• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Spaying or managing?

Spay or wait?


  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .

Anunukai

Member
Wich is better for a female dog's health(a female who is not intended to be bred).Spaying her at 1 yr old or just 'managing' her as an intact female until later on.(There was a study on rotties that suggested spaying at 5-6 yrs of age improved longevity and had a reduced bone/skin cancer risk.I have lost 2 dogs to cancer and I do NOT want to again-both diagnosed after being spayed/neutered)
I have NO problem managing an intact female.Never had an issue.What do you all think? Spay now or wait till she's older?
 
LOL this should be a fun topic ! :p When it comes to cancer, frankly I think its a coin toss either way. My sis in law had a female that was not spayed until 6 yrs old. Cancer. I had a dog that was Spayed as a pup, CANCER. A friend has a dog that is not spayed. Cancer. I think this for people too.. there are some families with no history of cancer, then someone comes down wtih it. I think its just a gene that like a light switch can get turned off or on for one reason or another, whether is environmental or in the genes.

There are pros and cons to each argument.
 
On the flip side of spaying, I'm going to wait to nueter my male. He's 10 months now, and I have done a TON of research and it seems neither side really wins. However it does seem most PROFESSIONAL Doberman owners, and I mean the one's that have had Dobe's their entire lives, seem to keep them in-tact.
 
Wich is better for a female dog's health(a female who is not intended to be bred).Spaying her at 1 yr old or just 'managing' her as an intact female until later on.(There was a study on rotties that suggested spaying at 5-6 yrs of age improved longevity and had a reduced bone/skin cancer risk.I have lost 2 dogs to cancer and I do NOT want to again-both diagnosed after being spayed/neutered)
I have NO problem managing an intact female.Never had an issue.What do you all think? Spay now or wait till she's older?

I believe the rottweiler study you refer to was done only on males so is useful to reference in a neutering debate. There seems to be a big difference between the effects of spaying at an early age and neutering at an early age.

From the studies that I've read, there does not seem to be enough health benefit to leaving a one year old bitch intact to outweigh the risk of pyometra and the inconvenience of having a bitch coming into heat. No matter what you choose to do, you are not going to have a girl that had an early spay, and early (pre 6 months of age) spays are what seem to cause health problems.
 
Leaving a female animal intact (specially if she's not bred and/or is given hormones to control heatcycles) will increase the risk of uterine tumors. If she's not beeing bred she will be experiencing false pregnancies after every heat season (yes, they do, but not every dog will collect toys and try protect them and to raise them as puppies) with a lot of hormones coming into play. The after effects of a false pregnancy may be infections in the uterus and breasts and is also very painful for the dog. I'd say its better to do it now than to wait 4-5 years and then have to do it just because she might be in pain after getting an infected uterus.
 
Early spay/neuter has been shown to lead to a host of troubles all it's own. The growth plates don't close till around 2 years of age, and early spay/neuter changes the hormone levels of the dog, thus impacting a host of other issues.
I personally do NOT recommend to anyone that they alter before 2 years of age unless it is for a major medical issue!
 
in my opinion leave them unless a medical reason. I think the riskof cancer is a hit or miss to be honest.
 
Oh, Kim, you are right....this will be fun..:eek: ..lol I'm just gonna state what I did and what I can live with. I know there is so much controversy on this issue and I've heard both sides til I'm crazy. I really don't know what to believe so I do whats good for ME.

Years ago, when I had my little Pomeranians, one had developed a tumor or cyst on her breast and the vet then told me if she was spayed before her first heat, they don't develop these. So my next one I spayed before her first heat. She never developed a tumor like that and she lived 5 years longer than the last Pom. She died at 18yo. And I believe it was a stroke that took her. :(

My first Doberman was my first male dog and believe it or not I did not neuter him until he was about 6! I never had any issues with him and I seldom gave it a thought until we moved out here. He seemed to develop a 'roving eye'! lol I had him neutered ASAP! And he died 4 years later to cancer. :(

My next Dobie was a girl that was already spayed when I got her and that was done later in life too. She died of Leukemia at 10 years old too. :(

When I got Buddy, being he was male, I didn't have to worry about having to fix him before or after any heat cycles ;) so I thought I would let him develop a bit. I decided I wanted to wait at least a year and I was lucky because I wasn't going through the summer months of waiting. I did not want to worry about him with Spring in the air and outside a lot! He also had done a bit of marking in my basement on a piece of exercise equipment that was from my sis....her dogs scent was on it and I'm sure that is why he marked it. But I was :nono::nono: I didn't want to start that! :eek: We were just going into Spring and Buddy had turned 1 year old in January. So for Buddy, it all worked out well to be neutered in April. He was 15 months old, Spring had just sprung and I felt he had matured well AND did not get all into the 'male' thing! I feel it was a good choice. For both he and I! I think he developed well and his temperament is perfect.

