Schutzhund - I am getting confused...

Does it make sense to work towards BH and tracking if I can not follow requirements for protection?
Absolutely. The reason you want to do this is to give Asha a job. If yu don't care about titles etc, it doesn't matter if you do the bite work.
You will get a lot out of just doing the two other parts of the work and if Asha likes doing it and you enjoy it as well, go for it. :)
 
Jess - I hope this is a typo and you meant MAKE a dog and handler. It is all about building the confidence of the dog and creating a positive bond with the handler. In the old old day Yes there were those who worked to either make or break a dog and they ruined many good dogs. We have come a long long way from that sad philosophy.

Today it is all about the postive relationship between dog and handler. Working with the dog over time through positive methods and training.

We are teaching them judgment and WHEN to bite and HOW to bite.. Not to NOT bitye that would defeat the purpose of bitework.
No I meant to break. The sport is designed to find where a dog will fail because no dog is perfect. It is what you do with that information that matters. You should take it and build on or around it to make the dog and handler better. I still stand by that we are teaching not to bite. We are teaching the dogs to control themselves and listen to us about when to bite and when not to bite. It is just as important that the dog control themselves and resist the bite as it is that they bite fast, hard, and sure. If we were teaching them only to bite then they would be out there biting everything in sight. We are teaching them bite discrimination, to evaluate a person or situation and determine if it is appropriate to bite, guard, or do nothing.
 
I will take Asha to the club again and let her bite a tug one more time.
We went to the river today. She was totally nuts running after sticks and biting a tug. She was barking at people who decided to approach the (her) area.
She has very strong protection instinct... but it's almost impossible to frustrate her. If I close her in the crate for a day and she will be OK. If I tie her to the tree and play with a tug in distance she will be pulling like crazy but she won't bark.... but if a stranger approaches our house her barking is horrible.
I can not make her bark on command. I was using food, toys, games... it doesn't work.
How to explain it?
 
I will take Asha to the club again and let her bite a tug one more time.
We went to the river today. She was totally nuts running after sticks and biting a tug. She was barking at people who decided to approach the (her) area.
She has very strong protection instinct... but it's almost impossible to frustrate her. If I close her in the crate for a day and she will be OK. If I tie her to the tree and play with a tug in distance she will be pulling like crazy but she won't bark.... but if a stranger approaches our house her barking is horrible.
I can not make her bark on command. I was using food, toys, games... it doesn't work.
How to explain it?
Have you tried to put a command to it when she is barking? So when she barks at something at home, say: speak, bark, check or whatever you want it to be called? That way she may put two and two together. I can't get Easter to bark on command either, but she is the one that barks to protect the home! Bailey on the other hand will do anything to please and can both bark and whisper/growl on command. Each dog is so different.
 
listen to us about when to bite and when not to bite
AHHHH that is what I said when and how to bite. But never to break the dog or the handler. If you push a dog beyond its capabilities that would break its spirit and desire to work. You test how much bressure a dog can take but a good trainer no an excellent trainer knows when to back off BEFORE crossong that line and let the dog win - never beyond that point. but it is critical to know when to back off before you overstep the bounds and break the dog. A broken dog does not work. You test the limits of the dog so you know where it is weak and where you need to work to build that dog up in that area. But never to break the dog or the handler. You want to build them up.

You are correct you are not teacing a dog only to bite - you are showing them the correct way to bite and the confidence to follow through with body contact full on in their bite. They already know how to bite as you said earlier. We are showing them in these circumstances and conditions so they can build good judgement - We teach them obedience so we can control it. That is not the same at teaching them not to bite.

GSD people may break their dogs although I have never heard of this for years and years but just like when they pushed Spock too far and then had to back up and rebuild his confidence. I would have some serious talk about this breaking mentality.

When you hiut road blocks with a young dog it is because there is a breakdown in the training method being used. . - You bring a dog along with the positive perspective too much pressure and it will break a dogs desire for the work. Dobermans are very sensitive. Obedience is not teaching the dog when not to bite but to teach the dog the situations when biting is acceptable and building control - It is not about teaching a dog not to bite. If you are worried about teaching the dog not to bite then you are going to have problems in the bite. Dobermans do not suceed with a lot of control early on and certainly no compulsion.

