Second Dog

malania

Novitiate
Hi, I am new here and I am not even sure if I am posting in the right area, if not please forgive me.

We are looking for a second dog. Right now we have a mini schnauzer that is a male. And we have considering a Doberman, but I have heard that they have same sex aggression. I haven't had a Doberman in many many years, and at that time I had another female Doberman. So I am wondering if it would be a problem getting a male Doberman with my schnauzer. The Doberman would be started in our family as a puppy, if that makes a difference. I also have 6 kids that he would be around all the time. Any thoughts, opinions, or ideas would be great. Thanks!
 
hello :dc: from FLorida :cool:

<~~~~~ I have a male mini schnauzer and a male doberman. I had the Dobie first since he was 2 months. he was socialized, very playful and not aggressive toward other dogs unless it was self defense. He was always good with small dogs.

I got the schanuzer a few months ago when he was 8 months old, the Dobie was about 1.5 by then. the little one was the agressive one at first. he didnt like the Dobie near his food or toys, so we snapped him out of that quick! they get along great. they love playing together although we do need to keep a close eye because they can get rough and i dont want either one getting hurt.

There are times when each one has whined bcuz the other bit the other to hard or w/e but they give each other a break without any correction from us and start playing again whenever they are ready.

There are toher times when i do have to pull them apart because they get too into it and i know the Dobie can tear him to shreads even though he likes it rough lol

So yea, it depends on the temperament of the dog, big or small, and how they are raised.

Playing @ the park.... sharing is caring:
photo 5.webp

chillin after a hot afternoon @ the park:
photo 9.webp
 
Hi and welcome from Minnesota!

I personally wouldn't risk getting same sex if you have a choice since you just can't know what the outcome is going to be. You'd have to be ready to keep them separated all the time if you do wind up with the aggression and that isn't a lot of fun either.

Don't hesitate to ask questions and make yourself at home. :)
 
It all depends on their training and how they're raised and whether you plan to neuter or not. I wouldn't recommend unaltered males together for most people because they are flooded with testosterone but have no release. It can be tougher training then for several reasons.

I don't believe sudden behavior changes are possible. There are always progressive signs or triggers that are usually missed, allowing problems to escalate. If you have well trained and exercised dogs that you expect to get along nicely, they should get along nicely...or you need to adjust your exercise and training. They should follow your rules and respect everyone in the home-including other pets. Size, breed or sex should have no bearing on whether or not your dogs follow your leadership and training if they are properly trained.

We diffuse warning signals/problem situations with commands before a situation escalates. All it takes is a few commands to establish a pattern and the dogs do the behavior automatically. If you have to resort to physically controlling or separating your dogs, you're not in control and neither dog can see you as a strong leader because neither dog is following your directions. If I refused to recognize those moments when my dogs let me know I wasn't in control, I never would have grown as a trainer.

You create the outcome with every dog your bring into your home, regardless of their age, background, temperament, breeding lines or sex. You love them, exercise them and instill discipline and training. The calm, well disciplined and adjusted dogs live together, walk down the street or go to the dog park without other dogs going crazy, barking/fencing or having fights begin.

When this male on male issue comes up, I always have to chuckle a little. I've had some females over the years whose dominance and potential aggression was off the charts compared to most males.

Awesome that you want to get company for your current dog!
 
Hmm, when I had my GSD'S x4, they were all unaltered. BUT, it was at a time in my life that I did nothing but train, train, train. I did not have any issues with them regarding same sex aggression.
The odd thing is that when I got my Wire Hair Terriers, THEY had same sex aggression and still do. I now have 3 female dogs and 1 male. Mason and Molly are fixed, Kiwi and Malina are too young yet.
I would have to say that it depends on your dog handling and training experience. My recommendation is that if you want to add a second dog, get a puppy between the ages of 8 and 12 weeks, male or female and take your time with the introduction by using wire crates/ kennels or even a separate room with the door closed. This will allow your adult dog to still sniff and smell the new family member from under the door, but my preference is using my wire crates/kennels and I house my dogs in them set right next to eachother.
 
There are some members on here that have pulled it off, like Max Hawk and a couple others........However why would you risk it ? I know my breeder wouldn't of sold me a puppy if it was same sex so I can assume most reputable breeders would not unless they really, really knew you could pull it off.
 
@Sophia's Justice You know what happens when you assume...:) and you can't assume everyone does it because your breeder does it or that a breeder is reputable because they don't sell males together.

