The Silliest Doberman Myth I've Ever Heard

I want to clarify: I don't have anything against pit bulls as a breed, my room ate has a pit mix and he's a bundle of joy.. But I never trust a pit bull until I know the owner very well and know how to owner treats the dog.. An owner doesn't have to abuse a dog for the dog to be aggressive... If an owner doesn't make it very clear that they are alpha, the dog (of any breed) will become very dominant and in turn will probably show signs of aggression.. The reason why I am more careful around pits than any other breed is because pit bulls are genetically made to be alpha dogs (obviously there are exceptions, but I'm talking about the breed in general) everyone here knows that dobermans were the same way, and in some cases still are.. They are both very intelligent breeds and if you don't have control of them they have control of you, which I believe was the case with this lady.. She didn't even try to pull the dog away from Brandi..
Oh and the whole situation was kind of difficult to describe, but when I had my hand on brandis collar she was laying down on her side half asleep.. She is lazy to begin with but after an hour of play she was pooped, when the pit came running up Brandi looked up and growled a little, and when the pit stopped she put her head down again and I let go of the collar, but when the pit lunged for her throat I grabbed her collar without even thinking, I guess to try to pull her out of the way because her eyes were closed and she had no idea what was about to happen.
 
I want to clarify: I don't have anything against pit bulls as a breed, my room ate has a pit mix and he's a bundle of joy.. But I never trust a pit bull until I know the owner very well and know how to owner treats the dog.. An owner doesn't have to abuse a dog for the dog to be aggressive... If an owner doesn't make it very clear that they are alpha, the dog (of any breed) will become very dominant and in turn will probably show signs of aggression.. The reason why I am more careful around pits than any other breed is because pit bulls are genetically made to be alpha dogs (obviously there are exceptions, but I'm talking about the breed in general) everyone here knows that dobermans were the same way, and in some cases still are.. They are both very intelligent breeds and if you don't have control of them they have control of you, which I believe was the case with this lady.. She didn't even try to pull the dog away from Brandi..
Oh and the whole situation was kind of difficult to describe, but when I had my hand on brandis collar she was laying down on her side half asleep.. She is lazy to begin with but after an hour of play she was pooped, when the pit came running up Brandi looked up and growled a little, and when the pit stopped she put her head down again and I let go of the collar, but when the pit lunged for her throat I grabbed her collar without even thinking, I guess to try to pull her out of the way because her eyes were closed and she had no idea what was about to happen.

No, it's fine, I wasn't there so I was just going off of what you said. Her laying down probably startled her even more with a dog and a person over top of her. I assume she was most likely just giving the pit a warning that she didn't appreciate that much over top of her at one time, and that can easily make the pit excited enough to a level of "lets go pal!" You are right in being cautious with pit bulls that you don't know. I do that with any dog I don't know. Like I said...unfortunately, there are lots of idiots that own pit bulls being that they are "popular" now a days, and unfortunately it sounds like that lady was one of them. In my opinion, I just thought there probably could have been better choice words. You want to set yourself as a good example of the breed and not stoop to their level. I can imagine how difficult it would have been though, to keep your calm after going through that.

Hoo, maybe we should have taken this to it's own thread. :P Sorry to derail.
 
