• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Are More US Doberowners Leaving Their Dobes Uncropped and Undocked?

Well, only if I had been the breeder. I wasn't, so that factor isn't one I had a huge amount of influence over. I also don't plan to breed her but if I did, that would be under my control and I'd most certainly uphold my own ideals. Standards don't need to be as lofty for a pet, and health/longevity and geographical proximity were my primary considerations. In that there is negligible inbreeding in the generations preceding Kira, the detrimental factors of linebreeding that would be amplified and possibly cause serious health issues also are much lower risk. That's how I rolled the dice.

Of course, if I had been dealing with a breeder with loftier aspirations, of course my standards would've been more stringent, even for a pet, due to the increased risks. I'm just hard pressed to find a reason why I should've put in several times more time to research, spent several times the $$$, taken a substantially higher risk, and probably would've had no choice in ear cropping/contract spaying (both things I wanted choice in), for approximately the same type of dog. Obviously, the equilibrium of risks vs. rewards does shift if the fulcrum of "goals" is moved, so if I had title-chasing ambitions, I might've looked to a hardcore breeder.

So am I reading this right, you don't want to waste your time doing research before buying a pet. You don't want to buy from a breeder that cares about the breed and requires a spay/neuter contract. Which is being responsible by the way. You want the choice to not spay your dog so are you thinking of becoming a BYB, or are you an irresponsible owner. Or do you just not like your breeder telling you what to do?
 
Choosing not to spay/neuter your dog has nothing to do with becoming a BYB. Even if I wasn't showing Ashra, I still would not spay her because after much research I do not believe it is better for large breeds in terms of health, and Dobermann females have a high chance of spay incontinence (I am not comfortable with medicating my dog for life for a problem that was caused by a choice I made). If you're a responsible owner, you should have the choice to do what you believe is right for your pet's health - and that has nothing to do with breed standard. You should not just do what is prescribed for people who have no idea how/can't be bothered controlling their dog. Some of us are comfortable with spaying/neutering, some aren't. I don't have a problem with whatever choice others make for their own pets, but that does not mean that the same choice has to be made for mine.
 
if I had title-chasing ambitions, I might've looked to a hardcore breeder.

A direct slam to anyone who strives to compete with their dog and who strive to work the dogs on some level and very unnecessary especially on top of this - Shwing and traing any dog takes a level of committment and an investment. This statement is garbage.

Standards don't need to be as lofty for a pet, and health/longevity and geographical proximity were my primary considerations. In that there is negligible inbreeding in the generations preceding Kira, the detrimental factors of linebreeding that would be amplified and possibly cause serious health issues also are much lower risk. That's how I rolled the dice. by Kaloric

Folks I want to assure you that breeding at 2, 3 4 5 or 6 etc is not guarantee on healht and longevity but being close to you is????? This is a stand we should adhere to???

This is probably what is for confusing to new people than anything someone who comes on and speaks of all these high standards that everyone else should adhere to but they didn't because they found a dog cloer to them that they could just run right over and pick up. I think we have seen the true color of this thread and it is why I work hard to quote standards andnot just slam someone for their program IF - they do any showing, training and testing. If they are honorable and honor their contracts and support their families when they need help and provide correct registration if they ae advertising legitimate registration.

I don't believe you can have two standards one for yourself and one for everyone else. This is the biggest problem we face in trying to educate JQP who thinks we are double talking and this to me is a clear example of double talk.
 
Choosing not to spay/neuter your dog has nothing to do with becoming a BYB. Even if I wasn't showing Ashra, I still would not spay her because after much research I do not believe it is better for large breeds in terms of health, and Dobermann females have a high chance of spay incontinence (I am not comfortable with medicating my dog for life for a problem that was caused by a choice I made). If you're a responsible owner, you should have the choice to do what you believe is right for your pet's health - and that has nothing to do with breed standard. You should not just do what is prescribed for people who have no idea how/can't be bothered controlling their dog. Some of us are comfortable with spaying/neutering, some aren't. I don't have a problem with whatever choice others make for their own pets, but that does not mean that the same choice has to be made for mine.


I don't think this is so much about spaying/neutering as opposed to the justification of purchasing from a back yard breeder. Unless I'm reading kaloric's post incorrectly, in which case I apologize. That's just what I took from it.
 
The infinitely uneducated on dog matters JOHN Q PUBLIC JQP!!

I don't have a problem with whatever choice others make for their own pets, but that does not mean that the same choice has to be made for mine.