Training is training, period. Your dogs either respect you as the leader or they don't. If you have to say "my dog is trained except when ___ happens, they (bark, attack, go crazy, etc), your dog is not fully trained. It is that simple. There is no miracle to pull off. It's basic training and complete respect for the owner as a confident leader that makes your dog safe in social activities.

If there was such risk involved in 2 males being together, owners of male dogs shouldn't allow their dog to come into contact with any male dogs. Dog parks, beaches, doggie day care and dog walkers would all have a 1 male limit for safety. Apt buildings and condos would ban all male dogs because having more than one would be a safety issue. Male Doberman pups would have to be separated at birth if genetics could create some mythical male on male species specific aggression.

All of that sounds ridiculous because the idea that you have to be frightened and cautious of 2 male dogs (dobe, pit or whatever) being together is equally ridiculous. (Breeding kennel and when all dogs are intact situations excluded for the average owner's level of dog behavior knowledge.) Millions of people have male dogs together (Dobermans included) without issue because millions of people train their dogs. It isn't just 2 or 3 people in the world who successfully do it, it's millions.

You should be cautious and it can be dangerous when you have dogs that aren't fully trained and don't respect their owner but it has nothing to do with breed, age, gender, etc. I've seen females go at it hard before they were trained and their owner became a confident leader. It doesn't mean 2 females can't live together happily.

The important thing is to get a dog or pup that works with your family and your current dog's energy and personality. If your current dog is a super laid back couch potato, I wouldn't want to bring in a bursting with energy bouncing off the walls pup because it will be annoying to your current dog. Get someone a little more laid back. I also wouldn't get a pup if your other dog is elderly because it's hard on a grandfather to have a toddler boy nipping at his heels all the time. You want them to have some relatively common ground and be able to play together for periods of time without one being exhausted and the other just getting started.
 
Very interesting read here! lol On BOTH sides of the fence! :) I've always been told that having a male and female is the best situation because, as my first breeder told me, they 'get along like an old married couple'. That made sense to me even at a time when I knew nothing about 'same sex aggression'.

Now, those of you that don't believe in same sex aggression make some good points too. (I'm usually open to at least listen! ;) )

Hmm, when I had my GSD'S x4, they were all unaltered. BUT, it was at a time in my life that I did nothing but train, train, train.
I think your point here drives it home for me. Same sex would probably work......if you WORK at it. :) Many people have multiple dogs for multiple reasons. Breeders, people who show, etc anyone who has more than one dog for any other reason except a pet, work at it to make it work. Some have to crate rotate, others may have no problems in the home but may sometimes need to leave one of the 4 dogs (arbitrary number of dogs for this example ) in the house because it "doesn't get along" on a romp, etc etc.

I don't want to work that hard! LOL! It's not that important to me to have one sex over the other. Male and female works fine for me and my family.
There are some members on here that have pulled it off, like Max Hawk and a couple others........However why would you risk it ?
My thoughts exactly.

All of this is just my opinion. :2cents
The important thing is to get a dog or pup that works with your family and your current dog's energy and personality. If your current dog is a super laid back couch potato, I wouldn't want to bring in a bursting with energy bouncing off the walls pup because it will be annoying to your current dog. Get someone a little more laid back. I also wouldn't get a pup if your other dog is elderly because it's hard on a grandfather to have a toddler boy nipping at his heels all the time. You want them to have some relatively common ground and be able to play together for periods of time without one being exhausted and the other just getting started.
The above is also very important to think about too. JMHO
 
I've never considered this an issue and we've had mostly male Dobermans since I was 3 or 4 years old. No difference from having any other combination of dogs.

Honestly, I am surprised and don't understand people arguing so hard based on something they have never experienced. It's like people who have never owned a Doberman advising others not to get a Doberman because they heard Dobermans are bad with kids, always kill their masters or some other nonsense. I have some ear posting experience but not a lot so I don't advise on those posts. I have no way to know if what I've heard or read really works well if I haven't experienced it myself.

There is no extra hard work, super feat, great luck or extreme risk that people who have never had 2 males say they want to avoid. It's the same basic training you do for any other dog. There is no denying that if you have to say your dog is trained and can be trusted except for ___, they aren't fully trained and can't fully be trusted. There are always signals leading up to any bigger incident or behavior. You correct the small issues and you never see big issues.

A breeding kennel is very, very different from a home situation. It is difficult to keep males around breeding females even if some are neutered without the extensive training people talk about. The last thing on earth breeders want is to have males they don't approve of as a breeder back in their kennel so maybe some really go the extra mile to prevent that hassle and expense? I know some people love their breeder but a breeder is running a business.

