Oh no Justice's first fight !!! Help !!!

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks for the info on using Neosporin on wounds on dogs. That is very good to know. I didn't realize that you could use it on dogs. :)

Katja,

Your welcome.... All I know is that it works ! I started using it on his tick bites a few months ago when they were so bad and not responding to the Frontline Plus. I noticed a HUGE difference in healing time, instead of a month or so, it would only take a week tops for the wounds to heal. In the past 24 hours since the attack he has no blood signs or puss on his wound. It's now just bald !!! I hope the hair grows back quickly !!! It has the same healing power as it does on our skin, and that was confirmed from two different vet's in my area. So far so good !!!
 
I have taken a short and quick video to show the control Justice has in case some think he's out of it..... This is playtime and I get him riled up and when he starts to play with his mouth a simple " No Bite " and he stops dead in his tracks..... sorry for the low light situation as were just chilling out on the couch. You have to watch the end of it to get the lighter view.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P6NTEh-myF0
 
I can't watch it with sound as my girls will just start barking and I don't want to deal with that right now. :)

I love his facial expression. I will say (and we have had this discussion before) that I would probably not rough house with my dog as they can easily tip over the edge. I don't think it went too far by any stretch of the imagination and he stops nicely when told to. However I feel it's such a guy thing to rough house and I just don't think it's necessary. My girls don't get to rough house with each other either for the above reason. :)
 
Oh boy here we go again !!! LOL

It's not really rough housing, but we do play rough from time to time.... have done so since he was big enough to play like that. He doesn't do it with Sophia, he only plays it with me when I instigate it. He is strong, but all I have to say is that word and he STOPS dead in his tracks....... I think that's pretty impressive for not a TON of training.

This has been debatable in the past, but I've had no issues with it. The only time I got hurt is when his boney leg hit me in the funny bone, and I went down like a fat man on pancakes !!! He stopped, licked me, and laid there with me until I stopped. I think I know this dog, if he changed for one second and didn't play like I wanted him too I'd stop. I just did the simple video to prove my boy wasn't out of control, and that he in fact does listen very, very well !!! All with as much training as he's had anyway. I'm going to training with Jan S in a month..... That's when the fun will begin.
 
I do think it's great that he stops immediately when you say so. I do think you do a great job with Justice and he seems like a lovely boy.
 
Stephen;
any discussion where there are differences of opinion and belief systems can be 'passionate' and each of us is passionate for a reason... Most of us who have had Dobermans or working breeds before know the intensity of the breed and the requirements of that as well.
Your terminology about "Freedom" for us as human beings should not be equated to 'freedom' for our charges/ ergo our four legged children. Any more than we let our children have the same "liberties' that we have until they are old enough, mature enough and responsible enough to handle those liberties.

Thinking it is ok to leave him to roam free anywhere on that property, is really no different for him than if you where to allow a 2 yr old child to have the same liberty to walk down busy street without supervision or a held hand... Like it or not, its a similar analogy... Dangers abound for that 2 yr child that it can not possibly understand or be prepared to deal with, Justice is a 2 yr old child who has no concept of dangers that await him around every tree, rock or bush that is not protected by you his owner with a fence..
he has the ability to understand his world and its boundaries based on what you show and demonstrate to him those boundaries are. You have chosen to leave him an intact male and now you have experienced first hand one strongest of the reasons why those of us who know more about the breed and dogs than you do , have stated that its a bad idea.

You are not a irresponsible guy, its clear you are a guy seeking guidance and wisdom.. and its clear that you just lack education in management of your "pack" and right now that pack has gone and gotten himself injured and caused injury too other people dogs...
I would like to add a bit of personal input that: had that been my property and your dog come running onto it without a collar, or a leash, no restraint whatsoever and then proceeded to get into a fight with My Dog and caused damage, I must say that I would be extremely pissed off at you and most assuredly be sending you the bill for any and all damages to my dog. I also might be inclined to send a letter from My attorney about your failure to control your own dog in an urban country area. The result of which quite possibly could have Justice quarantined for two weeks for attacking (since it could be considered his fault since it was on someone elses property and you had no visible means of controlling your animal on my property and your dog is un neutered and in some areas its frowned upon for un neutered dogs to be roaming free and unlicensed without a collar or a leash)
All because you are a firm believer in your views about 'freedom'
so I must ask you?
Are your views so well grounded in a responsible pet owners view as to be able to hold up in court in front of a Judge should you end up there over this?
I can tell you you will be redefining your views after a court appearance considering the facts of this incident.

