Albino invited to TT at nationals

I can TOTALLY relate to the whole doberman in the hospital thing! My Mysti was a registered therapy dog and visited our hospital every Monday. I got so many mixed reactions to her, alot of shock at first seeing this big doberman walking into the hospital. Alot of people tried to stop me and tell me she wasnt allowed in and I had to show them her ID card, which was always firmly attached to her collar. It got so bad at one point I went and bought her the red service vest that clearly stated "Therapy Dog" on it. After that people stopped hassling me about trying to bring her in, but were still surprised to see a doberman doing that kind of work.


Man, can I relate! Even the other therapy dog owners raise an eyebrow and take a step back. I walk in with two, so I get a double dose. Then my guys start their wiggle butt action and all you see is relief on faces.
 
D4E I could not agree with you more. Having rescued dogs for so long, I have come across some pretty serious health issues which may be why they ended up in rescue in the first place. It is a nice idea to think we can not set standards and then have all the big hearted people step in to save the day, but it is just not feasible. Why not set standards to save a lot of pain and suffering for both, dog and man? Are there problems in the purebred dog? Absolutely! But with responsible breeding practices can we not resolve this? No one is saying kill all the mutts. We are just saying strive for quality!
 
Good points paint - As I see it and please understand I am 100% died in the wool for purebred dogs and specifically Doberman's. They are my breed of choice. Standards are suppose to help eliminate some of the problems that people come on this forum and complain about - the lack of quality in BYB dogs. So true breeders who support the standard and breed to it plus do the health testing MUST be a little better than just breeding anything and everything.

Marijuana is illegal to grow so guess what I don't grow it. Albinos were banned by the DPCA and AKC from showing and and to help us protect the integrity of our breed the implemented the Z reg. That is enough for me to stay away from them, not support them and to advise others to do a lot of research before getting involved with them.

I also can't tell you the number of folks through the years who have contacted me either wanting to breed or wanting advise on their dobe only to find out it was Z factored and they did not even know what that was. So if they are so darn proud of them why aren't they honest upfront and explain to folks that even though the dog might be black and rust it is z factored which means it is shunned by its own breed club due to the danger of passing a a genetic defect which creates a handicapp???
 
I understand loving a dog regardless of it's defects, but I really think it's unfair to purposely breed dogs to have these defects. Dogs are not human. They, in most cases, are not responsible for the output/type of puppies they bring into this world. We as humans are responsible for that. Why purposely bring dogs into this world with defects? I think that is extremely unfair to the dog. It is not about elitists/pures against dogs with defects. I'd rather animals with defects be the rare case and more animals be happy and healthy! That, to me, is what one strives for when educating the public about the standard and the things that makes a dog a good candidate for breeding.
 
I understand loving a dog regardless of it's defects, but I really think it's unfair to purposely breed dogs to have these defects. Dogs are not human. They, in most cases, are not responsible for the output/type of puppies they bring into this world. We as humans are responsible for that. Why purposely bring dogs into this world with defects? I think that is extremely unfair to the dog. It is not about elitists/pures against dogs with defects. I'd rather animals with defects be the rare case and more animals be happy and healthy! That, to me, is what one strives for when educating the public about the standard and the things that makes a dog a good candidate for breeding.
Great summation. The point isn't about looks the point is about health. People need to realize that the albinos are just that, albinos. With that genetic defect comes a multitude of health issues and because of those health issues a lot of temperament issues. As Rits said, it is our responsibility as owners/breeders/HUMANS to ensure that we are producing and supporting the production of healthy animals. It is inhumane to knowingly create an animal that is absolutely going to have health problems. Good breeders do their best to produce healthy animals, bad breeders breed what will sell. That is what is happening with the breeding of the albinos, they know that people like "rarities" and because it is a genetic defect the white "color" is a rarity. These puppies are being sold for outrageous prices only to be lost at a young age and/or deal with bad health issues for all of their lives. How is that right?
People that rescue albinos have all my respect but that is a completely different discussion. They are not supporting these bad breeders but rather trying to clean up their mess.
 