I was going to start my own thread about myths until I found this one.. I can't believe some one thought they were extinct! That's hilarious! there are quite a few dobes out here.. Not as many as chihuahuas and pits but today for instance I was hanging out with 4 other dobe owners at the dog park.. Which brings me to my point.. So I'm sitting on a bench with these people, 2 of which I know very well, and one of which is a retired show breeder..and. Playing in front of us is our 4 dobermans, rooster, a 6 month female puppy, a 2 yr old female, and a 7 yr old female. A group of people walks in with a couple pit bull puppies with choke collars and super short cropped ears and the first thing they do is tell us to keep our dogs away from there's.. Well of course I call rooster over and assume they mean that their dogs rant friendly (don't know why they would bring them to the dog park but..) they find a spot and I can hear them talking about how we are trying to cause trouble by bringing dobermans around people and dogs.. And of course they reference the whole 'brain outgrowing the skull' thing.. Then they shout to us asking the ages of the dogs.. When we tell them the ages one lady says they always turn at 1 yr. So rooster and the female puppy are okay but the other two will kill you as soon as they get the chance. I don't usually start stuff with people but I felt the need to educate.. I called over Brandi, the 2 yr old female, who is the laziest dog I've ever met and took her away from our group, calling over the lady who was talking smack. I said come over here, I am holding her collar, come say hi to her and tell me that she's a killer. The lady started walking over and her pit bull followed, as the lady pet Brandi the pit bull must of had some urge to show his dominance, and ran toward Brandi, at which time Brandi stood up and showed her teeth at the pit bull.. Who then attacked her, going straight for the throat. I still had my hand on her collar and she immediately rolled over on her back in submission. The lady started screaming at ME about how Brandi tried to attack her, while her pit bull is still in the middle of trying to rip brandis throat out. Luckily brandis owner had a tazer on her and taxed the pit bull on full power, the dog fell to the ground and I immediately called the police. I was worried that Brandi (who was okay by the way) would be considered vicious by the cops until the man who owned the 7 yr old smiled and held up his camera.. He had been recording our dogs plying and got the entire attack on tape! Needless to say when the police came they didn't care what the lady said happened, they took her dog for a 10 day quarantine and wrote her a citation. I understand that the pit bull was just probably trying to protect his owner but he was obviously not trained or socialized well and I hope the lady learned her lesson... Best part about it.. After all was said and done I told the lady 'so sad, those pit bulls brains outgrow their skulls ya know.. You should get a better dog.. Like a Doberman." hahaha
I say - well done!!! (Gunnar barks his approval!)
 
Even though I don't see a lot of Dobermans and their owners in the streets of Chicago, I know we have a pretty large Doberman population here judging from the # of Dobermans I see at my Dobie's day care (3 Dobermans named 'Kaiser', and at least 12 others in our day care). Also I keep watch and will be volunteering at the Doberman rescue my girl came from (IL Doberman rescue) and I've seen a lot of Dobies come through this year - several hundred at least00000.
/
Have you started volunteering with IDR (IL Dobe Rescue)? I am a volunteer with them as well!
 
I find that most pit bull owners are highly defensive about their dogs, and offensive about everyone else's............... I strongly believe that people should be licensed to own a Pit Bull, excluding criminals, dog fighters, dope dealers, child abusers, etc.
Most I know are defensive,as they should be.Their breed is the "flavor of the decade" at the monent.Most I know aren't all that offensive about others,I guess it depends on the owner.
And on the liscense deal,carefull what you wish for.Ever hear of legal precedence? Require it for that breed and you can bet your a$$ our breed and several others will follow the trend shortly.So, in addition to liscensing your dog,now you have to get one too,and another state gvt. agency is born,because using the existing animal control would be much too simple:D and those people already have jobs.
Bottom line is these dogs have huge huge drive.Some people own them for the wrong reasons,thugs etc.Some people are idiots,true.Some others are just ignorant(and not meant in a bad way.If you dont know,you don't know) of the drive the breed has and know little about proper training of the breed.They got a dog not knowing exactly what it's capable of until it's too late.
 
/
Have you started volunteering with IDR (IL Dobe Rescue)? I am a volunteer with them as well!

I haven't yet - I've been travelling so gosh darned much since January. I'm hoping to get off the road soon and as soon as I do will be signing up to staff events, transport dogs, do adopter screenings, etc.
 
I haven't yet - I've been travelling so gosh darned much since January. I'm hoping to get off the road soon and as soon as I do will be signing up to staff events, transport dogs, do adopter screenings, etc.

If you get a chance to join IDR, I can vouch for the fact its a great group. I enjoy helping when I can. I enjoy so many people within this rescue. They are fun and an amazing group of dedicated people.
 