If having a male Doberman, pit or rotti together with other male dogs were such a fearful dangerous issue; there would be bans and restrictions on male Dobermans everywhere you go like I posed earlier-especially at doggie daycare, with dog walkers, etc. There aren't male Doberman (pit, rotti, GSD, etc) bans for a reason-it's completely unnecessary. The rule is always you are required to have a properly trained and well behaved dog, which should be a given for anyone.

I hate to see baseless fear possibly move people from taking a pup or dog that perfectly fits their family and other pets' energy, age, lifestyle and personalities. I always tell potential adopters getting a pet is a lot like dating. Looks can carry you through the first few dates but it's behavior, personality and energy levels that make the next 15+years (God willing) happy and fun. Given that most people want to be home pet owners and will spay/neuter (which removes the possible hormone fueled aggression) sex of the dog is the last thing I'd worry about in picking the perfect pet for your family.
 
This all reminds me of when I was in school and we had a male Doberman around 3 years old. I saw a story about an older female Doberman about to be put down because no one wanted an older dog...and naturally I had to go get her. Max was already neutered at 2 1/2 when we adopted him, she was spayed right before I brought her home.

We caught the new girl silently stalking our boy in mirrors on the first day! Teeth bared, everything but a sound that would give her away and only when she thought no one could see. We corrected immediately and kept watch. It was really hard not to laugh and be impressed with her intelligence at the same time.

We only had to be vigilant for maybe 3 weeks and they were best buds for years. It was a combination of her drop in hormones and the corrections that stopped the behavior so fast.
 
@Sophia's Justice You know what happens when you assume...:) and you can't assume everyone does it because your breeder does it or that a breeder is reputable because they don't sell males together.

Training is training, period. Your dogs either respect you as the leader or they don't. If you have to say "my dog is trained except when ___ happens, they (bark, attack, go crazy, etc), your dog is not fully trained. It is that simple. There is no miracle to pull off. It's basic training and complete respect for the owner as a confident leader that makes your dog safe in social activities.

If there was such risk involved in 2 males being together, owners of male dogs shouldn't allow their dog to come into contact with any male dogs. Dog parks, beaches, doggie day care and dog walkers would all have a 1 male limit for safety. Apt buildings and condos would ban all male dogs because having more than one would be a safety issue. Male Doberman pups would have to be separated at birth if genetics could create some mythical male on male species specific aggression.

All of that sounds ridiculous because the idea that you have to be frightened and cautious of 2 male dogs (dobe, pit or whatever) being together is equally ridiculous. (Breeding kennel and when all dogs are intact situations excluded for the average owner's level of dog behavior knowledge.) Millions of people have male dogs together (Dobermans included) without issue because millions of people train their dogs. It isn't just 2 or 3 people in the world who successfully do it, it's millions.

You should be cautious and it can be dangerous when you have dogs that aren't fully trained and don't respect their owner but it has nothing to do with breed, age, gender, etc. I've seen females go at it hard before they were trained and their owner became a confident leader. It doesn't mean 2 females can't live together happily.

The important thing is to get a dog or pup that works with your family and your current dog's energy and personality. If your current dog is a super laid back couch potato, I wouldn't want to bring in a bursting with energy bouncing off the walls pup because it will be annoying to your current dog. Get someone a little more laid back. I also wouldn't get a pup if your other dog is elderly because it's hard on a grandfather to have a toddler boy nipping at his heels all the time. You want them to have some relatively common ground and be able to play together for periods of time without one being exhausted and the other just getting started.
@Sophia's Justice You know what happens when you assume...:) and you can't assume everyone does it because your breeder does it or that a breeder is reputable because they don't sell males together.

Training is training, period. Your dogs either respect you as the leader or they don't. If you have to say "my dog is trained except when ___ happens, they (bark, attack, go crazy, etc), your dog is not fully trained. It is that simple. There is no miracle to pull off. It's basic training and complete respect for the owner as a confident leader that makes your dog safe in social activities.

If there was such risk involved in 2 males being together, owners of male dogs shouldn't allow their dog to come into contact with any male dogs. Dog parks, beaches, doggie day care and dog walkers would all have a 1 male limit for safety. Apt buildings and condos would ban all male dogs because having more than one would be a safety issue. Male Doberman pups would have to be separated at birth if genetics could create some mythical male on male species specific aggression.

