobermans and their make up. Just becaue a dog is a good couch potato is a far cry from being a good working temperament and since the Doberman is a working breed that has to be important.
 
Don't forget guys that there are different levels of sharpness. Looking at Korung, under Sharpness and Aggression there are 6 levels of grading

Desirability, in descending order with 1) being the most desirable and 3) being the least desirable, you get more points for 1), less points for 3)

1) Moderate without remaining aggression

2) Great without remaining aggression

3) Less without remaining aggression

Undesirability, in descending order with 4) being undesirable and 6) being the most undesirable, you get points deducted, less point deducted for 4), more points deducted for 6)

4) Insignificant without remaining aggression

5) Moderate with remaining aggression

6) Great with remaining aggression

Hope this all makes sense.
 
CRD you are asking such good questons and very valid. As a breeder I do not want to breed a "sharp" dog. BUT with some of the poor temperaments we have today a sharp dog can fit very well into a breeding program as a way to bring back more fight drive and defense drive. Then you pick a nice med sharp dog out of the litter and continue to breed on that.

You want to keep the confidence, alertness and assertiveness in while eliminating the handler aggression. While we talk about sharpness we have to understand that there are different facets of sharp and two things I would love to see bred out for all time is handler aggression and dog aggression. Neither are drives that are that productive. But sometimes you can't have one without the other so it is always a roll of the dice.

A doberman above all is suppose to be a balanced dog in conformation, square, angulation etc and balanced in working drives. A sharp dog tips the scales too far one way but can easily be used to bring more drives in to puppies proudced if you have the right bitch and understand what you are trying to accomplish.

That is exactly how we bred the "sharpness" out. Now as working breeders we strive to bring a little more back without tipping the scales to far. But a doberman should never be like a golden retriever temperament. That is just as incorrect as an overly sharp dog.

This is exactly what I was looking for, excellent information. Thank you.
 
I agree that our police officers and soldiers need the highest level of dog. The real question is does our government provide enough training to teach someone how to handle a dog of this magnitude?
 
Great info Marko and is exactly what I meant about the different facets. No dog fits squarely into the hole due to the different levels and facets of sharpness that exist in each dog.

It all depends on how the dog reacts to the ensuing correction - how does the dog respond - and does the dog beocme more manageable, if he remains aggressie then that would be very undesirable.

We having been brainwashed by the AR folks have come to the conclusion ANY dog that growls, barks or moves forward is DANGEROUS and they love to label a dog as such. But it is out of lack of knowledge of "DOGS" and they try to impose human thoughts and rationale on animals. I have always believed that the old myth that a doberman will turn on you stems from this misunderstanding when the dog becomes of age and decides it will now rule and either growls and/or nips the person and puts them in their place lower on the totem pole. It is always a people problem with the exception of unstable dogs with poor temperaments.

Probably one of the biggest reasons that the Euro fad by people who have never worked or titled a dog and the BYB who know nothing are so dangeous when they breed. They don't KNOW and put the wrong dog in the wrong hands. Look at Dale's Matrix - rehomed 4 times - I have seen him work in person - he is a great dog - but the breeder did not know what they had and placed him wrong which caused the dog even more problems and things escalated from there. In the right hands he is a fun dog to watch perform because he is clear about the rules and who will win the ultimate battle. I am sure he is far less challenging to Dale now but still as Dale stated you have to always be prepared to step up with this kind of dog. You can't let your guard down and misread the dog. The dog has his own rules and he doesn't always share them with us.

To add: Yes the military, police and Schutzhund trainers know how to work with and train these dogs. It is why I never tell anyone to go to a dog physocologist or any old trainer if they have a problem. They need to go to the folks who understand a working breed. The average dog phychologist or fluff trainer will say put this dog down because they don't know how to handle them.
 
This is a great video of very sharp dogs being used in military and police applications. This is a training exercise with an eastern european anti terrorist unit. watch this dog work but watch at around 44 seconds and you will see exactly what we have been talking about.
 
Probably one of the biggest reasons that the Euro fad by people who have never worked or titled a dog and the BYB who know nothing are so dangeous when they breed. They don't KNOW and put the wrong dog in the wrong hands. Look at Dale's Matrix - rehomed 4 times - I have seen him work in person - he is a great dog - but the breeder did not know what they had and placed him wrong which caused the dog even more problems and things escalated from there. In the right hands he is a fun dog to watch perform because he is clear about the rules and who will win the ultimate battle. I am sure he is far less challenging to Dale now but still as Dale stated you have to always be prepared to step up with this kind of dog. You can't let your guard down and misread the dog. The dog has his own rules and he doesn't always share them with us.

This was perfectly stated Susan.
 

Back
Top