When did your pup graduate from overnight crating?

MyBuddy

Moderator
Hot Topics Subscriber
... or any other overnight restraints?

Most of us have crated our puppies at one time or another. Some have not, I know. But overnight when we're sleeping is usually the time when a young pup is secluded to keep it from any unwanted activities while we are comatose.😴

Annie has been in a crate at night since we picked her up at 9 weeks. I would often tell my husband, I wonder when we should stop that? Because I couldn't remember what age our past dogs were when I stopped crating them. I think it was a gradual thing. Where maybe we tried it and it was fine? I don't remember! I know we've probably gone longer than some people. But it just got to be a matter of habit putting her in her crate each night. And she went so willingly that it really wasn't much of a thought. But one night I just decided to try it.

I was laying in bed reading and my husband was in the sun room " next door" ☺️ watching a game. A lot of times she would sit on the couch in there with him. That night she came up to the bed and started nosing me. She's not allowed on the bed so I just extended my arm and was petting her and talking to her. There was another dog cushion sitting on top of her crate. So I grabbed it and put it on the floor next to me and told her to lay down. She did. And she was very content. When my husband came to bed he told her to get in her crate and that was that. The next night she did that again and I told my husband I think I'm going to just leave her where she is, leave the gate to her crate open and just see what happens.

Well she slept on the pillow next to me all night. 🥰 When I got up to go to the bathoom in the middle of night she got up and put her head on the bed and looked at me like, is a time to get up? I said nope! LOL Go back to bed and she did!

That was the main thing I was afraid of. Her getting up every time I moved. And I hate being woken up by a wet nose on my face! :pullhair: But we did it for two nights in a row and she did very well. Sleeping all night and if she did get up she went right back. There was no sudden barking in the middle of the night at nothing or a wet nose on my face at 1:00 a.m. And even when I got up to go to the bathroom she never moved. So that was all very good.:thumbsup: I thought, 'we can do this. She could do this.'

So last night I broke down the crate and put it up in the attic. The second night she was free I brought her calming bed in the bedroom simply because I knew it is the most comfortable and the biggest dog bed. I contemplated buying another one to have at the other side of the house in the breakfast room where she used it a lot. But we have so many other beds! I hate to purchase another one. But we'll see how it goes. 😉

THE GRADUATE
20250430_082501.webp

That small crate is for Kali. My husband mentioned a while back that maybe we should put that away. I said no, actually she still goes in there once in awhile. So that will never go away while she's here.😌

So at what age did you stop crating your puppy? And how did you go about that?
 
Good girl!

We haven't crated at night since we were both working. I think all of our pups after Albert and Della just slept with us as long as they behaved, which they did. I have bed rules like no rough housing, no laying above our head, no laying on top of us and just settling down and going to sleep.
That said, they hate the turkeys and this morning there was a tom outside the window displaying for a long time so Olive used my hip as her chair to be able to see him better. That's just her though needing a chair if she's going to "watch TV". LOL
 
You didn't remind us how old Annie is now. I know I should remember, and I could look back on your Annie post...

But to show my memory is really going, I can't recall how old Asha was exactly when she was free at night and I don't think I wrote it down. I had an airline crate for her puppy crate but it was full grown Doberman size and I broke it down to nest the top & bottom and it became her bedroom bed. I think she was about a year old, or a little younger. And it didn't take long at all for her to begin sleeping on the bed with me, but always and to this day, nearer to the foot of the bed than the head. As the years have passed she'll fall asleep next to me and rest her head or paws on me while I read, but as soon as I turn the light out, she's scoots down to knee level for the night.

As an aside, my Doberman from years back (born 1991) - I only got a crate because it was the newest idea on house training, so by 5 months old there was no crating but I never let her sleep on the bed at night.
 
Good girl!

We haven't crated at night since we were both working. I think all of our pups after Albert and Della just slept with us as long as they behaved, which they did. I have bed rules like no rough housing, no laying above our head, no laying on top of us and just settling down and going to sleep.
That said, they hate the turkeys and this morning there was a tom outside the window displaying for a long time so Olive used my hip as her chair to be able to see him better. That's just her though needing a chair if she's going to "watch TV". LOL

Same here. The girls both sleep with me in the bed and zero issues.