Great summation. The point isn't about looks the point is about health. People need to realize that the albinos are just that, albinos. With that genetic defect comes a multitude of health issues and because of those health issues a lot of temperament issues. As Rits said, it is our responsibility as owners/breeders/HUMANS to ensure that we are producing and supporting the production of healthy animals. It is inhumane to knowingly create an animal that is absolutely going to have health problems. Good breeders do their best to produce healthy animals, bad breeders breed what will sell. That is what is happening with the breeding of the albinos, they know that people like "rarities" and because it is a genetic defect the white "color" is a rarity. These puppies are being sold for outrageous prices only to be lost at a young age and/or deal with bad health issues for all of their lives. How is that right?
People that rescue albinos have all my respect but that is a completely different discussion. They are not supporting these bad breeders but rather trying to clean up their mess.

Perfect! I entirely agree on everything, especially the bold parts (which is almost bolding your entire post, lol) Thank you!
 
D4E, your lenghty message well represents your emotinal state of mind, and I respect that. I have many doubts people in the "fancy breeding"have the same honesty and heart, though.
Once again, it is scientific truth that an albino's DNA (people can buy a kit and get a DNA test done for about 70$) is a dobermann 's DNA.
It is also a scientific truth that gene mutation is something that, willing or not, happens. A derivative of Darwin's theory.
Not sure if the question "why you got a dobie"was directed to me. In my case, Mercutio was left as puppy b/c he was blue. My neighbor has an albino, 5yrs old, and absolute no issues insofar.......
While we can agree to disagree, I just want to point out that the restrictions in the requirements for Show Dogs are antiquated, and will not stand the test of time.
With peace, love, and light.
 
I can TOTALLY relate to the whole doberman in the hospital thing! My Mysti was a registered therapy dog and visited our hospital every Monday. I got so many mixed reactions to her, alot of shock at first seeing this big doberman walking into the hospital. Alot of people tried to stop me and tell me she wasnt allowed in and I had to show them her ID card, which was always firmly attached to her collar. It got so bad at one point I went and bought her the red service vest that clearly stated "Therapy Dog" on it. After that people stopped hassling me about trying to bring her in, but were still surprised to see a doberman doing that kind of work.
We have dobies in the oncology dept., as company dogs for older patients. They actually carry the patients from room to room for tests, chemo etc.....
 
Perfect! I entirely agree on everything, especially the bold parts (which is almost bolding your entire post, lol) Thank you!
what's your opinion about pugs? They suffer terribly bt were bred with respiratory problems notwithstanding.
 
Eliza - there are always exception to every rull and I did not say that ALL albinos suffered I said they have a much higher incidence of problems. I guarantee you they can't work that dog outside in bright light for extended periods of time or they would see problems.

While we can agree to disagree, I just want to point out that the restrictions in the requirements for Show Dogs are antiquated, and will not stand the test of time.

While that may be true, breeders who are passionate about thier breed, clearly understand the importance of a standard and breed to that standard will not fall. The dog show is just one way we can prove we know what we are doing or that we are on track. If I were you I would not count on it falling anytime soon. People like their hobbies and the opportunity to compete - It is about doing a better job and whea that becomes antiquated then we are all done. Excellence is a word we have forgotten in our quest to try to make even genetic defects acceptable. While we must love and care for those who suffer I personally in breeding dogs will never stupe so low as to produce inferiority and push it off as normal leaving others to deal with the aftermath.

In my world there is still right and wrong and I nev er want to be on the side of wrong.
 
D4E, I clearly do not see the world as you do. But as I saw many societies accept women, universities and clubs forced to be open to women (and yes, their owners, too, were claiming "standards", "quality", "excellence") so I believe the same will occur to the AKC (which, in many ways is already behind other countries). My view and opinion is of course that of an outsider.
But I do believe that you can maintain standards of excellence beyond and above simple statements decided by some. And no, between right and wrong there is such a huge array of gray................
The fact that, after black and rust, blue, fawn and red are now accepted (a vet in MI told me all puppies of those colors were killed not long ago) seem to support my theory, more than yours.
Remember, once upon a time dark eyes/dark skin was the "norm"for humans, too: blue eyes/blond hair a genetic flaw, that time refined to perfection. Same goes with animals and plants, and to try to stop the process is pointless. I hear your cry for "good health", but again we are witnessing the ongoing process of making dilutes/albinos, and again other breeds are aborts of nature (dashhounds, pugs?) yet they can compete.......
Ultimately, only time will tell.
Maybe all owners of albino dobies should start a thread, logging in all puppies, so to monitor their growth and problems and challenges.
I conclude hoping that scientists will be able to fix dilute and albino's issues, period.
 
