• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

But I also don't think that titles are necessarily indicative of the quality of the animal.

In fact, I think it's mostly indicative of the skill and dedication of its trainers and handlers, it's their drive that makes the biggest difference. Unfortunately, the work someone has put into an animal means very little in terms of the potential animal's offspring. Every animal is "pet grade" when it is in pet-grade hands.

I disagree whole-heatedly.

Try making that argument to someone who gets a "pet". From a sire and dam both titled in schutzhund. That dog will have more drive then he knows what to do with. The same goes for conformation, but In a slightly different way. They are bred closely to the standard. Nasty poor examples of the breed do not get titled. Showing conformation is evaluation of breeding stock. This shows the quality of that dog or bitch. Puppy evaluation is extremely important. I could not imagine someone wanting a pet getting an incredibly drivey dog.


I got my pups from excellent lines with them being graded as "pet" quality.

When my boy matured I realized he was an excellent example of the breed and I wanted to show him. It was in his blood. He matured into the quality of his parents.

My girl was also graded pet quality. She has loads of drive, and is extremely focused in obedience.

There are do many things to take in to account with breedings. I think chalking every dog up as pet quality in a pet home is a complete falsification.

If qualities are not inherited why don't we just breed with only health in mind, since the owners can make any dog in to what they want it to be?
 
I don't begrudge anyone what they want to do with their time. But I also don't think that titles are necessarily indicative of the quality of the animal.

I'm not a breeder. Therefore the standards I would be concerned with if I were a breeder (which I'm not), and which I would like to see in a breeder, do not apply to me, as I am the purchaser of a pet.

Kalora Carry-on gen X
Kalora Carry-on work in progress ?
Kalora Casey & Lyric
Kalora Halo & Eragon Litter
Kalora Lyric & Casey
Kalora's A Bewitching Kiss
Kalora's Allakazam v Fabert
Kalora's Andromeda v Alisaton
Kalora's Angel's Serenade
Kalora's As Good As Gold
Kalora's As Good As It Gets
Kalora's Bada Bing v Cheriden
Kalora's Better Believe It
Kalora's Bettin' On a Dream
Kalora's Bettin' On Faith
Kalora's Blue Me A Kiss
Kalora's Blue Me Away
Kalora's Boldly Black
Kalora's Breathless
Kalora's Brilliant Black
Kalora's Causing a Commotion
Kalora's City Of Angels
Kalora's Cool Blue Nirvana
Kalora's Cool Daddy Diesel
Kalora's Decadent Soldier
Kalora's Diamond Dallas Page
Kalora's Dragon Slayer
Kalora's Eragon & Brea
Kalora's Fallen Angel
Kalora's Gabin DbleD v Cheriden
Kalora's Genesis v Devonquest
Kalora's Have Mercy v Cheriden
Kalora's Heavenly One
Kalora's Hitman Heart
Kalora's Holy Moly v Cheriden
Kalora's Hotter Than Hades
Kalora's Hubba Hubba v Cheriden
Kalora's I'm A New York Delight
Kalora's I'm A Supermodel
Kalora's I'm Gonna Be A Legend
Kalora's I'm One Of The Boys
Kalora's I'm Palisade Of Snoq
Kalora's I'm The Charmed One
Kalora's I'm The Jewel Of India
Kalora's I'm The Negotiator
Kalora's Immortal Angel
Kalora's Infatuation v Dabney
Kalora's Inspiration v Dabney
Kalora's Irresistible v Dabney
Kalora's Kiss And Tell Carry On
Kalora's Krimzen Dragon
Kalora's Latin Desire
Kalora's Latin Lover
Kalora's Latin Obsession
Kalora's Latin Sensation
Kalora's Latin Temptation
Kalora's Maximus B Kissable
Kalora's Mystic Smoke
Kalora's N the Zone v Cheriden
Kalora's Ooh La La v Cheriden
Kalora's Positively Priceless
Kalora's Raising a Ruckus
Kalora's Royal Dream v Cheriden
Kalora's Royal Queen v Cheriden
Kalora's Royal Vixen v Cheriden
Kalora's Sensational Sheri
Kalora's Sheer Indulgence Dabney
Kalora's Some Kinda Wonderful
Kalora's Spoiled Bratz v Cheriden
Kalora's Stone Cold
Kalora's Sweet Success
Kalora's Too Good To Be True
Kalora's Total Intoxication Dabney
Kalora's Unbelievable v Highbred
Kalora's Undeniably Dabney
Kalora's Unforgettable
Kalora's UnMistakable
Kalora's Unstoppable
Kalora's Vava Voom v Cheriden
Kalora's Wicked Cherry Wheat
Kalora's Wicked Crimson Voodoo
Kalora's Wicked Maple Porter
Kalora's Wicked Mardi Gras
Kalora's Wicked Razberry Brew
Kalora's Wicked Strawberry
Kalora's Wicked Winter Brew

From the web site Koloradobermans.com
xpected Co-bred Litters Out Of Kalora dogs & Bitches !
Health testing results can be found on the OFA Website
"Andie" Kissy and Hope's dam is show above with the Doberman Standard overlayed on her photo.

