What Would You Do? Possible i.d. of Dogbite Owner

Oh Little Oji

Hot Topics Subscriber
$ Forum Donor $
Just a little probe for your opinions.

I just saw someone from the neighborhood post that their son had been bitten by a small dog. The description of the dogs and the fact there were two of them that were being walked by a man, and the location, lead me to think I may know who the man is and where he lives.

It's an older/elderly man who walks/runs his two little dogs on my street. It happens he is the guy who, early on in our living at this house had to endure Oji charging his two little dogs, having run out of my yard and crossing the street. It had to be darn near terrifying for the man, having a Doberman intensely making a beeline for his two little dogs. I knew Oji would not bite the dogs, but I ran after him and got him under control and apologized twice to the man, who didn't accept it, saying "It's not the dog's fault, but he has to be kept under control!"

Anyway, subsequent to that, I tried to smile and nod at him when I'd see him, but he did not return the efforts. So I just ignore him now. Just this morning, I had to pull over and almost stand in the street with morning traffic as I held our toddler in my arms, and had our older daughter with me. as I commanded Oji to not bark at his dogs as we passed each other in a cramped situation.

Not to get too far afield here though...

The person whose child was allegedly bitten today says they just want to avoid unnecessary medical procedures for their child by being able to talk to the dog owner. Who knows if that's true, or if they really want to go after the man.

I've been on the side of this where my Dobe has bitten (nipped) a child and it's extremely difficult. I'm quite sympathetic.

If I told these folks where this guy lives, I would make sure I tell them that I am not certain it's him. They would know if they met him.

What would you do?
 
Personally, I'd tell them, but privately not publicly on a post in something like Facebook or Nextdoor. He sounds like a jerk in the first place, the way he's responded to your friendly efforts, and sorry but my impression of you/how you treat me reflects on how I respond to future concerns/situations. Hopefully they really do just want to speak with him- could be just a matter of proof of rabies and avoiding a shot for their kiddo.
 
First of all, ask yourself if you'd never had any unpleasant dealings with this guy & his 2 dogs, but the description fit him perfectly, would you have different thoughts? Why do you hesitate at all? If the bitten child family goes to meet him and it's NOT his dogs, they will just say, sorry, wrong person and go on. So he won't be falsely accused, you are just providing a suggestion so they can find the dog that bit the child. If it IS his dog that bit the child, you might help the family save a lot of grief with rabies shots for their child. I can see where he might get really pissy with you if he finds out you "told", but if he fits the description, he fits the description. And who knows, the victims might say immediately "oh, nope, I've seen that guy & his dogs, it wasn't him", then thank you for your input.
 
First of all, ask yourself if you'd never had any unpleasant dealings with this guy & his 2 dogs, but the description fit him perfectly, would you have different thoughts? Why do you hesitate at all? If the bitten child family goes to meet him and it's NOT his dogs, they will just say, sorry, wrong person and go on. So he won't be falsely accused, you are just providing a suggestion so they can find the dog that bit the child. If it IS his dog that bit the child, you might help the family save a lot of grief with rabies shots for their child. I can see where he might get really pissy with you if he finds out you "told", but if he fits the description, he fits the description. And who knows, the victims might say immediately "oh, nope, I've seen that guy & his dogs, it wasn't him", then thank you for your input.
Okay, I asked myself that question and I don't think it would change my thinking/feeling on this. I don't harbor any resentment toward the man, really, which is saying something for me. He just appears to be a rather unfriendly, possibly unhappy older man. Hey, I'm pretty unhappy seeming a lot of the time and don't like dealing with people.

I just hesitate to tell them because, as I said, I've been in the shoes of the offending dog's owner. (In my case, my Dobe just had a problem with kids and a toddler made a beeline for his face on the sidewalk). It seems to me that people are hyper accusatory and reactive and even litigious if a dog ever even nips someone.

At the same time (and I don't know how this works medically) if them being able to be shown shot records by the man would avoid more needles being put in their son or whatever then I'm probably all for telling them who the guy is.

Hmmmmmm.
 
You, know... I don't know what I would do. There are a lot of easily identifiable dogs and owners in our neighborhood so if I saw something similar on Facebook, I would be in your exact position.

So, if they can't find the dog they will have to go to the Dr's? In Illinois, if you take a child to a Dr for a dog bite, the police legally have to be notified by the Dr. From there, they do an investigation with animal control.

If it was this guy and these dogs, it doesn't sound like he'd be cooperative anyway so would the police be called then?

Can you anonymously call the police or animal control and describe the situation and that you suspect you know the offending dog but don't want to get involved?