Ataro - each breeder must work with their families and help them but for me as a breeder and responsible for my lines for the AVERAGE JQP they do not want to deal with heat cycles and are ill equiped to do so and that often fills the local shelters when the resident mutt digs through the fence and does the deed.

You are a different matter because you are responsible and there are Dobermans who have never been spayed who are incontinent.
 
I don't think this is so much about spaying/neutering as opposed to the justification of purchasing from a back yard breeder. Unless I'm reading kaloric's post incorrectly, in which case I apologize. That's just what I took from it.

I was referring to Doberman Gang's quote where he says the choice not to spay is either a) planning on becoming a BYB or b) being an irresponsible owner.
 
I was referring to Doberman Gang's quote where he says the choice not to spay is because one is either planning on becoming a BYB or is an irresponsible owner.

Sadly that is correct also - It is just too tempting when someone has their pet admired and told how beautiful they are with no knowledge of the standards and suddenly they want to breed this magnificant animal who is by far not the best candidate. Same reason people are critized for placing ALL puppies with full registration.

There is no hard and fast perfect rule that works everytime. I have a couple families through the years who have felt as you do but they have NO interest in showing - I add a $5,000 fine to the contract should they breed the dog and I am to be the owner of the litter and receive all the proceeds from any sales. I take irresponsible owners very seriously.
 
I was referring to Doberman Gang's quote where he says the choice not to spay is either a) planning on becoming a BYB or b) being an irresponsible owner.
It wasn't a blanket statement, it was a question. I thought that you were showing your dog, which requires your dog to not be fixed. I was asking what the reasoning was, for someone just wanting a pet, for not buying from a breeder that asks for a spay/neuter contract.
 
Sadly that is correct also - It is just too tempting when someone has their pet admired and told how beautiful they are with no knowledge of the standards and suddenly they want to breed this magnificant animal who is by far not the best candidate. Same reason people are critized for placing ALL puppies with full registration.

There is no hard and fast perfect rule that works everytime. I have a couple families through the years who have felt as you do but they have NO interest in showing - I add a $5,000 fine to the contract should they breed the dog and I am to be the owner of the litter and receive all the proceeds from any sales. I take irresponsible owners very seriously.

This is what I meant by irresponsible owners... of course you can never be sure, which is why I think limited registrations are a good idea (and in your case, the added content to the contract), but for owners who are responsible, I believe they should have the choice in regards to their pet's health (that does not necessarily mean full registration!). In rescue, there was always an S&N contract, but I have to say that the mentality still persists very widely in Mexico where they believe it is better for the animal to have one litter in their life, which of course is not true. And they are very ignorant about facts, some thinking if a turtle loses a leg it can sprout a new one (don't even ask me how the hell that works out). Most of them, in my opinion, are not fit to be pet owners.

However, I definitely do not believe the rescues are putting the animals' best interests first when they spay and neuter at 2-3 months old. Which is why I was very picky with whom I gave my cats away to (only to people vets knew personally did not breed their animals and/or have "accidental" litters), and did not spay them myself until they were at least 6 months old. The reason I did spay those few despite my beliefs and what I would have done with my own pets, is because these animals have a very high chance of ending up on the street (it is a very real consequence, when owners no longer want them), and the problem with street animals is so bad that any animal caught by animal control off the street has only 1 week to live before they are put to sleep.

Doberman Gang I am showing my dog, please re-read my post. And for the record, if in future I decide to buy a pet quality dog, I won't be spaying/neutering it either. I'll post my BYB litter announcement from the future pet quality dog first thing on this forum though, just for you :D .
 
So am I reading this right, you don't want to waste your time doing research before buying a pet. You don't want to buy from a breeder that cares about the breed and requires a spay/neuter contract. Which is being responsible by the way. You want the choice to not spay your dog so are you thinking of becoming a BYB, or are you an irresponsible owner. Or do you just not like your breeder telling you what to do?

I don't really like dealing with control-freaks, especially control-freaks with egos. Rationalize it and call it whatever you want, but I know more people who have been burned badly on puppies they purchased from these so-called "reputable" breeders who are "bettering" the breed than I know who have been burned buying puppies from conscientious BYBs who don't don't have a fancy program or contracts, but who do know how to recognize a quality representative of the breed.

As I stated, and it couldn't have been any more clear: I do not plan to breed her. Ever. Period. Ataro does a fine job of explaining the rationale.