We will be co-breeding this litter with Kathy & Jay Gregory (Hope's owners).
Litter will be futurity nominated ~ vWD Carriers ~ No Dilution
SORRY THIS BREEDING DID NOT TAKE !
Sire:BISS Ravenswoods Azure Sky DPCA AOM Winner "Blue"
Dam:Multi BOB Winner CH Kalora's Blue Me Away WAC "Hope"

Litter futurity nominated ~ vWD Carriers Only ~ All four colors expected
Puppies Due August 2nd
Co-bred litter with Chris Hertling "Phoenix's owner"
Sire and dam are champion producers
Sire: BISS Am./Can. CH.Tallyesyn Falcon's Fire "Phoenix"
Dam: Kalora's Blue Me A Kiss "Kissy"

Kalora's Litterbox
kaloradobermans.com/litterbox.html
KALORA'S LITTERBOX. Breeding for the standard. Image above of. Group Winning/Multi BOB Winner Ch Kalora's Andromeda V Alis

From DPCA breeder referral at DPCA.org

New York
(Farmingville) KALORA DOBERMANS *AKC Reg.
Estelle Corr and Keith Corr (631) 451-7337
[email protected]
www.kaloradobermans.com

Estelle then how did all these puppies end up with your kennel name and bred to titled dogs???? This info is on Dobequest BTW and you paid to be listed as a breeder in the DPCA breeder referral program. Can you please clarify.
 
I disagree whole-heatedly.

Try making that argument to someone who gets a "pet". From a sire and dam both titled in schutzhund. That dog will have more drive then he knows what to do with. The same goes for conformation, but In a slightly different way. They are bred closely to the standard. Nasty poor examples of the breed do not get titled. Showing conformation is evaluation of breeding stock. This shows the quality of that dog or bitch. Puppy evaluation is extremely important. I could not imagine someone wanting a pet getting an incredibly drivey dog.


There are do many things to take in to account with breedings. I think chalking every dog up as pet quality in a pet home is a complete falsification.

If qualities are not inherited why don't we just breed with only health in mind, since the owners can make any dog in to what they want it to be?
This is pretty much what I was thinking as well.You said it better than I would have.:)
 
Kaloric could be her husband but they have, did or do breed Dobermans. So I am not sure where they are coming from. I posted that info in regards to the comment "I am not a breeder" so it could have been her husband but both are listed in the DPCA directory as members. So he is not totally in the dark on this breeding thing.
 
Kalora Carry-on gen X

(huuuge snip)

Estelle then how did all these puppies end up with your kennel name and bred to titled dogs???? This info is on Dobequest BTW and you paid to be listed as a breeder in the DPCA breeder referral program. Can you please clarify.

Ummm, I'm not Kalora? How embarrassing for you, to jump to such a conclusion because there's a vague similarity between my handle and a kennel name. My name is Scott and I live in Colorado. I would certainly not name a kennel after a forum handle or vice versa. I'd wager that someone with such a fancy kennel would probably not have a natural-eared Dobe, that's for sure, or be defending that choice. Or picking-on the value of kennel-bred animals either.
 
Ummm, I'm not Kalora? How embarrassing for you, to jump to such a conclusion because there's a vague similarity between my handle and a kennel name. My name is Scott and I live in Colorado. I would certainly not name a kennel after a forum handle or vice versa. I'd wager that someone with such a fancy kennel would probably not have a natural-eared Dobe, that's for sure, or be defending that choice. Or picking-on the value of kennel-bred animals either.
So out of pure curiosity what does your handle mean?
 
I disagree whole-heatedly.

Try making that argument to someone who gets a "pet". From a sire and dam both titled in schutzhund. That dog will have more drive then he knows what to do with. The same goes for conformation, but In a slightly different way. They are bred closely to the standard. Nasty poor examples of the breed do not get titled. Showing conformation is evaluation of breeding stock. This shows the quality of that dog or bitch. Puppy evaluation is extremely important. I could not imagine someone wanting a pet getting an incredibly drivey dog.