Kali was adopted and I had no choice in her spay. She was spayed in March so the guess is she was 5 months old when it was done. That seems early to me now, but if I were to do it before her first heat, it's probably about right. If I had her before that time I may have waited a month or two. Just my feeling.

I am a pet person and despite the fact that I allowed my first Doberman to go so long without a neuter, I am not one to want to worry about an intact dog. If you're not a breeder or showing, I believe in s/n. I guess it's a matter of when. People have strong opinions on this like a few other topics. :) As you can see from this 'track record', I don't see any rhyme or reason with s/n and cancer or any other disease. I think our dogs are all becoming susceptible to cancer more and more and I don't think it has anything to do with when you s/n. At this point in my life, after losing so many pets to cancer, I'm just waiting for the other shoe to drop.

I also think there is a bigger portion of people that are usually not on a forum like this asking questions! ;) They are the ones I worry about. My :2cents
 
My Buddy very nice to have a history to share of your experiences. I do agree there is a big rush by the PETA/HSUS folks especially to spay / neuter way too early. Sadly some breeder are so neurotic that they do not consider the health of the puppy and will spay before the puppy leaves. For males I prefer they wait til 15 months at least and 18 months to me is perfect. For females the first heat cycle can increase their chance of cancer considerably so I prefer they be spayed at 10 months.

Heat cycles are hard on their systems if they are not going to be used for a program and there is always the chance that even though you are managing something decides to come visiting and then the choice is gone and mutts are on the way. I feel it is far better for a pet family to spay/neuter based on the above.

To add: and it would be sad if a male did roam because then you don't know what he has bred or not plus he could be shot or run over. Nope spaying/neutering is far better than to take that chance. JMHO
 
My Buddy very nice to have a history to share of your experiences. Yes, thank you, that's why I posted when I know this is a touchy subject. lol And if you look at that history, it's enough to make me crazy because nothing seems to make sense. I do agree there is a big rush by the PETA/HSUS folks especially to spay / neuter way too early. Sadly some breeder are so neurotic that they do not consider the health of the puppy and will spay before the puppy leaves. For males I prefer they wait til 15 months at least and 18 months to me is perfect. For females the first heat cycle can increase their chance of cancer considerably so I prefer they be spayed at 10 months. So I did ok on Buddy, as far as you are concerned! ;) But you say for females to spay before the first heat...is 10 months too late? I guess I was thinking they go into heat around 7 months. Again, it's been awhile since I had a pup and had to go through that! lol

Heat cycles are hard on their systems if they are not going to be used for a program and there is always the chance that even though you are managing something decides to come visiting and then the choice is gone and mutts are on the way. I feel it is far better for a pet family to spay/neuter based on the above. Me too. For the average Joe (and that's me too!) it's the way to go! For your next sentence too! :eek:

To add: and it would be sad if a male did roam because then you don't know what he has bred or not plus he could be shot or run over. Nope spaying/neutering is far better than to take that chance. JMHO
 
My guys usually don't come in for the first time til after 10 months sometime between then and 12 months. Of course if you have one come in early then you would just miss it and spay before next cycle.

There is a lot of controversy about it. I do feel there is enough real evidence that too early is not good. They do need the hormones etc for development.

I do feel that a pet person usually does not want to be bothered with all the precautions and constant watching that has to be done if they are left in tact. I also feel it is not worth the risk that a male get out and populate the neighborhood mutt community. It will also help avoid any aggression issues that might develop due a a very frustrated dog which does happen. They don't know why they are craxy they just know that they have needs that are not being met. It is very frustrating to them to have to fight nature everytime a bitch is in season somewhere. I read once that a dog can SMELL a bitch in season up to 5 miles away and I know I had a little MUTT show up at my door in the country - he had a name tag on and I called and gave them what for for not neutering him.

They said we got him from a family that got rid of him because he roamed. DUH!!! I told them he did not contribute anything that anyone with purebreeds wanted in their gene pool and if they cared for him they would neuter him because if he showed up at my door again I would not be responsible for his safety.

Poor folks were probably pretty traumatized by the time I was through with them. But I had just spent $1200.00 for a stud fee and did not want mixed mutts. Had I not caught him and returned him they might never know how many dogs he might have bred through the years - PUPPIES NO ONE PLANNED ON OR WANTED. That is why I do believe that pet people should spay/neuter pets.
 
