I definitely would be neutering him.......I think it will help with the marking. I had that problem only for a short time with Buddy when I first got him, but thankfully it happened in our unfinished basement or I would really been



. And it turns out, he was doing it on a piece of exercise equipment that I was storing for my sister that I KNOW had the scent of her 3 dogs on it!! Maybe even
their PEE on it! lol It was the only area he did this. I tried to watch like a HAWK which was difficult when it was downstairs outta sight, but I managed to sneak up a few times and caught him right in the act (which is the only way) and boy, did he see a mad woman!!!



He rarely even goes down in the basement now! lol Even if I'm down there! That's fine....I'm rarely down there myself.

But I stopped it and I got him neutered in April of '09....he was about 15 months old. I've never had a problem since with that.
I realize you still have decide if you are keeping him and it sounds like if you do, you are neutering. I just wanted to tell you my experience with the marking.
I'll make one suggestion with this....I don't think he is ready to be off leash. The recall should be much better (and him knowing you better too) before he is allowed the freedom of off leash. He is too free to be able to avoid or flee from you and that is only giving him control. If you call him and he doesn't come, you should go get him and how can you do that when he is loose? Once again, I've had experience with that type of thing with Buddy when I first got him. I'd call him to go outside and there were times he wouldn't want to go ....I don't know if he saw the leash as something bad or what! It was frustrating ! But I would call him and if he didn't come, I would just go get him. Sometimes he would run back to his crate but
without a word, I would walk up to him, snap on the leash and off we go. It got to the point that he knew I was gonna go get him anyway and it was almost comical...he would turn to go off in the opposite direction and immediately think better of it and come to me! The first time he did that I knew I did something right!