I understand what you're saying, and it makes sense. My point was mostly that there's a lot of untapped potential in a lot of dogs that aren't involved in competition, or are involved in other activities. But yeah, that's a reason I wasn't looking for a ScH-distinguished pedigree.

I got my pups from excellent lines with them being graded as "pet" quality.

When my boy matured I realized he was an excellent example of the breed and I wanted to show him. It was in his blood. He matured into the quality of his parents.

My girl was also graded pet quality. She has loads of drive, and is extremely focused in obedience.

Hopefully you could show him at the highest levels you are capable of, and aren't being precluded from doing so because the breeder made you sign a contract for neuter. I think it should be your choice what you do with your animal, not the decision of your breeder. If you have the drive to help your animals live up to their highest potential, you should have the unfettered ability to do that, without just paying an extra couple grand for the privilege. "Pet grade" is a glass ceiling. Not that I want to see the distinction go away completely, that would maybe bring on a BYB-fest.

While there are some sex-specific competitions in horses, most are male-only or female-only, not altered or non-altered. Ironically enough, geldings compete in the Breeder's Cup Classic, as an example. But of course they aren't eligible to compete in the filly races.:D

I don't really understand why things are that way in the dog fancy. I understand how you explained it above, but the most ridiculous reason I can think of for not altering an animal (when one would otherwise be inclined to do so) is to be able to compete in big-league shows and not be relegated to the minors. That is another topic though!

There are do many things to take in to account with breedings. I think chalking every dog up as pet quality in a pet home is a complete falsification

I'm actually doing the opposite to that; I'm saying that more dogs than receive a top breeder's nod (and extra money from the customer) to become "show quality" could be contenders. A good number of animals with undistinguished pedigrees will shine brightly in the right hands, too.

And then there's me. Most of what I'm saying is that I'm a pet-grade owner. It's all on me. I'm sure Kira could do better if I wasn't holding her back, but she's pretty happy being doted upon too. It just wouldn't matter if she had a better pedigree, I'd just be holding her back that much more with my "hiking several miles into the backcountry is a fun activity!" sort of mentality.

If qualities are not inherited why don't we just breed with only health in mind, since the owners can make any dog in to what they want it to be?

It's a balancing act, and it's heartbreaking to see how much the balance is off when it comes to the health. As I noted earlier, I think it's a disgrace that pedigreed dogs are generally plagued with poor longevity, when most domestication prolongs animals' lives. I wasn't the one who brought-up longevity in this thread, but I'm running with it, because it's so much more important (going full-circle) than worrying about cropped ears or a docked tail. There is no reason in my mind that we can't have fine examples of Dobermans who have great conformation, high drive, and wonderful temperament, who also routinely live to 15 years of age.

And yes, Suzan-- it is the most unacceptable reason in the world for someone to get a big head over their pet being complimented so they go home and get aspirations of breeding. It's not "distinguished" in any way, shape, or form to have a completely untrained eye in a casual social setting appraising quality in something they know nothing about. A contract stipulation about just not breeding, but being able to leave the animal intact is fine in my book, but were I a breeder (which I'm not :D), I suppose I would probably have trouble trusting even that. Yes, yes, I probably would probably have such high standards I wouldn't live up to them myself with roles reversed...
 
It was the name of one of my characters in a video game some years ago. It's mostly meaningless, but based on the word for "warmth", which had no significance. I like K-names. A lot. Probably more than anyone should!
Fair enough.
 
I have an interesting relationship with my breeder, so luckily the contract deal doesn't apply to hardcore here. We are more friends than business acquaintances. I do see why the contract is there though. To many people want to breed irresponsibly. I support having a clause in the contract for those who don't want to spay or neuter for health reasons, I like how Suzan does it with the extreme fine. Those who are in it for money will see this fine and take that as a serious ordeal. What worries me about not spaying or neutering is the accidental risk of breeding. We have to many Doberman without homes as it is. While I believe you and Ataro are fully capable of taking proper care to avoid this, I don't have the same faith in everyone. A good breeder will work with you on this and understand your concerns are soley health based.

When I got Raven he was a show prospect that could not kick out his rear in to a stack. It was generally assumed he would grow out of this, but it was also not required that I showed him, this has all been my choice to keep the pups active. A lot of times puppies are graded as "pet" quality from minor things like this. A good reputable breeder will bemore stringent on their standards with their litters. After all they are being judged in the community by what they produce. I also believe when buying from a good breeder you don't get bad puppies out of the litter, they are all high quality but some are nicer than others. Even though my girl Crow is not to high of a show prospect, if she wasn't spayed I am sure I could get some points on her.