Also, my previous Dobe suffered from urinary incontinence which was almost certainly due to being spayed, would any of these "reputable" breeders be willing to foot the bill for incontinence meds or the furniture/bedding damaged for any of those contract-spayed bitches when they get a little older and might have a problem? When my vet started pushing the spay speech, I asked her if she would cover the costs of long-term complications, that effectively ended that conversation, too. Everyone wants to give advice or tell you what to do, nobody wants to accept responsibility for the potential consequences you and your animal will have to live with. Oh, and I also really don't care much for the health repercussions of pregnancy either, so that kind of rules-out the speculative breeding contracts.

When you get down to it, I guess I'm hard-pressed to say I'm interested in other folks' ambitions. I'm uninterested in cleaning-up after their "pet grade" by-products or mistakes, taking undue risks, playing with the potential health risks that come from playing with inbreeding fire. I understand that folks want to get controlling when it comes to rigid contracts & taking away buyer choices so their good names aren't tarnished, but if it comes into conflict with my interests (my pet's health and longevity), that's not a place I am willing to go.

On the broader scope, the talk of "what's best for the breed" isn't necessarily really what this is about, it's usually "what's best for the breeder". It's the breeder who wants multi-tiered registrations and contracts to keep someone from dropping the big names in their pedigree to make a backyard buck. It's the breeder who wants the c/d so nobody sees his/her name attached to a non-standard animal. Again, that's fine and dandy. I'm not concerned with names on a pedigree, I'm concerned with getting a sound representative of the breed (sound especially in health) that is the best fit for me.
 
I have to say, this discussion has been quite interesting to read.
i8QIK.gif
 
Also, my previous Dobe suffered from urinary incontinence which was almost certainly due to being spayed, would any of these "reputable" breeders be willing to foot the bill for incontinence meds or the furniture/bedding damaged for any of those contract-spayed bitches when they get a little older and might have a problem?


Not sure your response holds up. A bitch in heat is just likely to damage furniture/bedding My female has incontinence and so far all furniture has been spared.
 
A direct slam to anyone who strives to compete with their dog and who strive to work the dogs on some level and very unnecessary especially on top of this - Shwing and traing any dog takes a level of committment and an investment. This statement is garbage.

A slam? Where do you get that? All I'm saying is that *I* have no competition ambitions, at least not at the moment, so those pursuits are not on my radar. I don't begrudge anyone what they want to do with their time. But I also don't think that titles are necessarily indicative of the quality of the animal.

In fact, I think it's mostly indicative of the skill and dedication of its trainers and handlers, it's their drive that makes the biggest difference. Unfortunately, the work someone has put into an animal means very little in terms of the potential animal's offspring. Every animal is "pet grade" when it is in pet-grade hands.

Folks I want to assure you that breeding at 2, 3 4 5 or 6 etc is not guarantee on healht and longevity but being close to you is????? This is a stand we should adhere to???

Kindly refrain from putting words in my mouth. But since you bring it up, I'll tell you what breeding a health-checked, sound animal at the age of 6 means: It means that the animal survived at least that long and apparently isn't suffering from a serious congenital defect that would have led to its untimely demise before the age of 6, and if you're lucky, its offspring probably won't just start suffering from such a thing out of the blue. Nothing more, nothing less.

As far as proximity goes, it would take a whole lot more than some half-baked "health guarantee" covering testicles & teeth to have me purchase an animal (especially a female who half of that doesn't even apply to!) sight-unseen, especially if someone else is going to cherry-pick the best animals as show or breeding prospects (and demand substantially more $$$ for them). Letting me take my pick, make my animal's health choices myself, and take my chances.

I don't believe you can have two standards one for yourself and one for everyone else. This is the biggest problem we face in trying to educate JQP who thinks we are double talking and this to me is a clear example of double talk.

I'm not a breeder. Therefore the standards I would be concerned with if I were a breeder (which I'm not), and which I would like to see in a breeder, do not apply to me, as I am the purchaser of a pet. You can't always realistically get what you want, I reviewed and rejected a few regional breeders because I judged them as unethical BYBs because they didn't answer my questions to my satisfaction and didn't seem to have a clue about anything other than their profit agenda.
 
Not sure your response holds up. A bitch in heat is just likely to damage furniture/bedding My female has incontinence and so far all furniture has been spared.

Not big puddles that soak-through almost everything, a few times a week, for the last 2 years of their lives, and smaller leaks a few times a month since she was two. Plastic sheets under blankets on chairs works, plastic sheets on the bed, not so well when it doesn't breathe, and I'm not about to kick my old dog (or young dog) off the bed!

The little blood spots don't get through the army blankets, and as for later onset incontinence, I may still have to deal with it, but I'll do what I can to avoid it, if it's avoidable.
 

Back
Top