• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Whining and then possessiveness

StateOfMine

Hot Topics Subscriber
Sometimes I'll give Flint something to chew on and he will whine and just stare at it. When I approach, he barks, dives at it, then growls and takes it away. When I walk away, he starts whining again without touching it.

I have no idea what he wants. I usually give him something to chew if I am eating or if I am doing chores. I was just doing dishes when he was doing this. Is this some weird doberman thing?
 
Speaking of whining I have stumbled across this collar and I wanted to know if anyone has tried it? I have heard good things about Dogtra's e-collars but I haven't heard much about their bark collars specifically.

Dogtra Smart No Bark Collar

Apparently it can detect whining, barking, howling and still act as an e-collar for short ranges. I have a $25 gift card for gundog supply and I am very tempted to try this collar.
 
Elroy whines with happiness when he gets something he loves (like a GoDog ball). It's like he's overwhelmed with happiness so I won't correct it. If he's getting overly possessive I would take it away.

Dogtra makes good collars but I would only use it for excessive barking. I want them to bark and alert me to things but I want them to stop when I tell them to.
 
Sometimes I'll give Flint something to chew on and he will whine and just stare at it. When I approach, he barks, dives at it, then growls and takes it away. When I walk away, he starts whining again without touching it.

Without seeing it, I'd guess at 2 different things: A game to him, to not touch it (in dog play, a "dare" by making it available) and when you come toward him he barks (a playful zoomie-type bark), growls, grabs it and takes it away - this would be an invitation to play keep away and zoom. I would totally ignore him as this is a dog/dog game and it's nothing you want to encourage for him to do with you.

The other thing would be is that he is truly resource guarding that chewy and seriously doesn't want you coming near or touching it or taking it away. He's not wanting to chew it because he's busy watching you in anticipation of you taking it or making him leave it thus making him uncomfortable and defensive. The tone of the bark and growl and the look in his eyes should tell you whether he's wanting to play or being extremely serious.

I never ever take away something that I've given to my dog. It's theirs and they know that. It's totally unfair for you to give it to them and then take it away "just because" or to prove you're boss, with the exception of an emergency like choking. So again, give him his chewy, then ignore him until it's gone. If you are innocently walking by and he barks/growls/gets defensive I would avoid eye contact, just ignore him and let him know you have no intentions of taking away his chewy. If he is doing this often I would either crate him with his chewy or not give them at all. I wouldn't put up with my own dog being that aggressive to me, - give them an inch they will start doing it with couch space etc. Some dogs are more possessive than others, even if you've never taken away his chew. If it's recently become a thing and there doesn't seem to be a reason, manage it by crating or not giving it to him at all.
 
Without seeing it, I'd guess at 2 different things: A game to him, to not touch it (in dog play, a "dare" by making it available) and when you come toward him he barks (a playful zoomie-type bark), growls, grabs it and takes it away - this would be an invitation to play keep away and zoom. I would totally ignore him as this is a dog/dog game and it's nothing you want to encourage for him to do with you.

The other thing would be is that he is truly resource guarding that chewy and seriously doesn't want you coming near or touching it or taking it away. He's not wanting to chew it because he's busy watching you in anticipation of you taking it or making him leave it thus making him uncomfortable and defensive. The tone of the bark and growl and the look in his eyes should tell you whether he's wanting to play or being extremely serious.

I never ever take away something that I've given to my dog. It's theirs and they know that. It's totally unfair for you to give it to them and then take it away "just because" or to prove you're boss, with the exception of an emergency like choking. So again, give him his chewy, then ignore him until it's gone. If you are innocently walking by and he barks/growls/gets defensive I would avoid eye contact, just ignore him and let him know you have no intentions of taking away his chewy. If he is doing this often I would either crate him with his chewy or not give them at all. I wouldn't put up with my own dog being that aggressive to me, - give them an inch they will start doing it with couch space etc. Some dogs are more possessive than others, even if you've never taken away his chew. If it's recently become a thing and there doesn't seem to be a reason, manage it by crating or not giving it to him at all.

I found out last night it's absolutely a game. My husband has some well meaning but pea-brained friends that love dogs. One of them grabbed his chew while he was doing that behavior. Flint play bowed, then grabbed the chew and they played tug. After the friend let it go to just let him win, Flint shoved the chew back into his hand. No injuries occurred, thankfully.

I wasn't a witness to this behavior. I was at work and my husband told me about it. I say this lovingly, but leave it to men to do everything wrong and find out only after they need stitches. I wish shock collars for husbands were legal sometimes.
 
If you are innocently walking by and he barks/growls/gets defensive I would avoid eye contact, just ignore him and let him know you have no intentions of taking away his chewy
I have had to take a few things away over the years because it was too high value between the two of them and they have gotten into serious fights over it. The last time I remember having to do that was with Albert and Della over a stuffed squirrel they got for Christmas.
 
I have had to take a few things away over the years because it was too high value between the two of them and they have gotten into serious fights over it. The last time I remember having to do that was with Albert and Della over a stuffed squirrel they got for Christmas.
Yes, between two dogs is a whole different method because it's not about you, it's guarding between the two dogs. One dog and their person/people is a different dynamic. So hard to say over the inter webs so it's clear.

I found out last night it's absolutely a game.
That was my first thought. It's harmless except if you are in the house and you play this game a few times it can escalate. Outdoors it could be fun and nothing breaks. :rofl: But still, you do it once or twice then he gets to expect it and pushes for it then it's just a hassle behavior. I'm really glad it wasn't serious threats that come with resource guarding. He didn't seem the type, but then you never know so I had to throw that in.
 

Back
Top