Sorry I am not as good at multi quoting as you are so I am attempting to answer each paragraph.

I do agree that from some not so good breeders you can see puppies come out that are extrordinary. A breeding is not guaranteed to produce the highest quality or the lowest quality. Where reputable breeders succeed in this is by pairing quality parents to produce the likelihood of quality stock. Like I said before even the worst puppies are still pretty high quality.
Where as with a byb they could have two untitled no health tested parents and make one or two beautiful puppies while the rest are not anything to scuff about. Sometimes weird stuff happens, but I would much rather have a breeder whom took the care and caution to produce high quality offspring then one who hopes a miracle will happen.


I honestly believe health is number 1 in a good breeders eyes. While that may not be the case for everyone that is what I have noticed with the few good breeders I have been around. That's why you see more health testing being done than ever before. The health and history of issues in Dobermans is not my strong point so I won't dig to deep in to this one, as I just do not know enough about it.

I hope I answered everything. I'm terrible at responding to long posts. I always seem to get the small stuff responded to, and not that which is more in depth.
 
Hopefully you could show him at the highest levels you are capable of, and aren't being precluded from doing so because the breeder made you sign a contract for neuter. I think it should be your choice what you do with your animal, not the decision of your breeder.

This is because you are not totally knowledgable of all the ins and outs of breeding, breed clubs, and showing. It never failes to amaze me that someone who has no actual real world experience suddenly thinks they should be telling everyone how things should work.

If you spend even 10 years establishing your line, showing your dogs, training, and all that goes along with it and then daily read on forums like these were everything you do is for nothing unless of course you bought from a BYB then suddenly good breeders are acceptable you might have a better understanding. If you ever went to the expense to ship a bitch to be bred that you had high hopes for and the breeding didn't take you might see a different side. If you had spent a ton of money on health testing and then still lost the dog you would see why it is important then you come on a list and people are complaining all over the place because they bought from a breeder who has stopped communicating with them because they were having a problem you might feel differently.

If you had spent those 10 years and at 10 years you are just beginning to actually establish yourself as a serious player establish your line you would be sick sick sick to read where one of your dogs had been bred to a Z factored or albino. It has happened to many top breeders with their dogs they placed in those smart pet home you are talking about who knew everything.

I have been fortunate so far as I have avoided the Z factor problem but it can happen to the very best. So you can't jsut throw your puppies out there with no thought to the irresponsible who do not care about the importance of a breed standard, a breed club, dog shows and correct breeding.
 
What worries me about not spaying or neutering is the accidental risk of breeding. We have to many Doberman without homes as it is. While I believe you and Ataro are fully capable of taking proper care to avoid this, I don't have the same faith in everyone. A good breeder will work with you on this and understand your concerns are soley health based.

This is what it comes down to, and I would have a lot of trouble trusting anyone I didn't know well to handle this sort of thing.

If you had spent those 10 years and at 10 years you are just beginning to actually establish yourself as a serious player establish your line you would be sick sick sick to read where one of your dogs had been bred to a Z factored or albino. It has happened to many top breeders with their dogs they placed in those smart pet home you are talking about who knew everything.

Fair enough, and yes, I would lose my :poop: if I was a breeder and a buyer pulled that on me.

If you spend even 10 years establishing your line, showing your dogs, training, and all that goes along with it and then daily read on forums like these were everything you do is for nothing unless of course you bought from a BYB then suddenly good breeders are acceptable you might have a better understanding. If you ever went to the expense to ship a bitch to be bred that you had high hopes for and the breeding didn't take you might see a different side. If you had spent a ton of money on health testing and then still lost the dog you would see why it is important then you come on a list and people are complaining all over the place because they bought from a breeder who has stopped communicating with them because they were having a problem you might feel differently.

I think you're failing to distinguish between levels of responsible, reputable breeder who does the right thing by their animals, competition breeders, and lastly, hardcore competition breeders who are too focused on an elusive goal to worry about health. I know more folks who got burned by the latter than by BYBs, it makes you sick either way, but more in the latter, because the buyer put in the effort to try to do things right, and got burned badly. But on this topic, something I certainly would jump through all the hoops for would be a top breeder who placed an inordinate amount of emphasis on health (because there's no such thing!) & low inbreeding coefficients, rather than finding a reputable local breeder where I can better make judgments for myself.
 

Back
Top