and to me? a tether in the wilderness is not going to keep skunks, deer, bears, mountain lions, raccoons, or other animals out of his line of sight to be enticed to chase them and its not going to keep the neighbors un governed dogs out of your yard either...
Just a thought....
No one wants to hurt you here Stephen.. we are sad for you and this incident, but we are also sad that your views are what led up to this incident and its why it happened in the first place.
Had you provided an nicely fenced, safe, protected area and kept a collar on him this would not happen and it wont happen again. Wandering WILL happen... his curiosity has been piqued and now he knows he can get away and he can investigate and he can do it again especially if he is left intact and un boundaried and un limited in his ability to venture off to follow his nose or his eyes...
he is a dog... thats what Dobermans do.. they have prey drive and its built in and it will kick in and more incidents will happen, and some could be fatal... I pray you never have to experience that...
I did.. when I was young, dumb and thought I knew everything there was to know about dogs in my twenties. Its been 30+ years and I too have learned the hardway, we that have simply wish to impart our hard earned wisdom to someone who will listen...
 
I respect your views Stephen. And I very much understand them. Growing up nobody outside the city limits had fences for their dogs, but we've become much more educated and aware since then. I LOVE going on hikes with Spock back home in rural Arkansas. I wouldn't trade that experience for the world. But let me tell you I would NOT let him wander those woods alone. There are far too many dangers out there and since I brought a domestic dog into that environment it is my duty to protect him. We're not talking wild animals here. Science tells us there is actually almost no wolf left in the domestic dog. Do Justice and Spock enjoy running off leash in the wild? Of course they do, don't you? But it is our duty as the owners to keep them under control and protect them. In those beautiful peaceful woods in Arkansas there are many dangers: wolves, bears, mountain lions, possibly rabid opossums and raccoons, other dogs feral and domestic, cars, guns, crazy people, and so much more. Whenever we take Spock back home where he has those miles and miles of open woods he could wander off into he is NEVER outside without someone watching him and he ALWAYS wears a freshly charged e-collar so we can "reach out and touch" him even if he's at the tree line or is on a leash or long line. It will be the same for his new sister when she comes home and makes the trip back to AR with us for Christmas. This ensures that he stays where we can see him, where we can control him, and where he is safe. Call me over protective if you want but it isn't worth it to me to put his life in danger for him to wander the woods alone. When we finally own property that is several acres of open land I can guarantee you that there will be at least two precautions in place. There will be a smaller area near the house that is safely fenced off so we can turn the dogs out to run and do their business where they are safe from wandering off and from other animals wandering up. Does this mean he'll never get the opportunity to wander his property? Of course not! I'm sure we'll take hikes around the property quite often and he'll be right there with us...under control of e-collar or leash. I realize none of us are going to change your mind, you've made that perfectly clear. I just want you to realize that there can be a balance between freedom and restriction that is still safe. You take Justice's very life in your hands when he is outside unrestrained.
 
I feel obligated to add to that last comment:

Free spirited doesn't hurt anyone. It's the price we pay for freedom. I think a well known president stated that once in a speech ( if memory serves me ). What bother's me is that it seem's most people follow suit. Is it the way we've been raised to believe in rules, regulations, and to follow the ways of what's been in the past ? I know I'm not a law abiding citizen to full capacity, I have rebellious issues at hand mentally. But guess what ? I'm happiest doing what I want to do, hair flailing in the wind, and not doing what' s been taught what's right and wrong. This isn't a battle anyone can win with me when it comes to caging my animal on a leash 24/7, or kenneling him all day while I'm gone, of course that theory has it's limitations. I don't walk down in canal park on a Sunday ( thousands upon thousands of tourists ) with my doberman loose. He's on a leash, in control, and obey's the LAWS of the land in that scenario......