what's your opinion about pugs? They suffer terribly bt were bred with respiratory problems notwithstanding.
I wasn't aware this discussion was about pugs. However...I personally don't agree with where pugs have gone or any breeds that have issues breathing. That is why I stick with the breeds I do stick with! :)
 
D4E I could not agree with you more. Having rescued dogs for so long, I have come across some pretty serious health issues which may be why they ended up in rescue in the first place. It is a nice idea to think we can not set standards and then have all the big hearted people step in to save the day, but it is just not feasible. Why not set standards to save a lot of pain and suffering for both, dog and man? Are there problems in the purebred dog? Absolutely! But with responsible breeding practices can we not resolve this? No one is saying kill all the mutts. We are just saying strive for quality!
Well I too have been in the rescue world and I have to
disagree with you, just because they are in a rescue does
not always mean ill health there are many reasons. I have
known many rescued Dobes that live a long happy life not
to mention being therapy dogs and other things. Some are
very well bred dogs.
 
D4E, I clearly do not see the world as you do. But as I saw many societies accept women, universities and clubs forced to be open to women (and yes, their owners, too, were claiming "standards", "quality", "excellence") so I believe the same will occur to the AKC (which, in many ways is already behind other countries). My view and opinion is of course that of an outsider.
But I do believe that you can maintain standards of excellence beyond and above simple statements decided by some. And no, between right and wrong there is such a huge array of gray................
The fact that, after black and rust, blue, fawn and red are now accepted (a vet in MI told me all puppies of those colors were killed not long ago) seem to support my theory, more than yours.
Remember, once upon a time dark eyes/dark skin was the "norm"for humans, too: blue eyes/blond hair a genetic flaw, that time refined to perfection. Same goes with animals and plants, and to try to stop the process is pointless. I hear your cry for "good health", but again we are witnessing the ongoing process of making dilutes/albinos, and again other breeds are aborts of nature (dashhounds, pugs?) yet they can compete.......
Ultimately, only time will tell.
Maybe all owners of albino dobies should start a thread, logging in all puppies, so to monitor their growth and problems and challenges.
I conclude hoping that scientists will be able to fix dilute and albino's issues, period.

The issue is not about the color of the fur, it is the health issues associated with that "color" (not really a color). There is a major difference between humans and domesticated dogs as far as reproduction goes. We are responsible for the output of dogs, the kinds of dogs - their health, temperament, and conformation. Blue eyes/blonde hair may have been thought a genetic flaw back then, but with our knowledge now, is it? Just because of lack of knowledge and information back then at the time, doesn't compare to the knowledge we do have about albinism now. Albinism is proven to be unhealthy. In what species is albinism, healthy? Albinism is not a color...it is a lack of pigment in the skin, hair and eyes, which is associated with a number of vision defects and lack of pigment in the skin which leaves the dog more susceptible to sunburns and skin cancer. To compare a domesticated animal (that we are responsible for) with animals and plants in the wild is not the same. Animals and plants adapt with the environment, their surroundings. Albinism does crop up from time to time in nature...but nature isn't so kind to those animals that are born that way. Thus, you do not see herds, flocks, or packs of whatever species you see fit here, of albinos, running about in the wild.

And, in regard to other breeds, my hope is that those that are into those breeds do whats right and strive to breed a well functioning dog that is healthy, has good temperament, and conformation. Unfortunately, some lose sight of this. I can only hope their ideals change in time. I personally do not know enough information in regards to, the percentage of dogs with short muzzles that develop or have issues so, I cannot fully form an opinion as I quite possibly could just be ill informed. Honestly, I do not see how a short muzzle can be good versus a "normal" length muzzle.
 