Exactly! I had a neighbor that had an intact mixed breed dog that roamed the neighbor and when we talked one day, she nonchalantly said, "Oh he just takes a walk and always comes home." :eek: I was shocked! I said, "Yea! After he's jumped every female around, he's tired and wants to come home to rest! ":stomp::stomp::stomp:

And these are the people I spoke of earlier who are oblivious. They aren't asking questions, should I s/n and when? They are in la la land and the scariest people IMO!
 
My guys usually don't come in for the first time til after 10 months sometime between then and 12 months. Of course if you have one come in early then you would just miss it and spay before next cycle.
Then in that case I would have waited a bit for Kali if given the choice but I still would have tried to do it before the first heat.

And even regarding the incontinence, .......it seems I've read here both sides of the spay issue, early or late, and some still get this. So I'm lost on that issue too. ugh....No one has convinced me yet which is better. :scratch::shakinghead:
 
Well Rosie has just finished her first heat cycle.(she is aprox 10 months old.) We DO want to do for her what's in her best interest.She still seems ''young'' to me and I really want her to mature more before I do it.De De,so you think it would be best to wait another year until I have her done then??? I have been himming and hawwing because of the losses I have had in the past. It just seemed so co-incidental that it kinda made me paranoid.
 
Yeah, personally I always recommend after the growth plates close. I just don't like to mess with them during this growing phase...
 
Yeah, personally I always recommend after the growth plates close. I just don't like to mess with them during this growing phase...

So she will gain more height after 10 months or just start ''filling out''?? When do most females stop growing heightwise?
 
So she will gain more height after 10 months or just start ''filling out''?? When do most females stop growing heightwise?



Good question.... I've heard that they pretty much stop growing after 10-12 months..... I'm curious to see how tall my guy will get. Someone else mentioned 18-24 months until the growth plates close, so it should be interesting to see how other's respond.
 
It varies from dog to dog, and from line to line. My guys normally don't finish growing till around 3 or 4, Cutter was almost 5! The best guage is to talk to the breeder. They 'should' know the growth rate of their particular lines...
Normally, for the most part, height is finished by 2. Some earlier, some later.
 
My guys usually don't come in for the first time til after 10 months sometime between then and 12 months. Of course if you have one come in early then you would just miss it and spay before next cycle.

There is a lot of controversy about it. I do feel there is enough real evidence that too early is not good. They do need the hormones etc for development.

I do feel that a pet person usually does not want to be bothered with all the precautions and constant watching that has to be done if they are left in tact. I also feel it is not worth the risk that a male get out and populate the neighborhood mutt community. It will also help avoid any aggression issues that might develop due a a very frustrated dog which does happen. They don't know why they are craxy they just know that they have needs that are not being met. It is very frustrating to them to have to fight nature everytime a bitch is in season somewhere. I read once that a dog can SMELL a bitch in season up to 5 miles away and I know I had a little MUTT show up at my door in the country - he had a name tag on and I called and gave them what for for not neutering him.

They said we got him from a family that got rid of him because he roamed. DUH!!! I told them he did not contribute anything that anyone with purebreeds wanted in their gene pool and if they cared for him they would neuter him because if he showed up at my door again I would not be responsible for his safety.

Poor folks were probably pretty traumatized by the time I was through with them. But I had just spent $1200.00 for a stud fee and did not want mixed mutts. Had I not caught him and returned him they might never know how many dogs he might have bred through the years - PUPPIES NO ONE PLANNED ON OR WANTED. That is why I do believe that pet people should spay/neuter pets.

I agree cmpletely and will apologize ahead of time for grammar and spelling, at the moment i have a week old baby goat sleeping on my arm and i dont have the heart to move him!!

I always rec. spay between 8 - 10 months and neuter around 18 months since most people who have boys want them to look like boys!! but always warn them that the boys can be fertile as early as 6 months and some even know what to do!!
 
It varies from dog to dog, and from line to line. My guys normally don't finish growing till around 3 or 4, Cutter was almost 5! The best guage is to talk to the breeder. They 'should' know the growth rate of their particular lines...
Normally, for the most part, height is finished by 2. Some earlier, some later.


Wow that old ? Amazing !!! It's hard to tell, justice's Dad is rather large weighing in at 107 lbs and is 30" at the withers. He was 3 back then so I'm going to say he's 4 now. I would hope his Dad is done growing. Justice is now 28" and 84 lbs at 10 months old. I certainly don't want some GIGANTIC Dobe since it has proven to be a bit unhealthy for their joints. I don't notice much growth lately, but then again since I'm used to seeing him everyday I wouldn't notice much change until I measured him. Thank you for the comment !
 

Back
Top