• Disclaimer: Hello Guest, Doberman Chat Forums presents the opinions and material on these pages as a service to its membership and to the general public but does not endorse those materials, nor does it guarantee the accuracy of any opinions or information contained therein. The opinions expressed in the materials are strictly the opinion of the writer and do not represent the opinion of, nor are they endorsed by, Doberman Chat Forums. Health and medical articles are intended as an aid to those seeking health information and are not intended to replace the informed opinion of a qualified Veterinarian.”

Obedience training (all positive or with corrections)

salisa826

Hot Topics Subscriber
I don't know if my title is correct. Feel free to change if needed.

Here is my question. I feel like I'm getting conflicting information. And I know ultimately it's going to be what I'm comfortable with using (method) wise.

Do you train using all positive reinforcement or do you add in a corrective collar for corrections? (Not debating the types of collars)

Recently Denali's prey drive has kicked in full force. Anything with movement gets him going. Running, swinging, cars, bikes etc. I have discovered he is a runner. He's not allowed off leash unless it's a safe and secured location. He will now lunge and bark at cars going by. I need to get this under control ASAP. And depending on the trainer I speak to I get different answers. 2 want to focus on all positive and one wants to use a corrective collar. I honestly want to use a mix of both. One trainer today feels if corrections are not used properly I can in essence ruin him and make him frightened.

I am open to your experienced thoughts. (Denali is almost 7.5 months old)
 
How old is denali? I am all for positive training especially in very young pups. However corrections are also most certainly needed. I don't use any sort of corrective collar unless you count her half choke. I use my voice as the first line of correction ( I have my very stern what the F are you doing voice). If stuff escalates I usually use a quick leash jerk or a tap on the bum or behind the ribs (only started the physical touch correction on Layla form 6/7 months). I try to avoid physical correction as much as possible. I also use my feet to stamp the ground hard ( this is dominant behaviour in dogs as well ) this works quite well most of the time. Usually I stand facing the dog and stamp my feet saying No loudly. It usually stops them dead. Remember to not stay angry with your dog as its not part of their language (holding grudges etc). Reprimand and then find a correct behaviour to give him so you can reward him.
[DOUBLEPOST=1429561658][/DOUBLEPOST]Its key to start and end training on a positive note
 
"The only thing that two dog trainers will agree on is that the third one is doing it wrong."

Everyone has their style and way of training, so you must find what works best for you, for you will be the one that has to reenforce what type of training your dog receives. It is also just as important to learn what NOT to do, as it is what to do. Personally I feel that you should use as much positive training as possible, and use corrections as a last resort, but it is very important that the dog understands what the correction is for, so it must be immediately after the infraction and not some time later.

Find a good trainer and work with them on what you want/need to achieve. Most dog trainers understand that it is just as important to teach the owner/handler what to do, as it is to train the dog. Learn as much as you can!!! Read, watch videos, take a class, ultimately it is up to you to handle the dog so you must learn all that you can.
 
I ALWAYS train a behavior with positive. I reinforce with positive. Then I start sporadically rewarding the behavior with treats. Once I know they can do the trained behavior over and over and over with treats or toys for a reward and then they "chose" not to, that's when I correct the behavior. In my mind it lets them know that it's not their decision if they want to do it, it's my decision and they WILL do it. On top of that though I still treat for the good behavior. That way minding me is a positive decision that they WANT to do. I got all of this advice from different trainers, members... and it's what I've put together because it's what works for G. Plus there's no freebies in my house, if you want a treat then do a behavior I ask for.
 
I personally like a mix of both positive and corrections when needed. I think you'll have to find a trainer that works for you both. I had a positive reinforcement trainer come to my house for Diesel and while it helped some it wasn't enough. I then found a trainer that uses corrections and did a course with them. That also helped but still was t enough. I decided to mix the two strategies together and that was it. We were actually beginning to see the results we wanted.
 
From my experience, and really it has only been a few years, dogs learn best in black and white. Meaning they learn and behave best if they have clear boundaries. To me this means a mix of plenty of praise and support AND appropriate corrections. Appropriate corrections means only once the dog has the idea of what it is they should be doing, using the correct equipment and methods, and making sure that the correction matches the offense. For example, we train the heel from a very very young age by using food and toys to lure them into the correct position and reward them. Once the puppy shows that they 110% get the idea of the exercise and are capable of following the command (and they reach an appropriate age for the collar) we introduce the pinch collar on the dead ring. At first the collar is barely engaged, just enough to let the puppy know something isn't right, it is quickly released and followed immediately by a reward once they do the proper action. As the dog ages and training progresses corrections become more severe but are always at an appropriate level (never actually hurts) and always followed by lots of reward when the action is performed. I have given a handful of very hard corrections, these are almost exclusively reserved for instances where the dog is either about to harm someone or put themselves in harms way.
 