They still have their own individual crates and can use them whenever they wish but it is very rare that I lock them inside anymore (new girl being the exception while she is still earning trust - If I can't directly supervise her her crate door gets latched if the other girls is out and about).

New girl actually likes her crate and chills in it often...
 
I forget. It just happens, or it doesn't. You just get to feeling that it's time and they're ready.

Oji actually slept in our room at night with our door closed. Otherwise, he would bark at stuff that he should not. Thus he was not able to fully protect the house and our children. He could not be left uncrated at any time when we left the house. Sad.

Our Dobe, Dax, had free range at night but we could not leave windows open or he would bark.

Dobe prior the that, Magnum, never saw the inside of a crate; but he did do a bit of destroying when quite young.

Zephyr here? Strange as it is, his place – his cave, you might say – is the rear living room, and a baby gate is n use. He is two years and three months of age. He spends each night there. He has never been a destroyer though! What he has been is a picker upper of small items to possibly eat. I actually think he has not ingested many non-food items, but it sure looks like he might as he mouths them. He is drawn also to mouthing and maybe eating socks and underwear should they be left out. I don't think he has actually eaten any.

The big reason he is gated in that room at night is ... Barking!! It's just a miracle that Zephyr, who is 3/4 LGD, does not bark at night in his living room. It's like he sort of turns off his watchdog-ness when in his "cave" at night – like he's safe there and off the clock and can relax. Still, he will bark at any noise that is, I guess, above a certain threshold, or if h sees something. Once in a while he will bark in the night and awaken wife and me. On nights when he seems barky before I retire, I may put on his zapper collar, which gives me great peace of mind and better ability to fall asleep. If he barks in the night, I hit the beep (not the zap) and it takes care of it. I know that if there is a real threat or a person in the yard he would bark again and do his job.

We do really hope to be able to ditch the baby gat one day. Another thing we can't trust him on is not going into the girls' rooms and awakening them. He is fantastic about not touching or bothering me when I ay down and close my eyes, (same as all my Dobes) but I think he may bother the girls.
 
You didn't remind us how old Annie is now. I know I should remember, and I could look back on your Annie post...
Sorry no I don't expect everyone to know all our dogs ages. I forget too. :oops:

Annie was a year old March 9th of this year.
there was a tom outside the window displaying for a long time so Olive used my hip as her chair to be able to see him better. That's just her though needing a chair if she's going to "watch TV". LOL
😄 Typical!

Not sure Pepper will ever be there haha she cobs all my stuff 😩
I'm sure she will settle in one day. 🙏
But to show my memory is really going, I can't recall how old Asha was exactly when she was free at night and I don't think I wrote it down.
It's probably all been so gradual that it's hard to remember. My first Doberman wasn't crated very long and I don't remember when or how we switched over to our bed. :facepalm:But three's a crowd! I didn't like him in our bed at all. I felt claustrophobic. I need to be able to move! I was thrilled when Buddy would never come up on our bed or couch even when coaxed up. After a number of years I was curious and I tried to get him to come up on the bed. I knew I was creating a monster! But no way! He would not come up there and I loved it! He always kept all four feet on the ground. Everywhere. Never a counter Surfer either. Annie isn't either. In her early Zoomies once in awhile she jumped on the bed but quickly jumped off. She hasn't done that in months.
 
forget. It just happens, or it doesn't. You just get to feeling that it's time and they're ready.
That's how I think this came about. Like I said. it was just getting to be a habit of putting her in her crate at night until one day I thought, nah I think she'll be okay. She's had free roam of the house, except for the upstairs and the basement, for months now. So she pretty much knows everything that is off limits to her. And we live pretty much uncluttered so it's not like there's a lot of stuff at her disposal for her to destroy. She's never been a destroyer. Except for her toys.