Most I know are defensive,as they should be.Their breed is the "flavor of the decade" at the monent.Most I know aren't all that offensive about others,I guess it depends on the owner.
And on the liscense deal,carefull what you wish for.Ever hear of legal precedence? Require it for that breed and you can bet your a$$ our breed and several others will follow the trend shortly.So, in addition to liscensing your dog,now you have to get one too,and another state gvt. agency is born,because using the existing animal control would be much too simple:D and those people already have jobs.
Bottom line is these dogs have huge huge drive.Some people own them for the wrong reasons,thugs etc.Some people are idiots,true.Some others are just ignorant(and not meant in a bad way.If you dont know,you don't know) of the drive the breed has and know little about proper training of the breed.They got a dog not knowing exactly what it's capable of until it's too late.

I understand your position Gelcoater, and maybe mine is a reflection of the fact that we have a high percentage and number of idiots who own dogs - in fact the idiots seem to be the rule, not the exception in Chicago, and there are dire consequences on the animals and the public at large.

I certainly don't want to give rise to another government agency though - we have far too many of those that we taxpayers pay for in the US, many of which don't provide any value to anyone and cost too much and do to little of the services that were intended.

Sigggghhhhh - if there were some way we could rocket the idiots to the moon, the world would be a much better place - wishful thinking I know! :rolleyes:
 
I haven't come across any Doberman myths here yet (people are just inexplicably afraid), but I do have a great example of stupidity from a couple of weeks ago:

I was standing outside an ATM shelter, waiting for a friend, and a group of three guys come up and stand in the line.
One guy comments to the others: oh look, Doberman.
His friend turns around and says: no way, that is not a Doberman. Dobermans have ears that stand up.
The first guy insists: no, I'm telling you, it's a Doberman. Ask her, if you don't believe me.
So, his friend turns to me: what breed of dog is that?
I say: it's a Doberman.
In disbelief, the guy examines my dog, he then replies in defiance: it CAN'T be a Doberman, Dobermans are big.
Me: ... it's 4 months old.
 
His friend turns around and says: no way, that is not a Doberman. Dobermans have ears that stand up.
Me: ... it's 4 months old.
It amazes me how few people realize they are a docked/cropped breed. For all the controversy out there about the procedures we've run into several people that had no idea. Scary how ignorant the general public is and yet they are voting on these issues when they come up.
Oh you didn't know? Dobes are born adults, LOL!
 
It amazes me how few people realize they are a docked/cropped breed. For all the controversy out there about the procedures we've run into several people that had no idea. Scary how ignorant the general public is and yet they are voting on these issues when they come up.
Oh you didn't know? Dobes are born adults, LOL!

Dobermans are so badass, they don't have babies! They're the only breed to reproduce by way of mitosis, you didn't know? :D
 
I have read most of the comments on here, and i have to laugh! Extinct...ya thats funny...I was walking Rogue today in a busy down town area where there was a lot of people during lunch hour (to get him acquainted with a lot of people around him, per part of my training exercise)....he walks on my left and there are people coming toward us, and i hear one lady say to her friend she was with "move over move over look at that dog"....really lady like i was going to "sick" my dog on you...like i have nothing better to do on my walk than ruin your day....Here i am trying to teach my dog to be in an environment with lots of people and noises and i have this sham of an idiot telling her friend to move over....Come ON! i Hate that people get the wrong view or misconception of the Doberman breed.....uggg so annoying!
ps...i swear since i have Rogue he has barked MAYBE 5 times if that....this dog doesnt bark at anything....doesnt even growl....will it come? lol And this lady is afraid of a dog walking by her! HA!
 
It amazes me how few people realize they are a docked/cropped breed. For all the controversy out there about the procedures we've run into several people that had no idea. Scary how ignorant the general public is and yet they are voting on these issues when they come up.
Oh you didn't know? Dobes are born adults, LOL!
Yep.When Daisy was about 7 months old a guy I know asked how long she had to grow before her ears would stand:D
 

Back
Top