• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?

How would you define a 'sharp' dog?


  • Total voters
    16

Marko1962

Hot Topics Subscriber
I was wondering how people define a sharp dog? Sharp is a word I use to define one of my dogs based on 'my' understanding rightly or wrongly on what sharpness means in a dog. I also understand that other people may view 'sharpness' differently than I do so using a simple poll I'd like you to share your thoughts.

So to start us off, I'd like to share my understanding of a sharp dog. It is that of a dog that has a low threshold to perceived threats and will react NOT out of fear but out of confidence and strength and will willingly, forwardly, engage the threat in a hostile manner.

Others may view a sharp dog as a dog that has a low threshold and acts aggressively out of fear from a perceived threat. Others may think differently.

Other questions I'd like you to ask yourselves. Based upon your understanding of a sharp dog, would you like to own one? if you work your dogs in Schutzhund or ring sports do you see it as a desirable or undesirable trait? If you regard your dog as a 'pet' would you want to see sharpness in your dog? Should sharpness be a desirable or undesirable trait in the Dobermann?

Discuss, I'd like to hear your thoughts on the subject but perhaps firstly we should discuss how you define 'sharpness' so we are all on the same wavelength or it could get confusing very quickly.
 
So to start us off, I'd like to share my understanding of a sharp dog. It is that of a dog that has a low threshold to perceived threats and will react NOT out of fear but out of confidence and strength and will willingly, forwardly, engage the threat in a hostile manner.
This is how mine reacts,sort of.I wouldn't say "hostile" per say,but a definite attitude of not willing to back down,with slow,forward movement,very focused,intense barking.From what I have seen several times there was no fear,this is in the case of an intruder in her space.The gas man,a couple of times,and me,behind the gate when she didn't know it was me.She knew someone was there,and opening that gate.The wind was coming from her back so she couldn't smell me.She lit out with barking,and slow movement towards me,with bursts of barks in between her steps forward.She showed zero interest in running away or backing off in any way but was cautious not to just come in guns blazing,so to speak.

In another case,I had her at work with me.The shop was empty except for me and her.I was told we would have the place to ourselves for the day.We had been there several hours,when 2 guys came.They were people I know and work with,I didn't hear them come,but she did.The bigger guy opened a man door to come in,he made it 2 steps inside,hand stil on the door knob when he see's Daisy running at him full speed barking her butt off.He managed to back out and close the door before she slid into it.I leashed her up and let them in,and let her smell their hands.Of the 2,she took an instant liking to the other guy,(a white guy who has dogs) and continued to growl at the bigger guy(a Mexican guy who has no dogs).He accused her of just not liking Mexicans,I reminded him she had met his brother just 3 weeks before and liked him just fine and all the girls in the upolstery shop too(all Mexican women),Jose the wood cutter,and Leve the janitorial girl,and Juan in the paint shop.I said"she's fine with Mexicans,she just doesn't like you):)

If she's afraid of something she avoids it,and fortunatly has never been "cornered" for her to turn from flight to fight.
 
Interesting question. I also think of a sharp dog who reacts aggressively to a perceived threat not out of fear. Isn't that what the WAE test measures for Dobermans? I want a doberman that would pass the WAE test and act aggressively toward a threat while friendly to strangers. I think this shows stability, so yes, desirable.

I think a fearful dog is much more dangerous than a confident protective one. A confident dog backs down fast after the threat is neutralized while a fearful dog's fears are still heightened and likely to attack unwarranted.
 
In a positive sense and the term I would use to describe Eva (from what I gather reading your posts), I would define sharp as your second definition. I checked "other" as well though, because I believe that your definition not clear enough. I would add to the end of that sentence that the dog has a heightened perception of threat (and reacts more quickly toward a perceived threat).

If a dog responds aggressively out of fear, I would call that dog a fear biter, and while it is technically sharp, that would be overly sharp and obviously also the result of having weak nerves.

Now to your other questions:

1) I currently own one (of the positive type) and I also previously owned an overly sharp fear biter that I had to put down.

2) I think it could help in the sport. For example, we haven't started training formally in protection yet (only the obedience part for the BH and some informal bitework the last time), but Ashra immediately took to barking at the helper when he hid behind the blinds.