Not trying to minimize what the family is going through but it sounds like it was not a serious incident or the child had provoked the dog somehow? It doesn't sound like the dog jumped a fence and attacked the kid walking by. Or was it serious enough that the child and parents left the scene to take care of the child and the guy just meandered off?

Sounds like an odd situation all around.
 
I read posts on FB where people were complaining about these 2 out of control rottweilers running off leash in the area. I thought wow, that would be scary. Some time later, I saw a couple walking 2 rotts and they were perfectly well behaved, sniffing, marking, had zero reactivity when they saw kids on bikes zip past them. Then when I started working from home, I would go on lunch time walks through the neighborhood and guess what I found - two more households with rotts! And that's just on my walking route. It made me think that matching a description is probably a lot harder than it seems.

For your situation, I wonder, where were the parents when the kid got bit?
 
Im curious if the child was with any other witnesses at the time. Honestly, they should have called the police as soon as the child mentioned it. Theres nothing police can really do if it becomes a he said-she said type deal. Especially days after the incident. Unless there were several witnesses. Even then, the question will be asked: why didn’t you file a police report to document the event?

So if it were me, I probably wouldn’t say anything. Unless I saw the incident take place. Its easy to assume things. Its up to the parents to follow up with local authorities and handle the situation. Its likely that the local dog officer would know who these dogs were from previous complaints. I find that we get a lot of dog complaints that are almost 80% the same dogs.

Im not a parent, but wouldn’t you rather your kid get the rabies shot to be on the safe side? Yeah it sucks. Life sucks sometimes, but rabies is a terrible disease. Better not to take chances. And this is coming from me, who hasn’t gotten a flu shot since I was 17.

Guess thats my opinion. May be wrong, but I usually stay out of peoples business.
 
Some more information on this:

I don't know if the parent(s) saw the incident.

It happened on the grounds of the school our daughter goes to.

The parents say they just want to talk to the man in order to avoid more medical procedures or whatever.

That, just above, is probably the only reason I'm feeling inclined to tell the folks where the man lives. I guess they tugged the right heart string in me.

It's pretty darn sure that I do have the correct guy in mind. If I weren't at least fairly sure, I probably wouldn't say anything. The description of the man and dogs and the vicinity of the incident (he pretty much walks a loop that I've figured out) make it fairly certain.

I did go ahead and contact the parents and after I described the man and his dogs, they say it's spot on.

I stressed to the parents that I am sympathetic to both sides, and also that I've not seen the man with a wife or with anyone but his two dogs, and that those dogs probably mean an awful lot to the man, and I'd hate to see one of them get taken away from him even temporarily. I told them I don't want to enable a situation where anyone is gone after excessively in terms of legally or anything.

I contacted them via private message; but another party replied on the open forum and gave a basic description of the man and that they always see him walking the dogs on a street which pretty much confirms that I have the correct man in mind.
 
Maybe they are just looking for a rabies certificate. I can definitely sympathize with the dog owner if it was a one time minor incident. Hopefully everything works out okay in both ends and these dogs don’t bite anyone else.
 
I think you did the right thing @Oh Little Oji - update this post if you learn more about the incident, I'm curious how it goes. Dog bites are a serious matter, especially involving children and the only escape one can get from responsibility is if someone climbed your fence and was on your property uninvited. Anytime anyone has a dog in public they are and should be in control of their dog(s) at all time. Sh!t happens, I know it does. Hopefully the child was at fault for badgering the dog and the dog has all vaccines documented and the case will just be a hard lesson for kids and the old man with 2 dogs.
 
you probably did the right thing. I know when animal control gets involved, they require the dog to be checked by a vet within like 10 days of the incident to ensure they do not have Rabies or something along those lines. Again, without those folks being involved, it sounds like they're just going to have to believe whatever the guy says.

I think you did the right thing @Oh Little Oji - update this post if you learn more about the incident, I'm curious how it goes. Dog bites are a serious matter, especially involving children and the only escape one can get from responsibility is if someone climbed your fence and was on your property uninvited. Anytime anyone has a dog in public they are and should be in control of their dog(s) at all time. Sh!t happens, I know it does. Hopefully the child was at fault for badgering the dog and the dog has all vaccines documented and the case will just be a hard lesson for kids and the old man with 2 dogs.

I know for our 'incident,' luckily there was video footage so it was ruled "provoked" even though it was in a public place. My dog was under control the entire time but was provoked and responded as dogs do. Certainly not a 'free pass' but a better scenario for us as the dog owners and demonstrated that my dog was not 'at fault.' UGH.
 

Back
Top