But at home ? He's free....... If some dog comes into my yard and my happy, go lucky guy feels like following him, that's my fault in lack of training. When I picked Justice up in front of the other dogs and they attacked, that's my fault. So I'm the guilty one here !!! Not my dog !!! He didn't know better. So that's the price I suppose we paid for freedom. But tonight I can sleep tonight knowing that I played outside for an hour with my best friend without tripping over cords, leashes, and didn't have to follow him around the yard scolding him for not staying within his cord restraint.......Did he look over there " YES "..... Did I clearly state " NO " and he listened " YES "....... It's obviously going to need more and more intense training, but that's what I'm willing to pay for having my dog HAPPY, CORDLESS, and most of all SAFE....... Accidents happen, it 's not that I planned on picking up my dog yesterday and having him get attacked. If I'd of known better I wouldn't of done it, but " I " didn't, not Justice. He was just being a free spirited dog, trying to make friends, that were not so friendly. He paid, I paid for the price of ignorance.

I don't need lectures of " You should do what we all do " because I'm not going to listen, and if that's the case of constant responses I just won't belong to this forum.

For the record my dog is safe ! I'm not trying to endanger him in anyway. But when I look at a dog that's caged, corded all day, I don't see a happy dog. When I come home to my dog, he's happy, he smiles, he loves me, and he LOVES to run free. Try seeing things from my perspective............ I don't live, nor will I live, in a city with concrete surrounding me, and have a yard that I can take a tape measure too........... If that was the case, I wouldn't have a dog !!!

I think most of us think close to along the same lines as you do. There are very few members here who have not posted pictures of their dobermans off-leash hiking, swimming or having fun in an unfenced yard. While you "preach" freedom, you are actually supervising Justice very well and not leaving him outdoors unattended. There are inherent risks involved with having a dog off-leash. The risks can be reduced by training and by location of off-leash actvities, but there is still the possibility of a dog being killed, wounded or lost. It's a risk I'm willing to take under certain conditions.

Did you get any info on e-collars Stephen? IMO, they are a wonderful tool to (like Jess said) "reach out and touch" your dog with when off leash. Many people use them just as they would any type of correction collar such as a prong collar, but there is no leash involved with a correction. I've stopped Ladybug a couple of times from chasing herds of deer with an e-collar. It's a very effective tool.
 
There will be a smaller area near the house that is safely fenced off so we can turn the dogs out to run and do their business where they are safe from wandering off and from other animals wandering up. Does this mean he'll never get the opportunity to wander his property? Of course not! I'm sure we'll take hikes around the property quite often and he'll be right there with us...under control of e-collar or leash. I realize none of us are going to change your mind, you've made that perfectly clear. I just want you to realize that there can be a balance between freedom and restriction that is still safe.
That's exactly the way we do it. We have the fence in the front yard, and if they go for a run in the woods, it's either the check line or an e-collar (which we haven't incorporated with Della yet, but need to). I do think the e-collar would be a good option for you Stephen since it gives them total freedom, but still gives you total control from a distance if you need it, and times will come up that you do as he matures, no matter how well trained he is now.

There have been lots of very good answers here and I think it will all be very helpful to many other people as well. :thumbsup:
 
Free spirited doesn't hurt anyone. It's the price we pay for freedom. I think a well known president stated that once in a speech ( if memory serves me ). What bother's me is that it seem's most people follow suit. Is it the way we've been raised to believe in rules, regulations, and to follow the ways of what's been in the past ? I know I'm not a law abiding citizen to full capacity, I have rebellious issues at hand mentally.

Back in the wild west were people lived 10 miles apart all this wonderful free spirit stuff worked. Now as populations have grown and people are crowed much closer even us free spriits have had to accept some responsiblity for being sure we do not infringe on anyone else. So you are free to do as you wish right UP to and UNTIL you infringe on my rights. Free spirit got Justice hurt and the neighbors dog hurt. Sounds to me like they hoped their dogs would kill him since they didn't step in and help..

I can guaruantee you had it been my dogs your dog attacked I would see you in court. You see this free spriit protects what is mine. I will respect what is yours and not infringe but I will fight to the death to protect mine from your invasion of my little bit of freedom. I have 11 acres. Creek on one side - the darn neighbors dog is in my yard a lot but I chase him off. I am quite sure they don't use any flea preventative or ever bathe the poor little guy.

But my dogs do bark so to keep pieace I endure their "free spirit" attitude til I could choke and to make sure I do not offend them I tolearate it and chase off their dog instead of shoot it.

What is hard to understand is that to a male intact dog once a fight happens they are charged up and ready, looking for the next one. You do not have the same dog you did before this happened. Are you saying that you do not care if your free spirit cost Justice his life and Dobermans the right to be seen in public on leash????