Well I too have been in the rescue world and I have to
disagree with you, just because they are in a rescue does
not always mean ill health there are many reasons. I have
known many rescued Dobes that live a long happy life not
to mention being therapy dogs and other things. Some are
very well bred dogs.


Whoops, I don't think I made myself clear. I did not mean that all dogs in rescues are sick. I meant that the ones that I rescued were most likely there because they were sick and the first owners gave them up because thet could not afford to care for them.
I agree with you. I have had some wonderful dogs from rescues. One of which was a lab that was around for my kids growing up...talk about some great boy and his dog stories.
 
D4E, I clearly do not see the world as you do. But as I saw many societies accept women, universities and clubs forced to be open to women (and yes, their owners, too, were claiming "standards", "quality", "excellence") so I believe the same will occur to the AKC (which, in many ways is already behind other countries). My view and opinion is of course that of an outsider

We are not talking about what happens in the human world - humans are far far different than the animal kingdom - All humans can think, reason and should have rights. If you are talking about slavery then that was wrong but I was not back there during those times so did not make the decisions - but it is far better now. You can't equate what bad people do and make it then wrong for everyone. You are comparing apples to oranges and totally off track.

How many times as an outsider have we as humans judnged something one way and then when we got to know someone and understand were they were coming from it completely changed our mind??? It has certainly happened to me. You can't sit on the outside and make erroneous judgements about something you don't have all the fact on. 99% of the time you will be wrong but once you learn about it you then have a clear understanding and can then make a more intelligent judgement.

The fact that, after black and rust, blue, fawn and red are now accepted (a vet in MI told me all puppies of those colors were killed not long ago) seem to support my theory, more than yours.
It is never true that ALL of anything was killed and that happened far more in Euro than here. BUT because they are a normal color that does exist in the gene pool FROM THE BEGINNING due to the selection of dogs in the gene pool we do get those colors. It is normal - NOT A MUTATION. That makes a big difference and there IS NO health issues related to dilutes - only baldness. Baldness is not a major illness in anyones book. Heck be have bald men and even some women. Baldness has never been considered an illness and every study you will find and you can see it on the DPCA web site there are no health issues associated with dilution. If that were the case then we should not breed weims or greyhounds which is thought to be where some of the dilution came in.

You have a totla misunderstanding of these things and have based your opinion on shakey ground.

I don't breed pugs so really can't say alot except I will say this - It should be up to the pug breeders to decided what direction they should go. It is not my business or my opinion that would count but theirs. Last I checked or from what I have heard pugs live for the most part a pretty pampered livestyle since they are a little breed and not aske to jump tall buildings or run long distant races. So really who am I to stick my nose in and interfer in their business. Now were pugs being abused that would be different. Also please remember that the breeders today did not invent the breed - they just fell in love with it and have continued that passion..

I believe in their right to pursue their dream as long as no people are injured or hurt and as long as no animals are abused. I believe that this is America and if we keep trying to change things to suit people who are not even involved in something and so have no clear understanding we are brain dead and should just revise Hitler and let him come tell us who can and who can't do what.

Have you ever shown or compete in anything??? I just ask because you seem so misinformed on a lot of things regarding genetics and don't seem to understand the difference between a mutant gene that is harmful and common genes that cause dilution. Dilution is just a color - Albionism has a miraid of other issues that come along with it just due to the albinoism.

I will also say this - I am far more afraid and terrified of people who think they should control what everyone else did like Hitler. He wanted to start a master race and thank God he failed. America has stood for the pursuit of Liberty and the pursuit of happiness and for me happiness is the competition of dog sports. Is it perfect NO but neither is anything else. So you do the best you can - as long as I am honest and don't take my losses personally I can continue to enjoy the sport - when I become bitter and just want to bad mouth it because I did not get my wey then I should get out. You must be willing to loose in order to win. And no ever wins all the time.

But I will never win if I breed inferior specimens. So this group of people who put standards together for us to follow I salute them and I thank them. I can't imagine any breed as great and noble as the Dobermans and I am thnnkful that down through the years people understood the importance of preserving that breed and will continue to fight for our dogs - The Doberman becasue without their vision we would not enjoy them today.
 
