• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

The good and bad of crate training

GennyB

Moderator
Hot Topics Subscriber
The Good
1. IMO, it teaches the dog to calm themselves
2. Keeps them safe from their own natural curiosity. Who needs a blockage right?
3. Helps tremendously should the dog have an injury and needs to be on rest.
4. Gives everybody sanity, especially during the crazy puppy stage.

I'm sure there are other good reasons, the ones I listed are the biggies for me. Feel free to add to the list.
The Bad
1. Okay, I've got nothing except maybe the crap you take from people that think you are being cruel.

I recently had a nasty experience on the topic. Thought it would be interesting to hear both sides.
Let's hear your thoughts....
 
Cons:
Dog cant sleep except in crate (Nero will lay down and relax for a few minutes but never falls asleep outside if his crate. )
Crate over use?

I think the pros outweigh the cons though and gradually as he spends more and more time outside his crate he will learn to relax outside it too.
 
Cons... Can't think of one! I do have a crate pad that Rubie gets during the day but we take her blanket out. She has pulled some of the stuffing out of her pad when she's really agitated during the day but that's the worst we've had.
 
Crating off and on and during training sessions and right after allows the dog to absorb what they just learned. It reinforces behavior and helps in becoming a routine that keeps them more focus each training session so your training is more productive.
 
It reinforces behavior and helps in becoming a routine that keeps them more focus each training session so your training is more productive.
This is what my trainer insists I do with the pups. Crating is an essential part of their training!
Also if you travel and need to take your dogs, they need to be comfortable in their crate when at someone else's home, a hotel, or even a hurricane shelter if you live in an area where there is a hurricane season.
Also while crated they cannot chew/swallow 'rocks', 'plants' or chew sheetrock or furniture.:D
 
I love the flexibility of the crate. He can be confined when it is necessary, without undue stress on him.
Also, if he ever has to be left at a veterinarian’s office, being in a crate then will be far less stressful as he's already crate-trained.

The only other bad side I see (alongside the one where uneducated people see it as cruel!) is where people abuse the whole idea of the crate, for example...a dog being left in one for excessive amounts of time. Not good!
 
Unless the crate is too close to the wall. LOL :facepalm:
:rofl::rofl::rofl::rofl: Omg I lost it on that one. I remember that picture. I also remember @GennyB making a note to herself not to put the crate next to a wall or furniture. Wasn't it @Doberman Gang that had their couch chewed from the crate being next to it?
Hahaha, ok I am starting to feel better. Lol
 
I am absolutely pro crate training!! But here is a con:

You have the most stubborn dog on the planet that will bark ALL.NIGHT.LONG for WEEKS... and you live in a small dollhouse with paper thin walls and a husband whose crazy schedule doesn't allow him to sleep well to begin with. :pullhair::pullhair::pullhair::help:
 
I am absolutely pro crate training!! But here is a con:

You have the most stubborn dog on the planet that will bark ALL.NIGHT.LONG for WEEKS... and you live in a small dollhouse with paper thin walls and a husband whose crazy schedule doesn't allow him to sleep well to begin with. :pullhair::pullhair::pullhair::help:
Is that Miesha doing that?
 
Is that Miesha doing that?

Haha, im actually posting about it on her Sick thread too because i'm at my wits end!

That's what she did when she was younger.. we fell asleep with her on our bed one night and she slept the whole night through.. we did it another couple nights and realized that a queen sized bed and a Dober-affe was not conducive to a good night sleep... tried to recrate train her and she barked all night long for over a week and a half. [It took us a long time to physically recover from the sleep deprivation too!]
After that, late one night Hubs forgot to put her away when he went to bed and she slept on the couch through the night and for months would come get me in the morning to let her out. So that is how we left it.

In the last several months she has been having issues with accidents and getting me up couple times a night. The accidents would happen at most a couple times a week, not all the time. It also wasn't UTI related [neg UA].. We would pick up her water at 8pm too. Occasionally it would correspond with her GI issues. Funny thing is she would still come get me right after the accident to go out and so i'd clean it up... so the mental connection is there.

If we had a bigger house i wouldn't hesitate.. or if we had a king sized bed even, just let her sleep with us so i'd more easily know when she needed to go out. We just screwed things up [and i knew better too!! :facepalm:] and now are suffering for it. Anyone who asks me about crate training, i give them the low down and tell them to stick with it AT ALL COSTS!!!!!!!
 
Anyone who asks me about crate training, i give them the low down and tell them to stick with it AT ALL COSTS!!!!!!!
Bacall will sleep through the night with the occasional annoyed groan but Bogie will wake up every hour and whine and then start the barking.
They sleep with me but a couple times a week I put them in their crate overnight just to keep it fresh in their mind. Hahaha
 
Mischa is a crate barker. We got her a bark collar. Now she is a crate digger. :rofl: you should see the marks on her crate... she learned how to make noise without getting shocked when she made about being in there lol!! I usually have to tell her to "lay down, it's night night" 3 times before she actually settles at bed time. (Not at one time... she lay, then about 5 mins after I leave the room she starts again, then rinse dry repeat)
 
Mischa is a crate barker. We got her a bark collar. Now she is a crate digger. :rofl: you should see the marks on her crate... she learned how to make noise without getting shocked when she made about being in there lol!! I usually have to tell her to "lay down, it's night night" 3 times before she actually settles at bed time. (Not at one time... she lay, then about 5 mins after I leave the room she starts again, then rinse dry repeat)
Hahah.. i was torn between funny and empathetic!

Don't know if this is technically a Con but- Dogs that eat their beds when in their crate. I wish there was a kevlar cushion or some other indestructible Superhero fabric that they cant destroy. I hate the idea of cold hard bed... and she certainly doesn't like it either or she wouldn't sleep on the couch! Tank switches from dog bed to floor 4-5 times a night but he has a hell of a lot more meat/fur for cushion!
 
All of the pros that have been listed that I can think of.

The only con I can think of is that it takes quite a footprint in the living room when you have the giant size but it's well worth it and Albert would be heartbroken if I took his "den" away, so it stays.

I remember when we had our terror Boxer pup who got into everything. It was really before the days of crates being used much so we wound up tying him to the wall when we left. Otherwise our couch would be dragged across the room, the fridge was open and he would get pretty much everything out, he'd get into knives in knife blocks in the kitchen and the list goes on and on.
 
I remember when we had our terror Boxer pup who got into everything. It was really before the days of crates being used much so we wound up tying him to the wall when we left. Otherwise our couch would be dragged across the room, the fridge was open and he would get pretty much everything out, he'd get into knives in knife blocks in the kitchen and the list goes on and on.
Holy moly!!!
I could not imagine that, well maybe I could with these two if I didn't have the mats to keep them out of the kitchen.
That would be a total nightmare Jan.
Sheetrock is easy for me to repair so I don't go ballistic but I still need to learn how to curb this behavior, quickly!
 

Back
Top