Our Dobe, Dax, had free range at night but we could not leave windows open or he would bark.
Yeah I wonder how that will be all summer. It was only one day so far that we slept with the windows open and it was just the other day. I can't remember, :scratch: but it might have been when she was free. But out here there's not a lot of human noises. If anything it'll be coyotes or raccoons. Gee, I can't wait for that to happen.😕😲☺️
 
We do really hope to be able to ditch the baby gat one day. Another thing we can't trust him on is not going into the girls' rooms and awakening them. He is fantastic about not touching or bothering me when I ay down and close my eyes, (same as all my Dobes) but I think he may bother the girls.
Our kids were teenagers when we had our first Doberman. And I always remember if we were in bed before they came home he always let us know when they came home! 😆 They would quietly come up the stairs (all our bedrooms were on the second floor) and he would let out a little bark knowing that someone walked in. He was a good Watchdog but he loved the kids. And they loved him too but probably hated that he was the guardian of the night! 🤣
 
New girl actually likes her crate and chills in it often
Annie never did chill in her crate in our bedroom. Mainly because it's on the other side of the house and during the day she is with us in the main living area. But she has another crate, a larger one, that is in our breakfast room. That one I used for when I was going out to the barn or going to be outside for a length of time or we are going away for hours on end. But most of that stopped months ago. The only time we actually lock her in now was if we were going away for hours at a time . But even that one has started to wane. She is free in the house now when we are outside. She will chill in there once in awhile when I give her a chewy bone. But she doesn't usually stay. And like I say even locking her in now when we go into town might be stopping.

Just last night we were going to run to our son's house which is about 15 minutes away. Probably would be gone an hour. She was laying on one of her beds in the breakfast room and I told my husband let's just leave her. I'll put the camera on so I could see what's going on but I said she probably won't be able to tell if we are right outside or if we're an hour away! LOL and sure enough, after we left I can see in the camera that she was sitting at the back door looking out after we left for only a few minutes. Then she turned around and went back to her pillow and stayed there the whole time we were gone.🤷‍♀️
 
Ragnar- 8months
Freyja- 6months, only because Rag was around. He was a great teacher for her.

Both would sleep in the living room on the couches. A couple of times in the night Rag would come into our bedroom and nose bump me for a checkin making sure all is well then go back to the couch. That always made me smile- miss that. Don’t know why, but sometimes he felt the need to sleep right next to the bed rather than in the living room. This would confuse Freyja and she would bark at him to come back in the living room. If he did not, she would lay down beside him on the floor.
Currently we have an ottoman at the foot of the bed that Freyja sleeps on now. She cracks me up because at around 8:30ish she is looking at me and easing towards the bedroom like- let’s go dad, time to go to sleep. If there is any chance the wife of out of town, then Freyja sleeps in the bed. She fricking loves laying in the bed, it’s like the ultimate reward, nothing is better.
 
She cracks me up because at around 8:30ish she is looking at me and easing towards the bedroom like- let’s go dad, time to go to sleep.
Asha does this, starts whining if I won't get up and go to bed. I mean, the door is open and she could go in there if she wanted, but she won't unless I go.
 
Glory has been in our bed since ? Falcon has been allowed to sleep in our room outside of his crate now for about 2 months. He is 1 1/2 old now....He sleeps on a dogbed next to the bed. He is not allowed on the bed yet....and we just stopped using the gate to keep him in the bedroom. He can sense it is a privalege and does not move all night! Even if we get up to use the bathroom, he doesn't move...but as soon as that sun lights up the sky around 6am he is UP!
IMG_8093.webp
GLORY....IN ALL HER GLORY
IMG_8094.webp
FALCON, STARTING TO WIND DOWN FOR BED
 
She cracks me up because at around 8:30ish she is looking at me and easing towards the bedroom like- let’s go dad, time to go to sleep
Omg, Buddy used to do that too! So funny!

Annie knows about the time we head out to the barn to feed the horses and will start bugging us if we are relaxing in the sun room after dinner. The habits are learned well! 😁
 
Our kids were teenagers when we had our first Doberman. And I always remember if we were in bed before they came home he always let us know when they came home! 😆 They would quietly come up the stairs (all our bedrooms were on the second floor) and he would let out a little bark knowing that someone walked in. He was a good Watchdog but he loved the kids. And they loved him too but probably hated that he was the guardian of the night! 🤣
Ooh, tattletale and watchdog! Good boy!
 