No one would touch one of my dogs with the mentaility that they would break it. Not ever.
 
Mine are like Katja's. Java never barks either. She only barks when there is a real threat and of course that is so rare, thank god. Paige will bark at almost anything. Are you wanting to do Schutzhund because you feel that's what a Doberman should do? Do what your heart tells you, do not feel bad for not doing Schutzhund. If you are doing it because that's what a Doberman should do then I think you would be doing it for the wrong reasons. Only do it if that's what YOU want to do and what you think Asha wants to do. You have to be in it 100%. I wish you luck in the next practice where you can make the decision a little more easily. Any job is a good job as long as you and your dog are both happy.
 
Katja I was thinking about rewarding her when she barks... but I don't want her to encourage to bark at people and other dogs.
See... there is a conflict between a good pet and a working dog. They told me if I locked her in the crate at home she would not bark at strangers.
I don't buy it. Their dogs were barking like crazy being crated in the car.

I want to do Schutzhund because I really like it and that's what Dobermans should be bred for. Asha has been tugging hard since she arrived to our house.
I like her drive and determination and pain tolerance and courage... that's a shock for me they think she doesn't have enough drive for the sport.
It's possible with all the training we went through I damaged her natural drive. I called them several times when she was a puppy. They didn't accept new members. Now they tell me I should have been training her as a puppy :furious:

The difference between the club Jess is working with and our local - they want to title all dogs.. and they work towards SchIII. They don't want to waste time on dogs that seems to be not VERY drivey. I am very confused and discouraged...

Here is Asha at 8 months...in the airport with her sister and the next day after arrival home.

Asha_Kazi_Playing.jpg


1-1-1.jpg
 
The dogs in there crates were barking because they love the sport. All it takes is a few cracks of a whip and the experienced dogs go nuts in there kennels, this us because they want out to work they live it.
Your asha is still very young and still learning she may not bark yet.

If you want to compete in any schutzhund titles you will have to get her BH, so I say train for that and once you have earned that title assess your next venture whether it is tracking, obedience or protection. My wife had no interest in protection but loves tracking and that will be her main focus once she has achieved all the obedience titles she wants with Redman. I believe obedience is the foundation of all training and should be done whether or not you compete in any other dog sport.

I am not sure I understand but I thought you said you do not want her to bark at strangers. Why, it is there nature to give warning of unfamiliar strangers. I encourage this in my dogs, they are the first to the door when someone comes to the house and only back away when I comand them and give them the ok.

It is very unfortunate that there are clubs out there with the mentality that you have described. It really hurts the sport and detours new people from getting into the sport. Our club welcomes all and we will help train you and your dog at whatever it is you are interested in. We would certainly never give a one day evaluation and determine your dog was not a schutzhund dog. I don't believe seeing s dog one time is enough to make that determination, especially a puppy.
I say continue training OB and let her mature more before giving up on her doing protection if that is what you want.
 
I'm not quite sure I agree with the barking in the car. If my dogs are barking it's because they are unhappy or because there are people outside the car. When they are anticipating they will just sit and watch, so I don't necessarily think it's a sign of them being excited about the work. It can be but not always.
 
I'm not quite sure I agree with the barking in the car. If my dogs are barking it's because they are unhappy or because there are people outside the car. When they are anticipating they will just sit and watch, so I don't necessarily think it's a sign of them being excited about the work. It can be but not always.

I guess you might say they are unhappy but its because it isn't there turn with the helper. Maybe I should have called it a frustrated excitement. I know Gunner gets fired up everytime he hears the whip and Matrix sounded like he was going to destroy his kennel until Dale yelled at him, so unhappy, yes because it wasn't there turn but excited non the less.
 
The dogs in there crates were barking because they love the sport. All it takes is a few cracks of a whip and the experienced dogs go nuts in there kennels, this us because they want out to work they live it.
Your asha is still very young and still learning she may not bark yet.

