Temperament talk please

Wanted to add but edit time limit ran out. But, having not had Dobermans before and not currently having any large dogs, I think you are really really going to have a hard time finding a rescue or a breeder that is going to feel comfortable enough leaving their dog in a situation without a fenced in backyard or even a fenced in potty area. Experience really talks and you would have to prove to them somehow that you can manage it. Without having Dobermans before or any currently large dogs...that will be hard to prove. I think it would be a good idea to go to a Dobe event in your area and talk to a few breeders/owners there and let them know you are looking for preferably an older puppy or adult re-home. Some breeders don't have websites or they don't list the adults on their websites due to wanting to be sure the next home is for good.
 
Rits that is a very good idea. And I have thought about putting in a run of some sort. I just do not want to fence in my entire home/property. That's we love being out in the country! Wide open space :) And if I can't get a rescue I will have to accept that. I can be at peace knowing my heart was in the right place. If I have to start with a puppy I can do that too. I just have to change my way of thinking. Part of me knows my girls would love a puppy anyway. We have had dogs all our lives, even before children. My adult children love dogs. All animals really. My 2nd oldest daughter is making a career out of it. She even spent a few months last year training with Michael Ellis out in California. She took our friends very green, hyper boxer and worked her.

DV I get your point. And I still love your dogs faces :)
 
...but you have bo build the fence if you want to have a Doberman. Most of them have pretty high drive and will chase dogs, wildlife and even birds.

I (respectfully) disagree with this statement. Only our current dobe, Marco, has had a fenced-in yard. Both Zep and Katie were raised and lived on my parent's 180-acre farm in Vermont. No fence, plenty of open land and woods (and wildlife GALORE) and there was never a problem with either of them running off.

Both dogs were also fortunate enough to spend half their lives living on lakefront property (also unfenced) in Florida.

Running away was never an issue for either dog in either area. I guess my parents did a really, really good job of training the dogs not to leave? Or over-loving the dogs so that they never went further than they could see them? :)
 
Well some people can have a huge acreage area like 180 acres and if raised from a puppy, wanting to runaway would probably not be an issue. I have had an unfenced yard for years with my mastiff's but they are not wanderers by nature, but I have a fenced in kennel area that I could keep them in if I went away during the day and did not want to leave them in doors all day.
So having an area that is a safe enclosure area to let them out in during the day when you may not be able to watch him/her for a hour or three if you wanted to...
well I can understand in some cases having no fencing for dogs raised from pups and might consider it a non issue, but an adopted dog? not so much...
Since you do not know the dog and its behavior or fear issues, it does not know you and in that you need to let them go out side to go potty several times a day and or just go outside for the nice weather rather than be indoors all day and of course until you know the dog well enough it needs to be supervised always when you take them outside in the interim period when you are getting to know this dog, so as in a adoptee, it would require an area that was enclosed and you can work on off leash training, if not, then otherwise you are forced to be on a leash all the time when outside until that animals is secure enough with the family to be let off leash when outside.
the issue of Tethering an animal when outside even if you have a massive amount of open space for them when tethered is USUALLY frowned upon by both reputable breeders and rescues or shelter. I can tell you for sure that If I were selling a puppy I would not sell one to someone who had intentions of chaining or restraining them on any kid of a tether for ANY length of time outdoors.
Many rescue persons feel the same about about chaining and or tethering and USUALLY require a secure fenced area or exercise area specifcally prepared for your dog. so that would most assuredly preclude you from getting approved for that one snag alone.
So in my experience Far more rescues would approve your kids than approve NO fencing or no kennel or secure area for the dog to be when left outdoors and unattended at any time.
Best of luck to you in your search! you seem like a very nice home for any dog... just need a fenced area of some kind set up... :)
 
We live in the city. Our backyard is tiny. We won't be able to manage dogs without fencing the yard.
If you have 180 acres it's different. I would set up fenced area for dogs anyways.
Don't you have roads nearby? What about wildlife?
Gino's mom was killed by coyotes when she run away from the acreage.
 
Well some people can have a huge acreage area like 180 acres and if raised from a puppy, wanting to runaway would probably not be an issue. I have had an unfenced yard for years with my mastiff's but they are not wanderers by nature, but I have a fenced in kennel area that I could keep them in if I went away during the day and did not want to leave them in doors all day.
So having an area that is a safe enclosure area to let them out in during the day when you may not be able to watch him/her for a hour or three if you wanted to...
well I can understand in some cases having no fencing for dogs raised from pups and might consider it a non issue, but an adopted dog? not so much...
Since you do not know the dog and its behavior or fear issues, it does not know you and in that you need to let them go out side to go potty several times a day and or just go outside for the nice weather rather than be indoors all day and of course until you know the dog well enough it needs to be supervised always when you take them outside in the interim period when you are getting to know this dog, so as in a adoptee, it would require an area that was enclosed and you can work on off leash training, if not, then otherwise you are forced to be on a leash all the time when outside until that animals is secure enough with the family to be let off leash when outside.
Very good points! :cool:

We live in the city. Our backyard is tiny. We won't be able to manage dogs without fencing the yard.
If you have 180 acres it's different. I would set up fenced area for dogs anyways.
Don't you have roads nearby? What about wildlife?
Gino's mom was killed by coyotes when she run away from the acreage.
My husband and I are in a city, too, so now we have a fenced yard for the same reasons. But the other areas did have roads and wildlife, and honestly it was just never an issue - the dogs just didn't want to run further away than where they could see their humans! And up in Vermont, there are coyotes but not NEARLY like we have here in Colorado. In fact, I'm pretty sure we wouldn't allow Marco to run around here in Colorado if we DID have all that land here, because of our coyote issues in Colorado. :(

Actually I'd be lying if I said we had no problems with dogs running off... I do remember one time where Katie was outside and I got in the car to go to the store, and she ran after me in the car. I just stopped and put her in the car with me. She never did it again, but we also made sure someone was holding her when another person drove off. (And she was less than a year old, and this was on a dirt road, right outside our driveway, but still...)

But anyhow, Dennisov makes good points, the fenced in yard is good if you want/need to leave the dog for a while. And now that I think about it, our other dogs we owned never had to be left alone (my dad was retired for quite some time, and my mom was always at home). So maybe that played a part, too. And we have to have a fence for Marco because we're in a busy area, and he's already run into the road and been hit even WITH the fence! :eek: So I would say the fence is situational, then - if someone is available to be with the dog at all times, THEN you probably don't need it. :)
 

Back
Top