Thanks to everyone that has responded so far. He's had 17 sessions with a trainer that just does positive training. And then he's had one session with a trainer that uses a corrective collar. I feel like we can benefit from both bc they are so different. When he lunges at passing cars if I wasn't holding him back I know he would chase the car. So to me that deserves some sort of correction.

Other than that everything else is positive reinforcement with food. When I work on basic stuff like sit, down and stay it's also all positive. We have done heels with luring and he's good as long as there is food. And if a big distraction is present food doesn't matter to him
 
I posted this in a thread awhile back and thought it might help explain things. I don't believe there is a all positive form of dog training.
I always get a kick out of people who preach the 100% positive training method.

1st dog training is done with what is called operant conditioning, also known as instrumental learning. To understand this it is based on four quadrants using the terms positive and negative. Positive not meaning good and negative not bad. Positive means adding something, negative meaning taking something away. Then there is reinforcement and punishment. Reinforcement meaning the behavior will more than likely happen again in the future. Punishment meaning it will less likely happen.

1- positive reinforcement; add a reward and behavior is more likely to occur in the future.
Ask the dog to sit, dog sits and you give them a piece of food.

2- negative reinforcement, this is removing pressure. It is the old school way of teaching sit. Pull up on the collar, when the dog sits you release the pressure.. Removing the pressure the dog is more likely to sit in the future do to avoiding leash pressure.

3- positive punishment, this is a traditional correction. Dog jumps up on the counter, you give a leash correction and that behavior is now less likely to occur in the future.

4- negative punishment, this withholding a reward. Your dog jumps up on you, you remove the ability for them to access there reward, whether it is food or a toy ect... By taking away there reward the behavior is now less likely to happen in the future.





Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
When I first got Kris, I started out with someone who calls themselves a "Positive trainer". I had only done Agility with her with my small dogs and had never really seen her training methods. I wasted several months with Kris learning basically nothing as her method was to stand with the dog on leash and "wait" till she went into the heel position. I was not supposed to direct her or correct her in any way. Well, you know how well that worked! I also found out how "well" her dogs were trained. They leap all over everybody and do not listen to her at all. I wish I could post the video of her first leg of her CD where the dog completely left her on the heel free, never sat once on the halts, etc. but people might recognize her. She should never have passed.

Anyway, I was lucky to hook up with a group that do use positive reinforcement but also use shock and prong collars but in the right way. Kris was quite reactive with other dogs, not in an aggressive way but wanting to jump and bark at them. (which a lot of people think is aggressive.) I went to a Practice match last weekend and she never reacted to any other dog, did her Novice run-through very well, stayed on her long sit and down and I was very pleased with her. She runs off-leash with her e-collar on but have not had to use it for months, just have it on just in case I do need it. (We do have big areas where we can legally have them off-leash.)
 
I feel like we can benefit from both bc they are so different. When he lunges at passing cars if I wasn't holding him back I know he would chase the car

Some seem to missing the point - All positive training vs positive training with corrections. Training with corrections IS a combination of the two. You can't train any dog with all negative so it is not one or the other as only the positive training with corrections includes BOTH methods. Always make training 90 to 95% positive. Be clear, confident and consistent in techniques.

Dogs works on a reward/nonreward (which can include a corrections) basis to help the clearly understand what is and what is not acceptable. Correct response brings good rewards - and once the dog clearly has demonstrated he knows the commands and does not do them then there are consequences he does not like so the dog chooses to do the thing that brings him reward.

If the prong brought you a positive response why would you then question it which sets you up for failure. You see positive results and if you continue doing it correctly you will continue to get good results.
 
Thank You for your insight. Using the prong collar is giving me the results I want. I also reward with food and praise when he makes the right choices.
 
