Oh, Kim, you are right....this will be fun..

..lol I'm just gonna state what I did and what I can live with. I know there is so much controversy on this issue and I've heard both sides til I'm crazy. I really don't know what to believe so I do whats good for ME.
Years ago, when I had my little Pomeranians, one had developed a tumor or cyst on her breast and the vet then told me if she was spayed
before her first heat, they don't develop these. So my next one I spayed before her first heat. She never developed a tumor like that and she lived 5 years longer than the last Pom. She died at 18yo. And I believe it was a stroke that took her.
My first Doberman was my first male dog and believe it or not I did not neuter him until he was about 6! I never had any issues with him and I seldom gave it a thought until we moved out here. He seemed to develop a 'roving eye'! lol I had him neutered ASAP! And he died 4 years later to cancer.
My next Dobie was a girl that was already spayed when I got her and that was done later in life too. She died of Leukemia at 10 years old too.
When I got Buddy, being he was male, I didn't have to worry about having to fix him before or after any heat cycles

so I thought I would let him develop a bit. I decided I wanted to wait at least a year and I was lucky because I wasn't going through the summer months of waiting. I did not want to worry about him with Spring in the air and outside a lot! He also had done a bit of marking in my basement on a piece of exercise equipment that was from my sis....her dogs scent was on it and I'm sure that is why he marked it. But I was


I didn't want to start that!

We were just going into Spring and Buddy had turned 1 year old in January. So for Buddy, it all worked out well to be neutered in April. He was 15 months old, Spring had just sprung and I felt he had matured well AND did not get all into the 'male' thing! I feel it was a good choice. For both he and I! I think he developed well and his temperament is perfect.
Kali was adopted and I had no choice in her spay. She was spayed in March so the guess is she was 5 months old when it was done. That seems early to me now, but if I were to do it before her first heat, it's probably about right. If I had her before that time I may have waited a month or two. Just my feeling.
I am a pet person and despite the fact that I allowed my first Doberman to go so long without a neuter, I am
not one to want to worry about an intact dog. If you're not a breeder or showing, I believe in s/n. I guess it's a matter of when. People have strong opinions on this like a few other topics.

As you can see from this 'track record', I don't see any rhyme or reason with s/n and cancer or any other disease. I think our dogs are all becoming susceptible to cancer more and more and I don't think it has anything to do with when you s/n. At this point in my life, after losing so many pets to cancer, I'm just waiting for the other shoe to drop.
I also think there is a bigger portion of people that are usually not on a forum like this asking questions!

They are the ones I worry about. My