WOW, not only you now launch in personal attack, but AGAIN give no scientific grounds for your reasoning.
1) blue were killed at birth, check studies in the US;
2) you mention baldness in humans, but tell ME that I am comparing apples and oranges;
3) did you ever show a bald blue in competition? I bet no.
4) albino/dilutes are not the SAME, but we are talking about breeding the modern way, which implies handling embryos, manipulating DNA etc.. You may not like it, but this is the reality.
5) are you mentioning Hitler? AHAH, you know that Hitlet/SS considered Dobermanns the "Arian Dog"? You know they had special unit that in 1933 started crossing dogs so that(according to their studies) in 30-40 generations they would have had dogs able to speak German? Based on what you think I want all the world to be the same?????
Since I find pointless trying to discuss with you these issues, I can only bid you good day.
 
4) albino/dilutes are not the SAME, but we are talking about breeding the modern way, which implies handling embryos, manipulating DNA etc.. You may not like it, but this is the reality.
And where did you hear all of this? You say she doesn't have scientific grounds for her reasoning but you don't provide sources for your outlandish claims.

5) are you mentioning Hitler? AHAH, you know that Hitlet/SS considered Dobermanns the "Arian Dog"? You know they had special unit that in 1933 started crossing dogs so that(according to their studies) in 30-40 generations they would have had dogs able to speak German? Based on what you think I want all the world to be the same?????
The Germans in Hitler's era had a lot of stupid, crazy ideas. What does that have to do with this conversation? If you go back and look Hitler was brought up by you first, she was simply addressing your earlier mention.

If you would open your mind and pay attention to those with experience and knowledge that are trying to share that with you here you could learn a whole lot. They are taking the time to answer your questions, they certainly don't have to.
 
I reread the post as I certianly did not mean for it to be construed as a personal attack. I did ask some hard questions. My dogs are not bred in a test tube and neither are most other dogs - there are studies being conducted but that is far at this point and certainly can't be applied to the dog show world as it has not invaded it yet.

I agreed that yes some breeders did "cull" blues and fawns" and that it was far more prevalent in Europe than here but it did happen. Now just so you know we do have a DNA test so that breeder who never want to produce a blue are fawn have that choice. I was not involed in what happend years ago - I have personally never culled a puppy for frivilous reasons.

No you would not win showing a bald blue BUT Bellas Granddam was a beautfiul blue AKC CH with a full blue coat right up to the time she was PTS due to injury at almost 10 years of age. So whether it has a full coat or bald a poor bred - blue would not win in the ring but for the most part neither would a black, red or fawn. Bella's Dam is a 8 1/2 years old fawn still with a full coat. Do you think I am just incredibly lucky or could there be more nice blues and fawns than you are aware of???

I am having a hard time figuring out what you are most upset about - albinos, blues or what science is doing that has nothing yet to do with breeders on any large scale at all. I have from personal experience not had one single breeder nor heard of one whi is producing dogs in a test tube. I do belive science is trying to "find" DNA strands to help eleviate disease and pain and suffering. So what manipulation of DNA are you most concerned with??? Eliminating dreaded diseases or helping mankind have a better quality of life if they succeed???

I will go on record so it is not misconstrued as saying I am not for cloning humans on any level but I feel God will take take of that one.

4) albino/dilutes are not the SAME, but we are talking about breeding the modern way, which implies handling embryos, manipulating DNA etc.. You may not like it, but this is the reality.

Who is breeding this modern way??? What exactly is your definition of the "modern way" you speak of. Test tube babies??? A lot of things can be inplied but that certainly does not mean there are true. Again looking in from the outside it is easy to misunderstand what is actually taking place. And I even if they are what does the analogy of the albino/dilutes have to do with it since you admit that they are not the same.

I do not want poeple like Hitler ruling anything. I don't want people who are not involved in something making the decisions about what I can or can't do. Is that unreasonable as long as I don't harm anyone, cheat, lie, steal, or kill????
 

Back
Top