• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Obedience vs Protection

henleyb8

Jr Member
We we have started Bob in an obedience class. We are being asked to choose between obedience and protection because there seems to be a drawback to starting with obedience and then changing to protection. Currently we think we just want a dog with good obedience and feel Bob would respond appropriately if we were being attacked, which seems really remote.
I'm hoping for opinions and more information on this choice that we need to make. Thank you
 
By protection do you mean Schutzhund or IPO? Schz. requires A LOT of time and includes OB so I can see why that's one or the other. I'm not sure why you would ever have to pick one or the other if it's just protection work?

I kind of agree with you, I think if it came down to it Gretchen would protect me. I've seen her step up to it many times.
 
That is very strange for you to have to choose between OB and PP. For you to have a PP dog without OB is not a good thing, and I have never heard of such. I would be very leery of any trainer suggesting such, and I for sure would not want them to do the PP training on my dog.

What kind of OB training are they doing?
Be careful who, and how, your dog is being trained!
[DOUBLEPOST=1435091036,1435090072][/DOUBLEPOST]Here is a quote from a trainer that I know about continuing forward in PP training with my two dogs...

"I want to tell you about my experience with personal protection trainers....I have worked with many, many, many of them thru the years. They can be crooks, ruin your dogs, money hungry & overcharging. Putting the least into it that they can. When the trainers reach a certain age, it is all about taking people's money. These boys from ... are young & hungry. They are both physically fit, LOVE what they do & treat the dogs with respect. They know when the dog has reached it's limit & put them up. They do NOT OVERCHARGE. They do not have giant ego's to contend with. Most trainers have that fault. If you decide to have them trained, I strongly suggest ...(them). They charge $.... per dog over a 4-6 week period. That is dirt cheap. The dog will know it's off & on switches very well. Like turning a light switch off & on. I could not believe they only asked for $... per dog today. It is usually $...... & the dog doesn't really get worked. A quickie is what I call it. These (my two dogs) dogs were worked twice each today. Also the $... charge for each dog is taken off the training fee if you hire them. This is your decision to make, and I will not push you either way. A good trainer also does not wreck the stable disposition. They are working on a contract to train police dogs for the city of ....... I will give them a great referral. They trained one of my offspring .... for his owner about 4 months ago. I went down for one of his workouts to take pics. When he graduated, he was the real meal deal. But watch out for the bad guys out there. Seems to be a lot of them. They don't care about what is best for the dog, only collecting their $5k paychecks." -end quote

Good advise from an experienced owner/breeder/trainer.
 
To do protection with us at my club, your dog must also do obedience. A dog that is trained to bite with no obedience is a bad thing and you are looking for trouble. Now teaching obedience for a future protection dog versus training obedience for a pet or house manners dog can be completely different so if your trainer knows nothing about training a protection dog you may want to go to someone who trains both. You need a trainer who can read a dog, whether it is for aggression, posturing, prey drive, defense drive ect...


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I am sad to see we are seeing fewer and fewer clubs who train all phases of protection - tracking, obedience and PP. It is a requirement for our club to train all 3. We will not allow someone to just come for PP if they are not doing obedience and can demonstrate the dogs responds to the. As stated it take obedience to be successful in protection as no one in their right mind wants and loose cannon who thinks it is all about biting. There is so much more the dog must demonstrate like willingness to work with their handler and obey their handler.
 
I agree with Doberman Gang. I'm starting my pup in Schutzhund also. I went to 3 different Schutzhund clubs before finding the correct one. The first wanted to start my 4 month old pup by putting him alongside adult dogs that had been training there for sometime. At the time my pup had no obedience training and they expected him just to pick up in their obedience and protection classes.
The club I ended up with started my pup out in tracking. Doberman Gang knows my Schutzhund trainer and told me I made a good choice - which is always reassuring. I felt my pup needed obedience ASAP, so I also enrolled him in obedience.My obedience trainer was the one who actually recommended my Schutzhund trainer. They know each other well. My obedience trainer kind of specializes in Dobermans. He's owned many and titled them all in Schutzhund except for his current which he titled in Ring Sport instead.
Since all Schutzhund titled dogs must first earn the BH, I don't see how there could be a choice. Both are required.
 
My main concern would be Whether or not he would miss out if he did only obedience training and we kept his protective instincts untouched
 
Thank you for all your thoughtful replies. I'm getting the idea that if one just wants obedience then the trainer does not add protection into it. So that if one decides to have protection later the dog has not had experience with protection at a younger impressionable age.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using Tapatalk
 
My main concern would be Whether or not he would miss out if he did only obedience training and we kept his protective instincts untouched

This is a good point, building drive and confidence is much easier if started when they are still young. Once they are adults, if trained the wrong way, it can cause major problems in confidence and teaching them how to deal with stress. I Recommend starting there training in all 3 phases if one is seriously considering this training. We start our dogs from day in each phase.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

Back
Top