You seem honestly distressed that he has been hurt - What would you have done had they shot him right then and there???? If he attacked my dog in my yard you can darn well be sure I would have. My free spirit ends at my property line and so does yours. You don't invade mine and I won't intrude on yours. It is a respect for one another and living together now that we have to be close.

Dog Under Fire because of irresponsible people who think they are enttiled to stll act like they live in the wild wild west with lots of room to roam. Day after day I post the articles on K9BSL - Day after day I sit and want to cry. 95% of the time it is dogs that are LOOSE that cause the damage. My heart breaks for the pit bulls and I sit and pray PLEASE don't let it be a Doberman that causes the problem. Right now Dobermans are flying under the radar but one bad incident like yours and you can send us all right down the tubes. They still make some hit list but they are not bashed daily like the pit bulls. Free Spirit - Dead Spirit you can't have one without the other.
 
Oh boy here we go again !!! LOL

It's not really rough housing, but we do play rough from time to time.... have done so since he was big enough to play like that. He doesn't do it with Sophia, he only plays it with me when I instigate it. He is strong, but all I have to say is that word and he STOPS dead in his tracks....... I think that's pretty impressive for not a TON of training.

This has been debatable in the past, but I've had no issues with it. The only time I got hurt is when his boney leg hit me in the funny bone, and I went down like a fat man on pancakes !!! He stopped, licked me, and laid there with me until I stopped. I think I know this dog, if he changed for one second and didn't play like I wanted him too I'd stop. I just did the simple video to prove my boy wasn't out of control, and that he in fact does listen very, very well !!! All with as much training as he's had anyway. I'm going to training with Jan S in a month..... That's when the fun will begin.

My Mysti was like that, we would get on the floor, and would rough play, she would jump on me, play bite and try to get whatever toy I had hidden under me. When she would get too "toothy" I would tell her "no teeth" and she would stop biting and we would just wrestle. When I thought play time was over I told her "enough" and she would lie down on her back and stick her snout in my face for kisses and she would get her toy. She loved her play time, and it would always get strange looks from visitors who saw us playing as they thought she was attacking me because of her growls and snarling with teeth bared, I loved it. But I knew she would never grab my arm hard or do anything to hurt me and with one word it would stop.
 
Back in the wild west were people lived 10 miles apart all this wonderful free spirit stuff worked. Now as populations have grown and people are crowed much closer even us free spriits have had to accept some responsiblity for being sure we do not infringe on anyone else. So you are free to do as you wish right UP to and UNTIL you infringe on my rights. Free spirit got Justice hurt and the neighbors dog hurt. Sounds to me like they hoped their dogs would kill him since they didn't step in and help..

I can guaruantee you had it been my dogs your dog attacked I would see you in court. You see this free spriit protects what is mine. I will respect what is yours and not infringe but I will fight to the death to protect mine from your invasion of my little bit of freedom. I have 11 acres. Creek on one side - the darn neighbors dog is in my yard a lot but I chase him off. I am quite sure they don't use any flea preventative or ever bathe the poor little guy.

But my dogs do bark so to keep pieace I endure their "free spirit" attitude til I could choke and to make sure I do not offend them I tolearate it and chase off their dog instead of shoot it.

What is hard to understand is that to a male intact dog once a fight happens they are charged up and ready, looking for the next one. You do not have the same dog you did before this happened. Are you saying that you do not care if your free spirit cost Justice his life and Dobermans the right to be seen in public on leash????

You seem honestly distressed that he has been hurt - What would you have done had they shot him right then and there???? If he attacked my dog in my yard you can darn well be sure I would have. My free spirit ends at my property line and so does yours. You don't invade mine and I won't intrude on yours. It is a respect for one another and living together now that we have to be close.

Dog Under Fire because of irresponsible people who think they are enttiled to stll act like they live in the wild wild west with lots of room to roam. Day after day I post the articles on K9BSL - Day after day I sit and want to cry. 95% of the time it is dogs that are LOOSE that cause the damage. My heart breaks for the pit bulls and I sit and pray PLEASE don't let it be a Doberman that causes the problem. Right now Dobermans are flying under the radar but one bad incident like yours and you can send us all right down the tubes. They still make some hit list but they are not bashed daily like the pit bulls. Free Spirit - Dead Spirit you can't have one without the other.