I'll let you know...
He'll never be allowed on the bed; dogs is dirty, he'll be big, bed not big enough. Bed in the master though, yes. The cats may play a role though. I don't want them unsupervised together for a long time (maybe ever), and cats are rude turds, who might try to sleep on his bed. That sounds like a bad scene potentially.

They wanted to be on the last dog's (rough collie) bed. She just yanked it down the hall, trying to shake them off. She was never crated, I lived with family then and they were very resistant to my management and training ideas -- certainly didn't stick to or enforce them. It made her potty training...challenging.
 
Glory has been in our bed since ? Falcon has been allowed to sleep in our room outside of his crate now for about 2 months. He is 1 1/2 old now....He sleeps on a dogbed next to the bed. He is not allowed on the bed yet....

Agatha was sleeping in the bed with me and the big girl from the first night here but...

I had her butt short leash attached to my wrist to make darn sure she would not be able to go far without waking me up. (standard way I do with puppies here as well)

Only took me a few nights to figure out that she was not going anywhere and not going to destroy anything. :)
 
I had her butt short leash attached to my wrist to make darn sure she would not be able to go far without waking me up.
I did that too since I'm such a sound sleeper and didn't want them getting down to explore without waking me up.
 
I did that too since I'm such a sound sleeper and didn't want them getting down to explore without waking me up.

Feel free to poke fun if you want but back when Patience and Dystopia were puppies and bed time rolled around I would attach Dystopia to my wrist and Patience to an ankle. Always did it the same way each night.

Did not take long before they were both 'all night long' potty trained and 'house safe' and I stopped attaching them but the Dystopia sleeping by my head and Patience sleeping by my feet thing continued for a good while on their own accord.

They got in the 'habit' of where their particular 'spot' was located is the best way I can describe it.

Dystopia still has her own special pillow up by the headboard and prefers that for her spot. I try to be mindful of the new girl and not let her get too close to anything that 'belongs' to Dystopia.

New girl here for whatever reason really likes me and rates way on up there for her Dober magnetivity towards me. One of those Dobemans that are just more content if they are touching you or right by your side.

Snugglebug is the word I use to describe how she likes to sleep at night. :)
 
Well after putting away Annie's overnight crate in our bedroom, I was contemplating putting away the bigger one that's in our breakfast room. I really only use it when we leave the house for a length of time. And lately I've been thinking that she doesn't really know if we were outside gardening or if we left for town. 🤷‍♀️. Honestly, we're in and out of the house so many times that she knows we're coming back and I thought, why even crate her? I still had the gates that we used to keep her in the kitchen, breakfast, laundry room, powder room 😆 area and I thought well, maybe we'll leave her out and just close her into that area. Don't let her have free reign of the house and also separate her from Kali.

So one day when we were running to our son's house and knew we were only going to be gone about an hour or so, we did just that. And she was fine! I looked at the camera and she was looking out the door when we left and then went to sleep on her pillow. No big deal.

So then Saturday night we went out to dinner with our son and his family and we did the same thing.

When I came in the door I wanted to get a picture of her to kind of show what she was doing and how she reacted when we came home. So I took one picture from the garage door with the Sun blurring the picture.
20250503_191821.webp

And I walk closer and I took another picture.
20250503_191827.webp

And then I was right up to her and she still hasn't moved and I took another picture.
20250503_191830.webp
And then I was like, are you breathing? I actually said that out loud! Suddenly as I looked at her I thought she was dead! 😳 I actually thought she was dead. Just the way she was laying there with her head hanging off the pillow. And I wasn't even looking at her face to see if her eyes were open. I was looking to see if she was breathing!

By then I was yelling at her... Annie? Annie? Finally she moved!! But I'm telling you, she gave me a freaking heart attack! My husband came in and I was wide-eyed and he's like what's the matter? I said oh my God I thought she died! All I could think about was that she ate something while we were gone and she died! Oh my God. So that was Um ..eventful. 😵‍💫I think she was so used to us coming and going that it wasn't like she was going to jump up and be happy to see us, you know? She was just laying there like oh, you're back. 🙄

Okaaaay LOL
 

Back
Top