3) I think that a certain amount of sharpness is a good thing. I prefer having dog with a medium level of sharpness and I look for that specifically when choosing a puppy (they should be alerting by barking and growling at strangers coming to the door by the time they are 10-11 weeks old, in my opinion). Reason being that I live in dodgy areas and travel a lot by myself cheaply/to other dodgy areas/at night. One other thing that is related which I believe is absolutely essential with a sharp dog is an on/off switch.

4) In the FCI standard, in the temperament section it is written "medium temperament and medium sharpness (alertness) is desired". In the ANKC standard (which I believe is the same as the UK's for the most part), correct temperament is described as "bold and alert".
 
Ataro, thats what I'm looking for, other peoples idea of sharpness perhaps different or more defined than mine, it's all educational ;)
 
Ataro I agree with your fuller definition and this is also my observation with my dog.

OK my slightly amended more descriptive definition of a sharp dog - It is that of a dog that has a low threshold to perceived threats that is easily and quickly triggered, also has a heightened perception of threats and will react NOT out of fear but out of confidence and strength and will willingly, forwardly, engage the threat in a hostile manner.
 
I think I've already said somewhere in one of your threads that Eva sounds a lot like Ashra. As mentioned, I like this level of sharpness, but I think a higher level could be quite stressful to deal with.
 
Your definitions #1 and #2 fit more to aggressiveness. Aggressiveness and sharpenss are two different things to me.

I would define sharp dog based on drive (prey and defense) and nerves.

A dog with weak prey drive would never get a good defense drive either.
You can see good defense drive in a dog that being threatened and begins to bark seriously, stands its ground, moves towards unfamiliar things. Other dogs may get stressed and show signs of avoidance and take a step back or hide behind the owner.

Some dogs can have strong drives but weak nerves. I would not consider them as sharp dogs either.
 
My preference is a dog with moderate drive and strong nerves. We don't have enough Schutzhund clubs in the area to train our dogs. A high drive dog without work is a disaster.
Definitely a good drive is fun and it's good for OB training too... but when dogs become defensive and bark at people or fight with other dogs or chase bikes/wildlife that's not fun at all.
 
After reading Rits link... It seems I got confused with a fight drive and sharpness.
I heard so many times that soft dogs are not good for protection training. Cindy has a different opinion :scratch:

What is "fine" dog then? One of trainers in Schutzhund club told that Asha is a fine dog after a short evaluation.
 
I found this over on Schutzhund Village by Armin Winkler regarding 'Sharpness' which in parts is in line with my definition (bold mine)

Sharpness

Sharpness is probably the most incorrectly used term in English dog terminology. I may be wrong here, but I thought the word sharpness was a translation of the German term "Schärfe." But the use of the term sharpness is very much a contradiction of the German term. In every conversation I have, people use sharpness synonymous with spooky or jumpy or nervy. But the word "Schärfe" in German texts is actually defined as being synonymous with aggression. So there certainly is a great discrepancy between the uses of the word.
The type of aggression that is talked about when the term sharpness is used seems to vary depending on the designed use of the dog. For example, in big game hunting dogs and terriers it refers particularly to the intensity and attitude with which these hunting dogs kill their respective prey. It is not prey drive as such; it is the actual killing response that is assessed. I have heard the term "gameness" used in the US in a similar context. For the large game hunting dogs the word used is "Wildschärfe," which translates as game sharpness. This assessment is made best when observing how the dog deals with wild boars. Because of the "bringing down" requirement in this type of hunting many of the dogs of these breeds use physical dominance techniques.
For terriers the term is "Raubzeugschärfe," which translates as small predator sharpness. Terriers are used to hunt and kill small predators such as martens, foxes, badgers, etc. It is no easy feat to kill these predators without suffering injury. So a particularly fast and furious shaking technique is very common, as is a chomping bite behavior. These types of sharpness categorize the dog's prey drive.
Now to the term that we should be most interested in for our service dogs. The term used here is "Mannschärfe," which translates into man sharpness. The definition of this quality states the following. The quality in the dog that leads him to actively confront any apparent, feigned, or actual threat from a person in a hostile manner. If I were to use terminology I have already discussed in this article I would say that sharpness could be equated to showing an active defense reaction to a real or perceived threat.
I did a fair bit of research and could not find anything written that stated that this quality has to come together with a low stimulation threshold for threat. So in fact how easily a dog is triggered does not seem to be a factor by definition. But to be fair, when I was growing up, the dogs we called sharp were the ones that would become very aggressive without much provocation. One thing that I never thought of when I used the term sharp was spooking away. In the old East German Koerung system, sharpness was rated from 0-5 with 5 being the most desirable. So when did sharpness become a bad thing? I don't know. I don't think it is a bad thing.
 