Your message is a bit clouded and I'm not seeing your point you are trying to make. My dog didn't attack your's so you will not be seeing me in court, nor did my dog attack the other two dogs until he was bitten first. My dog was in my arms 3 feet off the ground and he was getting bit in his rear end, while crying in my arms I let him down because they wouldn't leave him alone.

The lesson learned is here is my dog was out of control when he left the yard. That is what I've said timelessly that I will correct. If you feel the need to continue to lecture me and hear yourself chirp then do it on someone else's thread.
 
SJ
??? I don't understand the defensive approach you are taking. You started this thread asking for help. More than one person suggested more control and you choose not to take the advice. So did you just want to "hear yourself chirp"?
Not that I need to come to D4e defense, believe me she can take care of herself. It is just that she has devoted herself to the breed and is probably feeling some frustration because you asked for help and then did not heed the advice given.
I truly hope you are sucessfull in your quest for more training but please keep an open mind when it comes to limiting some freedom for everybodies protection.
 
I am keeping an open mind and have ordered the E-Collar upon suggestions and the advice I've requested. I don't like to hear myself chirp, but I didn't ask for people to tell me if " IT WAS THEM " they'd sue me, or shoot something !!! I don't find that appropiate, and yes I'm defensive because I'm upset, embaressed, and my dog was hurt on my behalf, and my thinking. LESSON LEARNED if it matters to anyone !!!
 
Yes it does matter very much. Exactly the reason there was so much passion on this subject. I am very happy for you and Justice, just sorry you had to learn the lesson the hard way. Most of us learn that way. I tell myself all the time that I will listen to the experts next time and not go that direction...do I? NO! It is almost always the hard way for me. In fact I have the perfect example of just that. Our a/c is old. We knew that when we moved here about 3 years ago. We have had numerous problems with it and several repairmen have told us it needed to be replaced. Did we?? NO! Now it is hot and humid (I'm talkin' HOT, upper 90's with humidity over 50%) and the a/c breathed its last breath yesterday. So now we are dying and can't get the a/c replaced until Wed. Will I listen next time?? I would like to say yes, but who knows?? LOL!
 
Well, I am going to add my 2 cents here. Everybody has their own
way of training, playing and whatever else with their Dobes. That
is an owners choice and I think Stephen is a responsible owner, some
people are not and SHAME ON THEM no matter what breed they
have. This whole thing has been a lesson learned and it would have
been for me too. Justice is young yet and there is time to get on the
situation where this does not happen again. Look at how he goes
hiking and what a good boy he is, that says something.

My place is completely fenced and I live in the country but my
WACKO neighbors have an Akita and a Bullmastiff although
they are not close I don't take any chances, never did with
Hunter and I don't with Schaudeh. Even though I am fenced
it is my choosing to protective of my dogs, I am their owner
and it is MY CHOICE on how I want to train or whatever
with my dogs (now dog). I have always trained my dogs
well and they have always been very obedient, it is my
choice of training, I have never had a problem. I have
had a huge German Shepherd,:love: Hunter my Dobe:love:
and my sweet Schaudeh that is a Shepherd mis:love:.
Schaudeh was abused as a pup and when I got her at a very
young age she showed signs of AGGRESSION I worked with
her and let her know it would not be tolerated and she turned
out to be a WONDERFUL LOVING DEVOTED GAL.



 
That's crazy! Sorry to hear about the fight, hopefully Justice has learned to always stay by your side. Have your neighbors came back to you for anything like a vet bill?

I don't have any suggestions or advice, I'm still trying to get my dog from biting me! :D
 
That's crazy! Sorry to hear about the fight, hopefully Justice has learned to always stay by your side. Have your neighbors came back to you for anything like a vet bill?

I don't have any suggestions or advice, I'm still trying to get my dog from biting me! :D

No I haven't heard a thing from the neighbors, I don't expect to either. They are not friendly people, but from what the other neighbors tell me the police has been there TONS of times for the boys. So i'm sure they aren't in favor of calling authorities. Besides their dog bit mine first, I think that would be hard to ignore in court.
 
No I haven't heard a thing from the neighbors, I don't expect to either. They are not friendly people, but from what the other neighbors tell me the police has been there TONS of times for the boys. So i'm sure they aren't in favor of calling authorities. Besides their dog bit mine first, I think that would be hard to ignore in court.

I'm no lawyer, but I think it would be easy to ignore that your dog was bitten first in court. All that matters is that Justice was on the neighbor's land :(
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Back
Top