• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

The good and bad of crate training

Con: A crying puppy in a crate pulls at your heart strings
Funny but true. Invest in some earplugs. Hahaha But that doesn't prevent the neighbor's from hearing it.
I warned my immediate neighbor's that they would probably hear whining and barking, but all of them usually have their AC on and can't hear it as loudly so they don't mind.
With all the dogs on our street we have a serious doggy telegraph that seems to go on for about 10mins until whoever is walking on the street makes it to the last house.
You can tell where the person is in the street by which dog is barking. Lol
 
I am on my fourth dobie. The first 2 were rescues, Chaos was 2 and crate trained when I brought him home. Greta was 9 months and pretty much lived in her crate unless she was outside before she came home. Drake and Rumor both had been started on crate training when I brought them home. Now that we are way past the crazy puppy stage with Drake he is out in the house most of the time. However he does get his crate time as a reminder. Rumor has been great in her crate. The first night she whimpered for just a second or two and now she just settles down and goes to sleep.
All crates away from anything that can be grabbed and pulled in or chewed. The naughty puppy thread taught me that. ;)
 
Biggest "pro" for a total novice owner (of any breed)...it made house training a complete breeze. In fact, I don't know how I could have done it successfully without the crate.
Biggest "con"...a dog who is SO comfy and accustomed to sleeping in his crate at night that no matter how much I want him to snuggle up in bed with me, he just can't settle on the bed. We are making progress here...In the past, he wanted his crate door closed in order to feel the most "at home." Now we leave it open (as well as the bedroom door.) Now, he kind of moves about throughout the night...crate, my bed, couch, ottoman in living room, etc.
 
Another pro and the reason my older brother and sister in law couldn't bring their dogs: Lets you be able to spend the night at family events because your dogs are crate trained. Brother's dogs aren't so they were told they couldn't bring their dogs. Big surprise, the dogs also are not well behaved and jump on furniture, counter surf, etc. They decided not to board their dogs so they had to turn around the same day to get back to their dogs. Too bad...

Java and Paige are often invited to family events because my family knows they are well behaved and if they start getting too rowdy, they are also crate trained! Never would even know they are there... its sooo nice.

One of my brother's dogs got locked behind a door and the dog ripped up their newly applied carpet on the stairs. :shock: Major separation anxiety... correct crate training would fix that ;)
 
I am absolutely pro crate training!! But here is a con:

You have the most stubborn dog on the planet that will bark ALL.NIGHT.LONG for WEEKS... and you live in a small dollhouse with paper thin walls and a husband whose crazy schedule doesn't allow him to sleep well to begin with. :pullhair::pullhair::pullhair::help:
I didn't realize we have that in common too – living in a house where noises travel throughout.
 
I can crate Oji in the basement and his carrying on is clearly heard on the second floor. Part of it is that the sound travels through the HVAC ductwork. I want to record his various noises and piece them together in a compilation. It would be hilarious.

Now we have a detached garage (which we did not have in the earlier days of Oji's residence here) but even when crated inside a car inside that garage, he is able to disturb the neighbor whose house is behind the garage.

Then there is the fact he will try to break out of the crate if stressed. If I were to invest big bucks in a crate tough enough to handle his craziness, more of the damage would simply be shared by his teeth.

Consider also the fact that he was a giant crate pee-er and poop-er for a long time.

Still the crate, with no doubt, has saved our home and belongings major damage and probably his health.
 
Biggest "pro" for a total novice owner (of any breed)...it made house training a complete breeze. In fact, I don't know how I could have done it successfully without the crate.

Except my dippy dog STILL PEES IN HER CRATE!!! No one was paying attention this afternoon while I was baking, and SHE WENT INTO HER CRATE JUST TO PEE!! WTF! :banghead::censored::facepalm::furious::pullhair::complain:
 
Except my dippy dog STILL PEES IN HER CRATE!!! No one was paying attention this afternoon while I was baking, and SHE WENT INTO HER CRATE JUST TO PEE!! WTF! :banghead::censored::facepalm::furious::pullhair::complain:

You were BAKING, Sarah...she thinks that soothes you, and also that she might get a yummy; she did not want to disturb your progress!
But...I'm with Tad...scoot that thing outside and see if it still resembles the toilet to her!
Somehow, I did not know Mischa was still doing this....maybe because all of our conversations are "all about me??!!"...I'll work on that!!!
 
You were BAKING, Sarah...she thinks that soothes you, and also that she might get a yummy; she did not want to disturb your progress!
But...I'm with Tad...scoot that thing outside and see if it still resembles the toilet to her!
Somehow, I did not know Mischa was still doing this....maybe because all of our conversations are "all about me??!!"...I'll work on that!!!

Oh shhhhhh! Lol its not super often, but it's often enough to tick me off. I really thought "logically" wed be done this by almost 2 years old. I even accidentally fed her in a "wet crate"... and after it was too late, figured maybe that would make her stop by eating pee flavored food... but no luck on that one! She's just plain weird, and apparently impossible
 
I really want us to have a thread of audio recordings...us talking to our dogs (mostly to make fun of each other...well, y'all would definitely make fun of me), the sounds our dogs make when they do different things, and their sleeping/dreaming sounds! I guess it would have to go ahead and be video and put up with YouTube, because I don't know if you could add "voice memos" from phone...
Yep...I AM this much of a nerd. I love your dogs so much I need to hear them "talk!"
 
I take into account that he may make the crate move.
LOL, our friend couldn't believe how Boris could make that crate jump across the floor when he came over. Every time we'd get together he'd have to tell people how that's the first dog he's ever seen being able to do that. ;)
I really want us to have a thread of audio recordings...us talking to our dogs (mostly to make fun of each other...well, y'all would definitely make fun of me), the sounds our dogs make when they do different things, and their sleeping/dreaming sounds! I guess it would have to go ahead and be video and put up with YouTube, because I don't know if you could add "voice memos" from phone...
Yep...I AM this much of a nerd. I love your dogs so much I need to hear them "talk!"
LOL I have lots of You Tube videos of both me talking silly to the dogs and them talking to each other or themselves. It's very endearing to me.
 
When it's food time Bogie gets all bunny hopping/running and slams inside his crate and moves it about 3' across the room then lowers his head and looks at you like...oh boy, oh boy, oh boy, FOOD YAY!! He makes this high pitched yippibg sound like a little kid that sees Santa by their Christmas tree on Christmas Eve. He is very chatty and squeals like a kid. Pretty comical at times.
He looks at me first thing in the morning and does his growly chatting, then stretching his paws toward my face, then rolls over on me like "Are you awake yet mom?"
It is endearing to me. Lol
He is just a huge dufus!!
 
I can crate Oji in the basement and his carrying on is clearly heard on the second floor. Part of it is that the sound travels through the HVAC ductwork. I want to record his various noises and piece them together in a compilation. It would be hilarious.
Our house is all tile floors and ceilings that arch up to 12' so the acoustics really make the barking and whining echo and loud.
 
When it's food time Bogie gets all bunny hopping/running and slams inside his crate and moves it about 3' across the room then lowers his head and looks at you like...oh boy, oh boy, oh boy, FOOD YAY!! He makes this high pitched yippibg sound like a little kid that sees Santa by their Christmas tree on Christmas Eve. He is very chatty and squeals like a kid. Pretty comical at times.
He looks at me first thing in the morning and does his growly chatting, then stretching his paws toward my face, then rolls over on me like "Are you awake yet mom?"
It is endearing to me. Lol
He is just a huge dufus!!

See??!!...We need to hear these things!
 

Back
Top