I suppose sharpness became a bad thing when a lot of Dobes lost the correct temperament for protection training. The image of today's Dobermann has taken a 180 and as such, it is now common to see people freaking out and thinking something is wrong when their Dobe shows any form of aggression. As much as they like the idea of having an intimidating dog (which is mostly just visual), there are many who are of the opinion that a Dobe should do nothing more than alert, which is pretty much what any dog of any size can do.
 
The original dogs that were bred by Herr Dobermann were very sharp. If you messed with them at all and did anything they did not like they bit and they mean it.

Sharp does not apply to a fear biter. Sharp comes from a hard core defense drive that takes no guff and is ready to back it up. Don't mess with me attitude. A fear biter bites only when cornered and has no were else to run so weak nerves, lack of confidence and stability would be applicable terms.
 
I also agree that the defense drive is not like it should be. We have clearly lost focus of that, and you can see it in so many dogs.

We have a lot of dogs that will bark up a storm but when push comes to shove won't act on it.

I would have loved to see some of the Dobermans from the early 70s as it seems that was the end of their prime.
 
I dont agree with the Leerburg definition at all. My opinion is that a "sharp" dog is a dog that is alert and aware of everything that is going on. I dont feel it has anything to do with fear or weak nerves!
Isis is a sharp dog. Nothing gets by her that she doesnt notice. Her ears are always up. But I also don't consider her "aggressive". I look at the term "Aggressive" as being a negative thing.
I have socialized her with people extensively. So to her she thinks of people and kids as being fun. I have no doubt that she will be great in protection though because she has zero fear of people and is always ready for a game of chase and tug!
That is just how I understand these terms. :)
 
I also agree that the defense drive is not like it should be. We have clearly lost focus of that, and you can see it in so many dogs.

We have a lot of dogs that will bark up a storm but when push comes to shove won't act on it.

I would have loved to see some of the Dobermans from the early 70s as it seems that was the end of their prime.

My two Dobermans are too defensive for my liking... and I have some issues with that. They bark at people when they find them suspicious or if people come too close without my invitation. They would act if I don't stop them.
I know Dobermans are protective breed and my two work as a great security system :)... but it's better not to have a sharp dog as a pet.... and it's much easier.
 
I think there is a difference between defensive barking and anxious barking and many times people can't tell the difference. A sharp dog to me is not an anxious one.
 
I dont agree with the Leerburg definition at all. My opinion is that a "sharp" dog is a dog that is alert and aware of everything that is going on. I dont feel it has anything to do with fear or weak nerves!

As you say this is your opinion on 'sharpness' in a dog and I respect that but I feel that what you describe is that of the characteristics of a good watch dog or alert dog. Sharpness to me denotes all that you say plus a willingness to confront head on with boldness any perceived threat.

Isis is a sharp dog. Nothing gets by her that she doesnt notice. Her ears are always up. But I also don't consider her "aggressive". I look at the term "Aggressive" as being a negative thing.
I have socialized her with people extensively. So to her she thinks of people and kids as being fun. I have no doubt that she will be great in protection though because she has zero fear of people and is always ready for a game of chase and tug!
That is just how I understand these terms. :)

I think that aggressiveness is integral with that of a 'sharp' dog acting upon a threat. A sharp dog in order to react to a threat must show aggressiveness through barking or growling or both and perhaps advancing towards the threat, he shows he is willing to react to the threat by showing an aggressive attitude. As regards it being viewed as a negative or positive thing I should imagine it would depend upon what a person wants with a dog. If a person wants a dog that will protect then aggressiveness would be definitely needed and would therefore be regarded as a positive but if all a person wants is a pure watch/alert dog, then I can understand aggressiveness being regarded as unwanted or a negative.

I also think that Dobermanns should naturally have a degree of sharpness in them; not over the top wanting to take on the world but rather having the skills learnt through proper socialisation, genetics and good training to be able to make good judgement calls when dealing with the big bad world and what needs protecting against.
 
I see that there are many different definitions of what people call sharp in a dog. When I hear the word sharp used, to me it means, on the ball or showing intellegence. So a sharp dog must show the ability to carry out its handlers wishes with no hesitation or fear while showing complete confidence in its work, alert and ready at all times.
 

Back
Top