All of that sounds ridiculous because the idea that you have to be frightened and cautious of 2 male dogs (dobe, pit or whatever) being together is equally ridiculous. (Breeding kennel and when all dogs are intact situations excluded for the average owner's level of dog behavior knowledge.) Millions of people have male dogs together (Dobermans included) without issue because millions of people train their dogs. It isn't just 2 or 3 people in the world who successfully do it, it's millions.

You should be cautious and it can be dangerous when you have dogs that aren't fully trained and don't respect their owner but it has nothing to do with breed, age, gender, etc. I've seen females go at it hard before they were trained and their owner became a confident leader. It doesn't mean 2 females can't live together happily.

The important thing is to get a dog or pup that works with your family and your current dog's energy and personality. If your current dog is a super laid back couch potato, I wouldn't want to bring in a bursting with energy bouncing off the walls pup because it will be annoying to your current dog. Get someone a little more laid back. I also wouldn't get a pup if your other dog is elderly because it's hard on a grandfather to have a toddler boy nipping at his heels all the time. You want them to have some relatively common ground and be able to play together for periods of time without one being exhausted and the other just getting started.

You are correct, I shouldn't assume anything so I'll base it on facts. Comparing a Golden Retriever ( looking ) and a Doberman you have seemed to manage together being both males maybe working for you, and glad you pulled it off, however again all the experts you speak too will tell you that it's not recommended. And being how you won't comment on how to post an ear, I'll leave you out of being an expert. Again I'll relate MY EXPERIENCE on seeing two males in a household, I'll relate to my breeder whom has been breeding Doberman's for 56 years now, yeah that's 56 !

My breeder simply refused to sell me a male even though I had my heart set on 2 males in the house. So then I thought " how could this be " ? So I shopped around, every reputable breeder I spoke with ( 12 to be exact ) told me in no way would the allow me to bring another male puppy home. Maybe at the pound or shelter they over look this fact as I'm not sure where you got your two males, but I'll have said this with confidence that it's not recommended.

Granted it can be done, but the person requesting the feedback had to ask this question in the first place, It's probably not a good idea.


If you have your heart set on two males, go for it......but train, train and train, then be ready to break up fights and battles as their hormones rage as it's recommended to keep them in tact for 24 months. Again, why risk it ?
 
I have to agree with Stephen here. Some temperaments make it work out, but for so many experienced breeders to not recommend it, I would leave owning same sex of the doberman breed to the experienced or dedicated only. Things don't always work out that way but if you have the choice (and me knowing no background on the experience of the prospective owner) I will always recommend to avoid the possibility of having to live a life of crate and rotate.
 
I have to agree with Stephen here. Some temperaments make it work out, but for so many experienced breeders to not recommend it, I would leave owning same sex of the doberman breed to the experienced or dedicated only. Things don't always work out that way but if you have the choice (and me knowing no background on the experience of the prospective owner) I will always recommend to avoid the possibility of having to live a life of crate and rotate.


Certainly not trying to create a hostile thread but for someone to recommend getting 2 males when it's so heavily advised against, isn't the advice I would want to side with. However it's a forum and everyone is entitled to their opinions, I'd just hate to come back to this thread in 6 months and see bloody photo's or one dog getting re-homed because of advice that goes against what so many experts agree on. Point being there is a reason breeders wont' place same sex's together. Can it work, sure I'm sure it could with proper training, constant monitoring, etc. But let's be honest here " would you really want to leave for work forgetting to keep them separated, then have to turn around only to find out they fought to the death ? ". Probably exaggerated a tad, but is it at all possible ? Yes........Is it at all possible them getting along ? Yes......... so now that the thought is visualized in your head, just beware and heed the good advice.
 
Now the 2 males I have are lab and Doberman but I've had mostly males including multiple Dobermans and pits at the same time. You say you won't assume, then state "all the experts..."
 
Now the 2 males I have are lab and Doberman but I've had mostly males including multiple Dobermans and pits at the same time. You say you won't assume, then state "all the experts..."


Fair enough I'll define it more for you " ALL THE EXPERTS I'VE TALKED TOO ". Multiple Dobermans but yet you don't know how too confidently define the methods of posting to anyone ? I suppose we could pick each other apart all night, or maybe even ASSUME we could, but the point is, most ( yes another variable ) will agree with not placing two males together. Again if you did it, more power too you. I'm not sure why the fascination you might have with males, but I'll let it be........... My major point is, just because you did it, many, many others agree it's not exactly protocol or suggested that males are placed together.
 

Back
Top