If you want to compete in any schutzhund titles you will have to get her BH, so I say train for that and once you have earned that title assess your next venture whether it is tracking, obedience or protection. My wife had no interest in protection but loves tracking and that will be her main focus once she has achieved all the obedience titles she wants with Redman. I believe obedience is the foundation of all training and should be done whether or not you compete in any other dog sport.

I am not sure I understand but I thought you said you do not want her to bark at strangers. Why, it is there nature to give warning of unfamiliar strangers. I encourage this in my dogs, they are the first to the door when someone comes to the house and only back away when I comand them and give them the ok.

It is very unfortunate that there are clubs out there with the mentality that you have described. It really hurts the sport and detours new people from getting into the sport. Our club welcomes all and we will help train you and your dog at whatever it is you are interested in. We would certainly never give a one day evaluation and determine your dog was not a schutzhund dog. I don't believe seeing s dog one time is enough to make that determination, especially a puppy.
I say continue training OB and let her mature more before giving up on her doing protection if that is what you want.

You answered all my questions and gave me a great direction :ty:
I need to learn more about footstep tracking.

I don't mind my dogs barking inside but it's not a pretty picture when Asha barks at strangers on our walks.

Katja they bark from desire to get into the field. I am not sure how they behave in other places and it bothers me a bit.
I may not do protection and have my dogs as good pets... My priority will be working towards BH and watching other dogs in protection.
 
You answered all my questions and gave me a great direction :ty:
I need to learn more about footstep tracking.

I don't mind my dogs barking inside but it's not a pretty picture when Asha barks at strangers on our walks.

Katja they bark from desire to get into the field. I am not sure how they behave in other places and it bothers me a bit.
I may not do protection and have my dogs as good pets... My priority will be working towards BH and watching other dogs in protection.

I learned how to teach my dogs to track from Dale and D4E so they could probably explain in better detail. You always want to start them in a b puppy box. You stomp out about a 2x2 area then sprinkle food all thru it. Then bring them up to the box, give your command (search, sook, find it ect....) throw a piece of food in the box and let them eat working in and out of the box so they figure out that the smell of the disturbed ground is where the food is. Once you have trained the box and they have it figured out you start with a box with food in it and then make a line of 5-6 footsteps with a piece of food in each one, then another box with a pile of food on it fit a jackpot.
 
Asha would love tracking... so much food! :)

I am done with the club.
They don't want me to do OB only. That's all about titles. If they don't see a very drivey dog and owner doesn't want to lock a dog in the crate for most of her life... no way to get in. Too bad my high energy, pain tolerant, determined Doberman doesn't have a chance to use her potential :stomp:
 
Asha would love tracking... so much food! :)

I am done with the club.
They don't want me to do OB only. That's all about titles. If they don't see a very drivey dog and owner doesn't want to lock a dog in the crate for most of her life... no way to get in. Too bad my high energy, pain tolerant, determined Doberman doesn't have a chance to use her potential :stomp:
Idiots.
 
Asha would love tracking... so much food! :)

I am done with the club.
They don't want me to do OB only. That's all about titles. If they don't see a very drivey dog and owner doesn't want to lock a dog in the crate for most of her life... no way to get in. Too bad my high energy, pain tolerant, determined Doberman doesn't have a chance to use her potential :stomp:

Well, hopefully all clubs aren't like that, because I just emailed the club closest to me so I could learn more about starting a puppy before I got one... It will be interesting to hear what they have to say.
-- I showed my MinPins in conformation and my first, 'Hindy' was with me a bunch, rarely crated, we both trained so much that it got to the point of it being 'old hat' for her in the ring and acted like she would rather be home on the couch (she learned much faster than I did ). The professional handlers thought she was a pretty girl and suggested I start crating her all the time, except when she was in the show ring, they said 'That should perk her right up'... Since she was my almost constant companion - there was no way... So instead, I taught her a word that would give her the animation she needed to finish her Championship! :) SQUIRREL!!! so you can train it back into them. Maybe not to the point of them being CRAZY DRIVEN, but enough for them to pass their tests.
I hope you enjoy whatever you end up doing with her - she sounds like a wonderful working companion, and she is lucky to have you - one who would put her best interest above any ribbon or title! Good for you!!
 

Back
Top