I'm in the same position with a 5 month old pup. I have 2 trainers one for Schutzhund and one for basic obedience (and possibly Ring Sport). My Schutzhund trainer says never to use a prong or choke collar. She says that is 'old school' and that they used to teach that way but now have moved to positive "lure" training.
My pup spent a week of day training with the obedience trainer. He is healing so much better after just 1 week, I have to believe there is some legitimacy with the corrective training. My Schutzhund trainer says that corrective training will likely get results faster but in the long run the dog won't be enjoying it (Schutzhund/Ring Sport) in the same way. After a week of obedience training my dog has gained a great deal of confidence. He now barks and alerts me to everything. He isn't aloof when other people approach him or other dogs. He will walk right into a Home Depot or pet store like he owns the place. He also thinks that he is alpha dog of the dog park but that is another discussion.

Now just putting the prong collar on my dog is enough for him to change behavior. Previously he would heal about 40% of the time, pull occasionally but mostly just stop, lay down, and resist. Now with the prong collar, he resisted one time - I gave a quick correction and he was back walking again and hasn't resisted again.
For the training that I do with him, I'm using both. I'm trying to "lure" him with food into the behavior and if he doesn't respond then I give a quick correction on the prong. I'm hoping to find a 'happy medium'.
 
Drogon - sound like you are on the right track. Keep up the good work!!! Always love to hear when someone has found a good trainer to work with!!!
 
I'm in the same position with a 5 month old pup. I have 2 trainers one for Schutzhund and one for basic obedience (and possibly Ring Sport). My Schutzhund trainer says never to use a prong or choke collar. She says that is 'old school' and that they used to teach that way but now have moved to positive "lure" training.
My pup spent a week of day training with the obedience trainer. He is healing so much better after just 1 week, I have to believe there is some legitimacy with the corrective training. My Schutzhund trainer says that corrective training will likely get results faster but in the long run the dog won't be enjoying it (Schutzhund/Ring Sport) in the same way. After a week of obedience training my dog has gained a great deal of confidence. He now barks and alerts me to everything. He isn't aloof when other people approach him or other dogs. He will walk right into a Home Depot or pet store like he owns the place. He also thinks that he is alpha dog of the dog park but that is another discussion.

Now just putting the prong collar on my dog is enough for him to change behavior. Previously he would heal about 40% of the time, pull occasionally but mostly just stop, lay down, and resist. Now with the prong collar, he resisted one time - I gave a quick correction and he was back walking again and hasn't resisted again.
For the training that I do with him, I'm using both. I'm trying to "lure" him with food into the behavior and if he doesn't respond then I give a quick correction on the prong. I'm hoping to find a 'happy medium'.

When I was about 10 years old I was taught to train dogs with a chain training collar using corrections and praise. We were never allowed to use treats or toys. Because of this I learned to train dogs without using treats and only praise. So that is the way I prefer to train to this day. However, I do prefer a prong collar to a choke collar because of obvious reasons. Some dogs and some trainers do very well with the lure/treat training. However, I have some so many dogs that once the treat is gone the dog looses interest and focus and the trainer doesn't know what to do. I find when you train using verbal and physical praise you are the one the dog is interested in and not the treat. They dog looks to you for the fun and the reward. Some dogs. that have a more laid back personality and seem to really resist training sometimes treat training works better but again if you want to show or ever get them off treats you will have to learn to train without them anyway. I have trained many different breeds and titled them...even toy breeds rarely seen in obedience. The only dogs that didn't love working also weren't food or toy motivated either, but they still listened and were obedient just didn't love training. My current Dobes love heeling. It's fun for them and they have great focus. They have been very successful in rally which is all heeling with lots of stops, turns and tight courses that often makes dogs who hate heeling shut down. My two love it and have excelled. That is just my two sense about it. Again I have seen some breeds totally excel with treat training, shelties and border collies seem to just think you have a treat and that works for them. Dobes are usually too smart for that. lol!
 
Thanks to everyone that has responded so far. He's had 17 sessions with a trainer that just does positive training. And then he's had one session with a trainer that uses a corrective collar. I feel like we can benefit from both bc they are so different. When he lunges at passing cars if I wasn't holding him back I know he would chase the car. So to me that deserves some sort of correction.

Other than that everything else is positive reinforcement with food. When I work on basic stuff like sit, down and stay it's also all positive. We have done heels with luring and he's good as long as there is food. And if a big distraction is present food doesn't matter to him
keep working with food and eventually you give it every other command done right then three then four till weaned off the food . A young dog it takes time and repetition with food then when steady slowly lessen the food
 
The tide comes in. It goes out.

We inhale. We exhale.

We wake, sleep. Speed up, slow down.

In the words of the immortal Ronnie James Dio: Like candy – emotion. Too much and sugar can turn to sand.
 

Back
Top